This is basically a standard and average NYC bagel place. It would be exceptional and worth the high prices anywhere outside of NYC, but within NYC I wouldn't make a special trip. Flavor is great, excellently doughy. I found the texture a bit on the squishy side, though to be fair, I'd bought them in the morning and was eating them in the airport 12 hours later. I should also note: they have bialys! Not the best bialys I've had (I like mine a bit more caramelized), but I appreciate that they're there at all. read more

$20 for 2 bagels with cream cheese. No coffee, nothing else. Most expensive bagels I had. Service is quick but definitely super overpriced. Definitely not coming back unless theprice becomes reasonable. It was listed abagel under $2. Obviously, more with a cream cheesebut $10+ for a bagel.. avoid. read more

Montague Street Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wow! Such an incredible bagel AND we saw the bagel maker in action! It's a great place. Definitely a line at 10 am on a sunny lovely Saturday. Lines are a good sign, in my opinion. I had a toasted everything Bagel with bacon scallion cream cheese. Man oh man. read more

Montague Street Bagels - So many cream cheese and tofu cheese flavors! - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Egg bagel toasted with cheese perfect. Called ahead to reserve the last one and it was delicious Have to ck out the rest of the sandwiches! Friendly and fast! read more

Worst salads ever. How do you mess up egg or tuna salad? The ones here are SO bad. My daughter wanted salads so we ordered delivery. Never again. Threw out the salads as they tasted like the mayonnaise had gone bad. Highly recommend NOT getting their salads. Bagels were OK but not great. Giving two stars because of fast delivery. read more

I loved this place during my Brooklyn visit. My friend suggested we stop by for a bagel before going to the Brooklyn bridge. It is a small establishment, looks family owned and it did not disappoint! We ordered a bagel with smoked salmon, avocado and tofu cream cheese. At first, I was skeptical about trying the tofu cream cheese because I am not a fan of vegan products (taste-wise) HOWEVER, I could not tell is was NOT dairy cream cheese. It was really good. They have a wide selection of several cream cheeses, I was amazed. The bagel itself is big, I split one with my friend and we both were pretty full. Price is reasonable $13ish? I believe it was. Not bad for a delicious breakfast in a cool area of NYC. read more

See all

I walked in this morning to get bagels and they had sheets of paper covering the bagels. I saw a roach crawling on the paper. I told the woman behind the counter who was helping me with my order. Her response was.... that's why we have the paper there. Ok... so do the roaches know that they have to stay on top of the paper?? read more

Bagels are fantastic. Good options for cream cheese including a number of vegan ones. Efficient service.

Stopped by here on Saturday while walking around and got a bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel. It took 10 minutes to prepare which seemed like a very long time for a bagel... despite that it was delicious. Stayed very clean(best kind-when it doesn't fall apart) and was able to eat it while walking. It was very good would go back. Also it's small in the bagel shop which absurdly made it less hectic in a way. read more

I've been here a few times now and I honestly really like their bagels. I usually get an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese and I loveeeee the veggie cream cheese that they make. It's so good. The bagels are a good size and texture. I also appreciate that they're not shy with the cream cheese. Not sure why this place only has three stars on Yelp. This might be my new favorite bagel spot in the neighborhood. read more

Montague Street Bagels - a person holding a bagel - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Solid NY bagel spot. Has everything you need, pretty quick service, iced coffee. Bagel sandwiches and a good spread of cream cheeses, including a tofu cream cheese. Fair price point Not out of this world great bagels but super reliable and good A few tables right in front, some benches down the street on Montague but the best is taking it down to the Promenade to eat! read more

My favorite bagel spot in Downtown Brooklyn! They always have freshly made bagels with the most delicious flavored cream cheese. The price is budget friendly and different flavored cream cheese never disappoints. Workers are friendly and nice. Order online to avoid the lines in store. Highly recommend! read more

See all

Proper NY style bagels. That means BIG. Just firm enough on the outside and wonderfully chewy on the inside. Had my bagel in sandwich form with ham and cheese and it was all fresh and excellent. A few little tables and chairs (including some outdoor) make it a suitable place for a quick lunch. Not gourmet, but plenty good. read more

Montague Street Bagels - Ham and Swiss sandwich on pumpernickel. - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This place was recommended by my hotel and it didn't disappoint. It's not a large place and its nestled among the neighborhood residence buildings. I ordered a coffee and my usual bagel, lox, cream cheese, and red onion. The bagel was fresh and airy, the cream cheese lox spread was excellent. I sat outside and watched the people walk by enjoying my breakfast. Sometimes you just got to sit back and allow the world to go by as you relax. read more

Great quality, although it has gone down since July 2022. Their everything bagels are good, though they were incredible. The service is impeccable. read more

Fantastic sandwiches to delicious bagels. Love going to this place when I want a great BEC Bagel in the morning.

