Wow. I just went to here with my boyfriend's family for his birthday and I'm so glad I did. The food was amazing. We ordered the porterhouse, creamed spinach, calamari, baked clams, the jumbo baked potato, and some pasta. The porterhouse was perfectly seasoned, and it was enough for three people to share. Whatever sauce the baked clams were doused in, I need that recipe. I used the complementary bread to soak up some of that juice and it was amazing. Their espresso martinis were also really good and strong. The only thing I did not like was the jumbo baked potato. It just felt like there was Velveeta cheese slathered on top, so if there's an item I would pass on, it would be this one. Just get regular mashed potatoes. The service was amazing. The owner came out to meet with us multiple times. Our waiters were very attentive and gave us ample time to order. They literally cut our meat and served it for us. The ambience was really nice. It's your usual steakhouse joint, with dim lighting. However, the best part about this dinner was that they seated us in a private room with one other party. It was very intimate and nice and I don't think I could've asked for better service. The cherry on top was that they came out with limoncello shots to end the night. If you're in the Westchester area, please definitely come check this place out. It is worth the money, time, and effort. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

We've been to Peter's steakhouse a few times and have always enjoyed our experience. Since children can't sit at the bar, we weren't able to take advantage of happy hour, which was disappointing but understandable. The owner was very gracious and offered us six complementary oysters since we couldn't sit at the bar. The oysters weren't our favorite that evening, the rest of the meal more than made up for it. The rest of the meal was very enjoyable. The crab cake was enormous, the grilled octopus was excellent - my son loved it - and the veal with prosciutto and melted cheese was tasty. The baked potato was huge and cooked perfectly. I ordered a cocktail and they made me one with elderflower which was nice but a little sweet for my taste. My friend's Manhattan was nice and strong. What stood it the most was the hospitality. The owner went out of his way to make sure we had a good experience, and that level of service is sobering we really appreciated. Next time we'll probably make it an adult only happy hour so we can enjoy the bar menu. read more

See all

Fabulous dinner at Pete's again . Calamari , porterhouse for 2, German potatoes and Mac n cheese all absolutely delicious! Service 5 star .. pistachio tartufo to top it off ... love this place :) read more

Almost two years after opening I am so happy to report that Peter's Steakhouse is still upholding the standard for excellence in food and service that first won me over. The food remains excellent and the entire staff could not be more welcoming or helpful. Treat yourself selves to a meal or two at this exceptional local independently owned restaurant, and by all means check out the outstanding Italian specialties! read more

Peter's Steakhouse - My happy smile after enjoying lunch with a friend at Peter's Steakhouse. - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

Steak was very good and cooked to perfection. The folks who were working were also great.

The staff were so sweet, and the food is just delicious. We went for the porterhouse, with two yummy sides of mash potatoes and creamed spinach. There's a yummy basket of bread and my husband swears the butter is just better at a steakhouse. Our steak was the perfect temperature and we finally had a nice date night in a while. Will definitely be back! read more

Peter's Steakhouse - Porterhouse for two, dude of mash potatoes & creamed spinach - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

Nice inviting atmosphere. Owner was gracious. Good service. Enjoyed our porterhouse steak for two (had leftovers). Pasts excellent. read more

See all

We had a great time celebrating a friends birthday at Peter's last night. For appetizers we had the tuna tartare and the calamari. The calamari was light and fried perfectly with good flavor. We split the porterhouse for 3 and split the lobster Mac and cheese, the creamed spinach and the mushrooms. All 3 sides complemented the porterhouse perfectly. Besides the steak I think my favorite dish was the tartufo for dessert! If you like pistachio ice cream definitely get the tartufo! read more

Peter's Steakhouse - Porterhouse for 3 - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

Peter and Ari understand the concept of running a great steakhouse. Both have a lot of knowledge and experience on how to prepare, cater, and welcome guests. Friendly and sincere are their underlying traits. When I arrived, i dis not know Peter was actually greeting guests. Felt at home immediately, and when I mentioned watching the NY Knicks basketball playoff game, he put me at a table where I can view the TV. 1st warm and amazingly great smelling bread with butter was placed on the table. I can have just eaten the entire bread basket alone! When my buddy arrived, I placed an order for a mule, but with mezcal, and it was easily accommodated. Ari, our waiter and partner, was easy in conversing with. We wanted to have the Chateaubriand steak for two, since it's not easily available in most places. I wanted mine Med while my buddy wanted Med Well. Ari found a way to make it happen. The steaks came out perfect and tender. Ari suggested we accompany the steak with sauteed spinach and the potatoes. The potatoes were crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle and super delish!! Meanwhile Peter floated around from table to table making sure the guests were satisfied and the people dining already were definitely pleased. Peter also helped clearing tables of plates and other items. That's makes a good owner!! After dinner, my buddy and I shared the cheesecake and some coffee. We truly had an exceptional dining experience. No need to go all the way into Manhattan especially with the dumb congestion pricing, paying another hefty price to park as well. I live in Queens and it was easier to get here than midtown Manhattan. My buddy is already planning to take his dates here as well. What a great night and thank you, Peter and Ari!! read more

