the other day my buddy told me about this place called Millie's. He said it's one of the best pizzas in all of Chicago. He pre-ordered me a pizza called the Only Pans, which I saw a photo of on Yelp. I had him order that one for me. We entered this tiny store, a little storefront, and learned that you could only order at 8:00 in the morning and then it sells out. You can't just walk in and buy pizza. Our pizza was ready to be picked up. It comes unsliced so you get a whole beautiful round pizza with a charred crust and we had them cut it for us in the store so that we could eat it inside. Upon the first bite I knew these tomatoes were just incredible. The crust was amazing. One of the best pizzas I've had in Chicago, one of the best pizzas I've had in all of America. That was such a memorable experience. The cup-and-char pepperonis, the pesto basil sauce, the perfect tomato sauce with the charred crust: it was a wonderful combination. This place is a must-try. I will definitely get it again the next time I come to Chicago. It is a pan-style pizza. Usually pan-style pizzas are made by Pizza Hut and Domino's but this place took it to a whole nother level and I'm so glad my buddy took me here. read more

See all

I think this is a new second location of Milly's and it was pretty easy to snag a reservation for a pizza just a day or two in advance and I think even same day was available for some of the less popular options. [[HIGHLIGHT]]This spot actually had 3 large booths for folks who want to dig in right away and we easily grabbed a table at 4:30 PM.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] This second location also offers Detroit style pizzas, which ate as an even cheesier version of their deep dish. Still absolutely delicious, but my friends and I were split on which we preferred. Onlypans (5/5): Their crust has a cheesy crisp on the end and almost eats like a fluffy, chewy focaccia. Every topping is a banger; I hate peppers, but have to know where they get pickled peppers that are almost crunchy in texture with that perfect sweetness. Tomato sauce leans on the sweet side, balanced by the saltiness in the cheese and pepperoni cups. Ricotta adds a nice mild creaminess. I'll dream about this pizza. Killtaker Detroit Style (4.75/5): Copy paste everything I just said about the Onlypans, but this one skews saltier and heavier with the extra cheese and lower ratio of sauce. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Killtaker Detroit Style - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We shared: 1. Craigslist.org - Peppadew peppers, sausage , mushrooms, red onions, toy box tomatoes, spinach ricotta cheese 2. Updog - Kumato tomatoes, spinach, red onions, pepperoni, sausage, olives, sweet mini peppers & fresh mozzarella Well worth the hype. No criticism of either pizza. Great quality, distribution, and combination of toppings. Crust is perfect - fluffy interior and golden crispy exterior. One of the best pizza in town for sure. No issues with service. [[HIGHLIGHT]]This location has one table and is basically takeout only.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

The hype is real. I tried the only pans and I can say without a doubt that this is my fave deep dish in the city. Milly's is deep dish but thinner than your standard deep dish with the best crispy bordering on caramelized crust ever. All the flavors were perfectly balanced, however, the star was the red sauce. I was mind blown by how fresh and flavorful it was!! My order was ready right at the promised time as well and pickup was a breeze. I got 1 14" and it was a good amount for 3 people. I'd say the 14" would feed 2-3 people depending on how hungry you are. 4 would be a stretch but maybe we're just big backs. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans 14" - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got clickbait, updog, Craigslist, and only pan. I think my favorite was only pan. The prices are 31-32 for 14 inches and definitely very filling. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's not very air conditioned inside and there's one table plus a couple of window seats.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff was super nice and very quick. Make an order for pickup or delivery online and they do sell out fast. My favorite was definitely the only pan and overall a great first Chicago pizza experience read more

See all

Best pizza I have had in Chicago. The pizza needs to be pre-ordered and picked up later in the day. This pepperoni, mozzarella pizza was a totally new take on the conventional Deep Dish. The bread was airy and crispy, and the flavours really stood out without overpowering one with a lot of cheese. We finished the pizza in one sitting, since it was difficult to stop at one or two slices. This pizza was an experience in itself. Loved it! I understand the hype around it. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Finally got a takeaway order. You have to log in in the morning and place the order online. They won't sell out in seconds (might do on a Saturday, but haven't tried it then) but by 11 or 12 they're going to have limited if anything left. I got the Only Pans. Pepperoni was delicious, love the little cupped pepperoni that curls up on the sides. The pesto and ricotta paired really well with the rest of the pizza and the pesto didn't overpower nor did the pesto's oil run everywhere. The peppers added a nice sharpness to it, but felt a little disconnected to the rest of the pizza; still liked them, but that brightness cut through unexpectedly. Really liked it, immediately went up in the Pequod's tier thanks to the delicious caramelized crust, not being anywhere near as heavy as most pan and deep dish options. Great pizza and will definitely order again. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans - delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Yummy pizza! You must order ahead online. Pick up was fast and efficient. I think the cheese shaped as little flowers are so cute. These reheat nicely. Crust is crunchy. Good filling/pizza ratio. One of the pizzas we got was pretty spicy for a few bites. read more

