The bagels are small and not really worth the money...but I'm just use to big bagels from...everywhere else. My waist line thanks this location for that reason. This location is always out of certain bagels/ specialty bagels. Therefore I can't order the items I'd like to. I don't think it's due to popularity. The bagels/sandwiches look nothing like the pictures hanging around the shop. Very disappointing. The real issue is the owner needs to hire more people. There is always a wait because there is only one woman making the food. I think they also only have one cashier, who also has to make the drinks. I've seen people walk out after waiting and then having to wait for the cashier to stop and make drinks. I would suggest going to any other location. The other locations always have a good supply of bagels. The coffee stations have hotter coffee and even include flavored syrups. The other locations also bring your order to you if you are eating there. Not this location! I've tried it three times and it only gets worse. The last time I even considered just going to QuickChek across the street. read more

Feeling lazy... didn't want to travel the 10 minutes to my 'regular' bagel shop... well that won't happen again. I'm giving the 2 stars to the courteous woman behind the counter, but the rest... meh! Everything looks really great and to be fair, I did only come in for the bagels, which again... LOOK great... well the pictures on the wall anyway. But what I brought home can barely be called bagels. WAY to skinny and so-so in taste. Bagels need to be FAT and delicious... like the pictures on the wall portray, not the skinny baked rolls of dough I brought home. Sorry... they just weren't bagel. read more

Never seen a place that moves at such an incredibly slow pace, it's like everyone was stuck in molasses, the food was expensive and I opened up my bagel and I've never seen such a small bagel before, the smoothie was good though read more

Pretty good selection of offerings and the location honestly is almost second to none being right on the side of a Highway and right down the road from a College you would think this business would be a Million Dollar spot on the 1st day!! But when you place orders here on multiple occasions and each time you wait either an hour, or close to it for a 10-15 minute function you have to wonder why exactly you Stopped here and gave them a chance...or more Importantly Your Time and MONEY!!! Time to Wake up...it's a New Year and All of the Improvements can Happen Today!! Happy New Year Everyone Time to Make 2024 Amazing for each and Everyone of us !! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

if there can be a no star review I'll put it. the lady who makes the bagels ALWAYS MESSES something up. I typically never leave any reviews, but this place makes it feel like an obligation to encourage people to eat at different bagel spots. if it wasn't for the sweet lady cashier I will never come back read more

I've come here a few times and I already expect something to be wrong. They always get the order wrong for some reason yet I still give them a chance. You ask for light cream cheese it's still a glob. You ask for extra butter and it's dry. Minor things but today is my last time as there was a piece of paper in side my bagel .. I'm assuming what the butters wrapped in? I wish I got a pic but I rushed back inside furious to show them and demand I get a new one or my money back. Sadly I won't be back cause I don't want to black out on someone for messing up my food. Don't bother coming here. read more

If you want to wait 20+ minutes for a bagel with cream cheese go ahead! Now I totally understand being understaffed but that's no excuse to be nasty to paying customers. As soon as I walked in one of the employees was already yelling at customers talking about some, "we're short staffed!! don't you see the sign we put up?" she was being completely obnoxious. I had to wait 10 mins to even be acknowledged and for my order to be taken. Being a decent human I of-course said "Hi! How are you?" when approaching to order. This girl just look me in the eyes and said "i'm not doing good, you'll have to wait".... IDGAF if you're having the worst day ever don't meet my kindness with being a b1tch. Do yourself a favor and go to your locally owned bagel shop!! This manhattan bagels location is not it and seems like no one is managing their staff. A general manager needs to come check this store. The only reason i'm even giving 2 stars is because the bagel was edible. Anyway hope the employee continues being miserable read more

Great spot! I enjoyed a delicious avocado egg white, though it would be even better if there were more power outlets near the tables for remote workers. read more

The worse 9 dollars I ever spent. I had a wrap. The wrap was cold. I asked for onions and tomatoes in the omelette. They put a slice of cold tomatoes in my wrap, cold cheese, and it was the most tasteless flat egg I've ever had in my life. I couldn't the difference between the egg and the wrap no lie. read more

Garbage. Dont waste your money here. They always get the the order wrong, croissants were stale, bagels felt frozen. Never coming here again. read more

Absolutely love the vanilla nut coffee here and when you bring your own mug to refill its $1.29. That is awesome. The sandwich's are are good as I like most of them but they are way overpriced to me. I had avocado veg out today and it is $7.49 for it. Come on. It's a thin bagel with avocado spread,onion,lettuce and tomato. It is tasty but I only get it once in awhile. The place is clean and they are very friendly. Enjoy read more

Manhattan Bagel - Refill at a great price - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Went there with a Groupon VERY overpriced Had the egg cheese ham bagel - Came in aluminum wrapping - half the eggs and cheese was on the bagel - the other half on the aluminum - Obviouly was rushed. Had the cheesesteak sand- Very good but had very little in the sandwich - Nothing like the picture shown on the internet - see attached photo Not a bad place to go with a 50% coupon but not otherwise ! read more

