Okay I was cracking up about my experience here because I literally asked the dumbest question to the guy working but he was so nice and explained the answer to me until I understood! So fun fact they are now advertising Banana Pudding Hot Chocolate and it is NOT actual hot chocolate but banana pudding made to taste like hot chocolate. Why I got so confused? I don't know! Maybe I have been watching too many videos about Tyra Banks Hot Ice Cream. Either way I appreciate the guys patience and kindness when explaining it to me twice especially because I did not end up ordering that at all (though it sounds interesting) but I did get the regular actual hot chocolate and it was amazing! It tasted like melted marshmallows were in it! Perfect for a cold winter day. In addition we got to the humming bird cake, a cupcake, and the regular banana pudding. My husband had never been here before so you know we had to get the banana pudding, it's their claim to fame. And it is decent. Growing up in North Carolina banana pudding is taken very seriously and is literally at every gathering. Would this be a contender for the cookout? Sure! I have no complaints about. The other baked items were delicious as well. The store is cute unfortunately this location has no indoor seating but plenty of outdoor. It was like negative degrees when we went so we definitely did not sit outside. All and all it's a cute bakery/ sweets shop. There are many locations through out the city. I've been to others and it is consistent. It's definitely not a bad dessert spot to try. read more

See all

Let me start with the positives, because there were some. Daniel was excellent--polite, attentive, and gave solid customer service. Credit where it's due. Now for the madness. Another employee, Kirk--an older gentleman who looked completely out of place--approached and coughed directly over the slice of cake that had just been cut for me. Yes. Over it. At that moment, I honestly wondered if it was intentional. A young woman nearby immediately caught my reaction and went to the back to replace the slice. She handled the situation professionally and deserves recognition. Unfortunately, the chaos continued. Kirk later made me a hot cocoa, and when I went to drink it, it spilled on me because the lid wasn't secured properly. At that point, I stopped believing in coincidences. And the cake? The German chocolate cake was terrible--dry AF and nothing like the Grand Central location. Not even remotely close. Between the coughing, the spill, and the subpar cake, this visit was uncomfortable, messy, and disappointing. Magnolia should seriously reconsider who they put on the floor and retrain accordingly--because this location is not living up to the brand. But honestly, I believe the 2 guys had to be the owners. I love a good watch but rolex's while serving Desserts is WILD read more

A haiku review: First bite and time stops Bananas melt in my mouth Creamy and cakey Life before this cup? Incomplete.. always wishing. Now .. I know too much read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Classic Banana Pudding Medium - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Tried the banana pudding and red velvet cheesecake, both of which were delicious, but very sweet. We were sharing both items between a few of us and it worked out perfectly, since I don't think I would've been able to eat either fully alone. read more

See all

Famous for their Banana Pudding! I've always loved their banana pudding. Came to this location to grab their standard pudding and also the pistachio banana pudding, which was a great change in taste and texture. Tried their mini cupcakes, which were decent. Did not have a good experience with the lady at the banana pudding bar, as she was a bit rude. Otherwise, no issues. A bit of a line, but expected. Price is a little bit high but reasonable for the brand. read more

See all

I came here for an afternoon sweet treat. I ordered the classic banana pudding, and it was delicious as expected. It was a nice day out and was able to find a table right outside Magnolia to enjoy my dessert. The shop itself is a little small but cute. Service was quick and easy too. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Banana Pudding - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I recently tried Magnolia Bakery, and the highlight was definitely their Classic Banana Pudding. It was so yummy -- creamy, sweet, and perfectly balanced with those soft vanilla wafers. Totally lived up to the hype and left me wanting more! You can actually purchase the banana pudding kit to make at home (see pictures). I wish they had a location in the Bronx because I would definitely visit more often. The young lady that was working the front counter and the register at the same time was so warm and friendly. You can tell this is a popular neighborhood and tourist hot spot ! There was a line out the door. They definitely sell something for everyone's sweet tooth. read more

