Came in for dinner with my nephew and had a great experience. We ordered a few slices--combination, sausage, and pepperoni & sausage--and everything was fresh and flavorful. We've also ordered their large pizzas to go in the past, and those have been just as satisfying. We used one of their stamp cards for a free drink, and the guy at the counter kindly let me choose between a fountain drink or a bottled one (I went with the bottle--just tastes better!). My nephew has a special connection to this place--his kindergarten class once came here to make their own pizzas, and he still talks about it. It's really great to see that kind of community involvement. He absolutely loves the pizza here, and it's easy to see why. We also found ourselves curious about the surfboard--would love to know the story behind it! read more

See all

Quick service and decent pizza. Parking is hard to find and requires payment. This place was clean and basically empty when I got here. They have fresh salads and a soda machine. They're able to heat up the slices for you. I'd rather eat this pizza than Costco's pizza and consider this pizza to be a good fast food pizza alternative that is better than Round Table Pizza. read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I really love your pizza but truly dislike the staff and how rude and rushed I feel on the phone. Also would like the restaurant to fulfill the delivery instructions provided. Tonight especially (like every time before) they forgot my ranch with delivery. When I spoke to the employee I told him twice that each time I order for delivery they forget the ranch and to please don't forget that and the plates/pepper and cheese. He told me not to worry and they would certainly would be with my delivery. When the delivery arrived it was just the pizza again. I'm not sure where the loss in communication is but I wish this location could fix this. read more

This place is garbage. I ordered online at 7:58 pm and they close at 9:00 pm. I got a call that they don't have any pepperoni slices. So after choosing another slice my pizza gets delivered and the slices have clearly been sitting around since I called, if not before. Also, parmesan and peppers MEAN PARMESAN AND PEPPERS dopes. read more

Super friendly staff and the chicken and bacon pizza was great. I appreciate them having single slice options.

This is California Pizza. The staff is always so nice each time I go here, and they never fail to surprise me. They help me answer and decide what pizza to order and make sure to feel we are comfortable. As for the pizza itself, it is the perfect amount of crispy and cheesy. Not too over powering of any flavor and I always go with the original flavors (cheese and pepperoni). The ambiance of Pizza My Heart feels very nostalgic and at home. I like the accents of surfboards and pictures because it feels very california and at home. Overall the experience of Pizza My Heart never misses and I highly recommend! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pesto and Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Love the pizza here it Taste batter here not sure why. They were quick to make it and the person at the front was friendly ...it was clean and medium busy read more

Solid East Coast-style pizza, no complaints. It's always good to have a spot in the neighborhood where you can get pizza by the slice! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I only come for the salads for TGTG which are a great deal. Every time I come in, the service is quick. Not the most friendliest but that's ok. A lot of seating. One day I will try the slices. Parking lot in back or street parking. read more

Here's a toned-down 85-word version: Rosie put together a fresh batch of pesto ranch today, and the whole kitchen smelled amazing. The basil brought a bright, herby freshness, while the ranch added just the right creamy balance. She moved around with an easy confidence, mixing and tasting until it was just right. When she set it out, it wasn't just a dip--it was one of those little touches that makes everything better. Simple, flavorful, and made with care, Rosie's pesto ranch was the highlight of the table. read more

We drove down from the North Bay just to go to this place, it was recommended highly in Social Media ( Instagram and TikTok). Nearly $100.00 for 3 pies.. all of which were burned, after we requested lightly cooked. We could have just gone to Dominies if wanted to have such a treat. We his wasn't acceptable, neither was the attitude... read more

See all

They only had cheese, ham and pineapple and veggies available. Asked how long for any other pizza (pepperoni, pesto, combo), not for 20 minutes. That's not acceptable. Left and went out of my way to the Burlingame location. They always seem to have a selection. read more

We decided to venture out of our usual pizza spots & give this place a try. We got our food delivered in less than 30min & were exited to dig in. The cheese bread not only looks delicious but tasted just as good as it looks. The pizza looked just as good but unfortunately didn't taste as great. The issue was the dough, it was thought if that makes any sense. Perhaps the dough was over worked? If it wasn't for that, this pizza would've been great as I really did enjoy the flavor of the sauce. I can't say that I'll be back but at least I gave it a try. read more

Pizza My Heart - Cheese Bread & Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Burnt bottom. I can't recall a time I've had to return a pizza because it was too burnt. The employees quickly replaced my pizza after I told them. I was already home, took a bite and had to drive back to pick up a new pizza. The fact they served it to me an entirely burnt is frustrating. read more

Pizza My Heart - The nerve to serve me this - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

