We tried the eggplant parm hero, and a medium size special pizza. The service was cheerful and pleasant. Fell in love with the pizza! And will be coming back even though its not the closest to our home. Incomparison, we were a bit disappointed in the eggplant which was greasy from being fried in dirty oil. But the sub roll was excellent read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - Eggplant Sub - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

The pizza you get is very inconsistent, it's either burned or not cooked all the way through. My child had pizza delivered to her camp today and none of the kids or counselors liked it, they all said it was like eating bread which is basically under cooked pizza which can you make you sick. I've ordered from them about 4 times and 3 times it came burned, and the 4th time my pizza needed viagra, it just dropped over because it was under cooked read more

The food is great! Great service and atmosphere. Nice neighborhood . I love their pepperoni pizza and Greek salad. A good price and a good value read more

Ordered over $550 of food for 5:45 and not delivered until 7. They forgot the order and then did nothing to make it better.

This is a little pizza place recommended by a friend. The ride is around 40 minutes from Hartford but is worth it. The dough of the pizza is fresh and doesn't have the after taste of yeast. It was one of the best pizzas i had in a long time. The ambience of the place is very humble and comfortable. If you are around Hamden, Ct. You must visit this little place. I am sure you are going to be impressed as i was. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - This is a small pie. It was delicious and fresh - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

Great food and laid back atmosphere. Excellent alternative to those other pizza joints in town. Portions are generous without skimping on quality. read more

Stopped in for take out after kids evening activities. Cheese pizza crust was so thin the sauce and cheese made it soggy by the time we got home. Pepperoni pizza was In slightly better but had the cheese slide as well. The crust was just a little thicker so not soggy. Best item by far was the Italian Comco Sub. The slice app offered $5 off $25 purchase, and they have a Monday thru Wednesday special with large cheese pizza and two 20 oz sodas for $20. If you are looking for good pizza drive a few miles further south to New Haven. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - Cheese pizza (slide of cheese) - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

Prefer Paul & Eddy's to any place near Wooster with better parking, chill atmosphere, & friendly staff.

There is something about eating 'in' for pizza that makes it taste that much better. A Sunday night at 7:00 and DD and I skipped the New Haven lines and grabbed a spot in the dining room of Paul and Eddy's. So glad we did! Excellent pizza and friendly staff made for a nice dinner. We'll be back. read more

Ordered & paid 4 extra sausage. Literally 1 piece os sausage per slice: Pizza, cold and doughy. Would not recommend P&E's. Would give them 1.2 out of 10. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - This is not extra sausage - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

Solid New Haven style thin slice. Bright flavorful sauce and good char on edges and bottom. Would happily return. read more

See all

Wow... just, wow. I just luh-oveee this pizza place! Whenever I'm feeling like I need a little, (or big(LOL) pick me up, boy, oh, boy. Let. Me. Tell. You! Nothing better than, a dazzling pie from Paul & Eddy's. Ummm... let's just say, when I go here, no need for trash can. ;) I eat all of them! They even brung me the pizza too! Eggsellent service!!!egg! I can also sit down to eat, and enjoy! Sometimes, I don't want to go home! I want to stay, here, forever! Yumalicious-diddley-don-scrumptiouso. read more

Pizza here is always delish! Best in Hamden. WAYYYY better than Sergio's, which I tried and didn't see the big fuss about.

My small pizza had the wrong toppings. Otherwise, it was inedible. The cheese was rubbery and tasteless. The crust was chewy in the bad way. I threw it away. On the plus side, delivery was rapid. read more

I'm a repeat customer. Just love the meatball grinder with red peppers and onions. Are the entire thing myself that day. Was worth every calorie. read more

If you're in the Hamden area this is one of my favorite local pizza joints! The Margarita pizza is hands down my favorite pie. It has become a weekly dinner in our house to order from Pul and Eddys. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

We took a chance on Paul and Eddy's despite mediocre reviews. I don't understand why their rating is so low because the pizza was delicious (I got my favorite - bacon and onion). They are now our go to pizza spot. I appreciate that they aren't crazy expensive and their delivery is always so quick. read more

Tasty neighborhood joint. Been going back for years even after having moved away from the area. Try the eggplant!

One of the best pizzas in Hamden, amazing service from friendly people and overall great place for pizza. Just don't get a gluten free pie.

The are good but they all ways something i order and the are not worth the price they make me mad when I call their they are so rude and Nasty they're food is good . That's why I gave two stars also cuz they never get yur address rite read more

Never again! I checked out the reviews so I decided to give it a try. It's Sunday night at around 6:15 and ordered a large pizza, half sausage half bacon. Was told it would be ready in 35 minutes. No biggy! Got there on time and picked up the pie, everyone was friendly and so was I. Got home, opened up the box, burnt bacon but sausage looked okay. I took a slice of sausage, one bite, tasted burnt. Flipped over the slice and it was completely black, so bad it couldn't be saved. Checked the rest of the pieces, same thing. Meal was a disaster, in the garbage it went, a waste of $22 bucks. This pizza should have never been served. Looks to me like Paul and Eddy's are willing to put their reputation on the line for a mere $22 bucks. Not a smart business move on their part. A good reputation is hard to achieve and if not careful, can foolishly be lost! read more

