Visiting the area, I'd never heard of this spot and seeing that it's a local area chain, I was a little skeptical since it's in a mall. When we arrived the place was busy but the line moved fast. We were told our food would take about 30 minutes but it came much faster than that. We ordered the 12 inch pepperoni and it was great. It was hot, fresh, and a good portions of toppings. I'm now glad to know it's an area chain as I'll visit another location next time I see one. read more

Pizza by the slice is gods gift to humanity. Pizza my heart is humanity returning the favor. They have a great selection of slices, give a slice with purchase of one of their shirts (go a size up - you'll need it), and the staff know how to move pizza! The line was probably 30 people deep but the team cleared it within 15 min! Ordered the classic pepperoni to judge them on. Fantastic ratio of pep to pizza. Their claim to fame is supposedly the Big Sur which is essentially a supreme but comes with whole cloves of roasted garlic. If you're a garlic lover like me, this is the way to go! I also tried the wings which I hear have to be ordered ahead of time. They're probably slow cooked in the pizza oven because the meat was fall off the bone, with a good crispiness on the exterior. Pizza my heart can have a piece of my heart. I'm going to need the room for this 3rd slice. read more

See all

8.8/10 Tried four slices here, Pepperoni Pizza, Mushroom Pizza, Pesto Pizza, and the D'Lex Chicken & Bacon Pizza overall, really satisfying and definitely worth the visit. Starting with the standout the classic Pepperoni Pizza. Easily a must-order and exactly what you'd want from a solid pizza spot. Generous amount of pepperoni, great flavor, and executed perfectly. You really can't go wrong with this one. Coming in second (and also a must-get) was the D'Lex Chicken & Bacon Pizza. It came loaded with grilled chicken breast, bacon, mushrooms, parmesan cheese, green onions, and a creamy white garlic sauce. I'll admit I've always been skeptical about chicken with white sauce on pizza, but this completely changed my mind. Absolutely incredible and honestly one of the pizzas that carried the whole experience for me. The Pesto Pizza had a unique flavor profile with basil almond pesto, garlic almonds, and parmesan cheese. I was a little on the fence with this one, definitely more of an acquired taste, but I'm glad I tried it. Not bad at all, just depends on what flavors you enjoy. Lastly, the Mushroom Pizza was unfortunately my least favorite. It wasn't bad, but compared to everything else it felt underwhelming. The tomato sauce and mushrooms alone made it feel a little too simple, and I think it could've used more flavor and a bit more punch overall. Service was great despite a long line, everything moved quickly and efficiently. The restaurant itself had a nice pizza joint vibe, was clean, and had plenty of seating. Overall, really enjoyed the experience and would definitely come back. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pepperoni Pizza/ Mushroom Pizza / Pesto Pizza / D'Lex Chicken and Bacon Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

We wanted to love this pizza SO much. It was the only spot open in town as late as we needed it and it looked like it had a slamming menu. Freestyle machines are also always a good sign. I ordered the Watsonville and my husband got the Big Sur. Two award winning pizzas. For the price point ($36 for a small pizza!), we figured we were in for a mind-blowing experience... we were mind-blown in the opposite way. Just HOW could the pizza be so mediocre? The cheese, the sauce, the meats -- flavorless. We were truly in denial, thinking at some point it would click. Sadly, we ate a few slices each and threw the rest out. We just knew neither of us would reach for any leftovers. It was that bad. read more

We ordered from here because of their gluten free crust and we went for the pepperoni and Maui wowie. The pizza wasn't bad, but it also wasn't great. The crust was crispy on the edges but it didn't have much color in the middle. It may just be our preference, but I prefer for the toppings like ham and pineapple to be a bit charred. I appreciated the gluten free options but overall I just wasn't really impressed with the pizza as a whole. I would not order from here again if I'm in the area. read more

Pizza My Heart is a fun place to grab a slice in Monterey. They have a great selection of pizzas available by the slice, friendly and welcoming staff, and a cool atmosphere. It's the perfect spot to enjoy some delicious pizza while watching a game and hanging out with friends or family. Forgot to take some pictures, but Highly recommend! read more