Oh we were so hungry and didn't have anything to cook - no one wanted to go to the store - decided to order pizza - 2 large - one with ham and pineapple and one with half pepperoni, half with pepperoni sausage olives and mushrooms - they came earlier than predicted thank goodness and we mowed them down before I could get a picture - we only have a few pieces left - I just ate one for breakfast - cold of course - happy with the flavor, the crust thickness (medium), and flavors and the amount of pineapple - more than other places - a lot more - I was so happy with that! So happy we didn't have to make my clean kitchen dirty and had an easy yummy dinner. The photo is from this morning - yummy cold pizza for breakfast! Look at the amount of pineapple on there!! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I wanted some pizza for my Super Bowl party and turned to Pizza My Heart. It was a good choice. It was easy to order them in advance on-line. The only downside here is that I wanted to change the order after I placed it. I called the store and they were nice enough to cancel it (I would had them change the order but it was a little complex). When I came to pick up the pizzas they took about 5 more minutes to cook then scheduled (no big deal), but most importantly the order was correct. And the guy managing the cash register was very nice. Manresa: 4/5. One of the best pizzas they make here, with fresh basil, garlic, roma tomatoes, and ricotta cheese. Great combination of flavors. Cowell's Combo: 3/5. Just an average combo pizza. Not sure I would order it again. read more

On a recent visit, I discovered that while making my large Pizza, the tomato sauce is squeezed as a bead around the pizza about a 1/4-3/8 wide [like writing on a cake]. Traditionally or typically, it is poured onto the pizza and spread entirely with the ladle. I know this bc, I worked at a pizza restaurant. I asked if that is how they always have done it, and the girl replied [qestionaby] with a "yeah?" Now, if it was a confident yes, then I would figure they found a hack...but I think the pizza lacked the tomato flavor and taste. So, it's 2oz instead of 6-7oz, but a lot of flavor missing, to me? so for that, I can only give it two stars, good luck guys! read more

One of the premiere pizza places I can think of in its vicinity. Mostly satisfied upon purchasing from this location. Fresh ingredients, good dough and sauce and they put forth the effort for a good customer service experience through the quality in food preparation. They do a great job of getting you to come back. read more

yo this pizza slaps bro. they give free ranch n it tastes so good. customer service hella chill

Great tasty pizza with quality ingredients. I generally place the order online but you can also call to order. The pizza will be ready by the time it's promised online. Some favorites are the chicken deluxe and Maui wowie. Staff is friendly and welcoming! read more

Love their gluten free pizza! Reliably good every time we have ordered from the San Mateo location. Absolutely delicious.

Stopped by Pizza My Heart for a second dinner with the guys recently after a delicious meal at Dash Japanese a few blocks over. Unfortunately, there wasn't a huge selection of slices at 7:45PM on a Monday but the food is always consistent. I usually go with combo or their pepperoni and sausage but all that was left was pepperoni, which was great. The slices were heated up in the oven a few minutes before being placed in a single slice box. They have some indoor tables open for seating but we opted for the tables just outside. Oh yeah, the ranch dressing here is one of the best and goes well with pizza! Friendly and quick service make Pizza My Heart a go-to place for a late night snack or even as a main meal. read more

See all

I'm glad to try Pizza my Heart at this location. The young man behind the counter was friendly and pleasant to chat with... explaining about the variety and sizes of their pizzas. I bought a few slices to go and it was properly pack. I had the 40 garlic and meat slice of pizzas. I definitely will come back. Go try it out, you'll find something to enjoy. read more

I just placed an order for Pizza My Heart through DoorDash. Disappointing is a good way to describe my order. As you can see from the pictures, my pizza was extremely over cooked. The crust is burnt so bad it's black on the edges. I WAS excited because they had more vegan topping options. It's hard to find good vegan pizza with more topping options especially vegan meat options. The only reason it's transferred onto a baking sheet is because the pizza arrived lukewarm but that's a product of slow deliveries from DoorDash. The logic behind my rating is how burnt the crust was. The crust is a key part of what makes a pizza great. When it's this burnt it tarnishes the flavor of the toppings and even their flavors couldn't over power the taste of burnt crust. Is this a normal occurrence for Pizza My Heart? Not really sure if I want to try them out again. read more

Pizza My Heart - a pizza with onions and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Tonight they did real good! Lots of toppings on the pizza and the crust was nice and crispy. I had the pizza my heart in San Ramon a they were so stingy with toppings we couldn't even tell which pizza was what they all looked the same. read more

Pizza My Heart - Vegan CYO, beyond sausage, olives, mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

Always solid, reliable thin crust pie! My only quibble is that my last delivery they forgot the side of roasted garlic ... I had been thinking of that roasted garlic ALL DAY ....mmmmm! read more

Despite living in San Mateo and having tried Pizza My Heart at other locations, I've never once actually ordered from this location before. With the CORVID-19 outbreak going on, and doing our best to support local businesses, we decided to order some pizza from this Pizza My Heart location through UberEats. Between ordering and it arriving at our door, the entire process was about 35-40mins, and it arrived still fairly warm and quite delicious. We went with two 12' Create-your-own custom pizzas, with two toppings each, which came out to $15/pizza. There's a current BOGO free promo going on, so our cost was just $15 for two pizzas! Which allowed us to give back the difference as a tip to help the driver out. For our pizzas, we went with Pineapple and Ham on one, and Pepperoni and Sausage on the other for the meat lovers in the household. Both pizzas were made perfectly, not burnt, generously loaded with toppings, and really good. Will definitely be ordering from this location at least a few more times before this shelter-in-place is over, as well as into the foreseeable future! read more

