Stopped in for a bit of a late lunch around 2pm on a weekday. Hopped off the blue line and decided to escape the rain for a few for some food. They had slices of cheese, pepperoni and sausage available. Usually there is a specialty slice but didn't see anything about it. Got a pepperoni slice and a sprite. The pizza was fresh, crispy thin crust and not very oily. Was delicious! They have the standard Parmesan and red pepper flakes on the table, which is nice. The menu does seem more extensive and I was intrigued by the buffalo chicken pizza and wings so I'll def be back. The place has like 6 tables and the decor is pretty interesting too. Overall, it was a successful visit and I'll be back. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got delivery from here on a Friday night, through Uber Eats. I got the 18" buffalo chicken pizza, a side of boneless bbq wings, and a 14" bacon pizza. They were both labeled as thin crust but were tavern style. Which isn't the same. The pizzas were virtually flavorless, almost no sauce and the crust tasted like one of those premade ones you get from the grocery store in plastic sealed wrap. Not sure it was for me, the buffalo chicken pizza comes with white onions on it, the only part that sparked flavor. The boneless bbq wings, which were free on Uber Eats due to paying $30. The were very wet, sticky, mostly okay. Definitely freezer to fryer style. I ordered a side of blue cheese which was very off, watery. Weird. Overall might be better if it wasn't delivered but I doubt it. read more

See all

My favorite pizza spot nearby! I typically just get a slice of cheese but everything looks really good. The staff is also super friendly. Id recommend anyone to stop by for a quick bite! read more

See all

Good place to get a slice of pizza for lunch. Quick service and good service. Spacious. Location is great. Unique interior. They have the standard pizza pepper flakes and Parmesan cheese. Yet also they have some Louisiana hot sauce which is nice. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Pie-eyed is our go-to for pizza in the neighborhood. Ian and crew are so nice, easy to talk to AND Rush was playing when I walked in tonight! I was so excited to hear music that I enjoy so much when I walked in. This is huge... they've got great pizza and great music! What more do you need? Really nice guys... always the freshest pizza hands down. I don't know of any other place that I make frequent trips to where they remember me. I love that. read more

I'm pretty floored by some of these negative reviews - I thought Pie-Eyed was awesome! It's in my River West neighborhood and I finally got to try it recently. We got the Summertime Chi Pie and loved it! We also went for a thin crust and that didn't disappoint either. The crust was super crunchy which I love and the flavors were great. We did take out and it was ready and hot when promised. We would definitely eat here again! read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We live in the neighborhood and have always heard good things about this place. Today we stopped in for a few slices and had a great experience waiting for our pieces while chatting with the owner. The pizza was thin and crispy. The sauce was tangy and sweet. Safe to say that we will be back! read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice, Cheese Slice - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place was recommended by a friend so we had high hopes but what a bummer. The crust here is not good - tastes like old cracker crust. The sauce is sweet and tastes like tomato paste. For the price point ($30+ for a large) Will not be eating here again. Cheese fries were decent. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ok listen I just had the best god dang vegan pizza in Chicago from here! Vegan pepperoni and chz. It was so freaking flavorful, the chz tasted literally like dairy. I was nearly fooled. Vegans RUN TO PIE EYED. It's way too slept on!!!!! They don't have it in slices so you have to order a whole pizza but literally thats fine cause I need the entire thing haha read more

Nice guy working and few folks in and out It's just really overpriced. Got a 14 in "gourmet" pizza for 34 bucks. It's not bad but it's just a slightly nicer dominos meatzza with red peppers (which cost around 12-14 bucks). I think they are around 30-40% overpriced. Ranch tasted really good but it was a dollar for a small cup. Maybe this is normal price in Chicago? read more

See all

Recently did a pizza by the slice tour in my neighborhood of West Town and Pie Eyed Pizza was a cool though unplanned discovery. I was driving by towards another pizza slice place and happened to see the sign for Pizza slice. The pizza here was decent. Nice and crispy crust, which is my style of tavern pizza. Good stuff, although they didn't have enough sauce in the pizza. I think if they had had more sauce, this would've been a really good pizza. No other complaints. I'd give it 3.5 if I had that option. Price-wise at $5.75 or so for the slice, the pricing was just in-line with nearby pizza joints. I'm willing to give this place another shot in case the less sauce thing was a one-time miss. Love when you find something unexpected, though. read more