See all

I waited here for 20 min on my lunchtime just to receive a wrong order. You know what's frustrating, that people just assume they know what I'm ordering after hearing just begging of the sentence. I like Sunrise Bagel much more. I wasted my whole lunch time here. read more

Just here to remind you this place is full of dumb@sses. My (well intentioned) boyfriend tried to pick up a sandwich from this location for me and as per all the reviews below and on Google, they screwed it up almost entirely. I forgot to tell him to go to Totowa instead. Avoid this location like the plague, you'll get more reception from a steaming pile of dog sh- read more

Miserable experience. I picked up lunch for my wife and myself. Shouldn't be difficult. A Turkey sandwich and a bagel with nova. When I got home, no nova. I drove back. The woman behind the counter remembered me and my order. After getting asked numerous questions, they returned my bagel with nova. No apologies. Just an attitude. Won't return to this location. See the response. Still no apology read more

Disappointed with Manhattan Bagel!!! There was only one other customer in the store who ordered prior to me entering. I noticed right away that a few workers were just standing around while some were cooking/filling online orders. This is just bad business. Finally, I ordered the new Avocado Egg White breakfast sandwich. When I got to work, I realized it's a totally different sandwich. There was no spread and it was not even on an everything bagel as advertised. It was also super messy and nothing bothers me more then trying to eat something and it all falls apart and gets all over the place. Disappointed. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

You want to talk about being uncomfortable the second you walk in?! Omg just awful I should have just walked out! I ran in to get a fast cup of coffee and walked into the owner or manager yelling at a worker right behind the counter while the other two employees looked on. I stood there a few seconds and finally got the cashiers attention and ordered. The man yelling then realized there was a customer and looked at me so I shook my head to let him know it was awkward. I then went to get my coffee and he cane running over asking if I needed anything and tried to make conversation . I just ignored him. Then two male workers came out of a kitchen and just stood there staring at me which made me feel disgusting. I would never set foot in that place again, clearly no respect for women and side note the coffee was awful I threw it away and stopped at Dunkin' Donuts instead read more

This place is way too overpriced $7.77 for a bacon egg and cheese on a plain bagel. Service is not great the did not answer the phone multiple times. read more

Manhattan Bagel had been teased for many months on the site of an old 7-11 which had closed close to two years ago. I arrived first thing in the morning on the day of their grand opening to be one of the first 100 folks to receive a coupon book for 52 free breakfast sandwiches. So I will be at Manhattan Bagel at least once a week over the course of the next year! The location looks gorgeous! Plenty of seating both with tables and without. This will be a nice alternative for me to sit down and do homework since they do have wi-fi. I ordered a ranchero wrap which was delicious. Fresh eggs cooked to-order, bagels freshly made, and they have an assortment of bakery treats as well. Coffee is absolutely amazing as well here! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Chelsea Chicken! - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Good breakfast sandwiches. Fast service. Everything seems freshly made. Definitely recommend for on-the-go quick bite.

Only stopped in quickly to grab a latte and bagel. First impression- clean, organized, presentation of items for sale- drinks, fruit, etc -good. Service was very pleasant and efficient which is a major bonus in my opinion. Latte is good and hubby said his coffee was good. The French toast bagel was tasty. They seem to have a variety of items on the menu. I'll return to try something else I'm sure. read more

Over priced for what I got. The lox wasn't fresh and had a small as well as the fruit they served was completely moldy.

Not great. Not horrendous to the point I was contemplating throwing it out but by no means great. Stale croissant, bagels weren't fresh .. mind you it was 0615, they had just opened. Quite possibly yesterday's stuff. Won't be back. Would have rather had 7/11 coffee than their vanilla latte. Save your money and pass this place. read more

This is our favorite Manhattan Bagel. It's spacious, and the staff is friendly. The manager is really nice and welcoming. He always makes it a point to walk around and greet everybody. He said hi to our kids and this visit gave them each a chocolate chip cookie. Who doesn't love free cookies? Today we had a sausage egg and cheese on a sesame seed bagel, an egg and and cheese on a multigrain bagel, and scrambled eggs with hash browns. For our drinks we had a coffee and a freshly squeezed orange juice. Our order always comes out correct and the food is cooked just right. We also had a local flavor deal that gave us $10 off $20. We will definitely be back for more cookies and of course bagels. read more

