Pizza was pretty good. Nothing special for a Long Island pizzeria. I tried a spinach and mushroom slice which was pretty good and their regular slice was also decent. I wouldn't travel a hundred miles to come here, but if you're in the neighborhood, I'd have no complaints coming here again. It's a pretty small shop with about 6 tables. Counter staff was friendly and efficient. read more

So happy to have finally found pizzeria where every component of their pizza works well together; tasty dough, tomato sauce and cheese (that' not too salty), making one delicious pizza . read more

Hi folks, Welcome to Oak neck Pizzeria. Right on Montatuk Hwy. On the way home from the beach. I ain't afraid of no sharks... but.. I had a good old Long lsland "Pizza attack" at my local Beach on a 90° summer day. it was all I could do to get out of the water and to the nearest pizzeria... coming over the bridge. I had but one thought ..Pizza rescue. Finding a pizza place in this neighborhood wasn't all that easy, but Yelp helped me find a great family-owned place right off the highway. Located in little one story strip shopping mall. The oak neck center, offers free parking. This small family owned pizzeria was very warm and welcoming walking inside. Young lady took my order and in 15 minutes my pizza was hot, ready, and so good. Only $19 ..not bad. I paid with my credit card, there were no extra charges. That was it, so easy. I was very impressed with the friendliness of this family owned neighborhood pizzeria. Loved the quickness and quality of my order today. Can't wait to stop back again, I now have another great pizza option for when I'm in this area visiting friends. See you folks again soon. read more

See all

What happen to Oak Neck Pizza? It was always a decent place to get a slice. The last two visits were disappointing to say the least. Pizza was not fresh at all. There at 1PM and pizza taste like it was sitting since 10AM. Slices were very small, like frozen pizza slice small. It's a shame because it was always decent for many years but don't think I will be going back anytime soon. Oh well, another one off the list. read more

I wish i could say something good, but this place, this place needs "adult supervision". Its a bunch of teenage rude girls running the counter, who know nothing about customer service and surely know nothing about pizza. The owner is never on site never on premise or hides in the back and enables the teenage help to be rude to customers there's one girl there w curly hair short person has a real attitude problem, nasty nasty (nojenta persona) . The pizza is so so, and often cold and would be better if the staff wasn't so rude. Rude people/gente grosera..simple as that. Very dysfunctional pizzaria, never saw anything like this. In this economy they're prices are high considering the bad customer service and cold food. Im posting my review dual lingual hope thats ok, i think the owner is also bi lingual, though i dont think he cares about his customers maybe he'll read this and get some adult supervision at the counter. Ojalá pudiera decir algo bueno, pero este lugar, este lugar necesita "supervisión de un adulto". Es un grupo de chicas adolescentes groseras que están a cargo del mostrador, que no saben nada sobre servicio al cliente y seguramente no saben nada sobre pizza. El propietario nunca está en el lugar, nunca en las instalaciones o se esconde en la parte de atrás y permite que la ayuda adolescente sea grosera con los clientes. Hay una chica allí con el pelo rizado, la persona baja tiene un problema de actitud real, desagradable desagradable . La pizza es regular, ya menudo fría y sería mejor si el personal no fuera tan grosero. Gente grosera/gente grosera... tan simple como eso. Pizzería muy disfuncional, nunca vi nada como esto. En esta economía, los precios son altos considerando el mal servicio al cliente y la comida fría. Estoy publicando mi reseña en dos idiomas, espero que esté bien, creo que el propietario también es bilingüe, aunque no creo que se preocupe por sus clientes, tal vez lea esto y obtenga la supervisión de un adulto en el mostrador. read more

I've been going here for about two years and in the beginning the pizza was great. I loved the buffalo chicken slice and regular slice but mfor some reason recently, the pizza has changed dramatically. The crust is extremely dry and it's just not enjoyable anymore. Dry and doesn't taste fresh. read more

This is my familys go-to pizza spot and its always delicious, fresh and filling! I am involved in a outreach program for underprivileged children in Wyandanch and I wanted to throw them a pizza party one day. When I told the owner about it, she donated10 pizza pies and several bags of garlic knots without hesitation. Her act of kindness went a long way that day! Besides the food always being amazing- they are good, generous people. read more

Moved into the neighborhood a few months ago and final tried this local pizzeria. We got a large pie and garlic bread. The pie was good quality and tasty. Garlic bread was cut into slices you can rip off, which I found to be pretty convenient. It was crunchy and had the right amount of garlic on it. When I picked up my order I saw the garlic knots looked tempting, so I'll probably get those next time. They also sell King of Corona ices. read more

I ordered spaghetti with meatballs easy on the sauce since they infamously drown there pasta in sauce. I was told 20 minutes. I arrived 20 minutes later only to wait an additional 20 minutes and I recieved a big bowl of sauce with a small side of pasta. I will not be going back here ever again. read more

Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering - spaghetti and meatballs - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

