I do not give out five stars lightly, and if I could I would add a sixth star to this review. Our dinner group met up at Nylas on a very rainy Tuesday for the early bird dinner ( yes even cool kids do it) , large group of eight. Our table was ready and the Manger himself took us to our seats. This adorable three story red barn was dripping in charm and homey vibes. We sat on the second floor, we didn't know it had stairs or we would have asked for a first floor , a few of the group are not great on stairs, but as a team we made it work. Plus note is that there is a bathroom on the second floor. Speaking of the bathroom it did feel very much like a airplane bathroom, a litte Claustrophobic. The early bird dinner is the way to go, three course for a great price. We started by getting the deviled eggs and the mushroom soup. Both were amazing, the soup was so creamy and the eggs had just the right amount of firmness. I had fried chicken which was the best I have had in the Indy area. My husband had stroganoff and he felt like it was made by someone's granny. I also tasted the pork belly, and it was out of this work good. Desert was simple individual cheesecake with sauce, nice small size. We will be back and will try the rest of the menu. read more

See all

My wife, my daughter, and I ventured to Nyla's to try their "Early Bird Special" menu items. You get a three course meal before 6 pm for $25 per person. My wife ordered the Nyla's Wedge Salad for her first course and remarked how tasty it was. I had the Mushroom Cream Soup and it was the best I've ever had. Highly recommend you try it. My wife's second course was the Mushroom Burgundy Chicken. It consisted of a rich and savory red wine reduction, tenderized chicken, asparagus, and garlic mash potatoes. My wife loved it. For my second course I ordered the Chicken Milanese. It was served with tenderized & breaded chicken with a creamy lemon butter sauce, capers, mashed potatoes, and broccoli. Very tasty and the portions were larger than expected. My daughter ordered the Chicken Bacon Ranch Sandwich. It was served with crispy fried marinated chicken breast, Swiss cheese, ranch aioli, candied bacon, crispy shallots, lettuce and tomato on a Challah bun. It to was larger than expected and very tasty. Our third course was New York style cheesecake for everyone. It was just the right amount and yummy creamy. P.S. I also had a cocktail called the "Aviator". Wow !! This is my new go-to drink. It was great and really made my night even better. I highly recommend you try the Early Bird specials at Nyla's. They won't disappoint. read more

See all

Nyla's is a must go to eat spot in Westfield! Every time we go to Nylas we are beyond satisfied! If you go out only once this month visit this place! The food is amazing the staff it friendly and attentive. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

I went to Nyla's with my husband to celebrate an anniversary and had a wonderful time. The atmosphere is super cozy and the food is delicious. We lucked out with the Early Bird menu - three courses for $25 before 6 pm. The standout dish was the mushroom burgundy chicken. Incredibly satisfying and savory with depth of flavor- perfect for a winter night. The s'mores crème brûlée was also delightful. Our server (Hogan, I think) was excellent and attentive to my gluten allergy. He suggested several dishes that were gluten free and recommended modifications. He was busy making drinks and helping others, but checked on us throughout the night. Our drinks were great too. My husband enjoyed the espresso martini and said it seemed to be high quality. The Aviation cocktail tasted like a sweet tart, but in a good way. We would definitely visit more often if we lived closer, but will keep it in mind when we venture north of downtown. What a great experience! read more

See all

100/10 - food, vibes, service all are top notch! This is not a place you want to miss in the area. The mushroom soup was the best thing I had ever had, I could have had just that as meal. For dinner, I ordered the beef stroganoff and I was not disappointed. It was such a large portion, I couldn't even finish it. My husband ordered a tavern burger, so this is a perfect spot for the picky eaters too :) Our server, hogan, was amazing as well. Kept our drinks full and checked on us regularly. Will definitely be back to try more dishes! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Beef stroganoff - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

If you're in Westfield looking for a fantastic sit out restaurant with a simple yet fantastic menu, Nyla's is your place. This beautiful location had plenty of seating that did not make you feel crammed in. They had a wonderful playlist playing with low lighting that added to the ambiance. The service was quick and phenomenal but the food was truly fantastic! I'm not a fan of mushrooms but the mushroom soup could easily get me back. Our meals featured in the photos were delicious and filling. All meals are made from scratch and you can truly taste it. It was a wonderful experience read more