pizza is always good. Love the t-shirt and a slice deal for $8!! they were out of sooo many sizes that I couldn't do it:( but, at least my grandude got one! 3 stars for the extra long wait! How long does it take to box a slice.. grab a cup , ring up?? ridiculously slow execution!! drove me nuts watching how slow the process was. And I really could have gone my whole life without seeing your pizza makers make the pizza:( grossed me out actually . But that's how far back line was and stood there for 10 minutes and only moved once!! Ugh.. One guy had 1 glove on 1 glove off. Made no sense. one guy had zero gloves. And one guy had gloves but what's the point if he's twirling the dough and it all over his hairy arms. I had to tell myself over and over... everything gets killed when it gets cooked in the hot oven... but I wonder how many hairs have fallen into the dough??!!! c'mon.. they have got to make elbow length gloves by now for these jobs! Some things are better left unseen if you don't follow healthy food practices. And, at no time did I see anyone wash their hands in between or change gloves:( on the upswing.. I did learn they make the circle of sauces with a baster. Here's a thought: why not do what In & Out does when it gets busy and send someone to the line with a handheld machine that swipes cards & takes orders....?!!! made me sick waiting over 25 minutes to get a slice of pizza when I know Whole Foods was in same parking lot:( but, I promised my grandude the shirt. Or how about a second register just for people who want a slice or salad. You lost at least 10 people when they came in and saw the line!! Not that that's going to break you... but.. there has got to be a better way. There's my 2cents. you get to make your own decision if you see the line backed up to the back room. ;) read more

See all

The kind of chain that other pizza chains should aspire to be. Eaten here many times over the last decade. Nothing is ever amazing. but everything is FAAAR from terrible. Even the pre packaged salad options are fresh and balanced. The pizza chain to beat. read more

Cute little spot at Monterey mall. Had healthier options. I'm on the dash diet this year. For health issues. But still gonna find you good eats. Good flavors, good service. read more

Pizza My Heart - Vegetarian gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

See all

Ordered a vegan pizza and cinnamon sugar dessert to-go. It was pretty good, though the vegan cheese wasn't my favorite. I do appreciate that they had the option! Didn't feel mind-blowing good but for pizza I was satisfied! Their non vegan options looked really tasty, but I can't speak on those! read more

Pizza My Heart DELIVERS: We placed an order online while staying at the Pacific Gardens Inn. Since the order was done online I don't have input on the ambiance of the restaurnat, but as far as online service is concern the order we placed was accurate. The food was delicious, the chicken wings tasted AMAZING! Large portions, fresh ingredients, tasty food made our "pizza night" (during our vacay) a fun stay indoor night. read more

See all

Man, I love Pizza My Heart, but I have to say this location is something else--and not in a good way. The issues range from the staff's service when taking orders and charging customers, all the way to the quality of the food.I ordered five slices. Four were readily available, but I had to wait on one. The cashier clearly asked if the order was 'for here' or 'to go.' I said 'for here,' so they put the four slices in the oven and told me I would have to wait about 15 minutes for the Maui slice.After sitting for a while, I walked up and stood by the counter until I was finally called. When I got there, I saw they had stacked all my other slices inside a 'to-go' box and just put the Maui slice on top. I kindly reminded them that the order was for here. The woman serving clearly did not like it when the cashier passed along the message; she gave a rude look and just walked away. The cashier then started laying out trays, but he seemingly gave up halfway through and went back to his post. The woman eventually finished the job, handed the slices to the cashier, and he handed them to me. I said 'thank you' but didn't even get acknowledged. I figured whatever, they just weren't in a good mood. However, when we sat down to eat, four of the five slices were practically cold. I'm not surprised, though, because these slices are so thin that they can't hold any heat. Compared to all the other Pizza My Heart locations, these slices are paper-thin. If you look at my Maui slice, it's almost see-through. This location seriously needs to check out the Santa Cruz and Downtown San Jose branches to see what real pizza and proper customer service look like. read more

Pizza My Heart - Maui Wowie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

Each time we head to Monterey for vacation, this is our first stop! Always get a cool shirt and a slice!! Staff is always very friendly. There is always a spot to eat, inside or out. Line moves quickly. Fancy soda machine too! Diet vanilla Dr. Pepper? Yes please! Located right off the freeway in an outdoor mall with tons of shops! read more

Pizza My Heart - Veggie slice and pepperoni slice! - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

We resided in the Santa Cruz area for over two decades and never managed to visit PMH. A couple of days ago, after the holiday boat parade, we decided to head down to Damertra. We were immediately drawn to PMH by the buzz and the long queue for their freshly sliced pizzas. It turned out to be a wise decision. My wife opted for the Chicken and Bacon pizza, while I chose the pepperoni and sausage. To be honest, there are many pizzas out there, but PMH stands out because of its exceptional flavor. The crust is great, and the team was incredibly friendly and helpful, even though the queue was quite long. Overall, I highly recommend PMH. Thank you for providing such a delicious and satisfying pizza experience. (No pics as we just demolished the slices before I had a chance to even think about it !) read more