This is how I imagine pizza would taste like if I successfully made it at home. There was a lot of tomato sauce and it moved the cheese around. I didn't like the crust so glad there wasn't much of it. But I felt that it could have been more crispier. The pepperonis was the only thing making it tasty. This is an 18" pizza so there was definitely enough. The price was average after a discount. Then again, I am a fan of Domino's and their garlic crust so maybe I'm not the best person to ask for pizza advice. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - a hand holding a piece of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I totally agree with another yelper in here that the Pizza tastes like Chuck E Cheese pizza. The crust tastes like day old flatbread. The sauce tastes as generic as Chef Boyardee. The only thing that was edible was the cheese and pepperoni. Plus, they say they're open at 11am, but they'll shoo you away bc they say they're not actually ready to open until 11:10am. And the people working there aren't too friendly. read more

So disappointed with this place. I had it bookmarked for a long time, they have a huge sign on the window claiming the best slice in Illinois. Anyone that knows me, pizza is my love language. I was having a day and I realized how close I was to the spot and was excited to try a slice. The inside was shut down due to covid. I called in my order- they grabbed the slices and heated them out then brought them out. Took my first bit, just not impressed. Even though thin, it was dry. It lacked a little flavor so added crushed red. Then went for the ranch which was not fresh and definitely came pre-made. It had a strong soybean oil taste and unappetizing. Overall, did not enjoy and probably wont be back. 2 slices came out to $12. Gave it 2 stars bc I am hoping they are not doing their A game bc of Covid and they really are a much better slice. So wish them the best of luck and on to the next slice! read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - The not good ranch - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Pie-Eyed Pizza is one of my top 5 pizza places "for delivery" I am in love with their Thin Crust-Pepperoni, Sausage, Red Onion, Red Pepper and Mushroom, and Tomato Pie! Their Perfect Crust-holds up the sauce and toppings, is soft and evenly cooked!!! The cheese is authentic shredded whole milk mozzarella which makes all the difference for leftovers being heated up! They also sprinkle pizza seasoning on the finished pie! Oh My Pizza Pie- I have ordered a pizza every week for the last 3 weeks! Love it!!!!!!! read more

See all

Came in one day for lunch. Things I Liked: Size of slices of pizza Crispy pepperoni when they reheated it Good music Friendly staff Location (right outside of Chicago Blue Line stop) Things I Didn't Like: Pizza was reheated and had consistency of cardboard almost Two slices and a drink was $12. A bit overdone, but not too bad. Just an average pizza joint from what I can tell. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

For $10 for a slice & fountain soda, they could really be making a better slice of pizza. As a matter of pride, guys, make a better slice of pizza. It's fine; it could so easily be better. You're charging $10 for a slice and a fountain soda. Surely could make this slice better. read more

Squarely in the middle, Pie-Eyed is perfect based purely on when and why you are eating here. If it's late, you are coming off the L to walk somewhere else nearby, and you have $5-$6 in your pocket and you're looking for slightly-above-average pie, PEP is great. I came in for lunch one day and had a slice/fries/drink combo for $8, and it was fine. Lots of fries, so good value proposition...love the local brand soda that was on tap here. The single slice of pie was enough for me, and while it didn't make me think I was eating the magic that is the original Dante's Pizzeria, I was in the neighborhood of PEP and hungry and wanted to stay on the cheap. For that, it's great. If you are looking for an elevated culinary experience, look elsewhere! read more

Best slice in Chicago, great family business where it's fun to catch either the owners or their mom for a quick chat for grab and go.

Reminiscent of Chuck E. Cheese, so like.... Do what you will with that information... Cheese 2/10 Sauce 0/10 Crust 7/10 Toppings 3/10 read more

I just ordered a full pie for the first time as I usually stop in for just a slice and WOW not only did the pizza look delicious it is the best pizza in Chicago! Order thin crust pizza you can thank me later! Perfect pizzas I'm so happy I ordered! Thank you! read more

This place does so many things right it's hard to decide where to start. The za is tasty, the staff is cool and the convenience is unparalleled. I typically try to hit this place at least once a week and have yet to be anything less than happy with my choice. The counter service slices are huge and accessible at the latest of hours. Their carry out pizzas are fresh and cooked to perfection. Love this spot! read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pepperoni and sausage 14" classic thin - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

As usual. A great pizza. I always order the Monster Pie. I'd like to also give a shout out to some of their other items they have. I believe I only reviewed their pizza. My mom gets their Buffalo Shrimp. She loves them. Today she got the Buffalo chicken calzone. She liked it. I ordered their Italian beef tonight. I will say it was average at best. Kind of skimpy on the beef. Beef was a bit on the bland side. But they are not famous for that. I love their chicken strips. Dessert tonight was carrot cake. So good. But I've never had a bad pizza and tonight that streak continues. read more

