Highly recommend! We are in town from the DC area and were super impressed with the freshness and…read moreflavor of the pizza. Also love the fact that they have vegan cheese for our vegan daughter. Ordering online could not have been easier and we all appreciated the infinite customizable options. We are a picky bunch and they got everything perfect and delivered so quickly. This place is a win!

I am beyond angry. We came here straight from the beach because a local gluten free group would not…read morestop raving about this place. As the mother of a gluten free toddler, and gluten free myself, I trusted that recommendation completely. I will never make that mistake again. Walking in, the place was flat out disgusting. A trash can shoved directly under the soda machine, jammed against a booth, flies swarming around it like nobody had cleaned in days. FLIES. Next to the soda machine. The only open table and booths were dirty. Like, more than crumbs. We should have walked straight back out the door but we didn't, because we were exhausted and had a 3 hour drive home, and we thought, "How bad could it be?" Incredibly bad, it turns out. The "gluten free" crust was thin, flimsy, and burnt around the edges. And the aftermath has been brutal. My toddler and I have both been glutened so badly we are sick, in pain, and completely wiped out the day after what was supposed to be a fun family trip. Instead of beach memories, I'm nursing my kid through cramps and misery because this place could not be bothered to handle allergen prep or basic cleanliness properly. If you have celiac disease or a real gluten allergy, stay far away from this place. Whatever cross contamination is happening in that kitchen is dangerous, not just inconvenient. I don't care how many people recommend it, the risk is not worth it. We will never go back, and I will be telling everyone I know to avoid it too.

Pizza is dull and tasteless. Same Pizza Hut experience wherever you go. I prefer real Italian pizza…read moreand not a cheap knockoff.

Horrible! the worst order ever. First, when we went to pick up the order it took my wife having to…read moreopen the door several times and tapping on the counter with her keys to get service! Second, we arrived home and we had like 2 inches of bread on the sides and like three in the corners. Toppings were in shape of a circle when we ordered the square pizza (big box) it seems like they have a bunch of lazy employees that do not like their job. I did not return it because my little daughter was really hungry and also to avoid them doing something to our next order for returning it! This has been the worst order that we have ever received and worst customer service. If they dont like their job send them to get a new one! Sorry but not returning nor recommending!

We moved down from Chesapeake VA and the only place to deliver was Dominos in Moyock and trust me,…read morethey were no prize but when you live in the country with limited options you just accept mediocre food. Well, our opinion of Dominos changed once we ordered from our new home spot. Our pizza has always arrived hot and looking as though there was a lot of care put into our meal. The quality being as if they were feeding their own family. When my husband chooses to pick up he always comes home saying the folks here are super friendly and nice. Something we are not used to in Chesapeake. I'm a pizza hut girl but I do love Doms bbq chicken and it is always yummy!

We used to order takeaway a lot from this location. However, the last few times they have burnt our…read morefood to a char. I am not sure why they think it's acceptable to give people burnt food. I wouldn't mind crispy around the edges, as that adds a bit of flavor, but when entire bites of food are darkened and burned, it's wasteful and disgusting. I didn't order charcoal to be eaten. The restaurant has parking but no dine-in area.

Don't let the location fool you! They make amazing pizza! I grew up on Godfathers Pizza and had…read morethought that they went out of business. This was the first time I had heard the name in so long that I wasn't sure if it was the same pizza place. It was recommended that we try their pizza and not knowing if it was the same pizza as my childhood, I ordered a basic pepperoni pizza and found that it tasted the same as the pizza from my childhood! That's why I say don't let the location fool you! Yes, they are located right next to a gas station, but they have good foodies, friendly staff, and the wait time isn't bad. If you're wanting to try something different from the other pizza places, I say give Godfathers a try!

I wish they had their own restaurant sad that one of the best pizza places in Jacksonville is in a…read moregas station

First time visitor. Excellent customer service. Small but might NY style pizza shop. Great flavor…read moreand a reasonable cost. Me & Bae ate pizza but I spotted some awesome looking subs/grinders across the room. We will definitely be back. Slice arrived piping hot with a crispy crust. Don't be afraid to get the balsamic drizzle on the house pie. They even have draft beer! The only tiny quibble bit is that the ranch isn't house made but don't let that stop you!

We got the Buffaroni pizza which is pepperoni with ranch, buffalo, and hot honey. I enjoyed the…read moretoppings. Both my husband and I agreed the pizza was undercooked. I would suggest ordering well done for a fully cooked pizza. The service was order at the counter and they were very polite. We would give it 3.5/5 stars.

Thank you to Sugar Hill Pizzeria for hooking us up with a free pizza after a long night working a…read moregas leak outside the pizzeria. The guys from Wright Traffic of NC appreciate you greatly. The pizza is great and the staff are friendly.

Really tasty food! Quick service and friendly staff too! Will definitely be back if I come to this…read morearea again!

Went here on a recommendation to grab a slice for lunch. I loved the white pizza and my husband…read moreenjoyed the pepperoni sausage. We had a salad which was a bit disappointing, but it didn't matter because the pizza was so good. Would absolutely get this pizza again next time we're in town. The crust was amazingly good. Highly recommend.

Fentoni's is the perfect pit stop when you're in full beach-and-boardwalk mode. This is their slice…read moreshop right in the heart of the action, serving up a variety of pizzas by the slice. No waiting forever, no breaking the bank. You order at the counter, they pop your slice in the oven, and a few minutes later you've got that crispy NY-style crust in hand. The pizza is solid all around.Classic flavors done right, nothing overly fancy, just dependable, tasty slices that hit the spot. Perfect for a quick lunch break before heading back to the sand or catching the next boardwalk event. Not a life-changing pie, but for speed, price, and location, it's a winner.