See all

Dropped by Magnolia Bakery on a sunny May afternoon, which turned out to be a solid people-watching opportunity thanks to their outdoor seating. It's a prime spot if you like your dessert with a side of pedestrian theater. I tried their famous banana pudding -- the one people rave about like it's life-changing. And honestly? I get it. If you're into soft, borderline mushy textures (I am), this one hits the mark. Creamy, sweet but not cloying, with just enough sponge to pretend there's structure. That said, eating a heavy, dairy-forward dessert on a hot day? Maybe not my brightest idea. Felt like my internal temp rose a couple degrees by the end. I grabbed a lemonade to balance it out, but... it was kind of there. Cold, sure. Tart-ish. Not offensive, but not memorable either. Inside, the bakery gives modern country housewife energy -- think white trim, pastel accents, and the faint whiff of nostalgia. No indoor seating though, so the outdoor tables are really your only hangout option. Staff was sweet, like the banana pudding, just less creamy. All in all: cute, classic, and a decent NYC dessert stop -- just maybe don't banana pudding yourself on a 78° day. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I've been to a couple of Magnolia Bakeries before, and they've all been consistently good. My go to is the banana pudding. It's cooling, mildly sweet, creamy, and addictive. If I had to rate this chain, it would be primarily for its service and seating. This specific Magnolia was understaffed by the time we arrived (it was late), but they were able to serve us quickly. There were also only a couple of tables, maybe 2 or 3. Would definitely be more of a take out spot. That's it from me, ty for reading :^) read more

If you're looking for good banana pudding, go here!! Mannnn I could eat their banana pudding daily!! Service was a little slow but nothing too crazy. The ambiance was nice! Overall I was satisfied! read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Classic Banana Pudding - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This was a must stop while visiting New York. Just happened to be in the vicinity while in Central Park so we decided to stop. The line was out the door, took about 20 minutes to order but the staff were very friendly. There are a few seats/tables in the store, but easier to pickup and go. 10/10 Banana pudding - creamy, sweet, delicious. I recommend getting at least a medium size because you will finish it, quickly!! 9/10 Red Velvet cheesecake - soooo rich with the perfect texture. The flavor was spot on. read more

See all

Stopped in on my trip to New York City. We walked past in the sign, noticed that they were famous for their banana pudding. After dinner, I forced my friends to make a pitstop. Oh my, I was absolutely not disappointed. While I was already stuffed to the brim, I made sure to leave room for a small banana pudding, which was affordable and absolutely delicious. My husband ordered a cookie and enjoyed every bite of it. We were greeted by the kindest staff and the cutest atmosphere. They had many different flavors, but the original was my choice. To be honest, I thought so much about that banana pudding that I had to make a second stop later in the weekend. This will definitely be a must visit every time I'm in New York City. read more

Absolutely delicious. Their banana pudding is to die for. This location is always packed but I totally recommend try in it.

I popped in to check the treats out while waiting for friends. The vanilla cupcake caught my eye and I decided to give it a try. It was delicious and I ate the whole thing. The cupcake was fluffy and light and the icing was sweet. The store was also very cute and had outdoor seating. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - One Vanilla Cupcake w/ Vanilla Buttercream - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Their cupcakes are great but I personally think their cake slices are even better! The cheesecake is good too but unfortunately the blondies aren't my favorite. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Cupcakes - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I've booked marked Magnolia Bakery and been waiting to try this place since the "cupcake hype" back in early 2000! Monday afternoon with zero line....and luckily found a table as a couple was leaving. Perhaps it's the Manhattan setting or the holiday season, but the store has an old-fashioned, nostalgic charm, like you are stepping into a classic candy shop. There are about 4 small tables but the intend is really order and take it home to enjoy. The interior décor is very simple with black and white tile, but once you step in there's dozens of cakes, cookies, and cupcakes. I really came in for the banana pudding. While Oct/Nov was pumpkin pudding, the Dec/Jan special is chocolate banana pudding. We got one of each flavor and I personally voted for the chocolate version. The dessert is perfectly sweetened with right amount of pudding and bread crumbles. The cashier was so nice and knowing I was visiting from out of state, had offered for a taste test of another item. Maybe the coldness numbed my stomach (or brain), as I've turned her down. read more

See all

The new banana pudding bar at the UWS location of Magnolia Bakery is pretty close to divine. Flavors include caramel brownie, cookies and cream, red velvet and chocolate hazelnut. We tried the chocolate hazelnut and it was absolutely delicious. I didn't think the Magnolia Bakery banana pudding could be improved upon, but I was most certainly wrong. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Banana pudding bar - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I tried the famous banana pudding and I was not expecting much, but I understand the hype now. I don't typically eat banana pudding, so I I was surprised to have loved the perfectly fluffy and sweetened cream that was not overly sweetened with the perfect amount of stiffness mixed in with sliced bananas and a type of waffers. The waffer maintained it's inner crunch texture or at least the batch I got. I would DEF order it again. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Banana Pudding large - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Crowded and not enough seats so we didn't stay. There isn't an area close by like a park where you can sit an eat either. The banana pudding bar looked inviting though. read more

