This place was very average. Food was not good at all especially for the price, and the bbq was the worst bbq I've ever had. The ice cream was amazing tho. Overall I would skip out on the food and get the ice cream. read more

Nancys is literally the most disgusting place to order food or ice cream. The kids that work there put there dirty socks on the ice cream containers and sit around. Over price food as well your better off getting McDonald's or subway. I live in new buffalo full time so I've definitely have seen what goes on there. The owners usually always there, so I'm surprised he allows this. I'm ready to call the health department. So watch out. GO TO BEACHSIDE SCOOPS RIGHT DOWN THE ROAD!! Cheaper ice cream and it's not freezer burned. And also good like trying to find a spot to eat inside because it's all taken by the employes. And the owner is so self centered, to even care for coustomers satisfaction. read more

Nancy's - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Buffalo, Michigan

Damn fine chocolate milkshake, perfectly drinkable right away thru an amazing oversized straw (a small detail that made a huge difference). Tasty enough that we ordered it two nights in a row. We found the price to be quite reasonable, under $4 for a small milkshake that probably was 16 oz. Service was totally fine, fast and friendly despite being pretty busy both nights. Toddler factor: Super-fat straw made drinking milkshakes easy, the kid loved 'em. Several benches, lots of tables outside so you don't have to worry about making a mess. read more

Nope, didn't eat actual food here...just ice cream from what I assume is a local creamery called Hudsonville. The Caramel turtle cheesecake was to die for, the brownie batter was malty chocolate ice cream with chunks of brownie. Pass on the mint chocolate chip. They also have typical Michigan flavors like Blue Moon and Traverse City Chocolate Cherry. Just a little divey ice cream/fast food stand. You can go inside and sit at one of a handful of tables or stand in line and order from the window outside. Nothing fabulous but good for something fast. read more

Great selection of ice cream and the strawberry shake was awesome! Outdoor seating area was small but shaded. Like most of the strip here in New Buffalo, the outdoor seating area is hardly stroller friendly. read more

Horrible customer service. We went there to get our 3 year old some ice cream. 4 people in there sitting around chatting. They said they were closed. I asked if they could tell me what time they open. "Well we have a huge hot dog order so I can't tell you". Seriously can't scoop one cone of ice cream for a 3 year old?? Two seconds. Dumb place. Now my kid is crying cause I said we were getting ice cream. Just FYI. We were there at 10:59 they were supposed to open at 11:00 read more

Busy. Got our orders wrong but raspberry chocolate chip ice cream was good. Wanted to have the brownie batter. Maybe next time

Great shakes! Could use a serious cleaning. Maxwell was charred beyond recognition. Buns were stale. Clean up your act!

HORRIBLE HORRIBLE, staff!!! They spend more time playing like children behind the counters, screwing up guests orders, making inappropriate comments among themselves with young kids around and make no apologies for their actions. There are several other places to go in New Buffalo that don't mess up your orders and aren't run by people acting like children. There seems to be no leadership and there is no way to get in touch with the owner, Jim. When I asked who the owner was I was greeted with an attitude. Clearly they have had issues before and knew more complaints were coming. Jim, if you're reading this comment, start spending more time at your business, remove those talentless kids that don't care about your customers and or business and maybe your railings may actually go up. NEVER GOING BACK AGAIN! Go somewhere else! read more

Ordered 2 over priced, mediocre ice creams. Black cherry ice cream tasted artificial. But that wasn't the problem. My recently potty trained 3 year old needed to use the bathroom urgently. I happen to catch a man leave a side door "Employees Only." I ask, and he says it's a bathroom, yes. [We used it last year, in fact so I knew already....] I had a hunch and ask - yep, the dude also says HE IS THE OWNER. My son is dying at this point. I kindly explain we spent $$ at his store and we need the john for 2 minutes. I will escort and clean it up. He still - incredibly - REFUSES to let us use the lousy toilet. He looked at us like we were aliens with a disease. Full on stink eye, he could have cared less. We were patrons! Bottom line - the world has too many A-holes already. Do not support him / Nancy's. Better off going to OINKS, a much better place close by, kind employees, better food! read more

