Let me start with the fact I love meatball sandwiches. As a kid in Delaware, that was my favorite…read morehoagie of choice when not having a cheesesteak. I had high hopes for this place but they were greatly exceeded. This was arguably the best meatball sandwich I have ever had! I was not expecting that from a place in Angier, NC and I don't give that designation lightly. The meatballs were perfection, served in a nice crusty roll with fresh mozzarella and a fantastic sauce. I want to drive back down there just thinking about it and I live 45 minutes away. I also had a cannoli and it was exceptional as well. I'm a cannoli junky and this one did not disappoint. I often don't like the ones where the shell is coated in chocolate because they're often some manufactured shell dipped in waxy chocolate. Not the case here. The quality of the chocolate this shell was dipped in was excellent. If you're in the area and want a great Italian sandwich, absolutely stop by. It's so good it gets the rare Stevie K Certified Legit AF designation.

Ate here for lunch yesterday. Jonathan was attentive and I ordered the Italian sub which was pretty…read moretasty. Fresh bread from NY and Boars head meats were key. I enjoyed this sandwich and will be back to try some others.

Great pizza spot in Garner. We walked in without a reservation and were seated after about a…read more15-minute wait -- they even had a comfortable couch for waiting, which was a nice touch. Service was quick and friendly from start to finish. We started with the meatballs and focaccia, and the bread was absolutely to die for. The salad with pears, cherry tomatoes, and vinaigrette was fresh and flavorful. For pizza, we had the buffalo cheese and it was excellent. We also took tiramisu and cannoli to go -- generous portions and all delicious. Good prices, cute atmosphere, and everything we tried was wonderful. Definitely coming back.

We tried a few times to order pizza from Amore Mio Pizza in Garner, North Carolina. The first…read moretime, the pizza oven wasn't working. The second time, the air conditioning wasn't working. But our third attempt was so worth it because the pizza was excellent! We had very friendly service, the restaurant was very clean and the food was excellent! So glad we kept trying!

Trusting my fellow Yelpers, we ordered a Large Brooklyn Special tonight via Uber Eats (which was…read moreslower.than.CHRISTMAS) yet far cheaper than the DoorDash option here on Yelp and on The DD platform. With that in mind, I am seriously missing the Gopher delivery service that doesn't take a cut of small business' sales and is far more efficient. Gig workers - Check out Gopher(dot)io- It's a NC company, too. I digress. The pizza itself was remarkably great. Next time, and there will be a next time, we'll opt for a medium with extra sauce and a longer (well done) bake time. Cost for this beauty delivered was $29.20, not including tip.

We were in town recently for a sporting event and decided to pick up a pizza after. I called ahead…read moreat like 5 p.m. and was told there was at least an hour wait. I mean, it was a Saturday - so - okay, but 5 p.m. is so early to be on that kind of wait already! We ordered a medium pie and the garlic knots. Even coming in after the hour wait, our order still wasn't ready and we waited for probably another 15-20 in the restaurant before it was done. At this point, I'm expecting this pizza must be better than anything else I've ever tasted. Unfortunately, not so much. The pizza was huge - I give it that. A medium was more like a large/extra large at other places. It's not the best NY style pizza I've ever had, but it wasn't the worst. The garlic knots were interesting -- VERY heavy on the butter/garlic topping stuff - so much so it cakes the bottom of the pan. I can see why that would appeal to a lot of folks, but for me and my kids, we found it to sort of just make the knots soggy and mushy instead of that nice balance of dough crisp bread and flavor. Overall, probably on the 3 1/2 star scale for me with the wait/service issues and mostly average flavor.

Horrible service and the skimpiest sandwich I've ever eaten. There were 4 slices of meat, 2 slices…read moreof cheese, and one slice of tomato cut into four pieces on my 12 inch sub. If it wasn't for the bread i wouldn't have known it was a sub. Don't waste your time or money on this place. I feel like we got robbed.

Pizza was overdone, and garlic knots were burnt. Disappointed with a restaurant that is usually…read morevery good.

Great food that is worth it even if you have to wait…read more Friendly staff and good service. We were greeted as soon as we walked in. It is nice to have a locally owned pizza/wing place that is genuine and serves a good product!

I will never order from here again.. I ordered this Wednesday night... This is supposed to be a…read morechef salad..

Best pizza we have had since returning from Rome. We had the seasonal special, white pizza with…read moreasparagus and prosciutto and it was fantastic. Don't miss the kale salad, the flavors were wonderful. Not a huge fan of the ricotta dumplings but they were ok, but the rhubarb crostini was delicious! Great cocktails too. Can't wait to go back!

Food was excellent and prompt. Service was fast …read more Great place for superb pizza, salad , and desserts.

The service was great and the food not only looked amazing but, also was bursting with flavors! The…read moreenvironment was welcoming and warm! Shoutout to Bellamy for her customer service and overall knowledge of the menu! She helped me make my decision fairly quick! The price is a little steep but, once you see the food you understand why! Thank you for the experience!

Every time we go we always request CAM he is always friendly and helpful. He always makes our…read moreevening out even better. I have never been disappointed with anything food or drink garibalidi is a great place to go with great food and cam is always the best. We travel from Sanford just to eat here. The best Italian food. Tonight we celebrated our 35th wedding anniversary and it was amazing thanks cam for making the night even more special

I have consistently enjoyed chicken wings, subs, salads, and pizza from this location. The food…read morealways comes out fast and hot, the portions are big, and everything is always right. I must try the pasta next! Everything I've had has always tasted great. The hosts are always friendly and there's always plenty of seating. There is something on the menu for everyone and this is definitely a an easy spot for a quick and satisfying lunch or dinner for me.

This Johnnys location is great , the pizza is awesome and we really like the subs as well…read more Very good ny style slice. Parking is no problem and the staff is always super helpful and nice.