See all

Wednesday at Nyla's? Why not. We went for a late supper. Midweek is a great time to walk in (without a wait or reservation) and have a great meal, experience the great service and atmosphere. We had the amazing mushroom soup. I had the sea bas: a good size portion perfectly prepared. The Rosie Cheeks martini features Glendalough gin. Our take: we are not going to save Nyla's for the weekend! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Sea bass, rose water lychee cocktail, steak and lobster for Valentines Day. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

The deviled eggs were awesome. The drinks were delicious and the fried chicken and pork belly were delicious. I would highly recommend but definitely make a reservation. It was packed and it was a tiny little place. The service was top notch too. I highly recommend for a fun date night. read more

Top notch food. I would bet you would be hard pressed to find better around. All 3 of us were raving about our meals. The mushroom soup amazing. The deviled eggs amazing. The chicken cordon bleu. Amazing! I was told the sea bass was amazing. We travel the country for work and the quality of the food rivals any place we've been. The food did take a while to come out. So just be aware of your In a hurry it might not be the best place. Very friendly and personable staff. The outdoor seating was very nice read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Mushroom soup - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Food was indescribably amazing. "Early Bird Special" makes every other restaurant in the vicinity unnoticeable. $25 for a three-course meal before 6pm. We walked in to the restaurant for our reservations on a Friday night, and before we left the table we made reservations for Saturday night. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Dulce De Leche Bread Pudding - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Heard good things about this spot. It is certainly a hidden gem in Westfield. It's small, so make a reservation if you are going. They have a nice patio, but we opted for drinkie/snackie at the bar. Hogan, the bartender, was very friendly. The drinks were excellent. The steak/Gorgonzola bites were also excellent. The vin bites were on point. Definitely be back! read more

See all

Nyla's is a cute, quaint spot. It's in an old home and they've done a great job transitioning it to a cozy restaurant atmosphere. Parking can be tough since it's on a normal 2 lane road without a parking lot. Down the road though there's a large space to park. The staff were more than friendly and super accommodating. We sat upstairs and I loved it! There's a bar up there and it was perfectly quiet for friends to catch up. I'd like to go back and try different dishes, I had the zucchini noodles and wasn't a huge fan but I've heard amazing things so plan to go back! read more

The service was impeccable at Nyla's. We sat at the upstairs bar. Caroline, the bartender and our server, was engaging, interesting and pours a mean martini. She made menu recommendations. The menu is well rounded. We started with the deviled eggs and candied bacon. The bacon is downright addictive. The eggs were fresh and delicious. Dinner comes with mushroom soup or wedge salad. We both had the wedge salad with blue cheese and was refreshing with more delicious bacon. My husband had the Chicken Milanese, which he raved about. The chicken was moist and the caper sauce delightful. The tomato topping on the green beans is delicious. My Sirloin steak was huge with a wonderful buttery sauce. The steak was fairly undercooked for me (rare verses medium rare) so my husband ate most of it. The potato to was huge and a meal in itself. The OG Martini is simple and served in a frosty glass, I love a cold martini. I recommend. The restaurant is in eclectic barn style house. There are two floors and not a lot of tables. Parking has improved greatly with the new parking lot at the end on the street. But don't wear your good heals, as the lot is gravel. Nyla's offers valet parking as well. read more

See all

Enjoyed the food and service. Steaks were grilled as ordered and were tender but somewhat salty.

The mushroom soup was piping hot and rich flavor. The goat cheese balls are a MUST!!! I enjoyed the 10 ounce sirloin, but it was a little dry. Not sure what type of heat they use to cook meat but it was rare which i liked, but dry. It was a great atmosphere, and a good dinner. The area is unique, with several restaurants in a row, and you can public park or valet which I liked. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Food was really good! Nice atmosphere and attentive service. Parking is limited nearby so be on the lookout for spots when you get close.

