First time ordering takeout here. We live nearby and wanted to support a local business. So glad that we did! We started off simple, ordered 6 plain wings and a half and half pizza. Everything came out fresh and delicious! Service was great as well while we waited. We would definitely return again! read more

Great experience at NY Pie. Not only is the food delicious (amazing arugula salad and excellent pizza), but the service is great! Great beer selection. Great location. read more

Well I finally got in here to try their pizza. I was impressed and pleased. This is pizzeria style pizza done really well. The quality of the ingredients is really good. They put fresh herbs on some of their pizza. I had a huge slice of the mushroom pizza. I actually saved half of it for the next meal. I was awesome impressed by the ranch dressing which had fresh herbs in it and tasted great and homemade. They're doing a good job here and I recommend it. read more

Be aware that if you'd like a small vegie pizza it will cost you very big bucks at NY Pie! $37 to be exact. Just order the basic 12" cheese for $16.99, hold cheese on one half (no discount for that), and ask for all the vegies. You won't find out that this will cost you $20 EXTRA until you get the check after you finish your meal. We were shocked to find they'd charged us $2 EACH for a very light sprinkling of onions, tomatoes, olives, mushrooms, bell peppers, garlic, spinach, basil, jalapeños, and artichoke leaves (not hearts). Not piled high, literally a very light sprinkling. The entire pizza had maybe 3-4 oz of vegies total. On what planet is it acceptable to charge $20 for that?? Service was great, except for failing to mention at any point such a ludicrous upcharge. read more

Looks like happy hour is back 3-5pm M-F (closed TUE). I've enjoyed food here several times in the past few months and it definitely hits the spot. Love the hazy IPA on draft, the wings go hard with the home made ranch and/or blue cheese, flavor combos are great on the pizzas, Caesar Salad is fantastic, great spot for football, clean environment, and friendly service. Love the new look too. read more

NY Pie - Happy hour Menu (Times), Hazy Henhouse IPA Pint, Draft selection, & Bar top. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

2 stars for quality of service...not pizza. Yeah, service was friendly enough, but we asked for 4 slices of pizza and waters. We had 2 west coast Henhouse and were delivered 3 slices of pizza...total was 46.00 and some change. We wanted to make sure since we didn't get the 4 th piece we didn't get.....3 slices at $6.75 and two Henhouses, do the math. No receipt, seems slimy..... won't be back, too bad, pizza is good, watch your wallet. read more

Great eat in experience every time we go and great quality pizzas when we take out! Always our go to for pizza and so happy they reopened!

Customer service 10/10. I placed an order for delivery online, and then called to make a couple requests and I was blessed to have Jenna answer my call. She just made my night. She was so kind and really made my night.... Great job! Love NY Pie for the food of course, but for having an awesome team with fantastic customer service! Definitely recommend! read more

The pizza is definitely the BEST pizza in Santa Rosa. The owners, Doug and Freddy are so nice and you can tell they care of the patrons and the food they put out. They have a great rotating tap list with some of the best local beers around. Karen and Lauren are so friendly and that goes for all the staff members at this pizza joint. Looking to watch sports and get some wings or garlic knots?! This is the spot! read more

Excellent NY style pizza. The thin crust, sauce and cheese were all great and the pizza was delivered hot.

Not much to recommend. Crust is tough and toppings (including sauce and cheese) are flavorless.

Dropped in on a Friday evening -- pleasant outdoor seating, busy but not crowded and the pizza was OUTSTANDING. The staff is stellar -- friendly, attentive and great to talk with. Our pizza was so good right out of the oven. We ordered one with no tomato sauce--it had a garlic sauce and was delicious. The beer selection is phenomenal and we will be regulars. They're also now staying open until midnight on weekends. Great, classic neighborhood and beyond pizza joint. read more

NY Pie - Garlic sauce, bacon, chicken -- to die for. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

See all

Got delivery, was a bit late but it was Friday night so no big deal. Pizza was still fresh and delicious. First time trying NY pie,will be coming by for a slice frequently! Too good not to read more

Multiple pizzas, multiple beers, good service and church chitgg to Jo guiding Fujitsu shingle gdrjopyhb having chin

