Cancel

Open app

Search

NY Pie

3.5 (730 reviews)
ModeratePizza, Italian, Salad
Open 11:30 am - 11:00 pm
Updated 3 weeks ago

Order NY Pie Takeout or Delivery

NY Pie Photos

Business Info

NY PIE ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Moderate noise
Casual
Good for groups
Good for kids

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - NY Pie

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Buffalo Style Wings
Laura A.

Driving through town and stopped here for a late lunch. Pizza slices are large portion and perfect thin NY crust. We sat on the patio with a nice shade and the service was very accommodating to the 2 dogs and 2 kids with us. Great place to stop for a slice! They have salads and wings too!

For the second year in a row our group, the St Rose Choir. Celebrated our fourth year anniversary together. Once again, the service that we were given was totally AWESOME. Our waiter, Wilson, once again, made our night special. The food was delicious and we all had a great time at NY Pie. The service once again was outstanding. I recommend NY pie to anyone who loves pizza and is a sports fanatic. They have TVs with different baseball, basketball and the other sports on while you enjoy a delicious pizza. The place is full of love and good atmosphere. Once again, with the greatest service that God has created. Thanks again, Sincerely, Randy Larsen with the St Rose choir.

Local breweries represented!
Heidi D.

First time, won't be the last. Kerren (forgive the spelling) was incredible! Totally professional, friendly, interactive, efficient. We ordered two slices, two beers and two salads. Approx. $45. So many local breweries represented - love that! Hubby chose hazy IPA and I ordered a Pilsner. It was nice to have a 10 ounce option. I ordered the arugula, salad and hubster got the Caesar Both were fresh, plentiful and dressings flavorful. The housemade croutons tasted brioche-esque. Buttery and airy. Pizza was also on point. I couldn't really taste the sausage but it didn't detract from the slice as a whole. Crust had a nice chew, sauce complimented, and it had good amount of cheese. I don't really have a comparison for what it used to be like, but we can definitely see this place being added to our list of favorites for when the pizza craving hits.

Meatatarian
Julie M.

Caesar salad was the large and it fed 3 adults. Pizza was the large and we took 2 slices home. Add some oregano and it is heavenly The wings were flavored so well. They came out heat hot so be prepared. They were mild but they had a slight kick to them. Service as awesome. Our server was so on top of things and she had such a great personality. I wish I knew her name but she had ink up her arm which was cool. We will back.

Mali-Nelson O.

Horrible service. No acknowledgement. No, "we'll be with your shortly, nothing". Yes, they were busy-I guess that's the exception it was to ignore other customers. I had to ask an employee for help or for someone to take our order at the counter. When we finally got our pre ordered sliced pizzas they were stacked on top of each other so the toppings and cheese was all messed up. Disappointing because I know they can do much better.

A slice of pie
Lesley T.

This right here was one of the best tasting pizzas I've had in a long time! They serve by the slice with over 6 pizzas to choose from or you can order the whole pie. I was driving by and it was my last day in town, i wasn't even hungry but i had to try it lol, made a U turn and bam!!! Enjoyed my slice of pepperoni, ricotta and hot honey, The vibe is chill, they have a few big TV's to watch the game (Sports) it was nice and cold inside, very comfortable place to enjoy a few moments and people watch. Definitely coming back next time I'm in town.

Bobbi D.

When I tell you you should RUN NOT WALK to NY PIE I'm not exaggerating. There are new owners. The staff are super friendly. The service is fast. The food is obviously made with love and fresh ingredients. The beer selection is HUGE. The environment is a total vibe. Freddie and friends..nice to meet you and keep it up!! You're our new favorite date night. Cheers !!

Fulton Street with added cheese, chicken and extra mushrooms
Lisa L.

Thought about trying the spot for a long time and finally did it. Parking is not impossible and there is plenty of parking half a block away. It was welcoming and busy. We timed it perfectly as my husband walked in, and his pizza was being placed into the box. Ordered two large pizzas for takeout. The Flatbush and the Fulton Street. The Flatbush was substantial, and meaty for a thin crust pizza. He said that it was flavorful without being sharp. It was filling and not very greasy. The Fulton Street was different because it didn't have red sauce, only olive oil in the base. I added chicken to it, but I'm not really sure I needed it. The flavors were just kind of fantastic along with a very good crust and a final element of lemon. It felt like a perfect spring pizza! The only thing I would add would be a sweet element like spring peas or something. All I know is I didn't need to add the chicken as the flavors were perfectly complex. The question of whether it was worth the price. With the two ads, it brought the price up pretty substantially for one element that should not have cost that much. The pizza was good though, and I will get three meals out of it so I guess value for money!