Amazing! My coworker has been suggesting this place since it opened. We finally went last night. Exceeded expectations! Our waitress was very knowledgeable and nice. The food was perfection. We definitely want the mushroom soup sold in gallons to go! read more

See all

Great location, very nice, quiet setting. The service was great, very friendly staff. The drinks they offered were unique and quite tasty. The food was good and clearly made to order. We also got the deviled eggs, which were okay. Not the best, I would probably skip them next time. Overall, I encourage you to check this spot out! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Beef stroganoff - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

WOW One of the best restaurant experiences I've had in the area. Everything from the character of the architectural design, to the warm cozy cabin feel on the inside. The food has a savory, ' country comfort food feel. EXCELLENT quality....on par with some homemade meals. We had the meatloaf and Wagyu burger. QUALITY meat ...very tasty gravy ...juicy succulent burger. Sam the Bartender / Mixology specialist freestyled two excellent drinks based off of our ' preferred flavor profiles ...she was GREAT. I'm telling you ....this could be a top 3 Indy Restaurant. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

Looking for amazing places to eat and Nyla's was recommended. This did not disappoint, made reservations for inside at the bar it was a beautiful evening asked to swap to outside, no problem. Fantastic setting on a covered patio. Wait staff was fantastic and prompt, made suggestions and answered questions. For starters we had cornbread and crab cakes, cornbread was hot and moist, the cakes were full of meat and teaming with flavor, mushroom soup, buttery deliciousness, moving to dinner I had the 7oz filet which was a fantastic cut of meat and cooked to perfection, my wife had the sea bass , I took a bite and the flavor of that dish was amazing. For dessert we had the bread pudding, would have like to seen more blueberries but it was overall very tasty. Nylas is a fantastic restaurant, clean flavorful dishes perfectly prepared. Parking was easy, valet service was quick, free parking just a half a block away. We will be back. Thanks read more

See all

This place is incredible. We just moved here, and wanted to take my parents out for a nice birthday dinner. The food was delicious. We started with the fried green tomatoes an read more

So close to 5 stars! I went here for a date night and I will definitely be returning! The barn style exterior is cute but the inside is cozy and classy with a rustic feel. There are 3 floors with moderate seating. The vibe is perfect for a date or a small group! The servers were friendly and helpful with suggestions. They were quick with everything except the 2nd cocktail I ordered, we had to remind the waiter for it. We had a mule and a margarita from the cocktail list that were amazing! We started with the filet tip's & Gorgonzola fondue for an appetizer which was good! The beef was tender and warm! We ordered the Ribeye and the Meatloaf. The Ribeye was cooked appropriately- medium rare. The meatloaf with a side of the Dijon gravy was delicious! I would order the meatloaf again! We added a side of the Million Dollar Bacon and the Honey & Dijon Brussel sprouts. Both were good but not amazing. Would try a few other items the next time we go. We got a dessert that was not in the menu, the blueberry dread pudding. This was okay. I'll likely try the chocolate cake next time. Overall, a good experience! I will be returning and would recommend this spot. read more

See all

This was our first visit. I have nothing but good things to say. Everything was fantastic. Food: The menu is well designed with lots of care given to flavor pairings and combinations. My ribeye was cooked perfectly, but the undisputed star of this show was the mushroom soup. I don't want to get too emotional, but it was life changing. Service: Our server's name was Luke, and he did an outstanding job explaining the menu and kept us well supplied all night with drinks and food. Ambiance: They have taken the big red barn on Park Street and fixed it up nicely inside. It's somewhat upscale, but intimate. I was a big fan of the former restaurant in this building (Rail Epicurean), so I'm glad Nyla's has done justice to this space. They already seem to have earned a cult following in Westfield, so I think this will be a keeper. read more

See all

The service was great. Attentive, but not annoying. The food was decadent. Lots of butter and cream, but worth the calories. The mushroom and potato Wellington was SOO good. I did not miss the meat. It was creamy, flaky, flavorful. The mushroom soup was delicious. The star was the sea bass and the cauliflower risotto hit the spot. The little converted barn was super cute. The ambiance was cozy. read more

See all

Ah-mazing. Get thee to @nylasrestaurant stat. Wow. Wonderful evening spent enjoying ALL the food. And, I do mean all. Candied bacon deviled eggs and filet tips with Gorgonzola fondue. Can't forget the cream of mushroom soup-heavenly. You can sub balsamic for bleu cheese if you opt for the wedge. Main of miso soy ginger sea bass over broccolini and a cauliflower risotto. Table also had the fried chicken with horseradish mashed potatoes and gravy and the double bone lamb lollipops with au gratin potatoes. Was that enough for us all? Sure, but had to go all in for the chocolate cake. Am I beyond full? Yes. But it was worth it. Menu changes soon so check it out! We will be back! Hogan- our server- was great!! Parking- still the worst part of this-and you can valet, but it's not free because they just changed companies. It's 10 bucks and tip of course. We like to park at the far end of park and just hoof it. Much needed after the huge meal! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Sea bass - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

