Crazy pizza thin crust, ask to have well done so the middle bottom is crispy. Great crust, sauce and sausage. Wings were very crispy too. A bunch of location in Lg. Great service and dog friendly patio. We will be back! read more

Great pizza and beer! The service is quick and attentive. It's in a great location and far enough from all the tourists downtown.

Excellent gluten-free menu! The cheeseburger pizza is delicious and unique. We will definitely be back to try other options.

Our first time here. It was a great experience. We had the spinach artichoke dip with flatbread for an appetizer. Also ordered a Geneva Pub Salad and a small garbage pizza. Everything tasted great! The service was fantastic too. Our server Carmella was the best. Thanks to all at the Next Door Pub! read more

We ordered the pizza and it was one of the best. We are from Chicago and have tried lots of different pizzas.

Pizza rated as best in the county seems well deserved! Cheese pizza for the kids and pepperoni green pepper for the adults. The circle pizza cut into small squares was great for vacation sharing and child portions. Seemed a little loud inside but we were carry out. read more

Short and sweet review. Next Door Pub is simply the best restaurant in Lake Geneva. I've been eating there for over 40 years. Best pizza outside of Chicago and the Supreme beef sandwiches and hamburgers are excellent. Next time you're in Lake Geneva try it and you'll agree with me. read more

Really enjoyed this spot. Somehow this was our first time here. Not sure how we haven't come before. The place was crowded on a Tuesday night but I guess it is still tourist season. We were seated right away. Our waitress was very nice and helpful. She was prompt with drinks and take our order. The food came out and it was great. I got the grilled chicken sandwich with broccoli. The chicken was cooked wonderfully. I really enjoyed it. The broccoli was good also. My friends enjoyed their food too. One got the southwest chicken and the other got Italian beef. Prices were good. We will be back for sure! Huge menu and so much looked good. read more

See all

This place is terrible. Their website promises delivery but in fact they don't deliver. But they will call you and tell you to pick it up, cold pizza, yum! Never again. Over priced and over rated read more

I came here expecting delicious pizza, but, not only was the pizza amazing, the ribs, meatballs, lasagna, and salad was all so tasty! The waiters are very nice and accommodating, the food is great and the price is reasonable! My only complaint is the wait, it's first come, first serve so the wait was supposed to be 30 minutes but after we put our name in there was an open table to take which was a bit confusing. read more

Is this the best pizza or what? We spend the summer here and all the time we are away I long for the pizza. The entire menu is great but I eat pizza more often. If you can't finish it take it home warm it up and enjoy it all over again. There is not much Moe to say after you have said it is the best except for go early as a crowd forms quickly most days. Back again in 2019 and find everything remains exactly as before. Thank God. read more

Came in with 20 people for a 50th Birthday get together. Alex, Maria and all staff were amazing. Made room for us! Pizza here is my favorite for the last 20 years and my husband knew that. Thank you!!! read more

Next Door Pub - Next Door Pub - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

I was blown away by this place. Got there around 8pm on a Sunday and had to wait half an hour -- seemed odd that a place would have that kind of wait on a Sunday evening at that time. We waited since we were already there and they have a very nice outdoor seating area. My group ordered the BBQ Pulled Pork Cheese Fries -- we were all AMAZED. I didn't know I needed that in my life!!! So tasty and that could've been a meal in itself. Then my friend got the Lasagna, I got the Portabella Mushroom and Fresh Mozzarella Ravioli, and my other friend got short rib ravioli -- tried all of those and they were all fantastic. Honestly wasn't expecting the food to be as amazing as it was, but the long wait late at night made sense then. Definitely will be coming back here !! 10/10!! read more

Next Door Pub - Bb - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Very friendly local restaurant. Service is excellent and food is very good and a lot of it.