See all

Took me a bit to figure out how I can order at Milly's. I tried for 2 weeks and finally able to order 2 pies on Thursday AM and pickup at 5 PM. I was able to order the craigslist and Leander. I modified craigslist with mushroom and pepperoni (enjoyed). The two pies was done exactly at the time they post. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There is literally 1 table in the restaurant, with many seats along the window.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Highly recommend and will try other pies. read more

See all

Milly's Pizza in the Pan is top notch! My hubby always finds the best pizza spots to try whenever we're in Chicago and Milly's fit the bill. They sell out fast so you literally have to put an order in first thing in the morning so that you can pick up later in the day. He put an order in at 8am and we picked up the same day around 4:30pm on a weekday. We got one cheese and another with pepperoni and sausage. I loved the one with meats, so flavorful, holds well, and marinara is spot on, not overly sweet as some are. The crust is so good, down to the last bite, as you would hope from a pan pizza. We picked up and had it in the trunk of our car on a perfect fall day. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Heads up, they do not have seating and they also don't offer napkins so they are truly a take-out only![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Check em out, Milly's definitely scratches the pizza itch! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - M - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Probably at one point in time, this was Chicago's best kept secret when it comes to pizza, I don't think this is any longer the case. Milly's is thriving as a no frills, "hole in the wall" pizza joint that offers a unique take on the iconic Chicago deep dish concept. You must order in advance at both of their locations (West Town and Berwyn) at starting at 8 am to even get a chance to try their pies. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Don't expect to be able to eat there as this is definitely meant for a grab n go scenario, but I was lucky enough to snag the lone table at the West Town location on a weekday at 5:30 to try my pie.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The gentleman working that day was kind enough to cut our pizza for us as well. I chose to order the Only Pans. Cupped pepperoni, drizzled with ricotta honey, spinach, and other delicious ingredients. Overall, this is just a well-made pizza. Not too heavy like the other deep dish behemoths you will find around Chicago. Great consistency in the crust and you can tell that thought was put into making the pie stand out it it's own way. It's as if Chicago deep dish pizza and Detroit Style pizza had a baby. Must try if you are a pizza lover of any degree! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans 14'' $32 - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Milly's is a unique take on pizza for Chicago. I don't know many other pan style pizza spots around but the first comparison I could draw was to pequod's. Which Milly's blew pequod's out of the park. They nailed the crispy melted cheese crust without it being burned. Personal preference but pan pizza is pretty low on my list. It always ends up being too doughy, bread drowns out the toppings, and leaves me feeling overfull. I will commend Milly's as this wasn't completely the case with them. The toppings were really good and although it was a lot of bread still, the bread had a very nice malt to it that added more complexity to the flavors. Overall Milly's wasn't bad but still not my favorite. Again, just my preference. But glad I gave them a try and will most likely order again to try more off their menu. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I don't know how I haven't had Milly's yet but it is SO good! I don't love pan pizzas but this is a MUST try when it comes to a Friday night pizza pick up. read more

Alright we finally tried super hyped up Milly's and it did live up to the hype! This is the pan pizza Pequods wishes they could be (controversial opinion sorry not sorry). The caramelized crust is done perfectly and the whole pizza was good. Docked one star because it's THICK even for pan style and it's pricey. We will try other kinds in the future but for now we tried their coveted "Only Pans" and it was good. They only make a limited number of pizzas for the day so make sure you order early in the day to avoid them selling out. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Only Pans - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I've never seen a restaurant call themselves the best of anything in the world and actually living up for it! This pizza was the bomb! I'll be recommending it to everyone I meet. The pickup process was fast and friendly, and [[HIGHLIGHT]]the pick up area was clean and well kept![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Tom's Killing - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Out of the many deep dish pizzas I've had in Chicago, this one's currently my favorite. But be warned that they sell out early, so order days in advance or hope more become available the night before. It's a hassle for sure to need to order a pizza so far in advance, but boy was it worth it! This time, I had the "Tom's Killing". The crust had a wonderful texture, the pepperoni were delicious, the ricotta gave it a perfect moisture, and the everything seasoning kept the crust enjoyable. I'll note that the chili crunch wasn't very noticeable and the bread-to-topping ratio was a bit too bready in my opinion, but overall it was an amazing pie! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Tom's Killing - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