See all

If this place is local it is definitely worth a try for a quick breakfast or lunch. They were out of croissants so we weren't able to get the chicken salad on a croissant. Had the nova lox on a plain bagel and the turkey and cheddar sandwiches were both pretty good but nothing to write home about. It was understandable that since it was about 1 hour before closing the bread choices were more limited and not as fresh. Later on, we were given some desserts on the house which was nice of them. That made me want to give them 4 stars but I can't based on the fact that overall the food was just okay. Atmosphere is good and place was clean which was a plus. I would like to try the breakfast as well and see if it's better. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Ok, not the best pictures but we were hungry. Nova lox and the turkey cheddar. - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Great new neighborhood bagel shop. It's brand new and been a while in the making. I have my favorite local bagel spots but this place holds its own. The staff is what makes this great place to get a bagel or breakfast/lunch. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Less than 1 star. This place is garbage. Don't go here. Literally go anywhere else. I stopped ordering from this bagel shop about 2 years ago because my order was wrong every time. They don't answer the phone, and when they do they hang up on you because their job is too difficult and can't handle talking on the phone. I ordered off of Uber eats today from Manhattan bagel. I figured after 2 years maybe they got themselves together. I wasn't shocked to find that the ENTIRE order was wrong. Every meal, hash browns, EVERYTHING. Even the orange juice is wrong. How do you mess up a bottle of orange juice? When I called to correct the matter, they only said i can get a refund on a $2 hash brown. What kind of business is that? They don't give a sh!t. Never have. I'll never order from here again. By the way, I got a full refund off Uber eats, so good job idiots. read more

I had a problem at this location the last time I went in and the ownership immediately contacted me and made it right. I'm very happy that they took the extra step to speak to me about my issues and concerns and make it right. I feel much better about this level of customer service and definitely feel more valued as a client and will most certainly be returning to this location again. Thank you. read more

They are the only Manhattan Bagel in the tri-state area that don't serve cheddar Bagels which is ridiculous and they're losing my business because they have no selection read more

It was good, but not the best I've had. The thing I liked was that it wasn't greasy like a lot of other bagel shops. I got a breakfast sandwich and didn't feel bad after I ate it which I liked. They also make an amazing ice caramel macchiato! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Turkey bacon egg and cheese with hashbrowns, salt pepper ketchup on a honey whole wheat everything bagel - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Had a very nice Chicken wrap for lunch and an awesome Taylor Ham, egg and cheese sandwich for breakfast. Delivery was a little slow but well worth the wait in my opinion. Breakfast done right, would recommend. read more

I ordered a nova bagel with cream cheese and smoked salmon. The bagel was a little too salty and had waaay too much cream cheese on it. The service was fast and friendly, I just wasn't crazy about the food. read more

One of my favorite breakfast spots. Not only because Rudy is always so energetic at 7 AM, but also because they have the BEST coffee ever! Their vanilla nut coffee is a perfect brew (sometimes I mix it with the original blend). I try to get creative by mixing the cream cheese spreads too. I like the assortment of flavors offered. Great sandwiches/bagels too! My favorite is the egg white, mushroom and asparagus on a wheat thin bagel. Yum! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

When this particular Manhattan Bagel first opened it was the place to go....but things have significantly gone down hill. I have tried several times, since the place reopened due to the Covid pandemic, but they have not be able to get my order correct once. There is nothing worse then wanting to enjoy the food you just purchased, getting all the way home, sit down and come to find out the food you were given does not even remotely come close to what you had ordered. I don't think I will go back, I am tired of paying for orders that they just can't get right. read more

I did not get to try their bagels. Their customer service was really dumb & upset me. I stood behind another customer, under the 'Order Here' sign. A group walked in & an attendant started taking their orders. I remained at my spot as another group walked in. Nobody looked at me for 10 minutes, & when I asked, they said, "Oh, this register isn't working; we're taking orders over there." I cursed them out & left. I will never try a Manhattan bagel! read more

Worst service ever ! They have like 7 people working the front and they cant, even get the orders correct , this is my 3rd time going there . read more

Ordered the Chelsea chicken and it was delicious. The bread was fresh, great tomato spread on it as well. Comes with a pickle and potato salad. Been looking for a good sandwich place in the area and for sure I'll be back. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Chelsea Chicken very good and fresh - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Placed an order with them for our Brunch, we were told no problem. Went to pick it up and were told they got busy and sold our bagels! Will never place an order with them again! We will stick to our Mom and Pop businesses from now on! read more

Bright, clean, ample seating, nothing like the other Manhattan Bagels I've been to -- a very nice addition to Wayne. Pleasantly surprised! Great selection of bagels. Huge selection of flavored packaged cream cheese, coffee bar, extra good yogurt parfait in the refrigerated area with nice mixed fruit in there. Good assorted drinks. Coffee bar, the cinnamon coffee is great. Bagel "package" deals with accoutrements. Catered orders can be delivered to your site. Lunch sandwiches are on the menu, too. Good parking. Convenient location. When I can't get a spot at Starbucks or don't wanna pay those prices, I will be perfectly happy to get a cinnamon coffee here for under $2.00, get a parking space no problem here, enjoy the happy 80's background music and have a better yogurt & fruit here than the other place! And did I see they have doggie treats for sale??? My lab says "thanks"! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Lox capers onion & shmear on whole wheat everything. Very good. - Bagels Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

I made an order and had specific instructions. Didn't get 2 things out of 5 items AND also asked for no egg on a specific sandwich which was completely ignored. I ordered the sandwich for someone without egg because they are allergic!!!!! What a mess! Probably won't be getting food from this location again....very unfortunate because I love Manhattan bagel. I attempted to call the store after this, and of course, their phone line goes straight to a voicemail. They seriously need to get it together. Not good for business. Customers, beware and be careful!!! read more