was looking for a new coffee spot to try out and this one had great reviews. The coffee was slammin', probably the best I've been able to find thus far since moving into the area. Staff is super friendly and personable. The location itself is small but comfortable with pretty decent seating. Food was also very good, I'm happy they offer turkey bacon since a lot of places don't. I'll definitely be stopping back in!! read more

The eggs, veggies, pastry and rolls are ALWAYS fresh, delicious and prepared to order! Mo, Abbey, Mathamet, Huney, and the lovely young lady make you feel welcomed and like you're part of their family. Of course the coffee is hot and fresh too! Gina Brooklyn read more

Stopped in for the first time today and was not disappointed! The service is stellar; both cashiers were pleasant and helpful, as well as the other employees who acknowledged me as soon as I walked through the door. I got the Greek Omelet (minus the olives) and an Iced Latte (with an added vanilla syrup) and thoroughly enjoyed both! I will definitely become a regular here as they also have free Wi-Fi and had seating available at noon on a Sunday-- both indoor and outdoor! read more

The moment you walked into the cafe you are greeted by friendly staff. The robust smell of coffee greats you with a warm embrace. Coffee is full bodied, and food is equally delicious. Highly recommend!! read more

am not an omelette type of person but just wow!! i have to come back here and i live in jersey :( cant wait to be back. read more

I had an excellent Iced Americano. Also had a ginger molasses cookie, which was very stale.

It's hard to find good bagel sandwiches in New York. I ordered THE NORWEGIANER packed with fillings and satisfying. I enjoyed it so much. My friend is a regular of Penny House Cafe and orders the GRILLED CHICKEN sandwich religiously. The coffee (Columbian) is perfect black and strong the way I like it. read more

What can I say? Penny House Cafe absolutely delivered in every sense. Right next to Prospect Park, we decided to go to start our day before exploring the Park & Library. Turns out, this would be some of our best food in Brooklyn. I'll start by mentioning how excellent the service was here. They answered all of our questions & provided a great first experience with fresh food & drinks to boot. I ordered an Egg, Ham, & Cheese Everything Bagel and my friend Kevin ordered the Norwegian. We ordered coffee as well, despite the fact I'm not a coffee drinker, which turned out to be perfect for the crisp morning. We decided to eat at Prospect Park, since the inside was a little crowded, so we figured we'd explore a bit. The bagels were incredible, from the texture, to the fresh ingredients, all of it. 10/10 there. We both were blown away. I loved the coffee too, perfect pairing with the bagel. I'd highly recommend Penny House & think it's an essential stop when you're in the north side of Brooklyn. read more

Penny House Cafe - Bagel with Egg, Ham, and Cream Cheese - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I've been here a number of times and the food is good, not great. I usually get an everything bagel with cream cheese but they don't usually put enough cream cheese on it IMO. The decor/space is pretty average. They have a time limit for how long you can be there on busy days FYI. What is appalling to me is some of the business owners' responses to reviews here. It's embarrassing when owners can't own their mistakes and get mad at the customer or convince themselves that they must be vindictive or a competitor. Maybe one or two reviews could come like that but sometimes you need to humble yourself and know you could improve. While you are LOL LOLing to reviews, people are LOLing at you because you're embarrassing yourself. read more

I'm trying this spot for breakfast very nice ppl working and a lot of coffee options for the coffee lovers and a lot of healthy eats also it's a small place but worth trying out door eating read more

Never tried any of the food yet, but I plan to based on the wonderful reviews. Five stars for the belly laughs I had reading some of these reviews and particularly the owner's responses. Hilarious and I loved it. I haven't laughed so hard in a while and really lifted my spirits during the crappy day I was having. I applaud your chutzpah and will definitely pop in for a coffee and sandwich soon. read more

Good vibes and good food! Mahmoud was wonderful! He was welcoming and accommodating. The sandwiches were fresh and delicious! Indoor and outdoor seating available. Clean and well maintained bathroom. read more

We stopped by Penny House Cafe to hang out and play card games while some of us got some beverages and pastries. It's a small place with sitting in the back and a very laid-back host. He let us stay until it was closing time, around 6:30 pm. I would definitely stop by again if I'm in the area and need a place to sit and read. read more

