Great Pizza, hands down. I am very particular when it comes to pizza, but this place really knocks it out of the box. The 44 years of pizza making shows. If you are around Lodi, go out of your way to get a slice for lunch. You won't be disappointed. read more

Thought it was OK. Just average pizza at best. Salad lacked. Wouldn't be my first pizzeria choice but good for a slice

My favorite pizza in the world. The dough is crunchy, the sauce is tasty, and the cheese is just perfect. Old school pizza joint that may not be much on looks but is huge on taste. Good, quality food, and great prices. Cash only business but has an ATM in store. I don't know why this place isn't in the top 10 pizza places of NJ. read more

People saying its bad or just ok are morons! You have to know what to get, you get the Sicilian pie, never the regular!

Great local pizza joint. Family owned and operated and has been for as long as remember. The Sicilian pie is my absolute favorite. The sopranos was filmed here as most places in lodi and they have pictures of scenes there. Cash only which is a bummer sometimes but great place all in all! read more

My Dad calls this the best pizza in NJ but I'm not sold, even after coming here for 10 years. Don't get me wrong, it's good, very good but its got some drawbacks. Some people call it a classic but I call a business that changes absolutely nothing for 40 years stubborn. They don't take credit cards at all and the place is generally kind of filthy. I usually have to wipe my own table down from the crumbs left by the last patrons. They have a bunch of sun-bleached posters on the wall signed by celebrities that is interesting to look at while waiting for your food. In a nutshell, the place is basically a hole in the wall with phenomenal pizza. read more

By far the best pizza in Jersey. Now that I live in California I try to get back once a year just to get my pizza fix. I've even had them ship out pies before. Anyone who doesn't give Lodi 5 stars, doesn't know pizza. read more

Holy moly! This pizza is great! So many very good pizza places in this area (Lodi, Garfield and Elmwood Park), but Lodi Pizza is right at the top. Great sauce, great crust. Wish they delivered. Crazy busy in there for pick up on a Friday night, ugh. But this is serious freaking pizza! read more

This is a Quality Local Pizzeria. They got decent pizza, but there are a lot of options in this area. The location is perfect for stragglers... read more

This review is strictly for the pizza. I've had Lodi Pizza a couple of times with others from the area that love it. The first time I had their pizza I was kind of unimpressed. Then i was at someone's house at the beginning of the summer and they ordered from here. We ordered some pies and it was SO good. I had a pepperoni slice and a square specialty slice with sautéed onions and maybe some grated cheese. I'm not sure what it was called because I didn't order it. But really flavorful. So a few weeks ago my sister and I wanted pizza so I went with a regular pepperoni pie and decided to try a chicken parm sandwich. The pizza was great again. They have a really crispy crust and I think it has a lot of flavor. The chicken parm sandwich however was terrible. It was tons of bread with a measly layer frozen chicken fingers topped with sauce and cheese. They should be ashamed serving frozen chicken fingers and passing that as chicken parmigiana to customers. I'll continue to come for the great pizza when I'm craving it but I'll stay away from anything else. read more

amazing pizza! My gf lives around the corner and I always wanted to try them. They've been in business for 47 years and they make great pizza!! As an Italian I approve! They aren't huge slices but reasonable prices. read more

We had a party yesterday and ordered 2 Sicilian pies. They were great...taste like homemade. Same great pizza from years ago. We hadn't been there for many years so forgot it was cash only. The ATM In the store didn 't work right so couldn't get cash out. The owner said "Just take the pizza and have a nice party! Next time you pass you can stop by and pay me." WHO DOES THAT!! Speaks a lot about the place and the original Lodi people! My husband will go there today to pay them. The pizza was THE BEST! I forgot how good it was!! Five stars for the quality of the pizza and the people that run it! read more

I eat here all the time. Pizza is amazing and aside from my mother's, I won't get it anywhere else. Place does look a bit run down, but don't expect some high end pizzeria. No credit, debit (though they DO have an ATM now...) and no delivery but they do one thing and one thing well: PIZZA. Can't comment on their other food selections since I've never ordered, but with pizza this great, why bother? read more