See all

We've been to Peter's Steakhouse twice now and have really enjoyed it. Both times we went service was friendly, professional, attentive and on point. We had terrific drinks, Blue Point Oysters were great, the burger was excellent and we had a terrific Pistachio Tartuffo. Our bartender Sam was super friendly and made us feel like we were regulars. read more

Had a very disappointing experience at Peter's Steakhouse in Eastchester this evening for a birthday celebration. We booked a reservation on their website, received confirmation of the reservation. When we got there, there was a hour wait for our table of two. We placed our order. The appetizer arrived at our table in about 10 minutes. Then we waited, and waited. After about 40 minutes my wife and I had just about enough. We asked for our check at that point. The manager came over and said the food would arrive shortly. We walked out. Terrible experience. read more

Delicious!!!! The filet mignon was so amazing and tender! Grilled octopus is delicious! read more

Peter's Steakhouse - Grilled octopus - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

Ate here today for dinner (9/15/24). The Good. The owner is very friendly and hands on with customers which is always a plus for setting the atmosphere. The place is clean and well taken care of. It's very quiet and intimate with a nice view of the roadway. For my entree, I had shrimp stuffed with crabmeat and asparagus; my son had spicy rigatoni with burrata; my husband had ribeye with creamed spinach and mashed potatoes. We all agreed that our entrees were enjoyable The Not So Good. My lobster bisque had chunks of shrimp instead of lobster in it. I inquired of the owner, Peter, why that was the case and he said he would have to consult with his chef but was adamant that what I thought was shrimp was really lobster. Needless to say, he never came back to confirm one or the other and my husband told me to leave it alone. Nonetheless, the bisque was very flavorful. I just didn't want shrimp in my lobster bisque. As an aside, that exact situation happened to me at Chez Palimintari in White Plains, NY and I did not give them a pass for trying to pass off shrimp in my lobster bisque. I confronted the waiter who confirmed they had run out of lobster so the chef substituted shrimp in the lobster bisque. I sent the bisque back immediately and asked the waiter to remove the item from my bill because it's disingenuous to do that. Besides, what if I had been allergic to shrimp? What then? I would have had an emergency room situation on my hands. That is not okay. The other downside to dining here is that the wait time was a tad bit long. From the time we sat down to the time we got our meal it was two hours. It took about 45 minutes for me to get my lobster bisque (which is why I decided not to send it back to the kitchen PLUS I was starving because it was already 4:30pm and I had not eaten all day). It took then another 30-45 minutes to get the entrees so if you decide to dine here make sure you are not pressed for time. As an aside, the owner did admit that Sundays are a hit and miss and because of that they don't have a lot of wait staff on Sundays. Also, he mentioned that he is a new business having recently opened on May 2024 so give him a chance to build up his clientele and staff. I plan to return on a week day since he has more wait staff during the week. read more

See all

Love Peter's steakhouse, it's become our go to Westchester restaurants. Consistently great food, atmosphere is cozy, drinks excellent - the owners go above and beyond to welcome patrons and make sure you have an enjoyable dinner. read more

Holy cow! I rarely give 5 stars but this restaurant deserves it. Some restaurants focus on making money as an end goal and then how to fashion a plan to that end. On the other hand, others focus on a supreme dining experience-- the ambiance, the service, and the food...and know that with that as the end goal financial success will come. Peter and PS Steakhouse is in the latter category. The service is the very top notch and multiple staff come and check in on you often and dutifully. They are experienced and good at what they do. The ambiance is quintessetnial steakhouse with plenty of wood and comfy tables and chairs. The food-- is absolutely phenomenal. It reminded me of Peter Lugers in their heyday of late 1990s and early 2000s. the steak was perfectly seasoned, perfectly cooked, and perfectly served. The taste was out of this world. Hands down...end of story. Now the other diners had the spinach ravioli and that was delicious too. If you come with some vegetarian friends, they will not just be happy, they will be thrilled. They will also reflect very well on the generously sized, perfectly dressed caesar salad and spot-on proportions of croutons, parmesan cheese and dressing. I make my own caesar dressing from scratch and my own croutons too-- I can tell when a restaurant does so too. The did-- and the said was a a win. The German potatoes were delicious and they were this very nice amalgamation of potato chunks ensconced in more mashed-style potatoes. They were nicely broiled crisp and very nicely seasoned and extremely toothsome. I was itching to get the steak fries...next time! The creamed spinach was creamed to a velvety consistency. I make my own creamed spinach too, and I tried to go through in my head how they got them to be one velvety smooth and seasoned so well without too much pepper or salt. Guess what--maybe I won't make it myself anymore and just come here instead! :-) The bread was made in house and had this delicious and thick crust. I was hard to refrain myself from eating more than a small slice. Since it was soooo good. Maybe one idea is to build on it. Make some sour dough rolls too and put them in the basket with a medley of different butters; and, of course charge for that. Finally, if you do come, there is a valet so don't fret about parking. So, in short--I really would suggest giving this wonderful new restaurant a try. You will be glad you did! read more