I popped into Montague's today because it's close to my apartment and I really enjoyed it. I opted for the classic everything bagel with cream cheese, toasted. The bagel was the perfect level of chewy and the cream cheese was delicious. The one thing I would have like is if the everything seasoning had stayed on the bagel a bit better. The bagels in the display window had much more seasoning than I ended up with on mine. All in all though, the price is right, the service is quick, and the food is good. I'll definitely be back! read more

Montague Street Bagels - Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best bagel I have ever had. Doughy on inside but firm on outside. Cream cheese and toppings are all great and they have everything you could want. Whenever I'm in Brooklyn or even the state, I make sure to stop here! You won't regret. read more

We gotta give Montague Street Bagels some love, because they run a tight ship for how hectic it is on weekend mornings! Don't be fooled if you don't see a line from outside- it's always packed inside and the line snakes around. I would say we go every other weekend because it's the closest bagel shop to us, and while they aren't the neighborhood's best bagel, they do make delicious NY bagels that hit the spot. I'm typically a "scallion cream cheese on a plain bagel" type of girl, but on occasion, I do like their scallion lox cream cheese, which is just the right amount of lox without shifting into fancy schmancy gear. For some reason, every once in awhile, I will end up waiting over 20 minutes for my bagel and people who come after me will get their sandwiches before I do. I have never run into this problem at Court Street Bagels (objectively better bagels, in my opinion, but they're cash only and further away from me), and it takes all of me to not let my hangry-self be known, but I can see they're backed up and struggling too. Anyways, I appreciate that they take card, and they provide us with tasty bagels and SEC bagel sandwiches, and for the majority of the time, that's just alright with me! read more

Good grab and go bagel spot. We had the everything bagel with scallion cream cheese & an everything bagel with bacon scallion cream cheese. We went there around the high school lunch rush so we waited a bit but once we ordered it went fast. read more

Montague Street Bagels - Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The classic lox bagel is a hit! The people there are super sweet and the service was super quick. Thank you!

They have lots of bagel options and cream cheese options. I got the one mixed with cream cheese and salmon and it was good!

Forever my favorite deli. I was introduced to this place when I first move to Brooklyn 6 years ago and I have been loyal to this place ever since. Their bagel will satisfy any bagel aficionado. Their staff is always sweet and they always perfect my order no matter how complex it is. I wish this place much success!l read more

Montague Street Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Bagels are amazing but what I love even more are their sandwiches! I highly recommend the pope of montague which is turkey and cheese with gravy. They have a bunch of excellent combination with cool names posted at the counter. You can order custom sandwiches, my favorite being chicken cutlet with lettuce, tomato, onions and bagels on a toasted roll. I do recall eating a very divine sandwich here last year around 3 am so this place is really great for anytime of the day. read more

Montague Street Bagels - pope of montague - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Two stars for the food. Zero for the service. I've been coming here for years because the bagels are good and the location is convenient, but they mess up orders, overcharge, and fail to include what you pay for more often than not. Three out of four times, I have to return to have them redo my order (for instance, once I ordered and paid for lox for husband's bagel, confirmed and reconfirmed my order, only to find that no lox was included). The woman at the front offers abysmal customer service. Once she once rang up my order wrong and I corrected her, she yelled at me. Another time, when we called to ask that they fix our order, she hung up on us twice--despite that we are, as she knows, neighborhood regulars. I shudder to think how she might dare to treat non-regular customers. Guard your wallets! read more

Nice little spot to grab a bagel. The folks were kind and based on my preferences, the everything bagel with cream cheese was good. I'd come back. read more

My favorite bagels in the neighborhood. Chewy, dense, and delicious. And the people who work there are so nice!

decent bagels. The manager that runs the place is pretty bad and takes pleasure in not caring, so it's 50/50 if you get your order via delivery at all, and super likely you get the wrong stuff if you're in person. They could not possibly care less. read more

no idea why the bad reviews - this place has some of my favorite bagels in brooklyn. you can order ahead via doordash if you don't want to wait read more

Montague Street Bagels - a man sitting on a bench in front of a hot bagel shop - Bagels Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We ate three big breakfast bagel sandwiches. Quick local place to grab a tasty meal. Great find!

