This location has some parking in front but you may have to park a little bit away. We made reservations but depending on the day you might not need them. We were seated quickly. I loved the music they were playing. It set the right tone for a chill and relaxed experience. My only complaint is the hard chairs. The service was great, our server took our order and checked in periodically. I got the shrimp boil and like the Queen of Hearts said yes to off with their heads. It was a good portion size. I really enjoyed the shrimp, the sausage, mashed potatoes and corn. No complaints. My friend enjoyed your roll and the chips were good. read more

See all

Let me start by saying that I didn't try any of the rolls or buns so my 3 star review is based solely off of my desert and fry experience. I want to be fair. I ordered ice cream with magic shell and got ...melted milk stuff and a smidge of magic shell. I would never order this again. My childhood memories are far better than whatever was served to me in a tin cup. The fries were warm, but I basically paid 5 x's more for McDonald fries. I don't know that I'd chance the rolls based on these two items but the wait staff was friendly. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - It smells amazing!!! - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I loved that it was peaceful and quiet as a family we could enjoy as a group. We were there for our daughter's birthday because they have the best crawfish boil. And they did loved the food and service and definitely the atmosphere. read more

From the moment we walked in, we were greeted and treated like family. The restaurant was cozy and welcoming and the staff was great! Mary (our waitress) made recommendations and thank goodness we listened to her. All restaurants need a lady like her working for them. The lobster roll was fresh and the bread was light and tasty. The buffalo steamed buns and Fried green tomatoes were wonderful! We will definitely be back the next time we are in Tulsa! read more

A business lunch done right! A short walk from the office lead us to this delicious place. Started out with the Lobster Mac n Cheese - highly recommend. Also had the Hush puppies - they might have been some of the best Hush Puppies I've had! A dozen oysters on the half shell were also devoured! My lunch was the Peacemaker (Oyster Poorboy) house chips and I added a side order of Cole slaw. The sandwich was definitely worth it and very tasty, the chips - meh nothing worth noting. They added nothing to the meal other than decoration. The Cole Slaw was on the brink of being great but there seemed to be something lacking. I can't exactly put my finger on what the slaw needed. One would have never known since the dish was cleared by the end of the meal! My colleagues had the Lobster Roll - (Connecticut style), Poorboy Smoked Brisket, and a Cheeseburger (definitely not seafood eaters) Overall the group was satisfied with lunch and it would definitely rate a return visit. I passed on the dessert but I'm told the Cherry Crumble was delicious! read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Oysters on the half shell - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Got a lobster roll and it was cold. Not room temp, luke warm, no....COLD. The food here is average. Go to Nola's instead if you want Louisianan cuisine. read more

I ordered a Lobster roll to go. It was disappointing to see a Rubbermaid container with some lobster and a roll in the sack. One employee told me I could have a refund so I said yes do that. then the manger Richard came over and said no too bad and that the employee was 'just a person' and his earlier comment of a refund didn't matter. Richard is up there with the most unprofessional and rude people I've encountered. read more

Peacemaker has a good selection of fresh seafood in downtown Tulsa. Probably the best seafood restaurant for the area at this time. We went with a large group of nine including three kids and it went great. Our waitress was attentive and friendly! The restaurant was not very busy for lunch, granted it was during a week day. We ordered a two tier seafood tower for appetizer for the whole table. It was pretty good, some crab legs, a few clams and mussels, some oysters, shrimps and salmon pâté. All the seafood was fresh and delicious. The price is a little steep at $55 but worth a splurge once in a while. We tried a Buffalo Crawfish ($15) poorboy and the lobster roll ($37) for lunch. The crawfish poorboy was okay, I wished it wasn't fried but still good. The lobster roll was pretty good, albeit a bit lacking on lobster meat for the price. Overall, pretty good place in Tulsa whenever you are in the mood for seafood! read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Two tier seafood tower - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

When traveling in Tulsa on business, I saw the high rating so decided to check this place out. Cute inside, expensive menu but then again - fresh seafood in Tulsa. I ordered a Maine lobster roll at $29 so expected quite a few chunks of lobster. The lobster had a lot of dressing which took away from the taste. Plus it hid how much/little lobster chunks might have been in there. Service was okay. Server brought my check when I was still about 2/3 into my meal. I thought that was odd. Interesting place. I guess it's hit or miss based on what you order and what you like. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Moderate size Maine lobster roll and chips - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Tulsa needed this. You get accustomed to everything being so blah. I still love the city! This place is fun! Lively! Cute! Everything we had was delicious. Generous portions with fair prices! The lobster Frito pie was definitely different, but still enjoyable. Frog legs were second to none and the oysters had me wanting more! No complaints in service! Parking might be a hassle but what do you expect In Downtown Tulsa? You're welcome! read more