No matter how much you Milly Rock outside thier store they will not let you order pizza in person, lol jk. It's a brick and mortar in the sense that it's physically real, but it's pick up only as they are not open to the public, open to order. It's online ordering only too, do they even have a phone, lol. Somewhere between NY and Sicilian crust it's got some Frico on it, though not climb the walls Detroit style. It's still Chicago pizza all the way. It looks alot denser than it eats, it's light, but with great structure. Sort of like a NY slice that's been reheated and these do reheat well. 400 for 6-8 minutes, but who doesn't finish these things right away. I know I don't considering the lengths it takes to get them. Online ordering opens and sells out in minutes, so set a timer. I actually ordered my first time before I even booked my flight to Chicago. I live in San Diego, but come a few times a year. It's Chicago pizza for people who know Pequads is good, but eat tavern style. It's next level becuase my local friends who gatekeep tavern style double gatekeep this. It's sort of the best of all the regions. Frico from Detroit, grandma style, but both light and satisfying, you don't need to eat multiple slices (but you will). I do regret eating a whole pizza by myself and then going to the bar. Now I know what it's like when an out of towner eats too much Lou Malnati's and has to walk around the city. The dough is multi day proofed and hydrated based on temp/humidity to keep the chew of focacia, but the half inch crust both cragly crusty brown, but leoparded to the toppings which are always evenly spread. It lays surpisingly flat despite having plenty of cheese and toppings. Definitely tongue in cheek names. Clickbait gives all the mouthfull of a meated pie, but without. The craigslist is almost overloaded, hearty. Onlypans is like a mikes hot honey on steriods. Que Suerte is odd with a spanish name, but Hawaiian inspiration. This is the closest to a BJ's style toppings list as you'll find. Honestly the Hawaiian style despite all it's detractors is better suited to this style rather than a thinner crust. Tom's Killing feels more NY than NY pizza tastes. It almost takes you away becuase of the vodka sauce, chili crunch and basil. They don't skimp on the pine nuts or the super aged parmegiano reggiano. 2+ years cmon people. Name another place doing both, even most authentic Italian places don't do that. Updog seems the least creative, but the most inviting. For some reason I was not able to order 1 of every pie for a pizza tasting I was having with friends, I was only able to do this with a friend doing a 2nd simultaneous order, our spots were 30 minutes apart, so close enough that it worked out. Our worry was getting pick up times far apart or having to order some from the other location in the burbs. Thank god they don't have arugula. It's the most overrated things Italian Americans try and hang onto from the old country. Prices are near a premium, but the quality more than speaks for itself. This is your favorite Chicago pizza lord's favorite pizza from Chicago. You have to work your way up to this, you can't just send people here without them having experienced the different levels of the city. This is all the best things that came from the pandemic. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Service is pretty smooth, decor is surprisingly nice considering it's pick up only and they got 1 booth for when the weather is bad.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I kind of thought they should go with a toned down sign to keep things low key. What else can I say, in a city that I can and will debate about best pizza's this is in the top 2 in the city. Alot of these pivot pizza places have what the Japanese call Kodawari to perfect certain things and that's what they do here. You want your pizza spot to have that hyper focus. read more

Placed order at 8am for pickup at 7. Pizza was ready when we got there. Ordered a large Only Pans, but they were out and made us two small instead (MUCH more surface area for free!!!). I'm a huge deep dish hater, but this was different. I'd describe it as a fusion between Detroit and deep. Very thick, bready crust and not as saucy as deep dish, but saucier than Detroit. Insanely good flavor. Cup pepperonis and ricotta were the stars of the show. Definitely worth checking out, especially if you're wanting a Chicago-only pizza that doesn't remind you of lasagna. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Only pans - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Excellent pizza. Got the untitled #1 with jalapeño and pepperoni. Thick crust, good sauce. Very tasty. [[HIGHLIGHT]]There are only 4 seats inside and 1 table so hard to eat inside and they don't cut it.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Untitled #1 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