This is sad to say because Pie-eye Is my neighborhood pizzeria, but this is the worst pizza i have ever had. Frozen pizza from CVS tastes better, to be honest. I do have to say, I have only had it at night, so maybe its not at its prime.. but its not good. Do try for yourself, please, and give me your thoughts. read more

Purely a Mother's Day delivery order! Heart shaped pie with a rose upon delivery and she loved it! Moms is usually a deep dish person, but she raves about the pizza! Support your local restaurants during the stay at home order. (: read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Special heart shaped pie for Mother's Day. Included a red red rose - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Very good pizza! I prefer thinner crusts so this wasn't too thick, so I really liked it!

Ordered the Mexican corn pizza for the month of May for delivery and it was delicious! Arrived on time and the driver was pleasant. I like their unique styles and everyone at work enjoyed it. A little on the pricey side but you do get great food, fun flavors, and friendly service. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Elote style - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Their pepperoni pizza is very oily, leaves an unpleasantly sweet aftertaste in your mouth. The cheese reminds me of school lunch pizza. Meatballs in their meatball sub were flavorless and had a chalky texture (too much breadcrumbs maybe??). The 2 guys that served me were not very welcoming. read more

Crap pizza and on top of that they don't follow instructions for the pizza. Go elsewhere.

Horrendously bad. Horrendously overpriced pizza. Hard to tell which is worse, crust or sauce. $6.25 all in for a cheese slice. If this was a 99 cent slice place it would be overpriced read more

No bad. Thin. Could use more Quality cheese. Guys are nice.I've found better. But not to compare here. Just not bad. Been here several time. Consistent. I'm sure Business would be better if there was parking. Good luck guys. read more

I really love this place for the tasty pizza slices. I don't like my pizza reheated and sometimes the pizza sits too long and they want to reheat it. Not good! I love that pizza fresh out the oven is the best. The dough is crispy and thin. The sauce is perfect a little on the sweet side just how I love and the cheese is perfect. They must use quality ingredients because you can taste it. There is seating available so if you want to eat in. The tables do lack attention most of the time and the music they play is a little too much on the ears Parking is terrible in this area read more

So nasty... The pizza sauce taste like tomato paste right out the can with a lot of other nasty seasoning on top read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - 12 inch nasty pizza never again not worth the price - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

My beau, best friend, and I found this place online as something to do in Chicago, so we ventured out. We were expecting something totally different, since this spot advertised a certain kind of brunch. When we got there, there was just one patron enjoying a slice, the cashier, and the cook. We could've easily turned around, but we decided to stay instead. We ordered the chicken Parmesan with fries, mile high calzone, and vegan pizza respectively. I also ordered the mushrooms as an appetizer. Everything was cooked to order for us, so there was a little wait. The mushrooms, portobellos to be exact, were piping hot and really tasty. The calzone was good. The bread for the chicken Parmesan was toasty just shy of burnt, minus that, the sandwich had good flavor and the shoestring fries that accompanied it were fried crisp, just how we like them. The vegan pizza was delicious. It was on a thin crust that had been toasted well enough that it had a little snap when you bit into it. We almost didn't get a chance to partake in this local spot, as there's some kind of construction happening in front of it, so the place isn't immediately seen. But, if you see the #66 Chicago bus stop, then you've found it and hopefully will give it a try. We did, and wound up having a good, local lunch. read more

Not bad pizza. Good for a late night bite on the way home after a drink or three. Not anything to really write home (or a glowing Yelp review) about. Wouldn't mind coming again. Also, the fact that they're open super late and sell pizza by the slice really goes in their favor. read more

Food was amazing, plenty of options. Reasonable delivery fee and wait. Can't wait to order again

The pizza was only fine at best and by no means the best pizza I found in Chicago. So why the 3 stars -- I was super impressed by the fired Twinkie dessert something that arrived super crunch crispy & warm but most surprisingly kept its crunch and heat until AFTER we finished our pizza as if just pulled out of the fryer minutes ago. Is there nothing a Twinkie can't do?! read more

Open late and sell by the slice! Best late night food in River West. They can also accommodate gluten free but you should call ahead. read more

Pie-Eyed Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Not sure why all the bad reviews. Great thin crust pizza. The slices are huge and good quality for a $5 slice. The prices are fair as well. Haven't tried their deep dish. read more

Right off train. Had a beef friends has slices. Was great not expensive. It was a Monday and had wrestling on all tvs. Was fun