We ordered delivery tonight and our driver was very sweet and polite. The pizzas were delicious and they were right on time. I'm super pleased with choosing Next Door Pub tonight- keep up the good work read more

Ok first time reviewing but this is a must stop whenever im in LG. They have the best pizza in LG. I would suggest asking for it to be cooked slightly more for a crispier crust but i throw it in a toaster oven when i get home because not everyone likes a crispy crust. The cheese fries with pulled pork and BBQ is so filling its for sure a 2 person app. Also this place is always busy and isnt that large inside so be prepared to wait a bit but its totally worth it. read more

Next Door Pub - half cheese half sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Excellent food! PERIOD! Great for years! The kind of place you are always comfortable in and a casual pub & pizza.

After some spectacular failures in the dining out department in Lake Geneva, we settled on this place for lunch. Huge burgers, pretty tasty too! The pretzel fries were definitely a hit... We liked those very much. Good drinks, good food, good service. read more

See all

I love their pizza and their service After collecting 20 coupons for a free pizza I was denied After many years of a loyal customer that I believe was not the way to handle my request I will still order my pizza from the pub, but I'm disappointed with their policy from a true pub fan read more

Cool spot, good food and good vibe. Ate at the bar, bartender was a pro...old school. It's a great off the water Lake Geneva place, always a good stop to escape the hustle and bustle of lakeside spots read more

This place is great! For food I ordered the The pubs bbq porker, and it was was ok. The meat was dry and a little under sauced for my taste. Service was great had no complaints about staff.Pulled Pork Sandwich read more

Next Door Pub - The Pub's BBQ Porker. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Awful just awful, food was decent. Horrible service had tons of problems. Would not recommend, especially if you have a large group. Tale your bus elsewhere. read more

Fantastic food and a shout out to their wait staff, especially Destiny. We were a table full of people which always makes me wonder if someone's order is going to be wrong, and that certainly was not the case. The food was fantastic, and the atmosphere was fun and family friendly. I will certainly be back read more

Stopped in for a quick dinner one night and really enjoyed the food. The lasagna special is probably the best deal in town on a Wednesday night. A plate full of lasagne with a soup/salad for less then $8 I think. I dug into some wings as an appetizer and they were delicious. Tons of meat and the two sauces we tried had us licking our fingers. Something to keep in mind is that their blue cheese is homemade. I played it easy with a bacon cheeseburger and it was really good! The beef is supposedly from the Lake Genever Country Meats butcher and it sure tasted better than most the beef you'll get at a diner. The menu is pretty expansive so you're bound to find something that you enjoy. The aesthetic is pretty old fashioned. Carpeted floors, wood panelled walls, and basically picnic tables with an unorganized assortment of condiments and some video gaming contraption. The clutter definitely interferes with the space you have on the table to enjoy your meal. Our server was kind and very assistive. I will make one comment though that is crucial in any restaurant, do NOT act disappointed when customers just order water to drink. Listen, I understand you're trying to increase a ticket as high as you can to incur a higher tip, but if people just want water act just as excited as you do when people order a cocktail and a round of shots. We went ahead and ordered appetizers so there ya go. I'd definitely return and try another dish or whatever is on special! read more

Next Door Pub - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Can not say enough about this place!!! Great food, employees, prices and service! Got takeout the first night and it was so good we got it again the next. I doubt you'll find a better value in Lake Geneva!!! If you want some great food tell them Consuelo recommended you! read more

Great (huge!) wings with unique flavor choices. We also tried and loved the fried pickles, mushrooms, and cheese curds. Nice casual place with tasty food and drinks. read more

Next Door Pub - Huge wings! - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

This has been our favorite family place for 20 years, food is always great, staff is so awesome and helpful. we always know we can come here as a couple or a group of 20 with grandchildren and the service will be awesome. a special shout out to Amanda for making us feel at home for so many years. read more

This place is yummy and hit all the right taste buds and lived up to expectations. Service was terrific. The wedge salad with its blue cheese salad was amazing. And the pizza was delicious and heated up well the next day. I look forward to trying different items on their menu. read more

This place is absolutely disgusting. My table ordered fettuccine Alfredo two pizzas and pulled pork sandwich the Alfredo was absolutely from a can. The sauce wasn't even mixed in the breadstick that I came with on the side it was 100% either microwavable or came like that in a package the steak that I ordered on the side it tasted like the defrosted it in the microwave gave it to me with a few shakes of Salt in it. Rubber! And the pulled pork sandwich came with a side of chips that were overdone. The only decent thing about this place was the staff. There is so many other beautiful and better places in Geneva don't waste your time here. read more

