A pizza like no other! I first had Mellow Mushroom in Athens, GA, the college town of their origin. I can safely say they are still the best! There's no substitute for quality ingredients. Look at the rise on this dough! It rained all day and they turned out a stellar product! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

We have always liked this location, even though we live closer to another one. Tonight we decided to go with friends for a quick pizza dinner. We ordered an appetizer of chicken wings and after about 45 minutes, asked the waitress what was up. She told us they had delivered the wings to the wrong table. I get that things happen, but if you mess up, say so and apologize. It would have made a difference. Then the manager came by and asked how everything was, like he always does, which we have appreciated on past visits. I said everything was fine, but we waited a long time for an appetizer of wings, that were delivered to the wrong table. He winced, but made no effort to apologize. Ok.... So the wings finally came, then the pizzas. We ate and paid the bill. I was surprised to see we were charged for the wings, considering how long we waited because of the first order going to the wrong table. They were only $7.99, but it would have been a nice gesture to take them off the tab or come by and apologize, something is better than nothing. I'm disappointed because this location was my favorite. read more

My hubby took me here to eat & visit for their Epic Trivia (vendor name) night. The kids then adults were competing for $mula$ playing Super Mario Cart. We got there too late to be able to compete but now that I'm fully aware of how much I'm not missing next weekends! Lol my hubby told me he thought it might be around 5-10 bucks, nope! I couldn't believe when the host told me how much for 1st, 2nd, and even 3rd place. They have a FB or IG page too if you want to check them out. Not sure how long it's going on but pretty cool esp w the fact that I'm youngest is home schooling so I been needing things like this for him to partake in. They also have other types of game night throughout the week like Trivia Night too... On to the food, I've visited the WP location but to me this one's far better. They have so much cool decor and huge tables as well as huge bar area right smack in the middle that is half inside/outside as well as outdoor eating. Kudos to them too because we ordered late and the food was still piping hot/freshly made. I got the marg pizza w peppers added and jerk wings (baked) mm mm! You don't have to ask me twice I'm sold on game night next weekend! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

This place has gone downhill since my last visit a few years ago. It has a cool atmosphere but the food is terrible. My appetizer was not cooked thoroughly, in fact part frozen. Had that taken off bill. Got a pizza togo instead....they do have good beers on tap. Got home, took one bite and threw the rest away. What a shame. What happened to this place?????? read more

I will start off by saying amazing pizza! I'm not crazy about pizza so when I find a place I like I know it's special. I tried this place once because a coworker gave me a slice one day and I loved it and I said I have to go back for more. We came in on a Saturday night and it was rainy so it was not crowded at all. I have been seeing ads for the Taco Nirvana pizza so I ordered that. You get to chose between chicken or beef topping and I went with the beef. I also ordered honey sriracha wings for an appetizer. Both did not disappoint as I knew they wouldn't. The wings were fresh, great flavor, and not too spicy. It was like a Thai chili sauce which I love. The pizza was hot, flavorful and that sauce was amazing. Make sure to ask for extra sauce to dip the pizza in. The pizza really did taste like a cross between pizza and tacos as the meat is flavored with taco seasoning. The service was just as great. We had a very attentive waiter that made sure we got everything we needed. Needless to say I'm a fan and will be back. Pizza quality was a 10 and the leftovers tasted even better heated up in the air fryer the next day. read more

See all

Ever since I've been in the central Florida area, I have enjoyed Mellow Mushroom. I recently went to this location and the experience was no different; a very colorful, dynamic atmosphere, delicious food always served hot, and fantastic shareables. This time, I got the Mighty Meaty, which is one of my absolute favorites on their menu. Our waiter was great, answering questions for us about the menu and giving us suggestions based on what we were in the mood for. The only downside to our visit was the cleanliness of the restaurant. It's usually very clean and organized, but it seemed like this time around, the table we were sat at was a bit more dirty, and the floor needed a bit more care. Aside from that, this is one of our fave places to splurge on pizza. It's not super cheap, but the food quality is well worth the price! They don't skimp on toppings and the pizza is always perfectly crispy and delicious! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Mighty Meaty - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