Something about pizza my heart... always a go-to for me when shopping at Del Monte Mall. 1 slice is plenty but you can absolutely do 2 if you're hungry hehehe Also, the salads here are pretty yummy. If you're coming here with someone else considering splitting a salad w/ your individual pizza slice. Or another option to just get a salad too :) read more

I'm not sure why when I select contactless delivery they smack on my door. 6-3-26 they still did it. It's not that hard to leave it at the door. read more

First time at this pizza spot as I was visiting and it was pretty good. $7 for a single slice is a bit steep but not surprising for the location. The service was good, a bit slow because they were busy but the staff attended to every guest properly. Location is cool as it's within a mall so perfect for a quick bite before or after shopping. read more

Lovely to see a Pizza My Heart in Monterey. They were pretty busy when we were there, service took a while but the staff gave us free drinks for the wait. Pizza here is always fantastic! read more

The pizza is pretty good here. I like to keep it simple but they have rather interesting combinations. The service is good and it's a cozy vibe with an old-timey feel to it. It's right by the parking lot so it's great for when you want to pick up and go. read more

I was excited to visit Pizza My Heart since we don't have one where I live. My family made a two-hour drive on Friday, March 27th. I was initially quoted a 30-minute wait. After 35 minutes, I was told it would be "a few more minutes," and the same response was given again at the 50-minute mark. When I spoke with the manager, it became clear there had been a mistake--my order had been closed out and likely given to another customer. While the situation was frustrating, the manager handled it exceptionally well. She refunded my order, quickly prioritized a replacement pizza, and even offered a salad while I waited. Most importantly, she was attentive, apologetic, and made me feel heard. Mistakes can happen, but great customer service makes all the difference. I truly appreciated how the situation was resolved, and it turned my experience around completely. I'll definitely be back. read more

My niece told me about this place and I couldn't believe it; a slice of pizza and a t-shirt for $9!? It's true. They have a wide variety of slices in the $6 range. Hubby had the Manfresa which is basically a Margherita. And yes, we got a t-shirt too. Wow, just wow! read more

Pretty decent pizza place. The pizza is pretty good, but what I liked about it was it wasn't very greasy. We got take out so can't say much about the restaurant, but it looked like a fun place. The cheese bread was better than expected and the pepperoni pizza was exactly as expected. Obviously popular because when I went to pick up it was pretty busy. The staff seemed a little overwhelmed when I came in but it was around 6pm on a Friday though. I'd definitely come back. read more

See all

Really good pizza if you want a quick bite while shopping and good vibes in the Del Monte shopping center. Service was good. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

I had two slices of the pepperoni and sausage pizza. With a large drink it came to over $18 . The pizza was very good and the ambience was a little noisy , mostly young adults . All in all I thought it was a little spendy but I enjoyed myself . read more

So fresh and tasty. They need to keep their restrooms clean Service is professional Glad that they cut their veg pizza with a dedicated green handle knife Always a pleasure to visit this pizza place read more

The pizza was delicious! Loved how they put a good amount of toppings! Staff was friendly...but also a big plus when they don't miss asking YOU, if you need parmesan and peppers. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

I really liked this place, and it's hard to beat the slice of pizza and t-shirt deal. If you're not familiar with the deal, you get a t-shirt and any slice of pizza for either $8 or $9, depending on which t-shirt you choose. If you were to just get a slice, it would be $6 (I think it's for any topping), so you're basically getting a t-shirt for a few bucks more. I was skeptical that the pizza slice wouldn't taste good, or wouldn't be big enough to fill me up, but I was pleasantly surprised that not only was the pizza good, it was large, so one slice was enough for me. Anyway, it was pretty packed the day we went, so plan to wait in line, but we would definitely go back here again. read more

Very unprofessional. We ordered two pizzas online for a quick dinner and waited 40 minutes. I arrived when asked, and they told me they had skipped one of our pizzas and that it would take another 10 mins (it took 20 mins) to remake. Once I got it, the other pizza was cold when I got back home. This is no way to run a business. How unfortunate, considering the food was okay, the place was clean, and they did refund the skipped pizza (unfortunately you can't buy time). read more

I love this pizza shop, but I'm really sad my favorite pizza ever, the Figgy Piggy is no longer on the menu! I really hope it comes back!