I like the ice cream here. I love the fact that you can order off of the window on the sidewalk. When I hit the beach, it's just a nice topoff to the day, to grab an ice cream here. I've had their food a few times. It's Ok, nothing to rave about but it was fine. I'm here mostly for the many flavors of ice cream they have. I've never had an issue with the service. It's a typical high school age employee group but they have always been fine with my family, friends and I. It's different. It's not the run of the mill DQ or fast food place (for ice cream), which is why I like to go. read more

have been to nancys many times but finally got the feeling they were taking liberies with the prices being charged for a scoop of ice cream when i came back one evening after having patronized the store for two consecutive evenings the waitstaff admitted they had overcharged me so i had asked how they plan to make up for the difference. first i was told, "mistakes happen", and then another girl working behind the counter chimed in to say, "if you dont like it then you can buy your ice cream around the corner at oinks". at this point i figured the high school girls lacked thorough customer service training and i kindly asked to speak to the manager, at which point i was told, "he doesnt want to speak to you". if the beach wasnt across the street i would have thought i was at the weiner circle! 1 star for rude service and 1 more star for a whopping 77 flavors! read more

For a tiny little corner ice cream stand/food place this was great. Didn't try the food, but they had so many ice cream flavors to choose from! Got the triple peanut butter and coconut cream ice cream. Triple peanut butter was mediocre but the coconut cream was one of the best I have ever had. Also they have 2 lines so if the line out front looks too long for you, remember that you can also order inside :) read more

Surprised!!!! Burgers tasted A lot like In n Out! Fries as well. Can't complain out that

My wife and I took a brief trip to New Buffalo in the middle of the week based on a recommendation from some friends. Nancy's was right down the street from our hotel so we had to try it out. I saw the sign for Famous Strawberry Shakes and thought that that was probably just a gimmick because strawberry shakes aren't anything special. So, I had to try one and I am a believer-it was delicious. All the ingredients were fresh and tasty and the strawberries had the right amount of tart and sweet. Also, the shake was creamy and there were plenty of delicious chunks of fruit. It had the perfect blend of milky and fruity. read more

I enjoyed my amaretto cherry shake. I didn't try the food, but was pleased with the ice cream and the shakes. The line got long after I ordered, but if you time it well, you can get your ice cream quickly. There is an outside line for just ice cream and treats and the inside line is if you want a hot dog or whatever. Enjoy! read more

This place has the best strawberry milkshake I've ever had, so thick with chunks of strawberry that you can chew it and have to suck it up with one of those big fat straws. Haven't tried the actual food yet. The big drawback to this place is that the kids manning the counter are pretty casual about opening up on time and could use some training in customer service. read more

located in the tourist area of downtown new buffalo michigan and walking distance to the beach...ice creams and shakes are good, with fresh fruits and ingredients...they pretty much can make any combinations of shakes you want even if it's not on the menu...i can't comment else on the other items they serve since I only get the ice creams and shakes when we come here...don't bother eating inside since it's very tight, just grab your food to go, find a bench along the sidewalk, and chow down while people watching... read more

Nancy's - nancy can shake! - Hot Dogs Near Me - New Buffalo, Michigan

This place has so many ice cream flavors - it took me a while to decide what to get. I ended up getting Smores, which was pretty good! I only gave it 4 stars because we got 2 single scoop waffle cones, and it cost around $12, which I think is a little expensive for ice cream. read more

Best strawberry milkshake ever. Always look forward to this place when summertime comes around. Typically go to Stray Dog across the street then wander over to Nancy's for the shake. A bit busy at times, but they work quickly. read more

Never be dismayed by three stars, ever. You've got to go in with an open mind and a forgiving stomach. Nancy's did not disappoint at all and it didn't have to hit any high notes either! We weren't feeling very hungry but decided to split a burger anyway. What we got was great service and prompt warm, warm food. The portions were just right and the value was spot on. I wish we had tried the ice cream as mentioned in the other reviews, but maybe on another trip. If you want a quick bit plus ice cream, for a decent price, you can't go wrong with Nancy's. read more

Best Chicago Dogs and Strawberry Shakes in town!!!! The Philly Cheesesteak sandwiches are also great- good flavor beef with soft French bread rolls. Served piping hot! Always a line for ice cream, shakes and food, so be prepared to wait a little bit. Totally worth it though. A must stop here location for all who visit New Buffalo. read more