We went to NY Pie for happy hour. We both had a draft beer and a slice of cheese pizza. The pizza was so good we had another slice! Friendly attentive staff. We got there about 5pm and by the time we left at 6pm, the restaurant was full. The place smells so good! read more

Popped by the newly owned and renovated NY Pie and I was impressed, we ordered a Longfellow large and some salt and pepper wings. Both were delicious but the wings were truly something else. I loved the wings so much I got some to go! Doug and McKenzie were warm, welcoming and they've done a fantastic job with the place. Will def be back read more

Delicious food and it's open late!! The best after a long night place to eat some great pizza! Service is great and all the games are on tv here!! read more

Really like this place :) slices are large and the crust has a nice consistency. I always get a side of ranch which is nice and herby. Appreciate their large beverage selection and that they have a kombucha available, as that's my boyfriend's go to. The servers are prompt and friendly. Lots of seating and clean tables. read more

NY Pie - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Absolutely awesome! The service was top-notch. The owner was extremely friendly, the ranch is by far some of the best in Sonoma County, and our pizza was to die for whoever came up with the idea of putting hot honey on a pizza is absolutely brilliant. read more

NY Pie - 42nd St pizza - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Best wings and pizza in town. Beer options are great too. The service is always friendly attentive.

We had a really great time at NY Pie Santa Rosa the other night. The pizza was delicious, and all the employees, and customers, were super friendly. I really enjoyed talking with the bartender "Jenna". She was funny, and knowledgeable recommending pizza, and beer combinations. Thanks for the laughs, and the pleasant evening Jenna! We hope to see you again soon. Thanks NY Pie!!!! Your our new favorite pizza place. Sincerely, NY Pie Fan read more

7/4/21 My boyfriend and I were looking for food to eat that night and NY pie was one of the last places still open at 10PM serving food. We decided to give it a try and oh my goodness it was a very disappointing experience. We parked right in front and when we went in, we got a table right away. The restaurant was somewhat busy even still at 10PM. My boyfriend wanted to order some wings but the server said "Sorry, we don't have any because there is a chicken shortage right now." We looked at each other like "Is this guy serious?" So no wings, but here is what we ended up getting: 1. Sausage slice (his) 2. Garlic knots (mine) The food came out in a few minutes and as soon as we saw the pizza slice, my boyfriend's face turned into an expression that screamed "what the heck is this??" The pizza slice was thin with barely any cheese and only one piece of sausage on it...and according to my boyfriend, it tasted very bland and just overall such a sad piece of food; it can't even be called a slice of pizza! The garlic knots were okay and eight pieces was actually a lot for me so I didn't finish it. Whoever was making these were too generous with the cheese powder, because it was completely covered and it was very oily at the bottom. By far, this was the worst pizza place we had ever been to. The service and the food were equally terrible and we will not return. read more

See all

Fantastic, simple menu for people who love beer, pizza, great service and friendly people. There's really nothing to complain about as everyone who works here wants you to have a nice time and enjoy your drink/meal. They'll be kind to you, just be kind back. read more

NY Pie - Razor thin slice of cheese with no flop and a beautiful undercarriage - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

A Friend told me he just went here and the pizza was really good. I been here in 2008 and two years ago it wasn't that good. My friend told me they just changed ownership and give it one more try. I called and order two slices to check out the pizza. I was really impressed the pizza tastes like new york style the type I like. I used to Work in San Francisco 20 years ago and was missing the ny style pizza I used to get all the time. Now I don't need to go SF for NY style pizza. Give it a try and the service is good too. read more

I've been coming to NY Pie since before the pandemic. It went way down under other ownership. It's now reopened and the food is much better. The staff is so attentive. They serve customers in an extremely busy environment and are always positive. The entire atmosphere here has changed since new owners took over. Make this your new best place. read more

First timer here and the food, service, and ambiance was all great. The customer service is excellent and so are the wings and pizza. Will definitely be back for another meal. read more

Expensive for what you get. A 12" and a small (really small) salad. $50. And no utensils or napkins. Did they expect me to eat the salad with my fingers? And they charge extra for the dressing. Also, I specifically asked for it well done. It was not well done. read more