The famous banana cream pudding is really just ok, nothing special. I wish it was more fragrant and that the wafers were more integrated; they tasted like Nilla wafers that were just thrown in; I wish they were either crumbled or more softened. Seems like a nice place for a casual little sweet treat though. The cupcakes look like there's potential but I haven't tried them. There's a few small tables inside for seating. read more

An ok bakery. The cupcake was moist and had a nice chocolate flavor but was too sweet. The banana pudding was good but nothing special. Service was only ok. read more

See all

Honestly, I really don't know why this Magnolia bakery location doesn't have five stars. This particular Magnolia bakery always has a fresh and plentiful baked good to choose from. Additionally, I've been to this location a few times, and I've never been disappointed with the service. Still further, This location is one of the best in Manhattan because it has cafe-style seating. You can't beat that, especially if you want to order and stay awhile. You may have to wait a bit, but it's well worth it to be able to sit down and enjoy your dessert. I will also say that the service has always been quick and friendly. So please give them a visit and try my favorite, which is the hummingbird cake. Absolutely delicious. read more

See all

I shouldn't have waited so long to try this! Stopped at the upper west side location after a late lunch & was thrilled that the banana pudding lived up to the hype. Arriving around 4pm ish there wasn't that bit of a line but when I got to the counter I was told they didn't have any banana pudding & had a new batch coming up in about 10-15 minutes. This location is slightly bigger than the original so luckily was able to grab a table & waited the 10 minutes. Totally worth the wait. So creamy & delicious all ingredients tasted fresh. They also have seasonal puddings which I will make sure to try the next time I'm in the area. Magnolia serves a variety of other items that were flying off the shelves. They have all you need to satisfy any sweet craving you may have. Make it a priority to stop by & try that pudding! read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Classic Banana Pudding Medium - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Service 5/5 Food 5/5 Their world famous banana pudding is out of this world!! You can't go wrong with their brownie and blondie combo ! Loved their key lime cheesecake. read more

See all

So as a New Yorker, I've been going to Magnolia bakery for years. yesterday I stopped by to pick up a cake and a few items for an event. Magnolia bakery must be really desperate for employees and very short staffed because this guy Nick is absolutely ridiculous and a complete embarrassment as an employee to this company! I'm assuming he's a cashier but I'm not sure exactly what his title was besides unprofessional gossiper. but waiting for my order I sat and listened to this guy, trash this place of business and the owners. He then went on to tell his coworkers how he had left some prominent position to work at Magnolia. The best part was all the loud profanity he was using during this lovely side show he was displaying. This is not what I expect going to McDonald's let alone Magnolia bakery on the upper west side . This was such a huge annoying disappointment and for their prices of food they charge they Really need to reevaluate what kind of staff they have and perhaps hire staff as high-quality as their bakery goods . I look forward to now going to Angelina's bakery for future orders . I can't believe how This place went downhill fast ! Pretty sad . *I ordered their classic banana pudding, which is the best anywhere . * a few of their mouthwatering cupcakes. * velvet cake read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - This is Nick - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

So I've had these multiples times. It's probably my least favorite place to get cupcakes or cake because the one thing they are consistent about is the quality. The cupcake cake and the cake itself is 9/10 times extremely dry and stale. The icing is dry and flaky. I can't tell if they are selling days old products or if it's a quality control issue. This time was no different. The only reason I visited was because I was looking for treats for other people that actually don't mind this place. They need better quality control, sell leftover item on tgtg? My suggestion if you are looking for better quality magnolia cupcakes, order the ones they make prepackaged through wonder. Is it the preservatives? Maybe that's it not sitting out? But, the pre packed ones are alot better than the in store bakery ones they are more moist. Get the banana pudding here, that's really the one item here that is always good. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

See all

There were a lot of people behind the counter and maybe I'm old fashioned but I wish someone would have greeted me or at least gave me a half smile. I hate feeling like I'm an inconvenience when I walk in to a shop. Anyway, I ordered the famous banana pudding. It was pretty excellent. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Banana pudding - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

The best thing about Magnolia Bakery is their Chocolate Covered Strawberry Pudding - It's an incredibly delicious strawberry pudding with giant chunks of chocolate cake mixed in. The texture is amazing and it's very tasty. I wish this was more of a regular item. It was goes very well with my latte. read more

See all

Tried their famous banana pudding and the taste did not disappoint. There were real banana and cake cuttings in it. I do wish they can add more bananas. read more

See all

Love this place, love the staff, love the pudding. Line moves quickly, and everything is always fresh!

