Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Me Oh My Pie

    3.9 (124 reviews)
    Open 7:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 2 weeks ago

    Me Oh My Pie Photos

    ME OH MY PIE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Good for kids
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Me Oh My Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Blueberry, lavender pie and Chagaccino Latte

    I highly recommend Me Oh My Pie for a fun locals scratch kitchen breakfast or lunch. They are best known for their delicious pies. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, and the staff is knowledgeable and friendly.

    Lox bagel
    Mary B.

    Once again this place never disappoints! Lox bagel was delicious... but they're taking a break on bagels for awhile... I got the last one. Always good, quick service. Thanks!

    had a great experience today with the server lizzie! she was very respectful and helpful when I asked her what pie to get and she looked like a very hard worker. the sandwich was delicious

    bike ride to pie
    Rachael R.

    Me Oh My has a great location, and the food is good. However, they have the slowest service and longest wait times in town. Today my two friends and I waited for almost an hour for a to-go order of a sandwich, an iced coffee, and a galette. After 40 minutes, my friend was called up and staff told her they were out of galettes, said they couldn't refund her, and asked what else she wanted. She opted for two slices of pie that came out right away. It was another 10 minutes after that she finally got her iced coffee. A long line of people waited at an un-manned cash register for an unreasonable amount of time, and at least 5 people walked out before ordering. I wish I could say this was an uncommon occurrence or an off day, but this is my experience every time I visit. I really want them to succeed and think they are a great asset to the community, but some serious restructuring might be necessary.

    Orion's apothecary goods
    Nora A.

    Delicious pie has arrived at Loveland location! A small shop with limited hours, the pie AND the crust are good! Its a cute spot to have a dessert after lunch or a coffee with a pastry. The staff was knowledgeable and nice. Also a place to buy Orion's Apothecary items! Teas and tinctures and potions galore!

    Chicken pie slice
    Martina O.

    This review is actually for the Loveland location at 29th St, next to Pho lan. This place is a gem with their pie selection! Plenty of seatings, meat pies are gluten free. Came in for a late lunch, a slice of pie and iced americano just the way I like it yum!! Casual ambiance and friendly service.

    interior away from counter area
    Michael J.

    Beautiful place, so comforting! Delicious sausage gravy over focaccia toast and a perfect bowl of pork posole. Try the spicy pumpkin chai, it's amazing.

    Zoom in to see the grossness
    Elizabeth P.

    My husband and I had lunch here last week and the food ranged from just okay to inedible. Also, even though it wasn't busy, our very simple sandwiches took a full twenty minutes to come out. My croissant sandwich was mediocre (turkey was weird and the bottom was super soggy) and my husband's focaccia sandwich was inedible. He said the bread tasted like a stale crouton. The salad on my husband's plate was just old and gross. He also got a chocolate chip cookie that tasted like freezer.

    Sweet Potato Hash
    Sandra S.

    This place is amazing! My boyfriend and I came for the first time the other day and got the build your own veggie sandwich and the sweet potato hash. And let me just say we were veryyyy satisfied ;) The staff are all very nice, easy going, and genuine. The restaurant itself is very family friendly, comfortable, and calming. It was so good that we decided to bike from Fort Collins for another one of their veggie sandwiches today! Love it here, definitely our new spot. (oh and there's local art for sale!)

    #2 sandwich with terrible gluten free bread, rock hard tahini cookie, blueberry muffin
    Alexa B.

    This place is pretty inconsistent on whether you will get good drinks, food, and service or not. I've had drinks that were so bad I had to take them back, and I've had drinks that were fine. Most of their baked goods are either too dry or hard, or soggy/soft. I am gluten free, and the way they offer GF bread for their sandwiches is a joke...the bread can't hold together. It has been served to me broken apart on the plate, and the fact they were serve that is embarrassing to them. They also have a bee hive on their deck, I think underneath, and they have swarmed and sent my two boys and I running inside. When I told them about the hive they seemed completely unbothered. The only pro, and reason I have been here multiple times, is that they have a few kids toys. All in all, I would skip this place and go to Little Bird or Explorado Market.

    Menu as of 11/20

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Me Oh My Pie Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Me Oh My Pie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Cafes 194 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Fox Den - PB&J