Wow!!! I have to say that the new owners of NY Pie have truly turned this place ALL the way around. From the cleanliness, the service, the vibes, THE PIZZA and everything in between. They are phenomenal. The pizza was the perfect texture and all of the flavors came together to perfection. And the Caesar salad dressing? Oof!! Delicious. And the wing texture too! Who even makes PERFECT pizza, salad and wings anymore? Only NY Pie. You HAVE to give this place a try! We already can't wait to go back. read more

NY Pie - Best combination of brews! - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

I heard they reopened after a renovation with new ownership so I stopped in for a pizza and beer. The pizza was excellent, the staff very friendly, and a lot of great beer on draft. The NY-style decor is fantastic. I will be coming back! read more

NY Pie - The Longfellow Ave pizza at the bar - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

10/10 so good !!!! best pizza I've had in a while :) service was great and such a cute, casual spot

We delivered take out. I am glad we have a place like this in SR where you can enjoy good pizza, watch sports and it's family friendly. Support local business. read more

RUN don't walk to ny pie for their chicken wings and pizza! The salt and pepper wings are crispy and cooked to perfection... and their home made ranch is 10/10! The pizza is thin, crispy and delicious. They have a wide variety of beer and wine as well. We have been several times since they have reopened and Everytime we have been thoroughly satisfied. Service is attentive and fast. We dined here on Sunday and had Nathan as our server and he was great. We had a few questions about the different pizzas and he steered us in the right direction. We will be back. read more

My friend and I ordered a calzone and garlic knots for dinner one night. I called ahead to place to order for pick-up. Ordering on the phone was pretty standard and easy. When I arrived, it did take some time for me to pay for my order as there was someone in front of me that was having some issues with the system. The wait wasn't too bad, and my food was basically ready when I was done paying. Overall, the calzone was pretty good. The garlic knots were kind of tough. It may have been a bad batch, and I would be willing to try them again another time. The restaurant is pretty standard pizzeria, no frills. Parking may be difficult as it is street parking when it is a busier time. However, the place is open pretty late which is always appreciated. read more

The food is delicious, the service and owners are phenomenal. The restaurant has so many small details that bring you back to New York. Can't wait to come back read more

We were celebrating National Hospital Week at Santa Rosa Memorial Hosptial and thought we would take advantage of National Pizza Day falling within our celebration week. I called NY Pie to see if they could accommodate our request of 60 pizzas in the morning and 40 in the evening, and without hesitation they agreed. They arrived on time with 60 piping hot pizzas at 11am and again with 40 hot pies at 6pm. I cannot thank them enough as I know this was a tall order and it was completely seamless! The pies tasted great, and our caregivers were all talking about the new ownership and which one was their favorite combo. Amazing work from the staff to the owners all pitching in to make this a success for us. I highly recommend NY Pie Santa Rosa and offer my sincere gratitude for amazing service! read more

The pizza is great & so is the customer service! Thanks to Jenna for the hospitality. We will be back

Decent NY style pizza for when I get a craving for this kind of food. It is kind of inconvenient that this place has no delivery option, because I think the quality is just one level above fast food pizzas, so not worth it in my opinion to sit down at the restaurant like a wood-fired experience from a few other higher end spots around town. But it does the trick in this genre if that's the style I want for takeout. read more

Ok I know you specialize in pizza by the slice, but when someone orders a whole pizza, don't serve them one that was reheated and meant to be sold by the slice. Pizza was dried out from being reheated too many times. Disappointed! read more

Definitely not the real thing. I'm not sure why it's so hard for places that make the attempt. But this is not it. There's almost no carmelization on the crust. It came out a pale straw color, with no crispiness whatsoever. I have a feeling they're conditioning the dough with something, maybe oil or milk... not sure. That's the first problem. The next issue is just the cheese. Common let's-try-and-make-NY/NJ-style-pie error: too much dang cheese! Like twice the proper amount. Looks like they're using Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, so that's cool. Wings were good. Service was good. People were very nice. Too nice to know how to put out a true NY pie. read more

Customer service was absolutely poor. We went to buy a few slices and stood at the counter for a long time and none of the workers even acknowledged us until we said something. The slices were packaged with little to no care at all. We had higher expectations for this place and sad to say it disappointed us. read more