See all

15/10. The place is a VIBE. Rigatoni alla vodka is AMAZING! Anthony and Yogev are the best part and added bonus, make the BEST drinks around -- unreal old fashions! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!! read more

Had an amazing porterhouse at Pete's must say it was impressive and seasoned to perfection would definitely return to try the other great options on the menu my server was on point and the drinks were perfectly made , definitely recommend this quaint cozy restaurant for a nice meal :) read more

Really great find, I was pleasantly surprised Great service, High quality meat, bar is very good too read more

Second time coming here and it was perfect, appetizers clams, calamari, salad was delicious. The ribeye cooked exactly how we like it, and today Chilean Sea Bass is what I wanted. Service was on point and the environment and decor is so inviting. Highly recommend this place to eat... read more

Peter's Steakhouse - Chilean sea Bass - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

A very good steak house They offer private parties Drinks are right on I have been here many times and it has been perfect read more

My wife and I enjoy the occasional Thursday night out with a simple burger and wine and a fine desert. Someone clued us into Peter's bar menu. You sit at the bar, you get a glass of wine, you get a burger, and you have desert. Pretty simple. But the burger was better than "simple." Well cooked and generous with a nice glass of cabernet. Unbeatable price. (I recently reviewed a place in Scarsdale where the burger was awful and awfully overpriced.) We're old and went early. Very nice bartender who took good care of us. On the whole, a place we'll be going back to fairly often. We've met the owner, Peter, a few times. He is focused on meeting the market, including with this separate bar menu. We've had the general menu for lunch, and it was good too. We're not great steak eaters in part because we do it so infrequently that it takes a while for us to recover when we do. This is a nice, comfortable place and we're pleased to have been told about it. read more

The steak was great and the friendliness of owners and staff was a throwback to more gentile times.

I joyfully found this place by accident one date night! Had enjoyed Peter's previous location in Scarsdale and was saddened when it closed. But serendipity prevailed and unknowingly I booked Peter's Steakhouse and had a great experience! Peter recognized me before I even did him and he welcomed me to his new "home." Enjoy the great downtown Eastchester location and homey atmosphere where Peter and his attentive staff make you feel like one of the family. My date and I shared a steak and multiple sides and was well worth it. Had a great back corner table facing into the restaurant. Bring your appetite and enjoy it for any occasion! read more

Food was delicious. Filet seasoned and cooked to perfection. Service was fantastic! Will certainly plan a trip back if we are in the area next year. Thumbs up for ambiance. read more

Peter's Steakhouse - Filet perfect medium rare, sprouts and mashed potato. - Steakhouses Near Me - Eastchester, New York

See all

The best happy hour! Really good drinks and food. The service is awesome! Highly recommend.

Very disappointed in this place, the staff was very nice that's the only nice thing I can say about this place. The service was ok I had to keep asking for my food and drinks , came here to celebrate a birthday and it was not a good experience I do not recommend and I'll not be coming back here. The ambiance was cozy, the music was classy. The drinks were not bad but took a long time for them to come out. The food was mediocre, crab cake was alright , same with the baked clams, we ordered a ribeye and it lacked flavor, it was medium rare but it was super chewy. I'd ordered the sea scallops and they never put in the order. When they finally brought out the scallops were horrible it had a metallic and bitter taste ... they try to make it up by brining sundaes but I was over it and took the check and left. read more

This place sucks. If you go to the bar you are treated like a second class citizen. Waited over 2 hours for a hamburger. If you don't want people at your bar don't offer food. read more

Best filet mignon I've had in years, cooked and seasoned perfectly. Calamari is very crisp and tender and is a large serving. Recommend the mashed potatoes too, overall very good experience with very good service. read more

The Food, the service, everything was exquisite. Came for dinner with colleagues (6). They did nothing but tend to all of us. The ambiance was very welcoming, we were welcome and seated promptly. I will definitely be returning. read more