For 7 of us, we got 3 medium pizzas and the honey Sriracha wings. It was enough for us, and still had a slice leftover to take home. There were 9 wings - tender meat with a good sauce. We asked for a side of Mike's hot honey which was complimentary. We got the mushroom, Pacific rim, and house specials which I liked in that order. The hot honey was especially good with the mushroom. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Our table of four came in around 9:00/9:15. The bartender was flirting with one guy at the bar and hanging all over him instead of serving the table. She saw we needed service once our food was out and still didn't come check on us. I had to get up for sauces/seasonings and the two times she came by for boxes and checks I had to call her back bc she was rushing away after she dropped off our checks. She didn't ask how we wanted the check, she just brought out one check for a double date. She was extremely distracted. None of us were happy with the neglectful service from her. Food was good and out in a decent time. Wish we had better service. read more

We came to have dinner last night, and the food and service were just GREAT! Our server, Zell, was amazing and made us several recommendations for the food and apps. He was, for sure, on top of everything, making sure we were satisfied. The food was AMAZING; we ordered the SHITAKE pizza... and it was short of DELICIOUS... one of the best pizzas ever!!! Seriously, this place has ALWAYS the best of the best... we have visited multiple locations, and quality is fantastic! Also, the decor, art and music is always right on the money! Highly recommend it! read more

See all

We went here on a Sunday about 5:45 pm, service was terrible. Our waitress kept passing us multiple times not even checking if our food was good or anything. The food took an excessive amount of time to get and our waitress when we were ordering we explained it multiple times still didn't get the pizza, right noticed that we were a little upset in picking off the items to put it on a different side so that it would be how we ordered it. Noticing that we were upset she gave us a sarcastic response, trying to lighten the mood, but made it even worse didn't even say sorry for the mishap. read more

Always solid pizza with great service ! I like the meat lover pizza and beer selection is good. Try it

I have seen this place for years but never dared to try it! Last night we finally decided to try it out and we regret nothing. The restaurant is beautiful and big. The service was good, Sel did such a great job explaining everything since it was our first time. We happened to go on music bingo! It was a fun experience while we ate our pizza and calzone. I also had the casa amigos margarita and it was tasty and fresh. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and it was exceptional. the crust was so crispy yet soft and seasoned beautifully. The pizza itself tasted delightful. The calzone was good and super cheesy! The only thing I would say, is that the restaurant could use a deep cleaning. The booths looked a little dirty, and the walls too. This is something that could make a big difference for customers. Other than that, I can't wait to be back and try new items on the menu! read more

See all

Really good service and food. Manager is very friendly. Every time I come the service is always excellent. Kam and Mackenzie are always amazing! read more

We decided on a whim to get dinner at Mellow Mushroom, and the store in Sanford didn't disappoint. The meals for the kids were perfect. We order the loaded potato pizza, which is so unique: so many carbs but worth the indulgence. The Artichoke dip is *chef's kiss*. Pro tip: don't order water. It's not their fault. The tap water is awful no matter where you go in Sanford. Mellow Mushroom has such a happy vibe. It's our go to when traveling. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Kids Pretzel - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

We came out with the kids after we got our tax refund. We got spinach artichoke dip, the loaded potato pizza. The kids got the mac and cheese and the pretzel dipper kids meals. The kids ate it all. I loved the dip and potato pizza. The pacific rim was fine. The restaraunt wasnt super busy on a thursday night. I was relaxed and had a good time. Wait staff was hustling and did a great job. I will be back. read more

See all

Waited almost five minutes to be seated. We were fighting gnats flying around. It took 40 minutes for the appetizer to come out, cold pizza rolls that were nasty. All the food was lukewarm. The QR code on the bill did not work to pay online. This location in Sanford is a disgrace to the Mello Mushroom name! Don't waste your time or money, you'll be disappointed! read more

Ordered by 8:08pm and 40 minutes later my order was not done! Was asked to wait ANOTHER 15 minutes for the pizza as they are "busy".... Seems as if they FORGOT to do the pizza and are NOW doing it! First time here and definitely the last... A free drink is NOT a good offer for waiting this long! Do better, be better! read more

