Trust the positive reviews - this place is great. Drive-up service on New Year's Day was friendly, easy and quick, and they included plates and plastic cutlery for us since we were staying in a hotel. Homemade dressing on the Greek salad was really good, but the standout was the grilled chicken-spinach-feta pizza. So glad we got the square pizza so we have leftovers to look forward to. Could not have been a better experience to kick off 2021! read more

Terrible establishment. Mediocre atmosphere, a plethora of drunk, belligerent patrons, seemingly intoxicated owners, and the aroma of slightly old cheese and vegetables greet you as you walk through the poorly painted door. You hear screams and angry yells in Greek from the kitchen- the owners talking to their employees in the most rude manner I've ever witnessed in my life. The food is marvelously boring and could be bought anywhere else for a much cheaper price. Would never recommend to anyone. Also they never pick up the phone so don't even waste your time trying to place an order. read more

Hi. I'd like two slices and a cup of water please. We're only selling water because there's a shortage in town (as she points to a handwritten sign on the wall). Lol. Seriously? That's the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Cheap, cheap, cheap. I hope you people are at least using your precious water to wash your hands after using the bathroom. No, they didn't get a bottled water sale from me. I sit here now eating two average slices of pizza with nothing to wash them down with. Never again will I visit here and I'm a year round resident. read more

I recently visited Chatham and stopped here. It was my wife, my 8 year old daughter and myself. We ordered a large cheese pizza and a bottle of water for my daughter. We got our number and waited. Then the people that came in after we did who ordered double the food including a pizza had their order ready. Odd, but OK. Then more people got their food who clearly ordered when they came arrived after us. I finally went up after 25 minutes of waiting on 1 pizza and said, we are still waiting on our pizza and she turns towards the kitchen and just said, so are we. No sorry about that or it will just be another minute. Well, it was another 10 or so minutes when the pizza came and not even any gesture of sorry it took so long. If I had to guess, they accidentally gave our pizza to the family after us and then didn't realize it until I came up to the counter asking. If they had just acknowledged that it was taking longer than usual it would have been fine, but no. Nothing. Then on top of that the pizza left little to desire. It wasn't worth the cost. It wasn't worth the wait. All set. read more

buyer beware. this is coming from a:local. sewing needle found in pizza today. pulled out of mouth. was serving to small children!! old band-aid found in pizza. big clump of hair in pizza. owner's response: "if you don't like it, go somewhere else" simple as that. judge for yourself. i usually don't post negative remarks but this was outright dangerous. read more

After trying this joint, I'd rather eat frozen pizza straight out of the freezer. Bland and over priced.

This is the world's best pizza and the world's best spot. Ask anyone in Chatham that this is really the best around. This place has been around my entire life - this is that kind of place and you will bring your families year after year. I'm not sure what the other reviewers are talking about but New England Pizza regulars are many and will all tell you that this is worth the trip (don't get delivery, come enjoy the AC after the beach and bring a quarter or two for your kids to play the arcade game) read more

I've been coming here since I was a teenager. Owners are great people, pizza is consistent, and the Greek salad is excellent. It was just recently renovated, and actually offers delivery which is nice because that's hard to find around here! read more

When we went the pizza was very bland and below mediocre. There were no options for large bottles or pitchers of drinks like at most pizza places, so everyone in our large party got their own individual drinks. We had heard good recommendations, but nobody in our party enjoyed the food or experience. I'd recommend trying any other pizza place on the cape first. read more

Walked in without much expectation, and found the pizza here to be mouth-watering, melt-in-your mouth good. The large size pizza comes in square sizes and is easy to grab and eat. We tried both custom order and plain cheese pizza and they were both fabulous. It has a large parking space which drew us in...given it's hard to find parking in Main st. Nothing pretentious, kid friendly, and run by family owners. Only complaint is they tend to be a bit slow...but well worth the wait! The only reason I give it 4 stars is because the restaurant interior and decor are what you'd typically find in a local pizza shop. read more

Recently remodeled. Pizza is always great. If you want pizza it is hard to beat this place

Medium pizza with meatball is the best thing you can order. I ate the whole thing for dinner. It was very fulfilling and came at a decent price. It is close to home and tastes amazing. They have some of the pizza around, and I highly recommend stopping for a bite if you can. This place is a go. read more

2.5. It has gone downhill with the new owner. I really only go there because it's close. The salads are great, but the pizza is greasy and gross. The staff is often unfriendly and the tv shows on are not appropriate for kids. read more

We ordered for delivery. This is a great place if you want cold pizza with the taste and texture of cardboard. And the wings were also cold and over cooked. Yum.... read more

Could find better, I hope. I'm spoiled being from NJ/NYC when it comes to pizza. Their crust is sort of crunchy, somewhat sweet, all together not good. That said, I ate 5 slices, because pizza is pizza and it is rarely inedible. read more

No ambiance but plenty of local character. Fast, friendly & very good pizza - classic New England style.

