Cancel

Open app

Search

Nicholas Pizza House

3.4 (49 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian
Closed 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

Order Nicholas Pizza House Takeout or Delivery

Nicholas Pizza House Photos

NICHOLAS PIZZA HOUSE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Quiet
Good for kids
Good for groups

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Nicholas Pizza House

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Crystal T.

Nicholas Pizza House has delicious pizza!! As the longest serving pizza house in Torrington they deserve more recognition than they get! The owner is friendly and always great with our kids who love that their pizza is cut into squares! I recommend trying them, you will not be disappointed!

My cheeseburger is still raw. You can see it is still pink. And my fries were not even done.

My cheeseburger was raw and you can see the pink. My fries were not even done. I will never eat here again.

Calzones with dipping sauce
Melissa R.

Pepperoni calzones was phenomenal. Homemade dipping sauce he should bottle and sell. I could only eat half, took the rest home.

Pepperoni slice, at Nicholas Pizza House in Torrington, CT.
Tom D.

I should've known better, when you see a pizza place with the name "Nicholas", it's going to be Greek pizza. And Greek pizza generally is not good. Fortunately, I just stopped for a slice. Yeah, it's your standard Greek stuff -- greasy, no flavor sauce, and spongy crust. What more can I say ? A lot of people apparently like this type of pizza, because there are plenty of Greek places in the state of Connecticut, and many have been in business for a long time. I'm just not one of the those people.

Salad not edible
Rebecca L.

One word to describe my delivery from Nicholas Pizza House: EW! I ordered a salad which came with brown lettuce and rotting cucumbers. The pizza was undercooked and raw in the middle. I thought I'd take a chance on this old Torrington standard, but never again! I basically just threw $25 out the window because this is not edible.

Hair in White Pizza
Diana B.

Pizza was okay. The bottom of the pizza gets soggy quick and the quality of the pizza dough is not great. Also, don't get the garlic bread. I took one bite and I've never had garlic bread that bad. Especially because it's very simple to make decent garlic bread. Although, the main reason for my bad review was the hair in my pizza! After the pizza had gotten cold enough for the cheese to harden, I took a slice. After a couple bites, I saw and pulled out a black hair from underneath the hardened cheese. There is many other pizza places in Torrington. I will not be returning.

Outside at night
Amanda S.

Dated decor inside- definitely one of those hole in the wall places that has been around forever. (not a bad thing!) A small pizza is *definitely* small and the garlic bread was pretty huge. We thought the pizza (a small pepperoni, onion & mushroom) was pretty basic. The crust reminded me of my mom's homemade crust- a plus- but it definitely lacked something as a whole. In my husband's words, "It was lacking some love". Not the worst pizza we've had but we won't be going out of our way to go again.

Angie S.

Ordered a small pizza and a piece of chocolate cake from this establishment. Paid $25 for delivery to the ER as I am essential employee. Not only was the pizza incorrect when I called to let them know they refused to make it right. Didn't seem to care and argued with me on the phone. His exact statement was " why would I waste my time and money when you (me) ordered the wrong thing. When in reality it was their error not mine, I ordered what it was called on their menu. When I said I would not be back he said "great" and hung up. Horrible horrible customer service. Especially as he is the owner of the restaurant.

Vegetarian Pizza...get one; and one for later.
Michael M.

I'm 55. I've been all over the world. This is the BEST pie I've ever eaten. We walked in and there was a party in the next room; 4 moms and 15 10-ish year old girls having a blast. The owner had to move a Pinata someone gifted him off a two-top so we could sit down...it felt like we were joining a family for dinner...and we were. The owner sent a young lady to help us. He walked her through it; from 10 feet away...give them a menu, tell them we now have draft beer... I ordered a beer and my wife the veggie pizza. Although we ordered only one, the young lady brought my wife a beer too (so I had to drink that). We had an order of delicious crispy fries while waiting for our pizza...which took about 30 minutes. Meanwhile, the owner came over to chat twice. He also had the young lady carry pizza's to go, to an elderly lady's car, and he made a fresh batch of Zepolli (Italian donuts) for us and the girls. Bottom line, If you're looking for fine dining or a fancy place; this might not float your boat. But, if you want to meet a great owner who knows how to treat people and you want a great pizza, slide on a pair of jeans and get the pie here.