Next Door Pub - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

This is by far the best food place in Lake Geneva!! All their food was amazing and delicious! The waiter we had was friendly and very helpful! The pizza was great, the pretzel was by far the best we have ever tasted!! Every time we come to lake Geneva this will be our place to stop for good food! Do yourself a favor and just go and you won't regret it! read more

Super pizza and beef sandwiches. You can't go wrong with the rest of the menu either. Great food, atmosphere, and prices too!

This place is amazing! If you are in town, run! Be prepared to wait but 100% worth the wait. I wish they had put their cheese soup as the dipping sauce. read more

Next Door Pub - Giant Pub Pretzel - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Great food and excellent service First time there and the wings were amazing. Pizza was very good and will definitely be back. read more

My family and I are in Lake Geneva for a long weekend and when looking for someplace to eat, we couldn't not come here with all the high reviews between Yelp, TripAdvisor and Google. We were all impressed with our meals. I got the Short Rib Ravioli without mushrooms on top and it was amazing! My husband loved it too. He got the Yuengling Beer Battered Cod. He said it was good but liked mine better. The kids ordered off the kids menu - Mac and Cheese and Buttered Cavatappi. The serving sizes were quite large and all but my husband brought leftovers back to the hotel. We have more family joining us this weekend and will recommend we all go here again for a meal. read more

There are few places that always make their guests feel so welcome. Bartenders and staff are phenomenal they work so hard to accommodate a very busy place. Great food Generous portions we LOVE the pizza there is no better around!!! If you are looking for a casual dining experience with great food and a wonderful staff this is it!! read more

Great food, something for everyone and reasonably priced. My family's new Lake Geneva stop.

Stopped in for a quick lunch which was absolutely delightful! The food was delicious! The staff was super friendly and the place just had an overall great vibe. If I could give it 6 stars, I would. Stop in, try it and Yelp away.... read more

Next Door Pub - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

I recently lunched at the Next Door Pub in Lake Geneva with clients (very casual holiday get-together) and was really quite pleased. Our server was friendly, polite, and courteous; she was also quite patient, as it took us some time to order our drinks and appetiser. The large pretzel is enormous, and arrived very fast, piping-hot and thoroughly delicious. It comes with several dipping sauces, all of which are spicy-hot and wonderful. NB The pretzel is sufficient for four persons, quite easily. We ordered a 14" pizza with toppings (sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions); it arrived piping-hot, oozing with cheese and blanketed with toppings. There is no skimping on ingredients here! NB The 14" pizza is perfect for four persons; believe me, two people can't even begin to finish this. Service was prompt, attentive, and polite throughout; we were never short of water, coffee, or sodas (I had a bloodie to start). The Bloody Mary was hot, spicy, and delicious, loaded with garnishes (jalapenos, salami, olives, celery), served with a beer chaser. The atmosphere is vibrant, lively, noisy, and fun; there were several families there as well as take-out orders, etc. But, we were never felt rushed or hurried; our server (a very nice young lady) made us feel welcome, throughout. I thoroughly enjoyed my visit to The Next Door Pub and will definitely plan to return, quite soon! read more

Next Door Pub - The big pretzel...is a really big pretzel; it is hot and delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Visiting a local resort and the in house restaurant was closed. Jumped on my trustworthy yelp and low and behold, I come across this restaurant. I WANT TO MOVE TO LAKE GENEVA AND EAT HERE EVERYDAY. Their homemade "chips", ham and swiss, cheese curds, OH MY. My hubby loved his burger too. When I ordered online, I thought, 45 mins-1hr. Delivery in 20ish mins. THANK YOU! And when back in Lake Geneva, we'll physically enjoy your restaurant and eat there vs delivery. read more

We went on a Wednesday evening and the place was packed. Great food and great service . There is a bar area as well as separate dining. I highly recommend the lasagna! They are known for the pizza . We will have to try next time read more