This place must be magic because although I've been here more times than I can count I haven't been able to get a picture of the ice cream, it just disappears :) There is a huge array of options and something for everyone including vegan, fat and sugar free too. They also have the option to order online so it's ready when you get there. All around the go-to spot for ice cream, really can't beat the Magic Fountain. read more

Extremely friendly worker. Bad ice cream. I could not finish one 'scope' of twist soft ice cream. I was craving for ice cream and when I do I usually get two scopes. Very unusual not to be able to finish ice cream. It was extremely sweet ... Thank you for the reply. I will definitely give it another try soon. read more

Hey I'm from Boston so I won't say it's as good as as Toscanini's, but it's definitely up there. Traditional flavors and experimental. Worth the side trip for sure! read more

Always a great spot to stop by after a great day on the east end. Wonderful flavors of "I never heard of that before flavors". They let you taste before you buy. I don't know why I even bother. My Goto will always be the blue Cookie Monster. Someone always gets the raspberry truffle and there's always a new flavor of the month to try. Oh yeah. They have soft serve but even better they have oak milk ice cream too. read more

Long line on a Saturday evening means that the ice cream should be good...but it wasn't. Although my wife enjoyed her soft serve twist, my sugar and fat free butter pecan had absolutely no taste. It was tasteless ice cream and I would not have been able to tell you what it was without the pecans on top...smh read more

Homemade ice cream in creative & delicious flavors, priced reasonably, and on the gorgeous North Fork of Long Island? Yup! That's pretty much as good as it gets! Flavors I've tried include: --- Honey Cinnamon - If Teddy Grahams were made into ice cream, this is what it would taste like. SO good! --- Hazelnut Biscotti - Flavorful hazelnut ice cream packed with pieces of chocolate-chunk biscotti. MMM! --- Salted Caramel - Do I even need to describe this one? Good, because I'm speechless. --- CHOCOLATE CHILI - Cold, sweet & chocolately at first... then spicy! Some people find it too overwhelming, but this one is definitely worth trying even if you don't get a full scoop! They have "normal" flavors too if you're not feeling particularly adventurous (aka boring)... and they create seasonal flavors as well. I can't wait to come back around St. Patty's day when they have their famous Guinness ice cream! read more

See all

This place does so well, it's open all year. And now that you can order online and pickup at the window....makes it so much quicker. Even whennthe line is long, it goes quick. We live local, but all of our out of town visitors request a trip to Magic Fountain to get their favs. read more

If heading out to the North Fork of Long Island hitting the wine trail for a bit of wine tasting this spot makes for a great cold treat along the way. Terrific ice cream! Salted caramel. So creamy. All homemade. Some standard and many unique flavors too. They have a bunch of awesome flavors here, and also have soft serve if that's your thing, plus a bunch of stuff in the freezers to take home or back to your hotel room to glom on. Small spot with no tables inside but some outside bench seating by the parking lot. So don't fret if you pass by the other great ice cream joint, Snowflake, as you also have Magic Fountain futher down the road to score some equally good scoops. read more

Kudos to Magic Fountain for inventive flavors and friendly service. Who doesn't smoke eating ice cream? read more

Magic Fountain - Honey and fig! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Awesome, delicious, creamy ice cream!! The hubs and I found this gem 5 years ago, and whenever we are in the North Fork of LI, Mattituk we ALWAYS pay them a visit. The ice cream is sooo good, they make most of their flavors on sight, and they never disappoint. Cakes, ice cream, sugar cones, waffles cones, banana splits, sprinkles and so much more...stop by! They have vegan, gluten free ice cream as well, low fat, and Fruit flavors. Pay this local gem a visit... read more

We've been going here for years !!!..never disappoints, went this past Sunday even though it was cold we took a ride out East ..stopped for some of their delicious ice cream ..two flavors posted on sign sounded great ..we got one Irish cream that had shaved chocolate in it and one Cannoli that had Chocolate chips in it ..easy order at outside window and employees were very accommodating ..will be back soon read more

The best ice cream I've ever had! They have such a variety of flavors but I absolutely love getting the black raspberry with a lot of toppings. The staff is also very friendly. Every time I'm in Mattituck I make a stop here read more