Lodi Pizza happens to be the best pizza around. I have been visiting this place for almost 40 years. Great service. This is the "real deal" pizza. read more

When you first pull up you get the vibe that your at a spot! The pizza was over cooked and slices small. Nothing special here. The Garlic knots were the best part of my meal. read more

Sicilian Pie-that's what you want to order. Been getting pizza there for years. Never an issue with the staff-find them quite friendly actually. Call, order, pick up and go home to enjoy. You want ambiance-go to a restaurant. You want a Sicilian pie-go to Lodi. read more

this is the epitome of real deal Italian , all around the real original, non tacky-corporate nowadays joints you find everywhere. The real thing!!!!!! read more

Best pizza, delicious Italian sub my favorite eat it every weekend. Not a fancy place but the food talks for itself oh and hawaiian pizza pineapple and ham. Forget a bout it. read more

Best pizza in NJ, or tri-state.... Maybe the country! Started going here as a kid and never stopped. I travel all over the US for work and searched everywhere for a better slice, a few places in brooklyn and queens NY come close, but this is the best! read more

Solid and consistant pizza, for the area as good as you will find

Love the Sicilian meatball pie! Lodi pizza is the best! This place has been around forever and it only gets better as the years go on.

Good pizza and great atmosphere. Must try at least once if you're in Lodi. Everything is made fresh and to order.

First, only went to this place because I saw it on a walk one day, then was even more giddy about it when I saw the Sopranos shot a clip there. Then, I got the pizza. It was ok the first time. 3/5 and 2 bucks per plain slice. I went back again a few days later, only to be handed what looked like 2 slices from a day old way over cooked pie. Never went back again. Nice people, but, we go for the pizza, not the service. read more

This is good pizza, REALLY good pizza. Far and away the best pizza I ever had baked in a pan, but don't let that scare you off. This is truly the top 10% of pizza I ever had. And I eat a lotta pizza. Cash only. Overpriced ATM on site. 70s ambiance that makes you want to put on a white polyester suit. read more

To each it's own as far as pizza preference. My boyfriend and I love this pizza. We live right in between Pizza town and Lodi pizza. Lodi is def our choice for pizza. read more

Best Sicilian Pizza Anywhere! Great Sandwiches! Order, Pick Up, Take Home & Enjoy! Try The Sicilian With Sausage, Their Sausage Is Homemade With No Casing! read more

On New Years eve we had no choice than this location Lodi Pizza we got two pies but the taste was nothing no sauce had taste not cheese had taste I don't no why they put name Pizza ? It was nothing tastes I was vey disappointed but I got my lesson not to go back again in my life time. read more

I live in the area and will tell you from experience. These gusy know how to make a pizza!!! In this day and age every bozo and his brother opens up a pizzieria will all this gourmet stuff and fancy everyhting that it become more of a restaurant than a pizzaria. Not this place. These guys have been in bussiness for decades and I can completely see why. Great service, employees, atmosphere, and food!! Nothing modern but what do you expect. Its an old school Italian pizzeria with a unique recipe like no other. That is why I eat at these old school places over all these new bozo pizzerias that keep opening up in Lodi. (cough cough) (Goodfellas)(cough cough) A good rule to keep is never buy pizza from someone who isnt Italian unless its ninos lol. Anyway, love this place and will always keep coming back!! read more

THE BEST SICILIAN HANDS DOWN!!! I was Born and Raised in Brooklyn so I know good pizza! I always have been in search of a Great Sicilian (Square) and have found pizzeria's in Brooklyn that I grew up on so I thought that they where the best. Well I was wrong!!! I now live in NJ and my family and I where driving on Route 46 and saw Lodi Pizza, it looked like an old school Brooklyn Pizzeria so I pulled out my phone and searched for reviews. Since I found good reviews we stopped off and had some pizza (this is about 3 months or so ago) well fool you not we visit this place almost every week and order a sicilian pie each time we visit. Me and my 2 additional family members demolish the pie and usually have maybe 1-2 sicilian's left to take home (which is great the next day once reheated in the toaster oven). This place is GREAT The Pizza Is DELICIOUS! You Definitely have to stop by and try this pizza! read more