Service was very slow but everyone there was super nice! I feel like everything was a bit expensive and small. The classic banana pudding taste good but the red velvet wasn't as good. Overall, not bad. read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

This is a small location but the staff and options were great. My friend had the banana pudding and i had 2 cheesecakes. All the options were great and fresh. We were able to sit outside and enjoy our purchases. I can't wait to come back when I'm in the area read more

Doubled down on the NYC banana pudding to keep it moving. Huge fan but don't want to tell ya'll to ensure there is stock for me and the crew. read more

See all

(Overall: D) - It appears Mangolia Bakery's desserts are all premade numerous days in advance and the lack of freshness is unfortunately quite noticeable. At this rate, I'm not sure why we should go to one of these storefronts to buy such desserts when we can do so at a supermarket instead. (Banana Pudding: C) - Their classic banan pudding is quite delicious and banana forward, but unfortunately the wafers taste like they have been sitting there for a long while and already lost its texture. (Strawberry Shortcake Pudding: F) - This had the same problem as the wafers in the banana pudding, but the strawberries were also discolored and lacked flavor. Would avoid. -- Food: -1 Presentation: E Price: E Atmosphere: E Service: E Menu: -1 Overall: -2 D Insta/Beli: @amei_eats read more

See all

They're famous for banana pudding and cupcakes -- both with rotating special flavors -- but our standard order (for 2 to share) is a $7.95 slice of carrot cake or hummingbird cake. My friend is partial to their icebox cakes and cheesecakes too. The desserts are on the sweeter side. It has a classic pastry shop vibe, featuring a bustling baking space for employees, a full-length glass case filled to the brim with goodies to salivate over, and a steady line of New Yorkers filing in for their fix. Oh, and three tables of indoor seating. read more

came here for the hot cocoa pop up and was soooo happy with the pudding. I'm such a big fan of their specialty pudding flavors, and this is one of the best they've had so far! there was a really long line when we arrived, but workers were diligent in attending to everyone. because of how the place is designed, it can get really really crowded when there's a lot of people, as the line starts to jumble up. however, it was still fairly easy to sit down at the tables and enjoy view outside with the large windows. would definitely come to this location again! read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - Hot Cocoa* pudding - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

Have Been to the Rockefeller center location twice in the past month. I ordered two slices of vanilla cake with chocolate frosting . Both slices were stale. This was not the norm for magnolia. Think the container is not keeping the cake fresh as it used to. The store is always crowded and lines out the door. Used to be my last stop on way out of town to have a sweet treat to go. Probably passing by this spot anymore Think it's grown beyond its capacity to keep quality control. Insert sad face smiley here ! read more

so excited to stop by here! their inside was clean and quaint. it was earlier in the morning so there wasn't many people. banana pudding was delicious. pudding was thick and the ratios were great. wish there was a bit more banana though. the chocolate chip cookie was a bit disappointing. nothing spectacular about it read more

Magnolia Bakery - Upper West Side - banana pudding - Desserts Near Me - New York, New York

I did not expect the freshness and deliciousness I experienced on my first visit. I saw they are constantly baking behind the counter, but I thought it was a gimmick. It's not. They have a ton of customers so they need to continuously make a fresh batch. And fresh it is. Everything I tried was to die for! I'm salivating just writing about it! Heck, I gained half a pound just from writing about it! The miss here is the feel of the place. The tables weren't clean, the floor was messy, the place didn't look very organized. It's an easy fix, but as of this review it was a miss for sure. read more

See all

An iconic piece of New York. We got the caramel pecan cheesecake. It was very sweet, a little too much, but very good. American sweets are always so sugary, which was this. But I ate the whole thing of course. Plenty of seating inside. Good lighting. Friendly staff. read more

See all