See all

First impressions were fantastic! Super personable hostess, waiter very attentive. When we started asking about the menu...we were in for some surprises. Clam Chowder...made with chicken stock. Seriously?!! Campbell's can make it without chicken stock, you would think a seafood freaking restaurant could...but no. Gumbo also made with chicken, but that was expected...so the waiter offered me a salad. Being a meatitarian, there is meat, and what meat eats. No on the salad. I had my heart set on some Good clam chowder...maybe I have a can at home. Moving on, and promising not to let the clam chowder ruin the dinner, I substituted amphibian for Gastropoda and had the frog legs...awesome! Momma had the gumbo, it was delicious as well. For my entree I had the crawfish boil....with andouille and taters and Brussels sprouts and a huge honkin biscuit and the crawfish were seasoned in a brown sugar creole spice blend that was incredible...I ate everything...and had to catch myself from over licking the sauce off my fingers like a little kid! It was soooo good! Momma had the shrimp roll, with homemade chips and loved it. We finished off with a pair of lemon Whoopi pies...I'm tapping out. Roll me home. Overall, super impressed with the flavors, which were outstanding! This is definitely worth a visit, and we will be back! read more

See all

This place is great go to spot. First time in today and I was impressed with the food, staff, and atmosphere. I had a shrimp poorboy which did not disappoint. The hush puppies were on point with the right amount of breading and the lobster gnocchi was excellent. The chips that come with the rolls/ poorboys were a light Cajun flavor that will have you going back for more. Food: 8.5/10 Food presentation: 8.5/10 Ranch dressing: 5/10 Atmosphere: 9/10 farmhouse meets New England Cleanliness: 10/10 Staff attentiveness: 10/10 read more

See all

Cool place & nice atmosphere in Downtown Tulsa. Our server was a bit snooty, but was fairly prompt. Food was a little pricey but done very well with good flavor & a nice change of pace. Worth trying it out read more

See all

I'm only disappointed with the clam chowder. It looked and tasted like brown gravy. It's not traditional clam chowder. One other thing, small metal chairs with no cushion and a metal bar on each side that cuts into my hip. Everything else is good. read more

Good food! Nice serving size. Daughter and I split the seafood tower for our meal. The crawfish cheese spread was worth the trip to eat there by itself. A little pricey but we will go again! Service was fun. They weren't busy at lunch noon on Saturday mid month. The place is clever with their decor. read more

Service was a little slow to begin with, but improved once we received drinks. 4 of us had brunch. 3 had country breakfast, delicious. The cornmeal pancakes were great. Bf had the crab cake eggs Benedict. Amazing. I will get that next time! read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Country breakfast - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Food was straight smacking. Had a party of 5 elite sigmas and got seated immediately. Fried green tomatoes rizzed us up drenched in seasoning definitely recommend. Ohio level decorations were gas. Overall Bussin experience no cap. read more

Service , and food were great ambiance ok. I think this the third time we have eaten here , oysters are wonderful. read more

Service, portions, quality, pricing... all off....we are a land locked state... we knowwww that fish isn't fresh.... So please adjust waits, prices, and attitude. Service was slow and bigger tables got more attention. If the wait was worth the food... happy to pay the price... but it's not. Also don't sit everyone that comes in right next to each other.... Makes the place look empty and makes the patrons feel weird. read more

It's been a while since I went but it was a weekend and it was very empty in the restaurant. My husband and I sat at the bar and there was one other person sitting there with a couple of tables in the restaurant. Service was slow and the food took a while. The lobster roll was not what we were craving. Very small portions for the price as well. read more

Very disappointed- went for the fried clams, and they are no longer on the menu. I ordered the clam chowder and no clams, and it was like brown gravy. Mac and cheese was soupy, normally you expect baked Mac and cheese, this was not that, it was a soup poured over the macaroni and lobster. I will say the lobster. was adequite read more

Now I will admit this was my first time sitting at a bar in 3 months! You know, having a beer and a whiskey while pondering dinner. I was giddy, I was relieved but most of all I was hungry. Add to that, really glad I stopped here for a beer and a bite to eat. Now I must start by saying Downtown Tulsa OK is one heck of a great area! I am already looking forward to coming back to visit this city and I already know where I am going to eat when I come back. This is the sort of place you come back to, not just visit. I sat at the bar, as I said at the beginning. Social distancing doesn't seem to be a thing anymore in OK yet things were a little spread out so I was fine with that. Had a very charming young bartender who gave me fantastic service and some good conversation. I ordered some of their oysters to start, nice and fresh with a wonderful homemade pepper sauce to have with them..fresh horseradish, yum! I simply had to try the crawfish steamed buns, it's crawfish season sort of. The steam buns were probably the best I have ever had. Soft, not mushy at all, so tender! The crawfish was fried with just the right amount of coating, served with a blue cheese sauce and a little slaw, man they were nothing short of delicious!! I have to say, if you find yourself wandering around Downtown Tulsa, enjoying the sights, the people and the great city. You simply have to make it a perfect day and have dinner here, highly recommended! KT read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - two glasses of beer on a bar - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