Don't order pizza to go! I like the pizza but oh my god the boxes are so cheap. 3 times this has happened the box is two flimsy and you will get bad burn the box will cave in and when you get home from driving 5 mins your pizza looks like shit. So disappointed. GET BETTER FREAKING BOXES! Wish I could leave no stars. read more

Oh Lodi Pizza, what has become of you? :( You used to be so tasty and have gone so far downhill over the years that I don't even recognize you anymore. The second star is for nostalgia purposes only. The sauce on the pizza is watery which makes for a - you guessed it - soggy pie. The meatballs, which were once pretty damn good, now resemble Alpo. Such a shame. read more

Only thing that kept me from giving it a five star is my need to try more things on the menu. All I've ever had was the pizza. Never tried the sandwiches even though i heard good things. Lodi pizza has been a personal favorite of mine for many years now. It also helps that it is right down the block from me. They are famous for their sicilian aka "square" slices which are very delicious. Great ratio of cheese to sauce and not too doughy. Also i would recommend the meatball slice. One of the best I've ever had. Another favorite of mine is the white slice. If you're like me and love you some ricotta this is a must try. Last but not least to wash it all down you need to try the homemade fruit punch that brews right before your eyes. Seating inside is decent in size as is the parking lot. While you're sitting inside you're bound to see at least a hand full of people walk in to pick up their pies. The staff is always friendly and sevice always fast. Never keep you waiting. Old school cash register and the staff outfits give the place a nostalgic feel. Only downer is no delivery. But worth the short trip. 2 corners and a fruit punch... Cant go wrong. read more

Loved the round pie with Onions.. Definitely going back. I think this is one of the tastier pizza places around Saddle Brook and the price was good read more

Excellent pie making. They, when asked, can make a top notch thin and crispy pie. No ambience and mediocre fountain drinks but you don't care while at pizza Mecca. read more

While definitely a good pizza place the problems I've experienced is with consistency. The main problem being the quality of the pie really depends on when you go and who's making it. We've experienced this on numerous occasions. While the pie may be delicious on one day it may suck a couple of days later. For this reason we stopped frequenting the place and now prefer T&J's Pizza (also in Lodi) which we feel is the best pizza in the area. And as 40+ year Italian American residents of Lodi, we feel we speak with some authority when it comes to delicious Italian food. I will say Lodi Pizza has the best garlic bread around, just as Pizza Town USA has the best calzones. read more

Amazing pizza and potato and egg hero!!! Only reason. For 4 stars instead of 5 is the soda machine needs to be replaced and the place needs a good cleaning. read more

Best pizza I have ever had period. His place has been here for over 40 years and is one place where you can truly get authentic original Italian pizza, yea sure it may not be in its glory days anymore but it still has kick ass pizza, love going here also for sandwiches and their amazing deep fried wings and fries, if you are looking for amazing pizza for good prices come here. read more

I haven't had their pizza in MANY years. My late stepfather Lou used to bring home Sicilian pies and their potato and egg hero's - always delicious!! I finally had the chance to get Lodi pizza and a couple of potato and egg hero's - it was like old times. The best Sicilian and the hero...simple true and totally Jersey! Thank you for staying genuine - can't wait to go back!! read more

Great pizza Love it!. The workers are really nice and attentive. My favorite pizza would definitely be the spicy buffalo pizza. I will definitely keep coming back here. read more

I grew up a couple of blocks from here in the 60's 70's and always have loved it here. I flew back here from Vegas recently and it's still great. I wish we had places like this out west. Now my daughter has a new favorite pizza place too bad its 2000 miles away read more