I am so conflicted about posting this review...but, I've promised to Yelp in good times and in bad...so here goes nothing. I was really excited to try this place, as I hear it's The neighborhood pizza spot. Being a small business, I wanted to love this place so badly - I wanted to add it to my regular rolodex of places I support regularly. I've been there multiple times, and given it opportunity for redemption, but sadly, I don't think I will be coming back. Three strikes, you're out. The first visit, we were immediately greeted; we ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. The concept of my favorite football snack on a pizza had me enthralled. When it arrived, it was everything I could imagine - buffalo sauce and chicken on a pizza crust, BUT it was completely charred around the edges, and on the bottom. Being new to the area, my husband and I thought it was due to it being the New-England thin crust mixed with open oven style, or possibly just a fluke (since so many people rave about this place!), so we ate around the burnt parts and tried to make the best of the situation. The second time we came, we waited quite a while to be seated, and only to learn after we had been seated and waiting for a while, that the kitchen was out of chicken. That would have been nice to know before we looked at the menu... The third (and final time), we again ordered a buffalo chicken pizza. It was so burned (complete with black suit!) that it was practically inedible. I asked the server about it (I promise, I wasn't rude!), and she shrugged her shoulders and stared at us. I was so disappointed! I could understand if the place was busy, but we were the only people in there! It was unpalatable! Sadly, We won't be coming back...even if it's only around the corner. Which is a total bummer. read more

Very nice delivery guy, however, spent $30 on a large VERY BURNT buffalo chicken pizza. Shocked they even boxed it up and thought it was acceptable to give to their customers. If I wasn't starving I would've called back and got a refund. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

See all

Great neighborhood pizza place. Hamden surprisingly doesn't have that many good pizza options but Paul & Eddys does just fine

I ordered a pepperoni and hot cherry pepper pie for delivery through Slice. Delivery was great, on time and still hot. There was pretty much no sauce and a lot of cheese so it was very greasy. Crust was thin and good. Pepperoni coverage was good but there were just a few pepper slices. read more

Paul & Eddy's Pizza - Pizza with pepperoni and jalapeno - Pizza Near Me - Hamden, Connecticut

Ordered a cheese pizza and a pepperoni. Not impressed at all. Cheese tasted funky and there wasn't much sauce at all and the dough had a weird taste also. read more

An anchor in the neighborhood, Paul & Eddy's is a fantastic place to grab a pie, sub, salad, or calzone! Great food, great prices, and great treatment of customers every time you walk in! read more

I just received my buffalo chicken pizza.... I didn't realize that it would be cold,bland and have no sauce .... is this the normal recipe?!

After ordering 3 pizzas here, we've reached some conclusions. Pros: the delivery is fast and hot! Cons: the clams casino has no clams; ordering extra cheese on half results in the same skimpy amount on the whole thing; ordering garlic on half results in no garlic at all; ordering a margarita has no visible sauce whatsoever. There are other, better places to try. read more

We grabbed 4 slices of cheese pizza to go, to eat in the car on our road trip home. It was the perfect choice. The staff were so friendly, the slices were ready very quickly, and there's a restroom available (important since CT started closing its rest stops in the highway). You know, a slice of cheese pizza has nothing to hide behind. There are no glitzy toppings to obscure bad crust, subpar cheese, or lame sauce. Paul and Eddy's serves straight up excellent pizza, even when it's just slices gobbled in the car. Thanks guys! read more

Ordered gluten free pizza this afternoon and it was delicious! We've moved from the area, but still love Paul and Eddy's pizza.

I was looking for a new pizza place and I was in Hamden, Connecticut which is about a half hour's drive from where I live, so I was choosing blindly. I bought two pizzas from Paul and Eddy's, the staff was friendly, and headed home and with anticipation tried my first slice. Delicious just the way I like my pizza, slightly charred, tasty. Perfect in every way! Will definitely go back. read more

so i'm gonna be honest, my overall experience with this place has been good. foods good, comes on time (most of the time). BUT tell me why on 11/9 my pizza smelt like old fermented diaper around the crust. who stuck their silly little hand in their crack while they were making this? be honest... read more

New Haven is known for its pizza, but the best pizza I've had here is Paul & Eddy's. They always deliver super fast, hot, and delicious pizza - and the price can't be beat. Love this place, and I highly recommend it. read more

Good cheese pizza...but ice cold. Delivery guy didnt bother calling or texting. Just left it outside in the cold, outside my apartment complex. I'll go elsewhere. read more

Long time customer I was hung up on several times Eddie said I never called , like why would I take time in my night to make this up ? Treated horrible this man does not deserve to have a customer service business of any kind rude rude rude and I don't know what happened with the pizza but it is not what is used to be which was only ok to begin with read more

I don't really post that much on here..but I had to write this review...I never been to this place before but I figured I would give it a chance because it's like 3 minutes away from my house. I think I should of done some research before because I made a big mistake. I see a lot of reviews about the pizza being burnt, and guess what my review is no different. They need to really watch the oven because it seems as tho they don't. I just ordered a cheese pizza and couldn't even eat it. I then went to my salad because I couldn't really eat my pizza, and I figured you can't really screw up a salad, or can you? Yes it is possible! My lettuce tasted like it was a week old and was brown and tomatoes tasted like water. Nothing was fresh that's for sure. Sorry thumbs down from me! Won't be going back. read more

Their meatballs are excellent and the prices are really good. I have ordered more than a few times from this restaurant and each time was great. Very happy I'm only around the corner from Paul & Eddy's but it's so nice that they do deliver. read more

They have some interesting items on their menu, but it's a bit on the small side for a pizza place. We got a pizza, a "turnover" (a calzone with tomato sauce inside), and meatballs and cheese in a cup. The pizza was quite burned on the edges, but was otherwise okay. The turnover I had high hopes for - it always confused me that there was no sauce in calzones - but unfortunately it was a bit bland and the mushrooms I got it with were canned not fresh. The meatballs and cheese in a cup were exactly what they sound like, and were probably the best part but not great. There wasn't any garlic bread on the menu or we would've gotten some of that as well. We'll definitely be ordering elsewhere in the future. read more

Received Over cooked burnt pizza multiple times. What a shame...could be a nice spot too.