The skinny worker with the acne on his cheeks passed some very rude comments about our son. He was pissed that my son forgot to mention he wanted toppings. Unfortunately he acted like a fool and said some very unprofessional remarks to his coworker like we couldn't hear him. Luckily for us our guests were videoing us for memories and caught his rudeness on tape. The guest behind us left because of this. This kid needs to be fired before you lose more business. SHAME read more

We drove by on a trip out to Orient & I was wowed by the flavors listed on the sign. For such an old school building, the flavors were truly unique and innovative. I had the sea salt caramel in a waffle cone, my mom had the peanut butter chocolate, and my son had the cookies and cream. They were all excellent. The scoops were large too! Just perfect for a warm spring day. read more

In what appears to be an old Dairy Queen, Magic Fountain prepares amazing homemade ice cream in many different flavors. After trying samples of flavors like Cookie Monster, English Toffee, and "Lots of Stuff," I decided to get a small helping of Raspberry Dream, and Cake Mix - which was the perfect combo. Don't let the line fool you - it moves quickly and the staff are great. As an added bonus, they make treats for dogs, too! read more

The best ice cream! Can't beat homemade! Don't let your trip to the North Fork complete without a stop. Cake Mix and Chocolate Raspberry Truffle are my faves. In the summer lines are long you can preorder on their website and pick up at a window if you know you will be in the area read more

Amazing! A favorite place of ours for years! The ice cream is genuinely created there at their establishment. The line is always worth it.

Legendary local ice cream shop. I worked there, my bro worked there, my mom worked there. I'm glad as they've switched owners they've continued making the ice cream homemade. Cookie Monster is my fave even though I look insane after because it turns your mouth bright blue. Worth the wait although the new online ordering function is awesome. read more

I love a good mom and pop style ic cream place with a ton of different flavors to try. I sampled the honey lavender and the cucumber (both delicious, but a tad overwhelming for me) and finally settled on the hazelnut biscotti. The other 3 members of my party also tried 3-5 flavors each, before settling on one, and I have to give a huge shoutout to the staff there, because although they were super busy they weren't ever impatient or annoyed that we were indecisive. Magic Fountain is a must stop after a nearby winery visit. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

We love Autumn Montgomery!!!! She's the best server ever!!!! We always get service with a smile!

The individual helping us was fast and helpful. However, the ice cream was okay and, for the price, the portion size was small. I got a medium sundae (3 scoops) - it did not even fill the sundae cup. Then I added syrup and sprinkles, which then filled up the sundae cup. It seemed that there was more syrup then actual ice cream. In total this sundae cost over $8 - which was mostly syrup. I recommend no toppings and to focus on the ice cream. read more

Magic Fountain - All syrup and no ice cream. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Our kids are obsessed w/ this place! We LOVE the rainbow cookie flavor. So many varieties to try AND I love that they clearly mark the allergens in each flavor. read more

Amazingggggg!!!!!! This place is super cute. Has dozens and dozens of homemade flavors. After trying a few, we settled on: - s'more: great flavor, somehow it made the marshmallow texture feel incorporated into the entire ice cream. Lots of crunchy Graham cracker bits to give extra texture - almond joy: loved this!! Ice cream texture was really smooth and just had hints of coconut flavors hidden into it. Add in chocolate covered almonds it it was a real winner! They also had lots of packed ice cream sandwiches and chocolate covered cones that I was dying to try. Price is vey reasonable- $4.50 for medium cup ( would be double that in Manhattan). Plus there are a lot of benches outside for you to sit and enjoy your tasty treat :) read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

I cannot believe the amount of flavor in a spoonful of ice cream. What a satisfying hidden treasure. Do yourself a favor and stop by this hidden treasure, there's something for everyone, vegan, dairy free, gluten free, or classic flavored ice cream. read more

Magic Fountain - English butter toffee with kuhr ice cream on the bottom layer - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

The Magic Fountain has many delicious, homemade ice cream flavors. It is one of the best ice cream shops I've been to in a long time! I recommend the Rainbow Cookie Ice cream and the Salted Caramel. read more

Came across this little gem while spending the days at the wineries out east. It was such a great way to end the day! There was a bunch of benches outside that we were able to sit at. Staff was friendly and they let us try a bunch of different flavors. Their pumpkin ice cream legit tastes like pumpkin pie- so good! Everyone got different flavors and there were no complaints. Definitely will be going back! read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Best Ice Cream around!!!! Once you come here you will always be longing for a cool taste on a summer night. Workers are pleasant and it feel like an old pop up ice cream shop. There is bench seating outside but most people sit in there cars during high season due to the long lines. read more