Half sausage half pepperoni and black olives.
Robert C.

Popped in here for dinner since an event we are going to is close by, and it was a great decision! We got a garden salad with the chunkiest blue cheese dressing I've ever had. The. We got a pizza with half sausage and half pepperoni and black olives. So delicious! I highly recommend this pizza place! Oh and their beer selection is top notch as well! The staff was very attentive and friendly.

Bar area and several tables available for sitting. There was an outdoor area too.

See all

Photo of Dew E.
0
255
322

14 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Best pizza in santa rosa by far every pizza I have tried has been awesome wait isn't that bad 45-60 mins delivery is typical

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Everytime we order food its wrong or burnt and they take no blame. Bad customer service horrible delivery service.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Mat is the MVP in the kitchen. Bernard handles the floor. Jimmy is the face of my pie and it's awesome

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Amazing pizza and their chicken cesar salad is SO flavorful! I can't wait to go back.

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

17 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Raj M.
19
15
1

15 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Last time I ordered delivery from NY Pie I waited for more then 2 hours and my pizza and wings arrived cold. I paid about 60$ for the food.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Bobby S.
47
21
18

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Dan B.
0
41
1

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Rafael F.
317
20
41

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ron T.
16
33
4

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

18 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Joy S.
99
1
2

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of John P.
2
258
133

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Sarah D.
174
19
6

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Jason M.
144
12
10

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Their pies are the best! so happy they are coming to Rohnert Park!!!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

19 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Linda R.
171
13
17

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

8 years ago

The happy hour is 5 stars. The pizza is 4 stars. Decent number of TVs and good beer selection.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Ron M.
24
258
100

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 11 of 19

Ask the Community - NY Pie

What Time is happy hour?

4pm-6pm. Best in town.

View All 4 Questions

Review Highlights - NY Pie

The BEST blue cheese dressing you will find in Sonoma County - I could just eat it by itself it's THAT FRIGGIN GOOD.

Mentioned in 22 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

L’Oro Di Napoli

L’Oro Di Napoli

4.5
(445 reviews)
0.4 mi
$$$
Family-owned & operated
Casual dining

I recently discovered there are 2 locations. This review was meant for the Petaluma location. I…read moream sure Santa Rosa is great, too! I love this place! From the moment I walked in, good vibes all around. Julie is serving me at the bar and she is on point. I started with a glass of Vermentino and the Insalata Della Casa. How many house salads come with artichokes and pickled onions these days? It was light and refreshing. Moving on to the pasta course. I ordered the Scarpariello and it was surprisingly light for a pasta dish, and loaded with flavor. Yellow and red baby tomato sauce with fresh basil, Calabria chili and pecorino. I wanted a glass of red to accompany the dish and was contemplating a Primitivo. When I mentioned this to Julie, she offered an off list Primitivo without the jammy punch. It was nice, she was on to what I was trying to achieve. I ended up with a Sangiovese and my dignity. All around a great experience and I didn't feel like I was mugged after paying the bill. I really appreciate a good glass of wine for $12-15. I am exhausted by paying $20 for mediocre wine in wine country. Thank you Julie and company for appreciating your cliente. Oh, and don't get me started on the pepper grinder. Seriously, order pepper on EVERYTHING!!!!!!

Absolutely delicious pizza, wonderful service, and a fun interior mimicking the streets of Italy…read more All the vegetarian pizzas were very tasty from the cheese to the sauce and the dough. Very happy to have found this place. Our sommelier during a wine tasting in Napa recommended it and L'Oro Di Napoli did not disappoint.