It was a dark and stormy night... we visited on a warm rainy evening. They graciously accommodated our request to sit on the covered porch. But there's where the visit went flat - our food was very good but didn't meet the mark when considering the high price point. I had the Chicken Milanese which was prepared traditionally, and was excellent. Always appreciate the difficulty of presenting a thick, juicy chicken breast. However, the mashed 'taters were heavy and skimpy, and my husband's entree was mediocre at best. Our server had a fantastic personality, but perhaps we were "out of sight, out of mind," as there were huge delays in the service. A party of 4 that was sat about 20 minutes after us was served their meal before we received our app. Not sure I'll be back. read more

Good comfort food, cocktails, small and cramped space. Responsive attentive staff. The menu is stale and needs to be updated more often. We would go more frequently but it's the same menu every time. read more

I made reservations for when they opened at 5pm so we were the first ones there. It is a cool red barn, cute and homey inside however seating is rather compact. Our server was great! Friendly, informative, and helpful. He really made us feel special. He took his time to go over any items we had questions on. For drinks we had the Rum Old Fashion and The Big Apple Tini. Both were good but that old fashion was better so I had that as my second drink. We ordered the Candied Bacon Deviled Eggs for our appetizer which was really good, the candied bacon took it to another level. We also had the wedge salad and I'm glad ordered the Miso Soy Ginger Sea Bass, it was perfect! My friend had the Shrimp and Zucchini Pasta, he said it was good. We ended with a chocolate chip brownie with ice cream. We were so stuffed. Everything turned out great. This is a nice place to go for special occasions. I just wish it was bigger. Things to take note of: This location is only for 21 yrs and older. Parking is very challenging but they do have valet. read more

See all

Only a mile from our house & we're wondering WHY we have not been here sooner! I'm a BIG Girl & I was afraid of the tight seating... BUT it was very comfortable seating! Bret was our server he was GREAT! All the staff were attentive, polite & impressive. The staff always looking & watching, not afraid of eye contact. Now the dining experience: The rum old fashion drink = A+ The mushroom soup = A+ The fondu appetizer = A+ The Sea bass entree = A+ The apple crisp = A+ Do you see a pattern? Thank you so very much for a Fantastic Dining Experience! read more

See all

We went to Nyla's this evening to celebrate a birthday. I'd made an early reservation for 4:30 to ensure seating. We'd been once before for cocktails and loved the ambiance so were excited to return for dinner. Once we checked in, the host said we'd be eating in the other building. We followed her back outside and into the small building (I remembered it previously as an ice cream shop). Inside was quite small with minimal design, 4-5 tables and there was a large counter which seemed to be for pick-up orders. Our wobbly table was across from the kitchen door, so we could hear all the clattering & noise. It might have felt especially awkward because we were the only customers in there at the time but I just couldn't shake that the vibes were off-- it wasn't the birthday dinner or experience I'd expected. I asked the server if we'd be able to sit in the main building. She was very understanding and instructed us to go back to the host stand with our request. Once we were reseated upstairs in the barn, we enjoyed the delicious food & complimentary birthday dessert while surrounded by the rustic, cozy ambiance I'd imagined. read more

Went to have a joint birthday celebration for friends. We had the crab stuffed shrimp. You get a choice of soup or salad. Both were ordered & delicious! The salad dressing was very unique. Our server was polite & gracious. Love the look, parking is kind of a pain. read more

mediocre food walked up stairs when downstairs was empty overpriced! atmosphere blah seating no rolls read more

I am from Florida, I have to say , I have been here before and the mushroom soup is amazing and the drinks are to die for but we ordered the beef stroganoff and it wasn't our favorite, we actually couldn't stomach it and to our surprise when we got the bill we were charged for it. I would never complain about paying for it even though I (we couldn't eat it ) because I am not trying to get a free meal that I (we) didn't eat at all but good customer service would be to take it off being we ordered other stuff to make up for that cost, but wow, nothing. Not a single care. I don't think I will come back here. But the mushroom soup is amazing and the Rosie cheeks drink is amazing ! read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Ribeye, steak, and broccolini - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