6/13/2026 Best Pan Pizza in Chicago!!!! Easy to order & friendly service. Definitely won't disappoint you and worth the wait. Make sure to get your order in early!!! read more

See all

Worth the hype! They aren't kidding about reserving your pizza ahead of time. If you're hoping to snag one on the same day, you best hope someone cancels otherwise you're out of luck! We ordered the 10" Only Pans pizza ($26 as of 8/2025) which contains pepperoni, peppadew peppers, ricotta and pesto. Oh boy was this delicious. The best way to describe it is if you took a Detroit Style pizza and made it a circle instead of a rectangle. The dough was perfectly fermented and pillowy and the crisped cheese gave the edge crust a perfect crunchy texture. The cheese, peppadew and pepperoni combination gave a fantastic salty and sweet combination that is out of this world. The 10" is perfect for 2! They are very precise with the timings (they'll let you know when your pizza is ready) so if you ordered for a 5PM pick up, expect it to be ready for you at 5! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Inside is very no frills with window bar style seating and a singular booth table inside.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Staff was friendly! If you want to eat in (like we did) make sure to let them know so they'll cut it for you! Overall we were quite happy and will definitely be back next time we're in the area! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - 10" Only Pans - $26 as of 8/2025 - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

You know how hard it is to get pizza from this place?! OMG! They play harder to get even compared to Uno's, Pequods, and all the rest. I finally ordered pizza online this week around 10am and we ended up having it like 7pm for pick-up. You really have to plan this one in advance. So I would say their pizza is great. We had one cheese and one veggie pizza. The cheese was better, but in the end it's a very pequods style pizza with overall bready crust and cheese burned pizza edges. But now I have one like right by where I live. [[HIGHLIGHT]]What I don't like is apparently you can't really go there to eat? Maybe I'm wrong, but if you are gonna move to a new place, why didn't they use get a bigger place so you can have their pizza fresh.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] What's up with this whole order online and this and that. Anyway, apparently that's what they wanted. Great new pizza join in the hood. read more

It's good, but I've had better. The crust gets too tough once it's colder. The crust reminds me of rye bread a little so I think they mix in whole wheat with all purpose. Everything starts separating when you bite into it. I like a fluffier and buttery base with a little bit of crunch. Maybe it would have tasted better if I got one of their menu items but they were mostly sold out. It had a lot of pepperonis but not the cheese. The sauce is good though. I would wait 5-10 more minutes from the pickup time because it wasn't ready when I went, even though the text came. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The space itself only had one table.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Phenomenal pizza, and infected so popular that you have to order pretty much right at 8 AM on the dot or else many things will sell out. We got three pizzas, the veggie, jalapeño pepperoni, and pepperoni sausage. Each of them had a very unique flare, but bursting with flavor. The people working behind the counter are incredibly kind. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It's definitely a high volume institution, you need to get it in and out, but it's such an amazing addition to our neighborhood.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very cool corner store vibes.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

I'm not usually a big fan of deep dish pizza, but Milly's Pizza in the Pan completely changed my mind. Their pizza is something different -- it's the perfect balance between deep dish and pan pizza, with an amazing cheesy crust that makes every bite unforgettable. By far the best deep dish-style pizza in Chicago. Even if you're not typically into this style, Milly's is worth trying. It's that good. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - OnlyPans - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I know I left 5 stars last time but I just need to reiterate how amazing Milly's is. We recently ordered again and I cannot believe how insanely delicious it is. You really can't go wrong with any pizza, but the Tom's Killing is a must try: the crust is coated in everything but the bagel seasoning and the pizza is topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni, red onion, chili crunch, ricotta, and basil. It is HEAVENLY. You can taste how fresh all the ingredients are. I need to try all the specials, but it can be hard to get your hands on them since they make a limited quantity each day. If you have the opportunity to try Milly's, it's a must! read more

See all

This is the best pan pizza in Chicago right now. The crust is so fluffy, and you can taste every ingredient! The 10" is perfect for 2-3 people. We placed our order around 1pm on Friday and got a 7:30pm pick up slot. Definitely worth the wait! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Tom's Killing - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