UPDATE: Ask for Marilyn. Much better service on our second visit. ORIGINAL: Food was great. Three of us split the 3 level tower. Some of the best oysters I've had. Unfortunately it took way to long to get our order and one person's order was left off. Waiter offered to get it, but at that point we were afraid it would take another 30 minutes. After we got our food we went probably another 15 minutes before we saw the waiter again. At this point most people's beverages were empty. The food is good, so if they solve their service problems, then I'm looking forward to what could be the best seafood place in Tulsa. read more

See all

Peacemaker Lobster is amazing! The shrimp is to die for. This was my first time to try oysters and I really liked them. I'll be back for sure. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Food was great and the drinks were really good. I think we were there a little too early for dinner so it was a bit slow and less energetic. But it was starting to fill up when we were leaving. We will be back! read more

This place really is a Peacemaker. The food is so good it could end wars! Seriously, everything we tried was fresh, delicious and elevated to another level, especially for seafood in Oklahoma. So happy to have a place like this to go. I got the Buffalo Crawfish Po'Boy, and holy firecrackers Batman, it was tasty! Not too spicy, not too bland, just perfectly seasoned, sauced and cooked. Each bite was so packed with taste, I kept raving about it the whole meal. The fries were also delicious! Every fry was crispy, crunchy and seasoned very nicely. I asked for a side of the taragon aoili with my fries, because I just wanted to try it, and I enjoyed that as well. I ate half of my sandwich and fries and took the rest to go, because we wanted to save room for the carrot cake whoopie pies. I'm glad we did, because the whoopie pies should be called the "Wha-BAM! Pies", because they were packed with flavor, soft, yet a crispy exterior somehow and the feeling so perfect to go along with it all. I can't say enough great things about the food that we had on our trip. The service was great and our waitress was very friendly. We had a bit of a hang up, because we asked to buy a gift card for one of my wife's coworkers, and nobody really seemed to know how to get a gift card for us. It took a while, but they got us taken care of eventually. I can't wait to go back and try some more food...if I can bring myself to not order that amazing buffalo crawfish sandwich again! read more

We were there on Friday night a couple weeks ago. I put off writing this review because I was so disappointed. Hubby was too. We avoided everything fellow Yelpers warned against, like the thin, runny chowder (which we love) and butter drippy rolls. The atmosphere is picnicy, waterfront casual. Great for families. One large group was having a youngster birthday party. They were thoroughly enjoying themselves. We've spent an ungodly amount of time in Nola, that's all I'm going to say. (Although when I think lobster roll I think northeast, like Boston or Maine. Nola's right there with other seafood) Hubby said his po'boy was okay. He paid the $2 upgrade for fries. Looks like most people don't mind the extra $2. I so craved a lobster roll. After reading the reviews I discussed it w/ our waitress. She completely understood and offered to put the butter on the side of my Maine roll. At least it wasn't dripping, I could control the butter. But the bun was dry and like another reviewer noted, just seemed off somehow. And with so little lobster it's always gonna seem like too much bread. I was charged $28. I liked the homemade chips, but was disappointed they weren't warm which would have made them so much better. The service was outstanding. I'd like to say we'd be back, but we'll proably just leave town instead. read more

See all

Ok... so all in all the food is a strong 3. I gave it a 4 bc the staff and atmosphere was nice and the wife really enjoyed the crab legs. They weren't overly big and meaty but the amount of legs makes it well worth it. Kiddos got the fish sticks and actually enjoyed them. I love some home made potato chips and they were actually good. I hate to say the roll was better than the crab but it was missing a sauce.. I'd say butter but it really needed a drizzle or something... the hush puppies came with a sauce which made them good bc I really hate to say it was similar to the corn breading in a corn dog... and I'm not saying it was 100 % there but a few steps... I'll come back to try something else most likely the lobster... read more

See all

Loved the atmosphere and service, wasn't wild about the food. My wife and I ordered the lobster boil and the steamed clams. The clams were tiny. The bread that came with them was great. The lobster boil was kind of a mixed bag. The tail was tough and chewy, though the claw meat was fine. The rest of the boil (potatoes, brussel sprouts and sausage) was pretty good. I think the thing to get here is the lobster roll, which I've had and enjoyed in the past. read more