Penny House Cafe - a pastry and a cup of coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best coffee and pastries in Brooklyn. The vibe is cool and the service is top notch! I will have coffee no where else when I am in this area. read more

10/10 for the customer service alone! Super friendly when you arrive and happy to give you recommendations if it's your first time. I ordered the three cheese omelette on a bagel with bacon and it was just what I needed! Great place to stop by for a breakfast sandwich or a quick lunch. I'll def be back to try more! read more

Incredible sandwiches and even more incredible staff! I'm new to the area and I've gone to Penny house like 3 times already and they recognized me! I already feel like a local in the area!! The sandwiches are always hot fresh and tasty! The matcha is also SO GOOD- and not all that pricey!! :) I'll obviouslyyy be back! read more

Penny House Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I gave it another try. If you have seriously different working hours of your working hours depend on your mood - post this information in cafe's profile and don't confuse possible costum UPD Excuse me, I posted it when I got home. You know you were not there. And no, I don't post only bad reviews. But very nice of you to respond this way. I was just on my way to come by again. Well, I think I'll better not. read more

Then food was amazing!! The lady at the register was really nice, and the other employee helped me when I needed assistance. The environment outside was really welcoming, and a perfect place to stop and eat on a rainy day. read more

If you're looking for a fantastic (pork-free) breakfast sandwich, this is your spot. Imagine your local halal deli sandwiches, if they did everything exactly right: - A neatly folded, perfectly seasoned omlet on a high quality bagel or roll, toasted just right, the cheese perfectly melted, everything in balance so it maintains its structural integrity to the last bite. - A TBLT on a bagel with mesculin for the lettuce and a just-the-right-amount-of-runny- without-being-too-messy fried egg. These sandwiches are made with love and pride, usually by the owner who always makes you feel welcome. read more

Penny House Cafe - Turkey Bacon BLT with a fried egg. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Really lovely restaurant - the staff are so great at recognizing their regulars, talking to customers and engaging them. I got a bagel sandwich with salmon and it was light and delicious. Quick service. Pretty filling for a quick lunch. Well priced less than $10. They have outdoor or indoor dining. Overall quite a lovely experience and would recommend checking them out. read more

Penny House is an ok place to go into if you pass by it. The coffee isn't bad and the food is average. I love a good bacon egg cheese and the one I had here was good but nothing special for the price it was The staff was friendly though read more

The food was really good! We got the "Best Seller" and penny house club. Both were good, but I really loved the "Best Seller" which is Gouda cheese, egg, turkey bacon on a bagel with chipotle mayo. It had a kick to it, great!! Also the hot chocolate was delicious! Staff is really sweet, however we did have to wait a while for the food. read more

Penny House Cafe - The Best seller - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The best food! The best tea! The best and most friendliest customer service. I bought the best seller and switched out the cheese for the ghost pepper, GAME changer. The staff are so sweet and caring and have made me feel so special everytime I come in! read more

So Penny House is an awkward place for me to review because I don't particularly dislike it but it has significant enough problems that it makes me avoid the place most of the time. I think every time I come here I always get the sense of disorder in the shop. In particular there isn't any ordered lines to the front.. in fact the front is setup on the left and people have to walk up to the cashier on the right so often the staff just pick out people they see in the crowd and ask for their orders. This quite annoying when they end up picking people who arrive later but just so happen to be in the staffs line of sight. This has happened a few times for me in the past and severely offended one of my friends when I showed them this place once. Besides the line situation it also feels like they have difficulty keeping orders, it has not been uncommon for me to have to clarify what I ordered previously because they were trying to juggle 100 or so other orders. It just feels chaotic here, especially when it's a crowded day. But besides that this place does offer good coffee and food. The breakfast sandwiches in particular are nice and I can't think of a coffee shop that offers something like that around the area. They also offer a unique dirty chai which I like. It's just not enough though for me to come back here considering the service. I can see why people would like this place but I can't honestly recommend it considering there is so much competition for coffee shops in the area. The chaotic feeling I get of this place doesn't help at all either. read more