Blt Triple decker with fries

See all

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Nicholas Pizza House Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Nicholas Pizza House

Review Highlights - Nicholas Pizza House

Ninoos and Danny are really cool guys.

Mentioned in 3 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 3,993 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Geppetto Osteria E Bisteccheria

Geppetto Osteria E Bisteccheria

4.3
(70 reviews)
0.2 mi

It was my first time eating at Geppetto's and I was extremely impressed, not only with the layers…read moreof flavor in the food, but the technique and execution of these dishes. While the entire meal started off with a salad, of course, the next appetizer was the tagliatelle Bolognese and the pasta was definitely the main star of the dish. I could tell that the pasta was homemade as it was very light and flavorful. The Bolognese itself was well balanced and not acidic. I chose the lamb for dinner and I was very happy with the port wine reduction, and impressed with the light compliment of the sunchoke puree. The herb crust executed on the lamb was extremely flavorful and not too earthy. While I was really going back-and-forth between the Seabass and the lamb I am happy. I chose the lamb for the main course. Panna cotta for dessert and I'm happy I chose a lighter option to fishing the evening. I feel like after all of the courses I had the Panna cotta really completed the meal. It was perfectly silky. I could tell the cream was delicately infused with lemon and the blackberry couli was a nice touch to add a level of flavor to the dessert which didn't overpower the panna cotta itself. Overall, I'm really impressed. Especially since I was in attendance with a large party. All of our dishes came out in a timely manner and were well spaced to really appreciate each dish. The cocktail menu and the wine selection was also very impressive and I feel like the amount of options were well balanced, many of which would complement each dish. Our service was great! The servers were friendly, personable, and very prompt with bringing out each dish. I especially appreciated how authentic each server was. The girls we had were especially helpful in assisting us in our selections in which options to choose off the menu based on their favorites. Overall, I would highly recommend coming to this restaurant if you want, authentic, flavorful, and delicious homemade Italian dishes. I can tell the chef puts time and effort into each plate not only in building these flavors but also presentation. Coming here, would be great for dates, special events, anniversaries, and to have a nice night out with the family, friends, and someone special.

Second visit for a family birthday last night and they exceeded our first fantastic impression…read more Service is unmatched. The feel is literally as if we are in a Tuscan farm home. There is not a more welcoming and comfortable place I can think of. The food backs it up - which is the main point. My only suggestion for first-time diners, perhaps ask your server if the chef will consider delaying courses a bit. In our group of four, we wanted to try/share 4 different apps and a meat and cheese board. Because of their dedication to a promptly and accurately coursed meal, all four apps and the boar all arrived at the time time (by design). Makes it really uncomfortable at the table with so many plates. But if that's my only gripe - that's all you need to know. This Is A Must Go!!! My favorite restaurant around.

Photos
Dinner
Dinner
Shelf
Shelf
Espresso martini made with fresh espresso dirty martini