Pizza My Heart - Pineapple and ham (Canadian Bacon) - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

See all

11/27/24 Love this restaurant, however this is the third time that they have no slices and they want me to wait 15+ minutes. Trying to buy 4 slices and they don't have Hawaiian, sausage pep, nor cheese. Bad management and it's only 7:15 pm. Now I gotta go to Dominos across the street. read more

Our family loves their pizza and salads The chicken bacon, pepperoni and veggie are our favorites. They have a great Caesar and Greek salad. I also like that you can order a slice or a whole pizza. My kids are grown now but it has always been kid friendly. The employees are friendly and helpful. read more

We LOVE pizza my heart. But this location is one of our favorites! Staff are always nice and friendly. The place is always clean. It is our first time to visit during COVID. They were busy with pick ups. We were the only family dining inside. There were only three tables open for dining in the entire place. You can use your stamp card to get free pizza/salad/drink. Parking can be challenging even during COVID. Street parking is available. read more

See all

I like that You don't have to order a whole pizza and you can order different flavors for affordable price and the pizzas are delicious!

I'm here on 12/15/23 around 5 pm and I had a bad customer service experience at the san mateo pizzamyheart. The food looked great, I was ready to enjoy a great slice, listen to some music and chill for a minute. I wanted to order a few slices. However, the woman working the counter said "I'll be right with you" and then ignored me for several minutes. At this point I am so hungry... there were no customers. Just me, 4 pizza makers and this lady that was focused on rearranging the pizza boxes. So I left. I hope that the owners see this. I am in no mood for a confrontation or to scold someone for bad customer service. I will simply let my dollars do the talking and let people know. Owner of pizzamyheart, you need to talk to this rude person. read more

Great customer service, decent value to the size of the pizzas and the place was quite busy when we recently visited. We enjoyed the mushroom pizza although I have to say that it couldn't beat the one at Rise Pizzeria nearby. read more

One of my all time favorite chairs. NYC pizza surfer dude style with large slices and combos like Big Sur with portobello mushroom, roasted garlic, sausage and pepperoni ... always have it crispy as the crust is great! Free birthday slice and get the frequent eater card to get a free something every 3 slices like drink, salad, and pizza slice! Did I say their chicken walnut salad is also great for $6. Beats fast food hands down! read more

Gluten Free review: Probably the best I've had. Crust stays chewy, not like a cracker. Toppings are fresh and generous. Regular pizza is superb as well. Very large foldable slices. Sauce is more on the spicy side. Can't speak for the atmosphere, as we had delivery. Order with confidence, you'll love it. **** edited after several hours have passed: I think I may have a dietary reaction to this gluten free pizza... proceed with caution. Due to having consumed other foods as well, I cannot be 100% sure the pizza is to blame. read more

See all

Stopped by on a weekday night and we were the only party eating outdoors. Made for a quiet and nice experience! Since we did take out, we were able to bring our own drinks! We called ahead, and the pizza took about 15 minutes from order to being ready. We got the Big Sur (40 cloves of roasted garlic, organic tomato sauce, pepperoni sausage, portabello mushroom, and green onions). According to Pizza My Heart, this pizza won first place in the 2007 west coast pizza championships! How do I sign up to be a judge for that!? Toppings were very plentiful. I really appreciated the large (3"+ wide x .5") pieces of meaty portabello mushroom. The sausage was nice and meaty, with a light fennel flavor. However, even as a garlic lover, I found the whole roasted garlic cloves overwhelmed the flavor of the other toppings-- they were roasted well and just soft enough, though. Overall, the pizza crust was a bit too soft for my liking and not quite chewy enough. I had to use both hands to support my pizza slice while I ate it. A tiny bit short of a 3.5/5 for me, but I wouldn't be opposed to coming back. read more

Pizza it's what brings a family together just like a big bowl of Spaghetti and meatballs! Yum! read more

Pizza My Heart - Surfs up! - Pizza Near Me - San Mateo, California

I ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza to go. The toppings were fine but the crust was dry and hard like a cardboard. I can't recall the last time I had such a bad pizza. read more

While in the Bay Area this week, we needed some sustenance. Our nephew recommended Pizza My Heart and we went to check it out. Upon entering, we found a surf-themed space, complete with polished vintage surfboards, and framed photos of surfers "back in the day" on the walls. They have a large collection of pre-made pizzas in different flavor combos, from which you pick a slice. They then warm it up for you, and bring it to your table. It's an okay concept, though freshly baked pizza out of the oven is superior for taste and eating enjoyment. Still, four of us got an energy boost from our respective slices, plus a beverage apiece, for a reasonable price. At 3:00 in the afternoon on a Thursday, we pretty much had the place to ourselves. We got to watch a stack of to-go boxes being built for the evening rush ahead. It passed for entertainment. ;-) Housed in an older building in downtown San Mateo, Pizza My Heart seems to enjoy a loyal following. It was a nice change from some of the cookie cutter pizza chains. read more

See all

Excellent pizza and fabulous service! I love the crust here! There is a young man who works here on who is so polite and genuinely helpful. Customer service is top notch. I highly recommend having their pizza! read more