I be love going in and grabbing a slice!! Great selection of slices. Cooked perfectly! And always service with a smile . Thanks. I will be back. read more

Solid option for ready-to-go pizza! Ambiance & Service: The interior is nice with plenty of seating. You can purchase pizza by the slice or have one custom-made. Service is quick for slices, but custom orders take a lot of time (approx. 30 mins). Food: - Mt. Diablo: Super spicy and delicious! The sweetness of the tomato sauce perfectly complements the hot peppers. I added garlic and highly recommend it! TL;DR - Custom orders can take a long time, but they're worth it! The Mt. Diablo is delicious--add the fresh garlic! read more

Pizza My Heart - Mt. Diablo - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

Got the Figgy Piggy but the restaurant ran out of figs (which they have informed), but also ran out of sage which we learned later after they've brought us the pizza. Pizza was still ok but incomplete without the two ingredients. Not sure if I want to come back to this location. The staff were friendly though. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

See all

Absolutely delicious place, been eating here for over a decade, pizza has been consistent and the homemade free ranch is amazing.

A great pizza spot. Options of signature pizzas and also build your own. Placed an online order for a half and half 14 inch: Big Sur and Cowell's Combo. Inside is nice and cozy with a lot of seating. Chilis, peppers, napkins, utensils all on one side for your own grabbing. The pizza itself was good. Nothing crazy but hits the spot when you are craving pizza. I personally liked the Cowell's combo more than the Big Sur. The garlic wasn't for me. read more

It's been over 6 years since we've been in town and the one place that's an ABSOLUTE go-to is Pizza My Heart. Unfortunately we got in late, decided to stay in and thought we would just get delivery. This was such a BAD IDEA! First off, for single slices, they only offer (2) slices, the pepperoni and one other. If you go inside, they have multiple to choose from. Mind you, we ordered directly off of their site also. Delivery fee wasn't bad, only around $3 dollars which isn't breaking the bank. But... for two slices, a salad and two bottles of Diet Coke came out to over $30!? What! Why!? Would've ordered a large pizza, but that alone was over $30. I'm glad we didn't because when we got the two slices, they were cold, the pepperonis were super spicy and greasy, it gave both of us borderline heartburn. The crust was fantastic to me, i love a nice crispy crust, but I couldn't fully enjoy the pizza when it was cold. My wife had a special request for her salad, no artichokes and extra feta, she loves feta. Our instructions were not met. I asked for plates and napkins, since we are staying at a hotel. We did not receive either. Shoot we didn't even receive a fork to go with the salad or the dressing; not cool y'all. I get if these salads are pre made; then ok. It did say "some special requests couldn't be fulfilled", we understand. But when you forget the dressing and the fork. We got problems. Love the inside and the ambiance of this place, would definitely come back to this location when we come back down in august. But NEVER doing delivery again. Way too expensive and such a let down. We love Pizza MY Heart and it's such a bummer to have to leave a review like this. But as hard as it is, we gotta keep it real with everyone on here. Hopefully in a few months we can come back and give this place the 5 stars we know it deserves. read more

Pizza My Heart - Don't mind the cucumber slice. The pepperoni slice is what were here for. - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

Oh my heart! I didn't feel like having tacos on this Tuesday but enjoyed a slice of Big Sur a slice of combo and a Greek salad. The service was quick with a smile They weren't too busy for a week day which was a welcome I was able to get a free slice and soda with my punch card! A definite win, win for not cooking tonight read more

Pizza My Heart - Big Sure and combo (forgot to take a photo before I ate them ) and a cold beer. They were good! - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California

Great food, awesome service but why are there TVs that are never on? Great food, awesome service but why are there TVs that are never on? read more

My husband and I decided to pick up a pizza and bring back to our room/balcony to eat. My husband ordered a build your own pizza with his favorite toppings and I ordered The Hook. All ingredients were fresh and tasty. We enjoyed our pizzas and would return to try other menu items. read more

We've gotten pizza here 3 different times now and really like the crust. It always has a nice crowd of diners either at tables or waiting in line to buy a slice. Today was PI day and we ended up getting a free second pizza. Also, Nick the manager is really helpful. read more

Ordered our pizza at 3:30 pm and staff told us 15-20 minutes. At 4 pm, we follow up and asked if our pizza is done yet and we're told to wait another 15 minutes. At 4:30, we're told to wait another five minutes. We were waiting over an hour for a small pizza. Additionally, the table behind us who ordered after us got their pizzas but their order was wrong and had to wait longer. The pizza itself was pretty good and we enjoyed it, however the service could definitely be worked on. read more

Pizza My Heart - Big Sur 12 Inch - Pizza Near Me - Monterey, California