    The Fox Den

    4.3(40 reviews)
    3.1 mi
    $

    I had been meaning to try Fox Den for a few years now. It gets good reviews and I've heard good…read morethings about them. Just a couple days ago a friend mentioned Fox Den was one of her favorite coffee places. I guess it was just a little out of the way for me. I didn't make my own coffee this morning on purpose. We were going out to get coffee and a bag of whole beans from one of my favorite FC coffee shops. I suddenly realized I could use this opportunity to finally stop by Fox Den. The SO asks if I want to go there instead. I say yes, but with a little hesitation. I mean how good can this place really be? Will it live up to expectations? Does the "No Waste" theme come at the cost of compromising coffee quality? Upon entering the cafe, I see a wall of mugs to choose from. I pick the Mickey Mouse one. I place my standard new coffee shop order-a cortado and drip coffee. The barista taking my order says that's his favorite mug. The drip coffee comes first. I chose the light roast. It has mild acid, barely perceptible bitterness, and nice smoothe coffee flavor. I really can't ask for a more balanced cup of coffee. One of the best drip coffees I've had in a cafe. My cortado is up. The barista apologizes for his subpar latte art. It's not that bad. Consistently good latte art is not as easy as some baristas make it look, and baristas are allowed to be human. Besides, this is not the Louvre and art is not what I'm here for, no apology necessary. This cortado is excellent. The high quality pulled shots of expresso shine through the nicely steamed whole milk. I have to know which blends they used in my drinks. El Zorro for the cortado and Foxy Gal for the drip. I compliment the other barista on the shop's coffee. She humbly tells me, "the shots are pulling well today". Typically, when I get my usual cortado and drip coffee, one is better than the other, even if slightly so. Not today. Today both are of equally high caliber. It is a good coffee day.

    This place used to be the spot! They had amazing food, great coffee, and wonderful staff…read more Unfortunately, it seems like the establishment has really gone downhill. They're no longer a waste-free café, and they no longer offer freshly cooked meals. Food is now prepackaged (and doesn't taste good!) and unfortunately, the service has declined quite a bit as well. That said, I will give them credit where it's due--the coffee is still pretty good!

    Photos
    The Fox Den
    The Fox Den - Grilled cheese and breakfast potatoes

    Grilled cheese and breakfast potatoes

    The Fox Den

    See all

    The Little Bird Bakeshop - Seasonal Fruit Bostock (my fav of the 3 items), Lemon Lavender Pound Cake (?), Brioche Cinnamon Roll with Orange Cream Cheese Frosting

    The Little Bird Bakeshop

    4.4(277 reviews)
    4.6 mi
    $$

    I'm new to Fort Collins and have already been to The Little Bird Bakeshop twice for business…read moremeetings. Both visits were great. Excellent coffee, seriously good food, and the staff has been incredibly kind and welcoming each time. The atmosphere is one of the best parts -- cool historic building, relaxed vibe, and just a really comfortable place to spend time. It feels like the kind of spot you can use for anything: work meetings, hanging out with friends, or just enjoying a quiet morning by yourself. Definitely becoming one of my go-to places in Fort Collins.

    I have been to Little Bird Bakeshop a few times, the old and new locations. The quality of their…read morebaked goods is consistently high. Today, the croque monsieur (the SO cringes at the way I pronounce it when I order because it sounds kind of like "croak mon-sewer") was particularly good. The SO's mushroom quiche was custardy with a good amount of mushrooms. The walnut chocolate chip cookie was an excellent thick homemade type of cookie. The sourdough loaf was spot on. As an every day black coffee drinker, I have to say, they were having a really bad coffee day. After a few sips of my coffee, I went back to counter and put a bunch of half and half into my mug of coffee. The barista was looking at me with an expression that said, "You should have ordered an espresso drink". They are forgiven for one bad coffee day.

    Photos
    The Little Bird Bakeshop - Plants too!

    Plants too!

    The Little Bird Bakeshop - Cherry Chocolate Pistachio Pastry

    Cherry Chocolate Pistachio Pastry

    The Little Bird Bakeshop - Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Alleycat Coffee House - Cappuccino

    Alleycat Coffee House

    4.0(243 reviews)
    4.6 mi
    $$

    The coffee shop is on the second floor, take the exterior stairs for the entrance (there…read moreunfortunately appears to be no way of getting up without stairs). Very cool artsy psychedelic vibe, with lots of comfortable seating in a few different rooms. The barista who took my order seemed friendly, and they called my name loudly enough when my drink was ready that I could hear it from the next room. I had a piece of strawberry bread and an iced spiced chai, both really good! The strawberry bread had this fresh, rustic homemade taste to it that I loved, and it was a huge slice. The chai was appropriately strong - the spicy chai is made with soy milk, but the tea was rich enough that I didn't really pick up on the soy flavour. I could tell it was proper chai and not something made from a packaged concentrate. I wish I lived in Fort Collins so I could come here all the time!

    I actually LOVE this place but unfortunately the last three times over different days and times of…read morethe week that I've gone there to get work done there isn't a single place to sit. Not even up at the coffee bar. Sadly this place is entirely overcrowded with students who instead of utilizing their on campus resources and places to study or do homework, take up spaces like this at all hours and evidently send customers elsewhere. It's frustrating for someone like me who needs/wants the reprieve from busy crowded daily life in the evening without going to a bar. This is one of the only late night cafes open in the area and every time I plan to spend any significant time or money there I unfortunately have to leave because there's nowhere to sit. Hopefully AlleyCat is making the money it appears they should be with a space so crowded.