One of the best, might even be THE BEST, pizzas in chicago!! I heard all the good reviews of this place and decided I just had to try it. It was so delicious and amazing. I am going to need to come back multiple times just to try all of the other pizzas on the menu. They only make a limited number of pizzas each day, so you will need to order online in advance. They come uncut, but if you would like to dine in you can just tell them and they'll cut it for you. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Woke up at 8 AM to order for a 7PM pickup - this sentence sounds insane but honestly it is so worth it. They deserve alll the hype and flowers, currently our #1 pizza spot. We got the OnlyPans and every component compliments each other so well: the ricotta added a bit of brightness to the flavor, the pepperoni cupped up so well with the honey giving a nice savory and sweet bite, the pesto added an extra depth to the tomato sauce. The crust was both crunchy and doughy at the same time (???). Pickup was easy and efficient. They don't slice the pizza but you can request it to be sliced if you dine in (which is what we did). [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant is small and accommodate maybe 5 people at most.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We were spoiled with very good pizzas having lived on the east coast and were on the streak of disappointment trying out a number of spots in Chicago. But Milly's fortunately broke that streak. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - OnlyPan - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I'd heard a lot of good things about Milly's and finally decided to check it out! I preordered a 14" Craigslist.org ($31; peppadew peppers, sausage, mushrooms, red onions, toy box tomatoes, spinach & ricotta cheese) and arrived with my group of three a couple of minutes early. Staff was very nice and friendly and gave us napkins and silverware when I mentioned we were going to eat in. The pizza came out a few minutes later and looked great, with cheese all the way to the edge and dollops of ricotta. The dough is pretty soft and bready, and the sauce is pretty good--not too acidic or sweet. The sausage and the cheese weren't quite as flavorful as other pizzas I've had, and even though the toppings looked nice, there could've been more. There'd be an occasional spicy bite (from the peppers?) and the end pieces with the crispy cheese were actually more hard than deliciously crispy, which I was surprised by. I thought it'd be a bit more like a Detroit-style crust, but this is definitely it's own category and much softer/doughier. I'm glad I tried it and I think it's good but it's not my favorite pizza around--I love a bit more textural contrast and more flavorful sausage and cheese. Our 14" fed the three of us with a couple of slices left over! read more

I enjoy an artisanal pizza and appreciate the effort that goes into making one, not to mention quality ingredients; which Milly's clearly utilizes! My family, not so much. They weren't impressed with the fine cheese and perfectly presented whipped ricotta flowers that had to have been hand created on every slice of the pie. Looked beautiful and elegant. Love a blackened crust with a little char from the pan. Price is consistent with good quality so I get it, but we're a two pizza order family so when a quick Sunday pizza night turns into $90 and the rest of the consumers aren't as impressed with upscale pizza, you make it a one and done or rare occasion pizza. No hate on my part, but I can't afford to eat one pizza myself on the regular. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - I'm a sucker for anything with peppadews! - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I'm amongst the Chicagoan's, & I think we're the majority, whom despise deep dish pizza. It's basically tourist food. While this is on the better spectrum of deep dish it's still deep dish pizza. You can definitely tell some effort & tlc went into making it though & I enjoyed the buttery crust as well as the slightly spicy aspect. Glad I tried it but doubt I'd order it again. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Prices - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Decided to check out Millys. This place sells out quick. I placed an order online for a specific pick up time and when I went back to checkout a different pickup time it was greyed out until later this evening. When I went to pick up my order there was a sign that said "sorry sold out." The staff seemed very relaxed and not overwhelmed. They all had smiles. Guess it was a good day for them, but perhaps they can push some more order out? I don't know. They're focused on quality over quantity at this joint and I dig it. I ordered their Onlypans. It came with cup and char pepperoni, peppadew peppers, ricotta, and topped with clabrian chili honey and pesto. Like most have said it's similar to Pequods and Detroit style but with their own special twist. Not exactly a Chicago style deep dish. The crust was amazing. It had the burnt cheesy crust and all the other toppings went perfectly with each other. I was planning on taking off the chilis but I'm glad I didn't. It really elevated this pizza to another level. Can definitely see myself returning very soon. read more