I want to like this place because the location is convenient. But during peak hours, the waits are long and there is no organization. They also get orders slightly wrong... Ex: I ordered a whole wheat everything bagel with lox/scallion spread, and received a regular everything bagel with scallion spread that might've been tofu. Little things like this can be frustrating. The taste of the cream cheese is inconsistent, not sure what that's about. It's not the cleanest shop compared to other bagel spots in the area. The staff is nice though read more

Loved this place when I lived in Brooklyn. Great bagels, great service. Hopefully will return when the Clark station re-opens :)

Well, when a bagel with cream cheese cost $5, you know something is wrong in the world and with this place. On the latter, charging 4% on debit card transactions is simply BS. Adding this place to the list of places that will receive a 3 month suspension of my patronage. Happy to walk farther for a reasonably priced bagel. read more

Montague Bagels (Hot Bagels) is one of the BEST bagel shops in NYC. They have a wide variety of bagel flavors and cream cheese spreads. My favorite is an everything bagel with jalapeño cream cheese toasted. Although a lot of my friends love their egg breakfast sandwiches. This is a perfect spot because you can grab a filling bagel and head over (less than a 5 min walk) to the Brooklyn Heights Promenade to enjoy a bagel with a view! read more

This place is WAY to overpriced and takes triple the time it should to make a normal sandwich. Also the muffins and donuts are moldy and they try to sell it to you. I've never seen the grill in the back but I bet it's not that sanitary, and the staff isn't as nice as they could be! Overall horrible deli to go to read more

Ordered through seamless and found mold on the carrot cake as I was finishing up the meal. Both seamless and Montague Street Bagels refused refund for full order (coffee, bagel, carrot cake.) So gross and unacceptable. We all make mistakes, but zero recovery and they wouldn't take responsibility. read more

See all

My review went from two starts to 0. My sister came in to this bagel establishment during her lunch break. She chose to purchase a bottle of water from here, and eat a slice of pizza from an outside source. No one else was in the bagel store, so she chose to sit down. She was going to sit outside but it was 25 degrees, and wet from the snow. Two gentlemen watched my sister eat the entire pizza without saying a word, and told my sister to take her pizza box out of the garbage can (very shy female that's polite). It was terrible and rude. Not to mention, she tipped $5. He said, "you spent only $1". He should have said something from the beginning. She left traumatized, and said,"if someone would have said something to me, I wouldn't have eaten it here." And they told her to take her garbage out of the garbage can. ::raised eyebrow:: I have ordered bagels here for my office and NEVER AGAIN. They are losing my business, and business from friends of mine through work. I should have remembered the mediocre bagels I bought there from a groupon while in college. read more

The bagels are pretty good...I've had better and I've definitely had worse. Downside: The service is slow; the food ordering, the prep and the register...they seem understaffed at peak times. Also, they have recently implimented an upcharge for paying by credit card. There is a sign with small print at the register but its not prominently visible and the woman that is always at the register doesn't verbally mention it...thats on you to notice the small print sign. I watched people on line in front of me pay by card and she didnt say a word...just rang them up and added the fee. She is also a bit rude. read more

My first experience eating NY bagel in NY, and I was absolutely blown away! I ordered the sausage-egg-cheese on an everything bagel. It was not only massive but also just $5! We had the bagels at the promenade, which is only 2 blocks away, and I was such bad company as I inhaled my bagel. The salty and substantial sausage was lovingly wrapped in creamy egg and cheese. The everything bagel tasted so fresh with a chewy interior and a crackly crust that also provided a kick. If you are going to carb load, do it properly and eat here so you can get a mouth-smacking delicious experience to satiate your guilt (if any) after! read more

Just walk in for the freshly made bagels baked on site... THAT'S IT. Cheap prices, friendly service and amazing bagels to boot. I honestly think these are my favorite bagels in Brooklyn (so far). Class whole wheat is the bomb... I just wish they had more cream cheese options. read more