With the Botanical Garden hosting a festival this weekend the neighborhood was especially crowded... so we walked a little bit farther down Washington Ave to the Penny House Cafe and discovered a little treasure on the border of Prospect Heights and Crown Heights. It's a cozy place with a small kitchen/counter and a few tables in the back, but they serve up a nice selection of baked goods, sandwiches and coffees. We both opted for something off their lunchtime menu - three-cheese quesadillas. Hubs added veggies and chicken to his order, I don't have time for veggies so mine just had chicken. The guy behind the counter made sure to mention "it doesn't come w/ salsa or anything..." ok...no problem. And it wasn't a problem at all. The chicken in this quesadilla was so juicy and flavorful you won't miss any of those silly condiments. The menu board says "three cheese quesadilla" ... come to find out the three cheeses are American, Cheddar and Swiss. Each cheese layer added a different element to the quesadilla and created a lovely gooey cheesey goodness. Paired with that amazing seasoned chicken and you've got a dreamy quesadilla. I tried to get the guy at the counter to tell me what was in the chicken marinade - but he smiled and said it was a secret... I guess I'll just have to visit again and order another quesadilla (or maybe their chicken sandwich) and see if I can figure it out for myself. Note - the website menu isn't updated. Quesadillas are $6 + $1 for veggies and $2 for chicken. They area also huge! So don't balk at the price... they're worth it. read more

Penny House Cafe - Chicken Quesadilla - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Absolutely delicious and fresh bagels. I had a beef bacon, egg, and cheddar cheese. It was all made fresh, very hot and excellent quality ingredients. The bagel was perfectly toasted but still easy to chew and flavorful. So so so good. The staff is very kind as well. read more

After asking for a recommendation, they gave me a fan favorite with bacon, eggs, cheese, avocado, and I think a lil sauce. It was so flavorful and satisfying. The staff was also v nice! read more

Penny House Cafe - a hand holding a sandwich - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love this place. They're always so welcoming and considerate. Great food / coffee / vibes. Thank you penny house!!!

Service - 10 Food - 10 Friendliness - 10 We've moved away from Brooklyn and still keep finding our way back! What else is there to say. read more

I found this spot accidentally and it fulfilled my breakfast sandwich craving. There were many good options so I plan to go back and try more again! read more

Penny House Cafe - Beef Sausage Sandwich - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The owner of this place is super nice. It's a great relaxing place to have a quiet coffee and read a book. Music is spot on for relaxing as well with some nice classic guitar playing over the speakers at just the right volume. My latte was delicious! read more

Penny House Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Would've been 4 if the notes on my order were accommodated. I got a egg whites and cheese sandwich on a roll, I requested salt and pepper in the eggs, and ketchup on the sandwich and got none of the above. I ended up only taking a few bites, being as there was no salt or pepper in the eggs it didn't taste good to me. However to someone else who enjoys eggs without salt and pepper it may have been delicious. I'm not sure if they could accommodate my request or if they just didn't bother to but I think almost every where that prepares food has salt and pepper in the area. Definitely wasn't worth $5.44. As far as the employee in the store he was friendly and had my order ready. read more

Penny House Cafe - 3 Egg Whites Sandwich with cheese. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

My boyfriend and I went here last Saturday before heading to the Brooklyn museum. The service is FANTASTIC, probably some of the best we've experienced in the city. Unfortunately their coffee machine was down, but we still decided to try their breakfast sandwiches, which were absolutely delicious! This is a must try spot! read more

Great service. Ordered their special sandwich and it was really good. It was with turkey bacon. It was a different take on the classic bacon egg and cheese. Would love to go to this place again. Service was top notch as well! read more