See all

Love the only pans- perfect to share with 3-4 people. We ordered first thing in the morning for pickup around 5pm and it was a smooth process read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Onlypans - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ordered take out at Milly's. Be sure to order ahead of time and online! Nice hybrid of a Chicago style deep dish pizza and pan. Clickbait consisted of fresh tomato sauce, creamy dollops of ricotta, peppers and cherry tomatoes on a lite, airy crust. Ingredients felt simple, fresh and high quality. I liked there was a slight char of parmesan on the sides but not entirely burnt on the bottom. Unlike Chicago deep dishes this didn't give me food coma. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Clickbait 10" - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very good! Got the tom killing pizza and it was unique and flavorful! If you don't like a bready type pizza maybe this isn't for you, but I thought it was a good balance and good bread and sauce. Very tasty! Definitely worth a try. Will try more of their pizzas!!! They email when it's ready too which is nice. read more

Hands-down one of my favorite pizza shops in the city. They recently received a well deserved ranking in the top 5 in the Midwest at No. 3. Who would think to come to Asia on Argyle for anything other than Vietnamese food? The ingredients are so fresh that even after polishing off a whole deep dish, you don't feel like hating yourself. I ordered the Untitled #1 which has pepperoni, jalapeños, mozzarella, oregano, and tomatoes--and honestly wished I had ordered two. The restaurant has an old-school vibe, with checkered tiles and curved benches, giving it a classic pizza shop feel. The staff is friendly but clearly hustling to keep up with demand, as each pizza is made fresh. A heads-up: their website strongly recommends ordering ahead since they stop serving once they run out of ingredients for the day. The story is cool, starting as a ghost kitchen and eventually opening a brick-and-mortar spot during the pandemic. It's worth a read if you're interested. read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - Untitled #1 Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

We heard about Milly's for the first time during the pandemic. At that time, it was so difficult to get a pizza. After hearing all the fantastic reviews and seeing all the delicious pictures online, we were so glad to see Milly's had an actual locale to visit. We've gone a few teams and the consistency is what makes this place special. They haven't changed too much and they still only make a limited number of pizza each day. So if you plan on ordering, try to order ahead. Once they're sold out, they're sold out. On our first visit, we got some of their great signature pizzas, but now, we usually just go for the simple pies. Cheese or pepperoni. The cheese is perfect, you get a real taste of the sauce and the amazing buttery crispy crust. The pepperoni are nice and perfectly crispy, almost spicy, overall just very flavorful. We usually like to dine in when we visit, the staff is exceptional. They are super friendly and on our last visit, this past Saturday, we were checked in on super consistently. We always feel super welcome when we go and the pizza is just steps above most local spots here. This pizza here is actually worth the hype. We typically order from the location on Argyle, but look forward to trying the Berwyn location soon too. Milly's pizza is outstanding. while it's a pain to get a pizza sometimes if you don't think too far ahead, you're always gonna enjoy your pizza and it'll always be worth it. Highly recommend! read more

Milly’s Pizza In The Pan - You Do You Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I'm so sad that Milly's is moving away from me but so glad they'll be able to expand their operations so the rest of the city (and world?!) can be blessed with their pizza. We got the OnlyPans and it will not disappoint. Perfect crispy cheese crust along the edge and fluffy dough. Normally when I eat deep dish or pan pizza, I walk away feeling heavy and bloated but that's not the case at Milly's! All that goodness and still felt light on my feet after read more

I absolutely loved the pizza that I had from Milly's on my most recent visit to Chicago. After doing a little research about the best-rated pizza in town, Milly's consistently came up as one to get. They only make a limited amount of pies per day, so I placed my order online the morning that I flew out from Vegas to the Windy City so I would have a pizza that night for dinner. Upon arriving in Chicago, I checked into my hotel and proceeded to take a ride share to Milly's. They texted me to let me know that my pizza was ready for pick-up at exactly 5pm, the time that I chose. Upon arrival, I was greeted by an empty Milly's, with 3 counter seats and one table--yes! It's not a big space, with the pick-up counter being the focal point. [[HIGHLIGHT]]I wanted to enjoy my pizza when it was nice and fresh and I was so glad that they had some seating so I wouldn't have to take it all the way back to my hotel (I was staying about 20 minutes away).[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The guys there had my pizza packed in a box, but they gladly sliced it up for me when they realized I was staying to nosh, providing a plate and a cup of water. I chose the create-your-own option for a 10-inch pizza, with mushrooms and pepperoni--delectable! This pizza did live up to the hype. There were eight slices and I ate five there, taking the leftovers to enjoy cold the next day (grateful for my hotel room's mini-fridge). The crust is to-die-for, with that superb caramelization. Trust me, get Milly's Pizza in the Pan in your mouth pronto. read more

See all