Photos
Capricciosa
Capricciosa
Antipasto della casa
Antipasto della casa
Burrata & Prosciutto

See all

Burrata & Prosciutto
Pizzaleah

Pizzaleah

4.6
(440 reviews)
9.3 mi
$$

Pizzaleah came highly recommended by a friend so i had to stop on my way home from Clearlake. The…read morestaff was extremely friendly and welcoming, Sarah was fantastic. I ordered their Margarita pizza which was cooked perfectly. The sauce was very tasty and complemented the thin style crust which was crispy with a little char. I ordered the their Roo pizza to take home. If you like mushrooms, this hits that craving. They also offer some different brewey choices you might not find at mainstream pizzerias. It turns out that Leah works Sundays so i got to watch her in action. Her passion and attention to detail is exactly what i was looking for in a pizzeria. It was a pleasure for the Legend General to meet her and converse about her great pizza. It was a very nice atmosphere and good experience. It's Definitely worth the stop if your traveling through the area. I highly recommend Pizzaleah!

I've eaten a lot of pizza in my life. I've been to New York and tried a bunch of the famous spots,…read moreand they were really good. But I'm honestly not joking when I say I prefer Pizza Leah to anything I had there. I don't understand how they get the crust like this. It's perfectly chewy and just cooked exactly right. Usually I like the crust but don't love it. Here, I actually do love it. I've been here at least 15 times and I've tried pretty much everything on the menu. My two favorites are the Roo's and the Po-Tay-To. I love how the place is laid out. You can see into the kitchen, and the eating area is exactly what I think a pizza place should look like. It just feels comfortable. One time on my birthday, my wife picked up the pizza and didn't realize that they gave her the wrong one until she got home. She called and went back to get the right one, and when she got there they had forgotten to remake it, so she had to wait. She was honestly pretty mad at that point after making two trips, which I don't blame her for at all. But they were so apologetic that they ended up giving us the pizza for free, and that honestly made up for everything and turned it into a really nice surprise. She got over it pretty quickly after that. Funny enough, it worked out as two trips for two pizzas, and my birthday is 2/2. Now whenever I eat pizza anywhere else, I end up comparing it to Pizza Leah. Other places have good pizza, but this one just checks every single box for me. It just is the perfect pizza for me.

Photos
Interior dining
Interior dining
Mushroom goodness.
Mushroom goodness.
Pizzaleah

See all

Sonoma Pizza Co.

Sonoma Pizza Co.

4.6
(484 reviews)
10.2 mi
$$

Insane meal at Sonoma Pizza Co…read more This is the type of spot all pizza places wish they could be. Unreal food, premium, hip atmosphere, and fantastic service. Pricing definitely on the high end for pizza, but completely worth it. Seated on the insanely gorgeous patio at SPC, we enjoyed one of the best pizza lunches I have ever had. Starting with the Patatas Sonoma. Crispy, creamy on the inside, and paired with a perfect dipping sauce. The corn ribs and shishito peppers were up next. Again, an insane dipping sauce with super tender ribs and nicely charred shishitos. We then enjoyed two pizzas, one plain cheese and the other being the summer special, the Peachy Piggy. Both were great, but the Peachy Piggy with the balsamic glaze over the fresh peaches and crispy pork belly was actually phenomenal. Forestville seems like a sleepy town at first glance, but SPC is a culinary delight disguised as an Instagram-worthy photo shoot spot. Don't let Forestville fool you; you can eat like a king for every meal. Don't forget to stop at Sonoma Pizza Co.

Sonoma Pizza Company in Forestville has cracked the code: build an outdoor patio so gorgeous people…read moreforget to complain about the food. Picture this -- covered seating, oversized hanging lamps doing their best "moody Pinterest board" impression, heaters humming away so you can pretend it's not 50 degrees out. It's the kind of space that makes you want to cancel your other plans and just live there with your friends. The pizza is solid, no notes needed. The salads, though? Borderline showing off. And the dessert and drink menu -- full beer, wine, and cocktail lineup -- means there's truly no reason to ever leave. Gluten-free folks, rejoice: their GF crust is so good it should probably be illegal, since it's somehow indistinguishable from the regular stuff. Plus my buddy Kyle from Camp Meeker says it is the "best he's ever had". No sad cardboard substitute here. Service is fast and friendly, which honestly almost feels like a bonus at this point given how busy you'll be admiring the lighting. Basically, I'd marry someone here. Or throw an office party here. Possibly both, same night, no judgment. This place is too hip for its own zip code.

