Unfortunately, Dillon doesn't have much to offer in the way of exceptional pizzas. If you're from Chicago or a metropolitan area, you're going to be disappointed with anything you find here. That being said, I like Nick N Willys for their variety and I think they have the best offerings in Dillon. They always give my kids a piece of dough to play with while we wait and service has been decent. read more

First time coming to this place. Got just a personal size pizza and I was impressed! Very good pie! The staff is friendly. Will definitely be coming back. read more

Expensive for pizza by all means. Definitely not the quality you expect for the price. I had the specialty pizza, the name eludes me, that was stacked with meat and toppings for close to $20 and could not finish it. Gluten free is extra here so it can get pretty steep. I enjoyed it but probably wont come back anytime soon. read more

We found this place hap-hazardly after we drove in for a few days for some good skiing. Such a pleasant surprise! It's a tiny little place with big flavor. We asked the workers what their favorite pizza was and they said the chicken and smoked bacon pizza so we tried it and it was absolutely incredible. They make and toss the dough as well as prepare the pizza right there at the counter infront of you. On top of that, the staff are very entertaining. I will definitely come back every time I visit Keystone! read more

Stopped here for some lunch after a day of tubing on the hill at Copper Mountain. The menu is varied, with a bunch of pre-made versions as well as the ability to build your own. Price of $7 for a personal pizza was reasonable. No tables but there is an eat at bar that seats about 10 is available. I watched them make and cook the pies, and they were very tasty. No beer or wine, only soda pop and water. They also have salads, and I watched them being made and packaged, so they are relatively fresh out of the cooler. This a place is worth a try. read more

Not the best pizza or the worst pizza I've had. Friendly service and after a day sightseeing the area was a much needed quick food fix. When I called in my order I asked how they would rate themselves in comparison to Papa Murphy's... the girl on the phone says they were much better. Highly disagree! Overall, it was okay. read more

I ordered pick-up from this pizza establishment and the experience was disappointing. I arrived ~ 5 minutes after my "confirmed pick-up time" and was told unapologetically that it would be another 5-10 minutes until my food was ready. 20 minutes later I was given 2 cold pizzas and mediocre wings. I will definitely avoid this place in the future! read more

Not bad for what it is, take and bake type of pizza place. Placed a telephone order and picked up in 15 min while other places were busy. Popped into oven and piping hot pizza in about 15 min. read more

I found this place by chance. I was happy to see that they had gluten free pizza. I decided to give it a try and had a vegetarian pizza with gluten free crust. İt was delicious and the crust was perfectly baked, not full of oil, not overly soft and doughy. Service was also fast and friendly. I'll definitely be coming back. read more

Awesome service and great food! Thanks for being the only place with common sense in Summit County.

Great service at this location, ordered our pizza and when I arrived 15 minutes later it was ready to go. Staff was very nice!

We had the chicken bacon pizza and it was delicious, it really hit the spot since we were so hungry! read more

Nick-N-Willy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Silverthorne, Colorado

I am confused as to why the girl at the counter told us it was an hour and a half wait for take n bake pizza and that they were closed over an hour before they were closed. ‍ We didn't get to try it but heard it's good! read more

They were all very friendly and the service was great. I used the yelp coupon with no problems. Recommend this location.

Very good pizza! Nice and fresh. Staff was friendly and welcoming! This is a must-go place.

These guys were great, had an awesome vibe, good music while you wait. Wish they delivered. But wouldn't change anything else about them!

Delicious pizza, decent prices and staff was helpful in making our decision on which pizza to order. Great service, we will be back!

33 bucks for two pizzas and one was half cheese. And they made the cheese side bigger than the meat side. OMG. RIPOFF. Crust is nothing and sauce they can't give you even if you order extra. For 33 bucks they should shovel it on. Will never go Back. N read more

A great place to stop in for Pizza! Great service and pizza is made in front of you. Our kids enjoyed playing with pizza dough while we waited:) read more

Stunningly great pizza and cinnamon bits. Im spoiled to have visited Italy many times so my expectations for pizza are quite high. This pizzeria was very affordable and had surprisingly quick service. read more

Nice little pizza place. Very much a takeout, so plan on that. They have a small counter for eating but it is....small. The customer service was terrific, very friendly. You can have them bake your pizza and take it home hot, or, if you have a drive like we did, you can take it home and cook it yourself. I wasn't that impressed with the pizza we cooked ourselves. I definitely want to try them again, but this time I will leave the cooking to them and see how the pizza tastes. read more