My family and I come up every year to visit family up on the Long Island sound and Magic Fountain is a true staple. I am a cookies and cream kind of person and I can't say enough good things about their icecream. Their dipped cones are also amazing!! read more

I bring EVERYONE here that visits to this shop. The ice cream is home made and delicious! My favorite is cherry pistachio and Heath bar crunch! So GOOD!! read more

The best, most fresh, delicious homemade ice cream I've had. This place is a gem in town. Lots of flavors, varieties, toppings. Had a scoop of Pistachio and Lavender, very creamy and full of flavor. Not to mention their big scoop, well worth the price. Oh, and they have the cleanest portable stand-alone restroom (sorry, had to throw it out there) I bet this place is pretty famous amongst the winery folks. If you happen to stop by on your way to winery/vineyard, check out the vineyard/winery map outside their store. read more

Magic Fountain - Vineyard/winery map outside their store - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

The very best! I believe they home make their flavors, too! The wait in line during July is always worth it!

If you're in the mood for ice cream then this Mattituck mad house in summer place is for you. They have a huge variety of flavors, some rather odd: goat cheese and fig! WTF?!! I also saw fig and honey, caramel apple and chocolate chili... No thanks. I ordered a couple scoops of banana and it was okay, nothing to write home about. Tried the black cherry bourbon which was a bit strange tasting. It is overwhelming with the crowds and huge selection so I felt a bit rushed but counter service was courteous. Prices are a little higher than say Carvel but with the variety of flavors it's to be expected. I'd like to come back again to try a different flavor and update my review. read more

See all

We used to love this place and it was the place to go after a weekend dinner, but they've never came back to normal business hours after Pandemic l. After we drove over there only to find the doors closed or closing we gave up! read more

Wow, incredible flavors . I recently stopped in and bought a pint of rainbow cookie and rocky road ice cream. Great homemade ice cream filled with bits of deliciousness. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

I love this place! Parking is sparse and in the summertime, lines will be out the door but worth the wait with flavors like Pineapple Express, rainbow cookie and more. I had the Pineapple Express which was amazing. Real chunks of pineapple! The only reason why I didn't give them five stars is because staff is hit or miss. Some are very friendly and courteous and others not so much. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Worst feeling ever is watching someone get turned away from an ice cream at 9:01 on a Summer Saturday Night. 9pm closings on Friday and Saturdays in a town that thrives during the summer and fall is a poor business model. Letting us down Magic Fountain read more

Randomly tried Magic Fountain on a day trip and was not disappointed. They have a lot of flavors to choose from to satisfy all tastes. Flavors range from traditional like mint chocolate chip to interesting like kulfi or goat cheese. They also have soft serve and a freezer with other frozen treats like ice cream sandwiches. Even a biscuit ice cream sandwich for pups. I tried cherry vanilla and hazelnut biscotti ice cream and was pleasantly surprised at how creamy and thick the ice creams were. Lots of chunks of biscotti. It a 90 degree day and the ice cream stayed cold and thick while I sat outside eating. Two largish scoops for only $5...definitely not in NYC anymore! read more

My family and I have been coming to MF for many years and we all have various (and many) favorites so I was confused as to how to choose a birthday cake that everyone would enjoy. I wanted to include one of my personal favorites, chocolate raspberry truffle and was advised to try almond joy (one of my sisters' favorite) as a complimentary flavor. I was very nervous at the feedback I would receive as I cut and served the cake. The compliments were endless and everyone thoroughly enjoyed this cake!!! THANK YOU MAGIC FOUNTAIN!! Oh and in case anyone wants to order the same we did have the chocolate crunchies? in our cake and the whole thing was so delicious! read more

A gem! This wonderful destination is a favorite of locals and tourists alike. The ice cream is creative and delicious. The staff incredibly helpful and courteous. My favorite are the cones but I have a secret obsession with the ice cream sandwiches. read more

Awesome fresh made in house ice cream! Every week I past they always seem to have new flavors on the menu board outside. I recently went once and it was so good I had to go back a second time in the week I usually always get a chocolate covered waffle cone with two different scoops it comes out to about seven dollars but it's worth it read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York