Photos
Pepperoni
Pepperoni
All vegan and gluten free baby
All vegan and gluten free baby
Lemon Sorbet

See all

Lemon Sorbet
Russian River Brewing

Russian River Brewing

4.0
(3.8k reviews)
0.3 mi
$$

Famous for their award winning beers, the Russian River Brewing Company was formed by the…read moreCalifornia Korbel Winery in 1997. The original brew master became the co-owner when the winery left the beer business in 2003. It was then moved this location in 2004, opening as a brewpub. It's been on my list of places to visit for a while, so my wife, her mom, and I took the opportunity to stop in for a Thursday night dinner on our way to San Francisco from Fort Bragg. The inaugural double IPA (aka Imperial IPA) was made by the current co-owner at a different brewery in 1994. Double means it uses double the hops and malts, and the ABV is quite a bit higher. He then created Pliny the Elder (ABV 8.0%) in 2000, recognized as the most famous DIPA. The track continued, with Pliny the Younger in 2005, a triple IPA (using triple the hops and malts with ABV of 10.25%). This version is available once a year in the spring, since it costs so much money and time to make. With so much malt being used, a large amount of time (and hops) is needed to balance. I've had Pliny the Elder in bottles before, and really liked it: I don't like the hoppy 'piney' taste in my beers, but also recognize that not enough will make the beer too sweet (which I've been facing with a lot my island beers lately). Parking is street only, but there was a lot of it, with the metered parking only requiring payment till 6 pm. We were greeted warmly by the hostess and immediately seated at a table near the bar. As expected, it was quite loud, with after work folks having a good time. We got menus, ordered our food, and then decided what to do about flights. The brewery is also known for their Belgian style and thus offers two different flights. It was my first time, and didn't know how much my wife could help, so decided to order the California Sampler (a selection of 12 different West Coast 5 oz. pours of ales and lagers for $15.45) to start: O.V.L. Stout (Old Vic Loyals) - Irish nitro stout - really beginning to love stouts, and this one was good. Velvet Glow - lager - solid. Ending up buying 6 pack to bring home ($12.99) STS Pils - pilsner. Bought a 6-pack for $12.99. Russian River Porter - Blind Pig IPA - West Coast IPA Happy Hops - Juicy IPA Mosaic Stack - West Coast IPA SimCoe 25 - West Coast IPA Citra Flash Mob - West Coast IPA Mind Circus - Hazy IPA DDH Pliny the Elder - really good. bought two cans at $5.99 each. Pliny the Elder - the original Felt pretty good, so decided to order the Belgian Sampler (9 different for $13.63), Surprisingly, I didn't like it nearly as much (my favorite fruit beer during this trip was the Howzit Punch beer). Petite Robert - table beer Little White Lie - Belgian White Robert - saison Perdition - biere de sonoma Damnation - golden strong ale Mortification - quad Supplication - sour brown ale Intinction - barrel aged pilsner Consecration - sour dark ale In terms of the food, it was solid. The 8 pc chicken wings ($17) were good, and the cheesy garlic bread ($10) was filling. I had the meatball sandwich ($16) and upgraded the fries to a spinach salad (+$4): it was tasty, loved the toasted French bread and marinara sauce, with the meatballs being OK (tasted from frozen)...loved the spinach salad with strawberries and blue cheese. We finished off our meal with a Vinnies (co-owner) sundae: good vanilla ice cream with whipped cream, chocolate sauce, and a lot of almond slivers. Payment was at the table, and me being again very pleasantly surprised at how little the flights were (a typical brewpub where they charge $3-$4 per 5 oz, would have cost 4 times as much...though of course I wouldn't have drunk as much either).

We ordered two salads, one large pizza and their pizza bites. The spinach salad was very good with…read morestrawberries, goat cheese, and some nuts. The green salad had a good variety of vegetables also. We got the jalapeño cheese pizza bites, which was good and the large pizza I don't recall what the name of it was, but it was also fairly good The service was a little bit slow. They were quite busy, but it took us over an hour and a half to get our table. While we were waiting my friend and I had to flag down the staff so that we could get a beer while we waited. The room was quite noisy, but the table was comfortable

Photos
Fantastic flight!
Fantastic flight!
Russian River Brewing
Consecration

See all

Consecration
Santa Rosa Pizzeria

Santa Rosa Pizzeria

4.5
(31 reviews)
2.1 mi
$$

Seems like it has closed permanently. Apple Maps says it's…read morestill open but the phone is disconnected. I went over there and it's locked up, dark, and all the furniture is scattered around.