Don't judge a book by its cover! We had a great pie, Greek salad and garlic bread served by an unassuming pizza chef at the counter. Almost as much fun watching our food being created as it was eating it! This is our new 'go to' pizza joint when we ski Keystone! read more

Went here instead of Pizza Hut and it's actually very good! I'm always skeptical of new places cause I hate spending money and at the end of the meal wishing I had not gone there. Going out to eat with a family of 4 means you're basically taking a minimum $40 gamble of the restaurant, right? And after that if the food was so bad you have to eat a crappy dinner or spend the same amount or more at another place. Anyway, food was good, glad we went. If you havent tried it, you should. read more

Such good pizza!! Staff is always helpful and friendly!!! Perfect food for being on hill all day! Good local spot

Vacationing in Silverthorne as we ski the Summit region. This was phenomenal pizza in an assuming place. Ordered the Aegan and a pepperoni pizza for the family after a day of skiing. Cannot say enough about how tasty the crust and sauce were on these pizza with the toppings as they were cooked to perfection. read more

Very good pizza! Enjoyed the food immensely...very flavorful, came out in good time and hot. Great place for kids.

Ordered 2 pizzas and while we waited one sat on the rack. And they forgot to put the other one in because they were to busy chatting. Pizza was ok. Nothing compared to Chicago though. read more

You are looking for the right pizza? Not just a pizza, right? Well I tell you what, I had a lot of Pizza in my life but these are the best and best priced pizza my mouth had for sure. They even have GLUTEN FREE pizza. I can not remember the name of the veggie pizza (something with 'A') but hello, most delicious! read more

I was in town for a conference so during lunch one day I pulled up yelp and ran across the reviews for Nick and Willy's. They are not false! I had the Mediterranean personal size pizza....wow! Soo so good! And the lady working was so friendly! Stellar marks for Nick and Willy's. read more

Was ready for pickup on time - picked up a salad too and baked the pizza at home and had a wonderful diner.

So Good! Just in for tonight. Was going to go out but staying in sounded so much better. Ordered on phone, used coupon, 2 8 inch pizzas and a side salad for $9.08. I had Nick-N-Willy's Classic and son had meat eaters. Quick and great pizza. read more

Got the Magellan pizza which had lots of basil and great sausage; all ingredients tasted fresh with a good blend. It was takeout so a bit cool bt the time we got it home. I would highly recommend this place. read more

Nick & Willys has excellent pizza and service. They have a variety of choices and the service from order to pick up is less than 20 min. I highly recommend for a large group or family. The pizza was fresh and the wings were great too. read more

Pizza was done fast, glad we came a bit early to hang out as the pies were ready when we arrived. Staff was great; friendly, funny and great attitudes all around. Helped us out when our online coupon had issues. Pizza was good as well. Fresh toppings, great crust. Our go to place when we're in Silverthorne. read more

Out of all the restaurants in the word my favorite is Nick-N-Willy's! I like it because of the service, the cheese, the crust, and the pizza itself! Going to Nick-N-Willy's makes me crazy,happy, and excited. Also makes my day complete. Their cheese is always perfectly melted on the pizza. I think the cheese is delicious because cheese pizza is my favorite. Their cheese is all melty and when I take a bite it stretches out and makes it even better.A pizza couldn't be a pizza without the cheese! The next reason I like it is because of the crust. The crust is always soft and delicious! I like the crust soft because it taste better than hard to me. When it is soft it is white and that's how I LOVE it!!! The crust is AWESOME!! I also think the pizza is good itself. Every time I eat their pizza I devour many pieces because it is so good!! I like it because when I finish it all it fills me up! When we pick it up it smells so fresh! It is always hot when we eat it! I like it for many other reasons. Pizza is delicious especially Nick-N-Willy's!! Out of all the pizza places in the world, Nick-N-Willy's pizza is clearly the best! read more

Good quality take and bake pizza at a reasonable price, especially when you take advantage of the Yelp special.

We are just visiting Dillon Colorado and looked for a place to have dinner. Very nice staff and there pizza was fantastic!! And pretty quick! Would recommend the Aegean! Also had the garlic chicken with smoked bacon and it was very good as well. read more

We had a custom pizza. Fresh ingredients. Nice flavor. Take and bake option. The quality it the food is top notch. Only 4 stars because it was carry out only. read more

Great pizza and gluten free! Friendly staff! The crust was amazing and so yummy. Very nice.

This place is amazing, great staff, fast and great quality pizza. I had the bbq chicken pizza with red onions and cilantro. AMAZING.