See all

Espresso martini made with fresh espresso dirty martini
Anthony's Restaurant

Anthony's Restaurant

3.7
(73 reviews)
0.3 mi
$$

"Anthony works in the grocery store Savin' his pennies for…read moresomeday" (Billy Joel) Ladies and Gentlemen, welcome to tonight's main event, the Chef Salad Rumble. In this corner is the last Chef Salad I reviewed, hailing from Granby CT, let's hear it for Gio's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Pub. And in the far corner is this week's challenger, hailing from Torrington, CT, let's hear it for Anthony's Restaurant. Anthony's sells their Chef Salad in two sizes -$9.95 and $13.95. We went for the "small" at $9.95.and the word "small" is an understatement. Their small is LOADED with 11 ounces of ham, turkey, roast beef, and provolone. I know it was 11 ounces, because that thick log of deli was so huge, I couldn't believe it, so I weighed it on my food scale. That's more than 2/3 of a pound of stuff, over a big salad of lettuce, cucumber, big tomato slices, shredded carrots, and a full hard boiled egg. Oh, and it comes with two big slices of fresh Italian bread, so the "small" easily gave us two big portions. So how does last week's Gio's salad compare. Well, if this was a boxing match the referee would have stopped the contest. Gio's cost $10.99, didn't include bread, and the serving of cold cuts paled in comparison to what we got at Anthony's. So Anthony's Chef Salad cost less than Gio's and gave us a ton of more stuff. Anthony's is a very cool little family restaurant with seafood, pasta, veal, chicken, and steak entrees, along with grinders, paninis, pizzas, and the salads. If I lived in Torrington, I'd sure be a regular.

Owner is insane about his parking lot and will yell at your for parking there to go in to eat…read more Total nut job and food is far below average especially with the other options around.

Photos
Chicken Parmigiana Grinder
Chicken Parmigiana Grinder
Buffalo Wings
Buffalo Wings
Hostess station

See all

Hostess station
Oliver's Restaurant

Oliver's Restaurant

5.0
(1 review)
0.9 mi

"And so please help (To teach your children) Them with your…read moreyouth (What you believe in) They seek the truth Teach your children well" (Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young) When was the last time you ate a meal in a high school? Maybe it was at an award dinner for a high school sports team, or at a Boy or Cub Scout dinner? Or maybe it was way back in the day between your history and algebra classes? Well, we had a unique lunch at Oliver's Restaurant. Why unique? It was unique because the restaurant is located within the Oliver Wolcott Technical High School in Torrington, and it is staffed by students. You see, the school's Culinary Arts program trains their students for experience in the food service industry. It's an ambitious program that uses a public restaurant to provide 1,775 hours of learning and training in all phases of restaurant business - from the public facing front of the house to the back-of-house. If the students decide to enter the food service workforce, they leave Oliver's with a fantastic skill set. The teacher is Chef Michael McDowell, and he had a crew of 25 High School Juniors operating in two rooms preparing the salads and sandwiches, grilling the chicken and salmon and steaks, baking the meatballs, preparing the soups, slicing the complimentary bread, waiting the tables, and every possible activity they will see when the food service workforce. Chef Michael was fantastic as he oversaw the operation, offering nonstop commentary and tips to his young staff - "did you offer ketchup with those fries?", "too much oil in that pan", "check on your customers and get off your phones", "where's the dressing on the side?", "put the dressing in a takeout container for the takeout orders, and a ramekin for the diners", etc., etc. Oliver's has a real dining room with an open kitchen, so you can see and hear the entire class. There was a steady stream of takeout orders, and three parents popped in to say hi to their kids. The freshman and sophs in the Culinary Arts program start with the basics -how to sauté things, make salads, and the like. Today's class was all juniors, and that's when they actually start to operate the restaurant under the Chef's guidance. We chatted with Chef Michael, and he said that when they become Seniors, they really run Olivers by themselves. Our lunch was a $3 cup of clam chowder, a $9 turkey BLT, a $14 Salmon Caesar Salad, and a $4 Apple Crostata. The food was very good, check out the generous portion of turkey on the BLT and the half pound slab of perfectly cooked salmon on my salad. And we were amazed when Chef Michael called us at home to get our feedback on the meal and service. What a wonderful experience! We really enjoyed watching the Chef train his staff and watching them execute his instructions. I hope whoever is reading this, goes to the school and supports these young restaurant workers of the future. I know you'll enjoy this unique experience as much as we did. PRO TIP Olivers is open to the public Wednesday to Friday from 10:45 to 12:05, and they ask you to call 860-496-5369 to make a reservation.

Photos
Oliver's Restaurant
Very good cup of clam chowder
Very good cup of clam chowder
Oliver's Restaurant is inside the Oliver Wolcott Technical School

See all

Oliver's Restaurant is inside the Oliver Wolcott Technical School

Nicholas Pizza House - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...