So, I know this is mainly a seafood place.. but their brunch... *chefs kiss* My fiancée and I both got the Country breakfast. It comes with 2 eggs (how you like), bacon, amazing potatoes, and Johnny cakes.... which are absolutely incredible. If you love brunch, this place is a must try!! read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - 2 Country Breakfasts, coffee, mimosa, and Moscow mule - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

I am sad to write this review. This is a neat spot and a nice change to our local dining community. It has a nice vibe, the service was friendly and efficient. All element that would cause a return visit. Food- this is the issue. I have had outstanding rolls on the East Coast and was excited for this new addition. The lobster was cooked perfectly but the bread .... this is an integral element of a roll and we have a failure. Rather that a roll they use some type of bread that looks like toast. That is bad enough but then they use butter or oil and grill it. The oil gets on your hands and gives an oily taste to the sandwich. At $28 this was a failure. I would consider returning but ask how bread is prepared for any sandwich before taking the leap. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Lobster roll - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

This place is a new favorite. The oysters are flown in daily by helicopter, and you can tell. When you eat the oyster, they are still salty from the sea. The atmosphere is modern coastal, very beautiful. read more

See all

Oyster were good but the other food was not good. It was like they served us old mussels and the shrimp were chewy. The service was friendly but slow and they were not busy. Overall we won't be going back. read more

I went here last week and had such high hopes but sadly Peacemaker did not meet them. I would have given them a better review if their prices matched their quality. The prices were the same as they were in Boston yet they lacked the flavor, quality, and freshness. It was good but the food just wasn't worth the price. I ordered 4 oysters, a crab roll, cajun fries, and one glass of wine, this came to be 69$ and 79$ with tax. I would happily pay this if they just took it out of the ocean and it was good, but not worth the price. The servers were INCREDIBLY nice, and the environment was pleasant and fit the Cajun, and North Eastern theme. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - $36 - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all

Great food. Friendly staff. Love the lobster roll both ways. Great ambience. Clean. We will go back when we get the opportunity.

Heard there was a new restaurant in town a few weeks ago, so convinced my coworkers that we should go here for lunch. Located in the Blue Dome district, this will be a great location. Easy to get to when downtown for events and such. I really wanted to try their Lobster roll, but just couldn't bring myself to pull the trigger for a $24 sandwich. Instead I ordered their lunch special, which is Soup + Half PoorBoy sandwich. My choice was the Buffalo Crawfish which was served on a nice, soft roll and was dressed with celery slaw, ranch & blue cheese. The clam chowder is New England style, but not as creamy as others I've had, however it was delicious. Great atmosphere, but I believe it could get very loud. The food was great and my only negative comment would be the chairs used in the dining room. They were just so uncomfortable! Will definitely go back and will recommend to my friends. read more

See all

I loved this place. It has a great relaxed atmosphere in an old industrial style with some nautical themes. The food and service were excellent. The lobster roll was outstanding and a little overpriced but if don't mind the spend you will love it. My wife ordered the shrimp boil and it was superb with just the right amount of spice. The shrimp were giant and potatoes and corn were perfectly prepared. I love that they threw in some crisply potatoes too. Lastly my daughter inhaled the Mac and Cheese before my very eyes so I know it was way above the norm. It didn't come out of a box! Go. You will love it. And now more than ever, please support your local restaurants!!! read more

See all

This is a new Cajun joint that opened up in Downtown, and it is by far a very welcoming addition to the food community. The original location is a very popular one in the heart of St. Louis, and I am glad that they opened up another location right here in Tulsa. We started off sharing a half dozen fresh raw oysters from the sea served with delicious mignonette sauce. We just missed their happy hour deals, so they were more expensive, but the taste was well worth the price. We also shared their shrimp boil, which consisted of boiled shrimp, boiled and fried potatoes, boiled and fried brussels sprouts, and a complimentary biscuit with garlic butter sauce. I'm normally not the biggest fan of shrimp, but they did a fine job with this fresh recipe. We would definitely come back and try their other seafood options, including their lobster and crab. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Shrimp boil - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

Exceeded all expectations. The lobster was the best I've ever had (a pleasant surprise being in Oklahoma.) The homemade chips are amazing. Goes great with the extra butter from the Connecticut style roll. Great service! Thanks for taking care of us Craig! Will be back soon. read more

If you are looking for some good seafood this is definitely the place to go. It is a bit pricey but worth every penny. The service was wonderful. The owner even came to our table and made us feel comfortable and welcomed. read more

Peacemaker Lobster and Crab - Seasonal spread - Seafood Near Me - Tulsa, Oklahoma

See all