We stopped in this sleepy town of new buffalo on the way to northern michigan. Perfect place to grab a nice juicy burger, fries, and a yummy fresh milkshake. Loses one star for needing an update on their outside picnic tables read more

1st Strawberry Shakes are awesome, real strawberry chunks are key. 2nd the burgers are great they butter then toast their buns so they have a little crunch, yum. 3rd Dean is probably one of the nicest people to run a restaurant in New Buff. Lots of local kids working there just as a beach town spot should. read more

Four of us went to Nancy's for a treat to cool down. The line was pretty long the whole weekend we were there so that made us want to try it out since people were willing to wait in line for that long. We definitely were not disappointed! The ice cream was amazing! I personally had cookies and cream in a cup as it was too hot to have in a cone. It was worth the wait in line. The guy who took our order was extremely friendly and helpful. This is definitely a stop I will make when in town. read more

Great fries...GREAT icecream but the rest was sub-par. I also didn't like how the kids basically running the place sat and talked and fooled around instead of actually trying to help people. read more

Good ice cream but the workers aren't really paying to the customers waiting on the line. There were more than enough workers there at 4:00 on a Tuesday. Wish the kiddie scoop was posted on the board. read more

I love Nancy's- It's one of the first stops each time I'm in New Buffalo! They have every flavor you could imagine and then some. The staff are high schoolers working hard for their money and are very sweet. Definitely recommend! read more

Stopped in for ice cream and the famous strawberry shake. The ice cream was very good and they had a ton of selections. If you like having ice cream options, this is your place. I am quite fond of strawberry shakes and I have to say that I've had better, but it was still pretty good. I asked them why it was famous and they couldn't give me an answer. It was still a mystery after drinking it. read more

The owner is awesome, he treats everyone like family. Today when I went he handed me an empty cone and a scoop and told me to try all the new flavors I wanted to, all of which were amazing by the way because this is the best ice cream in the world! It is a close walk to the beach in a beautiful little town and going to Nancy's is a delightful experience. read more

Great ice cream, so much to choose from. Great location. I came back after walking along the beach for another scoop. My husband & I had been here 10 years ago and thought they would be gone. read more

A lot of ice cream choices, very good flavors. Didn't try anything elsebut will next time in new buffalo. There was always a line, that has to say something! read more

I ordered 4 pizza puffs and got back to my hotel room to discover 3 in the bag (a 2 block walk). I also Ordered a bratwurst to be cut in half to share. They didn't cut it in half and I had to rip it. 75 cents extra for hardly any sauerkraut. When I walked bag and complained, the teenage cashier was nonchalant. No apology. read more

This place is the worst. There are about 6 teenagers running around (and into each other) trying to figure out who is doing what. There were two cooks making the hotdogs/hamburgers. I ordered a cheeseburger, a chicken salad sandwich (that was a mistake) and three hot dogs. They served the two people who ordered AFTER me and I asked where my food was. He said I ordered more food than other people so it would take longer. My hamburger and chicken salad were already on a tray waiting for hot dogs. I pointed it out to him and said I just need 3 hot dogs and the cook said I needed to take it easy and not get mad. When I got my subpar food, he said, "have a nice day," very sarcastic. Did I mention it took 40 minutes to get this. NEVER going back again. There are too many food places right on that street. read more

Great food and great service. We were there on a busy Sunday afternoon and I was very pleased with the speed of service - the line was long, but it did not take a long time to order and get our food. Food was great - and the ice cream was wonderful! read more

We waited line for 25 minutes and finally left. There were many customers who were cutting ahead of us by simply walking inside to order. We finally left after it seemed they were getting the orders wrong. They may of had an off night and perhaps they were just too busy. read more

Delicious ice cream every time! There was a 20 minute wait for the ice cream because of their popularity on a weekend evening. But the staff was still patient and courteous to each customer. read more

I mean... its only fast food... so you get exactly what you expect. But the strawberry shake is FANTASTIC. They also have a nice outdoor area for seating, if you are interested, and live music from time to time. read more

Good ice cream, average service. We grabbed ice cream here one night. The selection was good and so was the flavor. The service was okay, but not overly friendly or helpful. read more

Great, casual spot to take your family for some delicious hot dogs and ice cream! Very friendly staff and we love the outdoor space!