I hate to be a little harsh since the people working there are such nice people, but I think…read morethere's a lot to improve on the pizza at Santa Rosa Pizzaria. I got a half and half of the bear cub and the fountain grove. Starting with the dough - it was quite bland and odd texture. Not quite crispy, not quite chewy either - a weird in between. Perhaps the dough hydration was a little too low? The sauce - well seasoned, good ratio of cheese to sauce. If anything, maybe a little on the sweet side. The cheese - good ratio, no notes here. the bear cub - good amount of pep applied on the pizza, no cupping action, but tasted fine. Doesn't taste like anything special, but holds its own here. The fountain grove - unfortunately quite a disappointment. Starting off, it was very salty. Maybe from the sausage or salami? I personally still don't understand the craze with piling on ingredients just to have them in California. I've seen it happen so often, and it always falls short of a cohesive pizza, and this one is the same story. Each bite it took just kind of tasted like an amalgamation of random ingredients, there was nothing complementing one another. Overall, a 2/5 pizza. Their employees are very friendly and seemed to have good service. My personal pizza tastes may disagree with others, but I hope there is some room for adjustment or improvement.

Photos
Lobby
Lobby
The Roseland Pizza: pepperoni, salami, sausage
The Roseland Pizza: pepperoni, salami, sausage
Kaleidoscope Hazy IPA

See all

Kaleidoscope Hazy IPA
Ausiello’s Homeslice

Ausiello’s Homeslice

4.0
(97 reviews)
3.7 mi

Just visited Ausiello's Homeslice again, and felt it was worth updating my previous review - since…read morethat was a year ago and I hadn't included any photos in the original review. On most recent visit we had their Garden Salad and Chicken Parmigiana. Both the salad and the pasta were great! We loved the use of the three-bean salad in the Garden Salad. The Chicken parm was fresh, crispy, and the sauce was wonderfully tangy and fresh tasting. We thoroughly enjoyed the food, atmosphere, and the friendly service. We plan on making an effort to visit more often! Previous review: Only been by here a few times, as it is at the farthest end of town from where I live... That said, every time I have come, I have had great food and service. The fresh wood-oven pizzas are tasty - it is hard to beat a real wood-oven pizza. I have to say their smashburger is one of the best I have had (fries are pretty solid too!). They have a full bar, and good selection of beers and wines - so there is something for nearly everyone here. They get the basics here right - and the overall experience is pretty solid.

The club Sando had brown avocado and the bacon was cooked terribly, raw spots and over cooked spots…read moreat the same time. Also I get different answers about the fries being breaded every time. EVERY TIME. Used to go a lot, but after that experience I think I'm good

Photos
Located in the heart of Rincon Valley
Located in the heart of Rincon Valley
Fan Favorite: Sesame Street
Fan Favorite: Sesame Street
Great for larger Parties to enjoy!

See all

Great for larger Parties to enjoy!
Gio's Pizza

Gio's Pizza

4.2
(396 reviews)
2.4 mi
$$

My nephew and I were in the neighborhood today and craving some pizza. Gio's is a small, pizza…read morejoint in a plaza filled with local businesses in the Bennett Valley area of Santa Rosa. They have a fun selection of pizza toppings and other foods. The guys working there were friendly and helpful in making choices. We sat inside at one of the booths and enjoyed watching football in their TV. My only complaint was that it was kind of cold since they kept the front door open and it was a foggy day. We started with some wings with their mango habanero sauce. The wings were good and I really liked the sauce. I wish they could have been a little crispier, but they did the job. We had a split pizza. We did the Stormy, which was a BBQ chicken pizza. The other half was their Mac and cheese pizza. The BBQ chicken was really good. Sadly, the Mac and cheese was just not that flavorful. I probably would try something else next time. Gio's feels like a decent neighborhood pizza joint. If I lived in the area I would probably order from them pretty often, especially that BBQ chicken pizza!

Pizza dough was so undercooked it was still mushy and raw under the cheese, but what really earns…read morethe one star review is the restaurant deciding to help themselves to a $10 tip even though I tipped the driver cash in person!! Now I get the fun task of disputing this issue with the merchant, and likely my bank! Stay far away! So unscrupulous and disrespectful! I have never experienced something this brazen at a restaurant.

Photos
Gio's Pizza
Gio's Pizza
Kimo's Hawaiian Slice with a Pepsi!!!!

See all

Kimo's Hawaiian Slice with a Pepsi!!!!

NY Pie - pizza - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...