Best Steakhouse! What a wonderful classy place, the nicest steakhouse I have ever been to. The host was wonderful and welcoming, offering good suggestions for food and drink. There is an extensive wine list and many wines were available by the glass. The tomato and mozzarella appetizer was great, and we split it between 4 people. The shrimp cocktail was fresh and tasty. The steaks were all excellent and cooked to perfection. One person in our party had the scallop risotto and enjoyed it. There were several non-meat options on the menu for people who don't want steak. The service was excellent, the wait staff was attentive and efficient. I would highly recommend Peter's Steakhouse! read more

Oh if only you could find a fabulous vibe in an upscale spot, with a Happy Hour menu that reads like a novel of delicious cuisine...served until 8pm!!! While we're dreaming, let's add a staff that greets you with warmth, owners who shake your hand, happy you've returned. This gem is a reality. Peter's Steakhouse. Food is exquisite. Service is beyond expectations. A $9 Manhattan made with love. Ari and Anthony at the bar, wining and dining you...it's hard not to pick this spot every bloody evening after work. 5 stars and well done. Treat yourself- you're welcome. read more

The food was amazing?!!!!. The staff was great, they made sure everyone in our table was taken care of.The drinks kept on coming

Peter's Steakhouse in Eastchester is a delightful little gem sitting in the middle of town. The space is quietly elegant, the food is outstanding and owners/partners Peter and Ari, along with their wait staff, are adept at providing a standout dining experience. Our thick-cut filet mignon was beautifully executed and my ribeye hit all the right notes. The cocktails were smart and flavorful and to top it off we had key lime pie with Schlag (new term for me, but heavenly) and a glass of port to close the night. If you're looking for a refined steakhouse that mixes warmth, attention to detail and serious cuisine, this one hits the spot. I highly recommend! read more

A Hidden Gem in Eastchester!We were originally planning to go to Benjamin's for steak after checking out Yelp we decided to give Peter's a try. Smartest move we've made all year. Honestly, I can't decide what's better: the ribeye or the service. Both are absolutely phenomenal. If you want to be treated like royalty and enjoy an unforgettable meal, Peter's is the place. From the moment we walked in, the staff made us feel like VIPs, and every bite of food backed that up. Highly recommend for a special night out -- or just when you want to treat yourself to something incredible read more

Visited Peter's Steakhouse several times. Each time the service was excellent and the food was very good. MUCH better than other Westchester steakhouses. Nice atmosphere and good decor albeit a bit plain. Food was good and served hot. Taste varied on several occasions from excellent to just good and that's the reason for the 4 star review. Prices are a bit expensive but in line with most other steakhouses... not as high as NYC locations. Definitely a good place for dinner and worth a try. read more

One of the best steakhouses in Westchester (in my humble opinion, THE best!). From the delightful cocktails, variety of appetizers, salads and soups to the out-of-this-world steaks and sides (the German potatoes are sublime bite after bite) and the delicious non-steak entrees and joyfully sweet desserts, the entire eating experience is great! Adding to the fantastic food are the attentive, pleasant staff who engage at a personal, authentically caring level as well as the ambiance which is beautiful without being pretentious. A great venue for special occasions, romantic dates, office events as well as families with young children--my kids (6yo & 9yo) had a wonderful time! If you're looking for class and comfort, an excellent menu in an elegant, friendly setting, Peter's Steakhouse is THE place to go in Westchester! read more

Great service and great food. Highly recommend this restaurant. Definitely check them out for a good night out

Peter's is a real gem! We're new to the area, and thought we'd try an upscale steakhouse. After reading many reviews of many restaurants, we decided to go to Peter's. Win! There's lots of metered parking in the area. (We've learned that is vital info in Westchester County!) I had the Classic Negroni, the best one I've ever had. We started with the Garden Salad and the Onion Soup. Both delicious, and the house vinegarette dressing is excellent. We had the bone-in NY Strip, flavorful and cooked medium rare, yum! We also had the Baked Clams, lovely stuffed small clams, wonderful! We'll definitely be returning! read more

Just had a Father's Day's dinner with friends and couldn't be more impressed!! The food was amazing, Ari our server was not only helpful and knowledgeable about the menu but was very friendly!! The ambiance was great like a true steakhouse should be with the PGA golf tournament on the TV and the noise level being such that our table can enjoy our conversations. I had the Veal a la Peter and it was outstanding. Our friends had the porterhouse for 2 and loved it! I highly recommend Peter's steakhouse for dinner as I will be back soon. read more

Took an out of town visitor to dinner here. She was looking for a good steakhouse experience. Service was fabulous. Ambience is ok. I've had better steaks though. Not bad, but not great either. read more