You enter this deep rectangular chamber and immediately get the sense that this is a cafe's answer to a railroad apartment. Which sits well with your pal Johnny. For your pal tends to practice trainspotting near the teeming tendrils of Broadway Junction, where a good third of Brooklyn's subway lines converge into a irreconcilable cobweb of broken rails and shattered dreams. But there are no severed promises at the Penny House. Not if you have something going on in your life that the affluent and the empty will never know. This place has been around forever, long before they painted the surrounding buildings in bright hues to spike property value and jack up rent. Long before the attorneys and the bankers replaced the artists and the dreamers in Prospect Heights. But there are still some of the latter handful around. And Penny House is a subtle Mecca for them. The generous garrulous gent who runs the place has a head for regulars and fist-bumps ambiverts who swing just this side of ephemeral misanthropy. He has an uncanny knack for making the right people feel welcome and for tolerating the ones who will never swing by again. Beneath his gregariousness, he is a very patient man. He is doing his part to tell the best of Brooklyn (the ones never lauded or laureled by the smug yuppies who think nothing of blowing a Ben Franklin on tasteless lunches spiced down for the vanilla-minded and who are regularly belligerent to anyone who remotely counts as Bohemian these days) that this is a second home. Second homes (and, your pal would argue, first homes) are becoming rarer as we chase away the best, the brightest, and, alas, the broke. So that ethos is good for three solid stars right there. But let's secure the other two stars. There are four tables. And the seating scarcity says to anyone that you'd better be serious about hanging here. You'd better appreciate the place and do something with your life. Something different. Something that drew you to the five boroughs. A vision that jolted you out of bed when you lived somewhere else. When you said to yourself that you'd come to New York and not be swallowed up, only to learn that your only real chance of surviving and of making a mark meant making an effort. So if you sit down at one of the quartet, you'd better rise to the occasion. If you're firing up Excel as you open your laptop, this ain't the place for you. If you're here to engage in fake meetings for your startup (which your pal espies in every other cafe these days), this ain't the place for you. Even so, the feel hasn't stopped certain venture capitalists from inhabiting the place. But don't worry. They usually don't last. For if an authentic original sits at an adjacent table, the six figure salary man will flee. There are laughs from the front and an amusing triptych of toilet paper in the bathroom. That the joint manages to serve as much food as it does -- given its underdog stature -- says much more. This is a scrappy place that makes the most of what it has, much like the best people in Brooklyn. This is the kind of place that the hopelessly incurious describe as "okay." This is the kind of place where nobody quite announces that it's not okay to be "okay" with this place. But the feel is implied, communicated by what now counts for semaphore. Penny House is a holdout against the digital revolution. Your pal Johnny has no idea how it survives, but he's glad it's here. read more

Order: The Turkey BLT on whole wheat wrap was compact and stuffed. It was presented on a very nice ceramic plate as well. Although I'm glad they provided a whole wheat wrap option, there was a little too much turkey bacon for me. Price: $5.95, so not cheap nor expensive. Atmosphere: We went around noon time yet it wasn't crowded, felt very casual, was quiet, and had many available seats. There was also free wifi so would be a nice place to study & do work. Overall very nice cafe vibes!!! read more

Penny House Cafe - Turkey BLT on whole wheat wrap ($5.95) - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Penny house is a small quaint restaurant with yummy sandwiches. Very welcoming and friendly staff. read more

Penny House Cafe - Bagel with egg cheese and turkey bacon - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Popped in one (hungover) morning for coffee and a quick bite. Coffee was great (and a huge cup) I got the Israeli: lox, hummus, onions, tomatoes - on whole grain. It was...ok; definitely a little messy to eat since the hummus got a little soft(er) in the warm bagel. It cost $8.95...eeeek!...even for smoked salmon. $12 for a bagel and coffee is a little steep for my blood, especially when you could walk a block or two in any direction and get a full plated breakfast for that amount... I'd skip read more

Penny House Cafe - The Israeli. Hummus instead of cream cheese. I can dig it - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Uhm yeah! Cheap, fast, good - just what ya need when you're hungry and in a hurry. I got "The Russian" pictured here. With tax came out to be $9.47 - I like these prices since I'm coming from the bay. I thought the salmon was prepared properly and tender and easy to eat. sesame bagel was made perfectly, ohhh New York bagels, ain't nothing better read more

Penny House Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Ultra quick service. Deliscious breakfast+coffee, and very casual environment. Really enjoy my time here. Very relaxed vibe, nothing to fancy, nothing bourgeois about it. You order a bagel with some breakfasty things ontop and the wait is short. I love their homemade hummus on mine.. and in the winter they have an incredible homemade lintel soup... so nice Coffee is great too, big couch in the back for a meet up with friend, or just to sit and draw. Light NPR in the background so also good for getting work done. Wish it was closer to my place, or I'd be there all the time! read more

Penny House Cafe - Backroom - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all