The Best Pizza and everything else too! We have been going there for pizza, garlic knots, calzones, pinwheels and entrees for about 5 years, mostly for take home because we don't live nearby. The food is always fresh and the taste is always great Real homemade Italian food and they have specialty pizzas like vegetable pizza, chicken parma and many others.. We live in Huntington and there are numerous choices out there but this place is second to none. It is a relatively small place for takeout with a few tables as well. We have been there many times and have never been disappointed. read more

Been cranking slices here for as long as I can tell. Specialty slices always get me off in just the right way; if they were a little cheaper say 4 bones a specialty slice this place would have me slinging 5 stars at the drop of a hat. Super convenient location as well since it's right back on the way to Fire Island. Buff chicken slice gets a (7.7) read more

Oak Neck Pizzeria & Catering - Just copped a buff chicken slice - Pizza Near Me - West Islip, New York

A favorite of the locals here in Oak Beach! Fast delivery tonight a Sunday, less than one hour total. Food arrived piping hot and excellent! Chicken Piccata with penne was absolutely delicious, as was the calamari and Caesar salad. Yum! Delivery minimum ($20-40) based on location, but no delivery charge. read more

We love this place and stop here any time we take the Robert Moses. The pizza is fresh, authentic, DELICIOUS, and the staff is really nice. I especially love the salad pizza but all the speciality ones are really good -- just beware trying to eat them in the car as you drive down the highway! : ) read more

Been coming to this place for a long time, and the pizza has remained fresh, hot, and good.

I find the pizza to be good here. The Old Fashioned is very nice, a slightly sweet sauce with good flavor.

you must be kidding me. I look up the menu online and order rigatoni Bolognese. $8.95. I go to pick it up and the girl behind the counter says 11.99. I said, excuse me, but that is incorrect. the order should be $8.95 plus tax. How much did you charge me for the meal? $10.95. I said on your web site it says $8.95. Oh she says, that's an old menu and the owner doesn't have the password to update it. REALLY!! do you know how to run a business. They didn't even offer the online menu price, just kind of shrugged their shoulders. When I said they should honor the other price they looked at me like I had 2 heads. I don't care if they are convenient and down the block from where I live. I will NOT go there again. And believe me it wasn't the $2. It was the attitude and complacency!! read more

You charge a fee for using a credit card. Never ever buying food from you again. Total BS.

Good pizza but not the best wouldn't get hero's from this place. The people were nice and welcoming great atmosphere.

My husband got a chix parm hero he liked- i got a salad and tortellini soup. The soup was extremely oily and inedible. Threw it out. The salad was just that- salad. It's convenient bc it's by the hospital that's the only reason why we went. read more

Came back to NY for a visit and hit three different pizza shops while there. This was by far the best. Nice crust, not to thick or too thin, the right amount of sauce and plenty of toppings. Service was good. Space was small for a party of 8 to sit but everything was well made. read more

I love this place! I've been going here for years and just stumbled onto it on my way to the dog park. I get their specialty slices and their Grandma slice is prob my favorite. I have them deliver now too when I don't feel like going out. My cousin used them for catering her son's bday party and everyone loved the food too. Chicken Verde, Eggplant Parm & Rigatoni Alla Vodka were awesome!! read more

We loved this place when it was Martino's and have been giving it another shot. The food is inconsistent and I fully agree with the others that some of the counter staff have real attitudes. I wish mgt would read these reviews and make changes because some of their food is really tasty, like the fried chicken cutlets and some of the specialty slices. read more

Food is amazing!! Love eating here when i come out to Long Island to visit family. Great service too! Prices may seem high, but you get a lot of food. read more

I really enjoyed the flavor and consistency of the crust. I ordered a Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken slice, and neither were sparse with the toppings. Both were completely loaded with chicken. The entrees are a bit pricey though. read more

Got my wife two slices of pizza - one pepperoni and one sausage. They were dry. The sauce had barely any flavor (and seemed to be an afterthought) and the toppings were generic. It was not worth the money. And let's talk about the money for a minute. Two slices cost more than $5. But they won't let you charge anything less than $10. Apparently, the owner is really strict about that policy. How does it make sense when a common order is around $5? It does if you don't care about your customers. Won't be back. Ever. read more

Mediocre Food, with Horrible Service, went there for Chicken Fingers, and a Chicken Caesar Salad, they said 15 to 20 minutes, I was there for 35 minutes when I asked why this was taking so long, the two girls working there both responded with an attitude. I explained I was going to miss my daughters dance solo, they could not car less, and yes, I missed it by 5 minutes. So Pissed, my family and I will never go back. read more

Pizza is decent but way too expensive. Went there instead of Francesco's and two slices of margehrita and a dollar drink cost me 11 dollars. For there quality it's not worth it rather go to Francesco's on john st or joes on 5th ave. this place used to be one of my favorites cause mama santinas and joes didn't deliver not anymore. read more

fellow yelpers, I will warn you not to go here for a couple of reasons. 1) the price for the pizza, i got two grandma slices and a buffalo chicken slice and it came out to 14 bucks. 2) The slices were dry and the sauce was poorly seasoned. 3) There were a family of flys gathering in the vicinity of where I was eating. Don't go here!!!! read more