Finally got here, after discussing doing so for about 20 years, lol! They have a full bar, which is where we sat to eat. Husband happy with the beer selection, unhappy with the beer menu, as it was not up to date and had one of his favorites listed, which they did not have. We split a Cuban po'boy, which I guess had the addition of lettuce and tomato because the preparer thought it should? It was delicious on french bread. In fact, we both agreed it was even better then when pressed. Or maybe it was just how good that bread was? Also the pork was out of this world. I thought the ham was good, but my husband thought the ham was even better than the pork. At any rate, bottom line, Delicious! read more

See all

The wings were $13 and the small veg out pizza was $13. With that being said the wings were 100% NOT WORTH IT! We ate outside and the amount of flies surrounding us and our food was disgusting. We left around 5:15pm and we were bombarded with them the entire time we were here eating and waiting. We ordered beers via the happy hour menu but we were charged regular price for the beers. We needed to remind our server that he said it was happy hour and the price should be $4 less per beer during our time sitting here. The waiter messed up our order 2 times and was visibly unhappy to be there. We overheard him complaining to his coworkers that he was hungover from the night before. Not a great experience here! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Oven Roasted Wings- not worth it. Overcooked - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Love this place. Good service. A great menu and I've never been disappointed with a meal.

My Son and I visited the Mellow Mushroom today and order two medium, two topping pizzas, two sodas and an order of their new pizza rolls. The server was attentive and courteous. The food tasted good and we enjoyed our meal. The restaurant was clean and there were plenty of televisions to keep your attention. When we were finished, the server gave us the check and I was shocked. Maybe it's me and it very well may be. However, $71 seems high for pizza, in my opinion. That's not including the tip. If you decide to visit this restaurant, be prepared.... read more

I have been to this location two times in the past 4 weeks. The first time was a dine-in experience. When we got there, the hostess was busy doing something at the bar, but she acknowledged us right away and told us we would be seated soon. I ordered a cheese and avocado hoagie. It came stuffed with plenty of fresh avocado that was just the right level of ripeness. I also had the creamy Mellow Mushroom Soup, chock full of portobello mushrooms, a mushroom lover's delight. My son ordered a pizza. Both came out rather quickly, Unlike many pizzerias whose crust is just a conduit for delicious toppings, Mellow Mushroom crust is like eating a soft pretzel--two yummy treats in one. The second time I ordered from this location was for takeout. We got my favorite--Holy Shiitake with portobello mushrooms, garlic aioli, chives, and caramelized onions. Yum! When I called, they said the order would be ready in about 25 minutes. When I arrive in 20 minutes, it was already out piping hot! I will be back whenever I am in the area. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Avocado and cheese hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Excellent pizza and service Our go to pizza place when visiting Sanford Service has always been very good too read more

We waited for an hour for our food and finally left without our pizza. Super slow and inattentive service.

Mellow mushroom has a great menu, especially if you are gluten free! This restaurant features one of the best GF crusts I have had in a long time. The pricing is fare and the atmosphere is great for any kind of party. The bar area is large and usually empty. This visit I had pretzel bites, a tequila mule, and a half cheese half bacon pizza. The pretzel bites are good, but a little greasy. The mule was nice and refreshing! The pizza came out cooked well, with nice flavor. It does have a thicker crust so thin crust fans beware when ordering traditional pies! The only downfall here is the service is a little on the slower side but not terrible if you have appetizers and drinks to help the wait seem less. However, the servers and bartenders are all friendly and welcoming. I love coming here for a great pie and drinks with friends! read more

See all

It's been a long while since I've some Mellow Mushroom. I definitely felt deep in my soul that pizza was necessary, so Mellow was the way to go! Didn't feel like going to pick it up, so ordered via Uber Eats. I ordered the Philosopher's Pie: olive oil base with grilled ribeye, portobello mushrooms, artichoke hearts, and kalamata olives, along with provolone, feta, and mozzarella cheeses. Yes please!! It took a while for the pizza to get to me, so it wasn't as hot as I would have liked upon arrival, but nothing a lil nuking couldn't fix. That Philosopher's Pie had me feeling as such when I contemplated life and the awesomeness of each bite with all those great toppings. And the perfection of that crust, not too doughy and nowhere near crispy. Absolutely magnificent!! I probably shouldn't take so long to patron the Mushrooms of Mellowness again. Duly noted. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - a cardboard box with a logo on it - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