Sometimes you can judge a book by its cover. This place has seen better days. If you want to see a tired restaurant, try it out. If you need the bathrooms, leave the restaurant, go around back and go through a sketchy door. Enough said? read more

The pizza tasted like cardboard. Also, they messed up not only on our pizza order but also on our sandwich order. There are plenty of other places nearby that are better options. read more

My daughter and I came to the Cape for the first time to visit family. Very hot outside do to a heat wave in the area and we were looking for a cool place to chill and grab some lunch. Very good food, best cheese blend I've ever had for a pizza, and not too busy. Hopefully people will read yelp and go visit New England Pizza... read more

We were in from out of town for a night for a wedding. We had lunch here and we ate some of the best subs I've ever had. The bread was amazing. Service was great! The older woman who helped us was amazingly sweet. It was simple and easy which was just what we wanted! read more

I go there often. The food is excellent. I have never had a bad meal. The Steak and cheese Sub with mushrooms, onions and peppers is the best I have ever had in my life, and I eat out a lot. The pizza is fabulous. I have recently started watching what I'm eating and decided to get a Greek salad with grilled chicken. It was unbelievable. If you eat there they put it in a large wooden bowl and give you silverware as opposed to the average type place that crams it in a crappy aluminum container and gives you plastic forks that bend so badly you can barely eat. This place puts love in all of their meals and it really makes a difference. The owner is very nice and personable as is the woman who take your order. Honestly I am hard pressed to find such a place anywhere. Real quality food and real quality people running the place. Family owned and run from what I can see. You will not be disappointed. read more

New England Pizza - Grilled chicken Greek salad. Awesome - Pizza Near Me - Chatham, Massachusetts

We ordered a pizza and salad for takeout over the phone. We were told it would be ready in 20 minutes. We arrived in 15 or 20 minutes, paid for the pizza and proceeded to wait for another 40 minutes. We finally went up to the counter and asked what the deal was with our pizza because we had been waiting for a long time and the irritated gentlemen said it was ready and we were "all set". It wasn't all set as another employee came up and gave us our salad. The gentleman was annoyed with us for questioning our order. Our pizza was not hot, and the crust was burnt. They had clearly forgotten about us and made us wait until we said something and then gave us an attitude about it. The previous week i had a problem getting someone's attention behind the counter. I had to lift my arms and say "hello" to get her attention. We will NEVER go here again. read more

Basic no-frills pizzeria. Tasty but somewhat oily pies. Good for families or a quick meal. They also have pasta dishes and salads. Different from NY pizza but one of the better pizza places on the Cape. read more

New England house of pizza is an awesome family owned restaurant that my family and I have been going to for years. Get the Greek salad...it is bomb. Onion pizza is also a winner. Awesome people here and a good atmosphere for families. read more

Will not go there anymore. Used to go there all the time. Not fancy but reliable decent meal. But now that we have little kids the video games in the dining room are totally inappropriate. Games with guns attached that children shoot with. Terrible and inappropriate. Not at all family friendly. read more

This used to be one of my favorite places to grab something quick for dinner. I ordered a personal pizza that took half an hour to come out and was on a par with frozen Mamma Celeste with extra parm cheese on top. This place has lost it since new owners took over. read more

Excellent pizza, we ordered the "New England Special", also ordered a Greek salad with grilled chicken which was fantastic (btw the olives were not pitted), also ordered mild buffalo wings. Everything was great, timely and friendly delivery and great prices! read more

Awesome pizza but the Greek Salad is the best. Fresh ingredients and the dressing is so good they even sell it separately. Fun atmosphere - good, casual for the entire family. Highly recommend. read more

I like it. It's decent Greek style pizza shop. The prices are reasonable. They deliver now and I like it. Bottom line is that this a solid choice in an expensive town. read more

Should have gotten dominoes. Actually, we would have, if it was available. So greasy. Step your game up. I love pizza and this was pretty lame. read more

If you order from the menu that is displayed behind the counter the item written as "Grilled chicken walnut pecan salad" and order it in those words, most people would expect grilled chicken with that salad. However, when I ordered that salad it came in a small take-out container and was only lettuce and a few nuts and it was $9! I went back in and the woman behind the counter said that the chicken is an added cost?! There was no where on the menu that stated the chicken would cost more... Salad was not tasty at all and the dressing was a pink tub of sugary liquid. I would never go back again! read more

An older Greek woman seems to work there and she said all is homemade and they even had baklava. We only got pizza but it was very good, nice and crispy crust, really liked it. Wasn't noisy as we went at lunch time and it was empty but some people were coming in to pick up pizzas they ordered. We never like paying $4 per beer but did it. I just really liked the pizza. read more

I love their pizza. Perfect Greek style. And they have the best salad dressing that you can buy in a bottle to take w you. Perfect place for an affordable dinner. read more

Ok pizza.. basic salad, basic everything. beer and wine available. Dined on rainy July 4th and they were very busy which may be why the service was slow and food sub par. I can't recommend this place. read more

I ordered 2 pizzas from here, they were the most tasteless pizzas I've ever had. The marinara sauce had zero flavor, the BBQ chicken had no BBQ flavor, the pizzas were under cooked. I will not be ordering from here again. They could really stand to use some spice in/on their piazza. read more

As a celiac, it is not easy to find good pizza that you can trust is gluten free. Upper Crust in East Harwich also has GF pizza but it tastes like frozen. This place has the closest I have ever seen to "real" pizza -- I had a small pepperoni GF pizza and it was almost like the real thing!! They do it in a separate oven instead of just a separate pan. Very Greek atmosphere, nice people. We ordered to take out and they were boxing it on time as I arrived. Will be doing this again. Only reason for the 4 stars is that the place had a table that had not yet been cleared and a bunch of people standing around for take out. Not sure I would be thrilled with that if I were eating in. read more