This is my favorite restaurant, not just in Westfield or the Indy area, but anywhere. My wife and I have been 3 times, two for special occasions, and they absolutely crush it. Shoutout to Taylor. She is the perfect waitress for any occasion. The deviled eggs and goat cheese app are so incredibly good that we are yet to order anything different for starters. I am not a huge mushroom soup guy and I get theirs every time. The entrees have all been great but the pork belly is out of this world. The drinks are always well made. The bacon fat old fashioned is the smoothest old fashioned I have ever tasted. With seating inside and outside there is something for everyone. It's cozy without feeling cramped. I have recommended Nyla's to several friends who often eat at the nicest restaurants around Indy and they agree that they'd rather go to Nyla's than any of the steakhouses around. The owner is often there and comes around to make sure everything is great. Go to Nyla's. You won't be disappointed. read more

Even on the rainy weeknight of Wednesday, November 13, 2024, the foot traffic kept coming. Nyla's is situated on a one-way street with free parking just a few steps away. Nyla's is a three-story barn restaurant with an upscale farmhouse feel, which creates a warm ambiance unlike some other fine dining spots. I dined on a wedge salad and the shrimp and zucchini pasta. The pasta was delicious. For the price, the portions were petite and these options are suitable for a slightly hungry diner. My friend devoured his wagyu burger with fries. His eyes lit up when the ample-sized burger was served. It's worth returning, but I will try another menu option next time. Also, credit is due to Nyla's for the prompt and attentive service, so I'll definitely come again. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - The tasty shrimp and zucchini pasta dish was served as a pricy, petite portion. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Visited newly opened Nyla last night. Got there early so headed to the upstairs bar. The atmosphere definitely felt up scale but it also felt intimate. I ordered the Apple Tini while I waited on my friends to arrive. It was very crisp and refreshing. A delicious way to start off the evening. When my friends arrived we got seated at a table also located upstairs. I started off by ordering the deviled eggs. It came with candied bacon which was so good. It was then time to order a second cocktail. This time around I got the Lavender Margarita and it was just as lovely as the Apple Tini. As my entree I got the chicken with horseradish mashed potatoes broccolini. Everything was so good. I wasn't disappointed with anything I ate. Something to keep in mind it is a bit pricey. This is the perfect place for a romantic date or celebration. read more

Nyla's Restaurant - Apple Tini. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Such a cute place! My second visit. Food is absolutely delicious! I had the chicken cordon blue this time and stuffed shrimp before- both the best ever! And the goat cheese appetizer also outstanding. And they were busy on a Tuesday evening which is a good sign. read more

Service was excellent. Friendly staff. Our food was terrific. I had gluten- free pasta primavera - generous portion and so delicious! My husband couldn't stop bragging about his bone-in pork chop dinner. It was a very nice birthday experience on the patio read more

Great restaurant in the heart of Westfield. They have valet parking which I recommend because it can be tough to find a spot in busy nights. They serve steaks, seafood and items that remind you of home. Deviled eggs, meatloaf and fried green tomatoes. We had the fried green tomato app and they were great. Better than grandmas. I had the duck and it was fantastic. Nice wine and drink list. I would love to come back again. read more

Checked Nyla's out after meeting their manager Brent on a whim. Took a colleague there to check it out and was more than impressed. It's tucked away in an area that looks to be being revitalized. It's a beautifully charming red farmhouse with an amazing, yet not intimidating ambiance. We sat outside which was perfect for the weather and the view of the, unbeknownst to us, thriving little district. Sam was our server and she was amazing!! Between myself and my colleague, we tried 5 of the listed cocktails, although you can order off the menu as they have a full bar. Don't let the descriptions fool you because as complex as they were, the flavors married so well together. We tried three appetizers, fried green tomatoes, deviled eggs, and filet tips fondue. All were AMAZING!! It's been two days and I'm still thinking about how good they were. We shared the lamb chops and cauliflower risotto. All so tasty and prepared perfectly. I will definitely be back to try more of their offerings. Highly recommend!! read more

See all