They have really good pizza and a cool vibe with friendly employees. Their mighty meats pizza is awesome and a must try if you are a meat eater. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Slice of their Mighty Meats pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

If you are gluten free, don't eat their pizza unless you want to be sad. Worst crust I've ever tasted. I've had better pizza from the frozen section of Walmart, I'm not even sure the crust is even made in house. Very disappointing. read more

We recently discovered this Mellow Mushroom franchise in Sanford, and it's become a regular Sunday night event for us! We always ask for Elizabeth as our server because she's warm, ebullient and attentive. She's a great conversationalist. The meatballs are a must! They're filled with mozzarella and top with an excellent marinara sauce, and shaved Parmesan cheese. The house special pizza is awesome, the ingredients are always fresh and we always order the small because it's more than filling we end up taking some home anyway. read more

Great service At the bar and they will prep and cook your pizza any way you want it!! Wings are great, pizza oven baked off!! Owner is in the floor all the time and makes sure everyone is having a great time! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - At the bar on Fantasy Football Draft Day! - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

The servers are very friendly. Food is great . Loved the pizza options they have. Definitely worth a visit. Only complaint is about those ambient lights attracting lot of flies and resulting them on lading on the food. We had to keep waiving hands at food to move them away. This sounds off yes, but food is good though. I hope the management really takes care of this problem. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Spinach Artichoke Dip - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

I dined in on October 15th. I felt bad because we came in close to closing time around 8:15. I know that servers can be annoyed when coming in close to the end of their shift, but your server Zadia was so attentive and just an overall nice person. She greeted us with a smile, talked to us, and made us feel like we were friends just after sitting down for a few moments. Servers like Zadia are hard to come by and I thought she was definitely worth mentioning in this review. Thank you, Shanna read more

Good for lunch. I had the Italian Sandwich and it was delicious. My server, Victoria, was great. The restaurant seated me quickly and the host even noticed my briefcase and asked if I'd like to seated near an outlet. As I travel for work and like to work through my lunches this was a great choice. I didn't feel rushed but service was polite and prompt. They do play music in the background but it wasn't over the top loud so I didn't mind one bit. The only reason I put 4 stars instead of 5 is because I ordered kettle chips with the sandwich. When I order kettle chips in a sit down restaurant I expected fresh kettle chips but instead it was a bag of chips and they weren't very good. read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Italian sub - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Went to pick up family from Texas at Sanford airport. They arrived hungry so the closest was this Mellow Mushroom on Rhinehart. A safe choice for the party of 6. I knew it was good as I've stopped their before. We ordered a large Kosmic Karma, Maui Wowie, Cheese Pizza & a burger. My family enjoyed the food as they did not have this in Texas. We ordered well & had leftovers good for the next day or 2. This restaurant did not disappoint. The food is consistently delicious & fresh, the service was great with friendly staff. The decor is cool looking. My family really liked it. Conveniently located. Overall a happy experience for all! read more

Super yummy food! Prices are a bit high for pizza, but it was really good pizza (I did a build your own)! We shared the meatball appetizer and my companion had a really nice looking Greek salad! Friendly service. I been here before and will come again! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Build you own pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

The pizza is always so amazingly delicious. One of my favorite pizza places to eat. And of course the customer service is always great. Love this place. Definitely a must!!! read more

Excellent service! Excellent Food! Excellent local creation Mellowterranean Pie! Super friendly staff! A big happy Family! read more

Mellow Mushroom Sanford - Mellowterranean Pie - Pizza Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Always love the vibe of a Mellow Mushroom. The pizza was mediocre. Unfortunately, there quality has gone down hill.

Pizza was delicious and the service and ambiance were excellent. We had hummus, cheese bread, a cheese pizza and a sausage pizza. All were delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Great food, lots of salad options. Consistently good service and food. The Sanford location also has a trivia night.