    Photos
    Alleycat Coffee House
    Alleycat Coffee House
    Alleycat Coffee House - Menu and main order counter

    See all

    Menu and main order counter

    Wolverine Farm Publick House - Library area

    Wolverine Farm Publick House

    4.8(43 reviews)
    4.3 mi
    $$

    Wolverine Farm is a curious oasis of humanity in a sea of mediocrity. Buy or browse their eclectic…read moreselection of literature and poetry while enjoying a latte and scone. They have ample room for groups upstairs and outside and host a wide variety of public events. Be sure to look for unexpected wonders in their garden outside, or craft your next poem on their outdoor magnetic poetry wall.

    Tip Extortion Been…read moregoing there occasionally for 5 years. Service was hit and miss. Some staff friendly, some merely aloof, some seemingly hostile. Never could figure it out. Gave them the benefit of the doubt. I always support independent shops when possible. Friends don't let friends go to Starbucks... A few days ago it became clear. I ordered a bagel and requested it be toasted enough not to be raw inside. About half the time that's what I got. I paid and saw they wanted a tip upfront. I feel asking for a tip before earning it is unethical. So I selected no tip. I would gladly leave a dollar after. One of the staff, let's call him "Chris", toasted my bagel and delivered it to me burnt. No overdone. Burnt. As in mostly black. I said it was burnt. He replied that I requested it "double toasted". I looked at him like he was speaking in Swahili. I explained that I merely wanted it toasted and not raw inside. He insisted that I ordered it that way. He did not take my order. I said she wrote it but I did not say it. He insisted that I, the customer, was somehow so stupid as to not know how to order a bagel. I said "would you eat this"? Amazingly, he said with a straight face "yes". I replied that he could eat it but I want what I ordered. The baged was an insult. A childish lame attempt at revenge or punisihment. At this point "Chris" leaned over and told me I should be nice. Nice? Nice! I was flabbergasted. I was being scolded by kid a third my age. I was stunned. Was this a joke? Yes, but he was serious. It was an absolutely stunning display of passive-aggressive behavior. Delivered with a condescending smirk and self-righteousness. I replied that I am not nice and so what. He then insisted that I be nice. I said I am from the Midwest and we tend to be direct. It's not rude. It's the way we communicate. Honestly without hedging. This sailed right over his head unacknowledged, Then the truth. You didn't leave a tip he said. How did he know I didn't tip on the little checkout screen? I tried to explain my view on tipping that it needs to be earned. "Chris" was adamant that they expect tips as they are not paid much and work "hard". I reiterated my view and called tipping up front unearned and possibly undeserved as like Socialism. "Chris" did not like that and said that "people of my generation (Boomers are Bad!) don't get it." He further lectured me on how underpaid they were and that the "need" and thus "deserve" tips regardless of what service they offer. He then declared that a dollar tip was entirely insufficient. I replied that $1 on a $4 bagel was a 25% tip. He repeated that it was too little regardless. I said then how much is fair. He did not answer. My guess is that he knew as much about the mathematics of percentages as he knows about Swahili dialects. I offered that if they were to ask for tips after, the honorable way, they would earn more. People are motivated above all by fairness and would hedge on tips not knowing if they would be earned. "Chris" gave me the obligatory hourly-wage employee response that "that's the way it is"... The self-declared creatives have the ingenuity of cows munching grass. Then a kid decided to be a hero and intervened saying "WE don't have a problem with the tipping". In a stunning display of sociotropic behavior, he elected himself to defend the shop and represent all other patrons. I ran out of patience and told him to STFU. At this point the heroine server, who decided I like burnt bagels, told me to leave. So I did leave. I regret every penny I spent there to support their shop. So now I know why even as I liked the layout of the place, and all their countless little books promoting a myriad of pretentious woke socialist utopia topics, I never felt comfortable there. The all-inclusive did not like me invading their "Safe Space". Instead of just telling me "hey, this is our space not yours Boomer Boy" they instead were a case study in passive aggressiveness. A coward's way to feel all smug and self-righteous. Since they present themselves as fans of "literature" here is a literary quote (Kurt Vonnegut Jr. in Slaughterhouse Five... said to the character Billy Pilgrim in a hospital upon his return from being a prisoner of war in Dresden, Germany... "I can carve a better man out of a banana" So I see that they have high ratings from their intended audience and I am a mere interloper. My little One star rating will not be noticed. I will end this saying "Be Nice"... "Stay Safe".... be good little normies.... tell your friends to go to Starbucks. p.s. The Wolverine is the state animal of Michigan, where I am from. It is fearless and righteous. No other animal takes it on. You don't deserve the name. May I suggest the "Weasel Farm Safe Place"...

    Photos
    Wolverine Farm Publick House
    Wolverine Farm Publick House - Sitting next to the outside patio with my Cuppa Joe.

    Sitting next to the outside patio with my Cuppa Joe.

    Wolverine Farm Publick House

    See all

    Me Oh My Pie - cafes - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...