This place deserves NO stars. Poor service and bad customer service. They had us seated and place water on the table. But never return to take our orders. I don't like playing the races card. But it was very plain to see. We were looked over. One guy acted upset when we first sat down. After 20 minutes we just decided to get up and leave. Rude. It's funny how the other race was being attentive to and Noone ever looked our way. It's sad how we are being treated for the color of Our skin. This really upset me. Glad we didn't spend one cent up in this place read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Solid food and service in a shotgun pub with a traditional design. The messy burger is a popular choice, and would indeed have been messy--or perhaps impossible--to eat if I hadn't taken a knife and fork to it. Great service from the solitary server handling the whole place. read more

See all

Seems like a tradition that we come here after seeing a play. This place is close to the Imperial and Richard Rogers Theatre. We first came with our friends Debbie R and her family. We had the fish and chips and it is definitely one of the best fish and chips we had. It's nicely lightly battered fish with a nice crunch. Short review as this is what we order when we come here. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Fish and chips - New American Near Me - New York, New York

A great Irish pub close to the theater where our show was. Perfect. Toni and I stopped in to fuel up before the show. I got an Irish mule and grilled shrimp appetizer. Toni got a gin fizz and bruschetta. Both of the appetizers were delicious. The shrimp were cooked perfectly and served with a corn relish that balanced the shrimp. The bruschetta were loaded with toppings. Toni used a fork and knife. I am an animal and unhinged my jaw to get my bites. The topping were fresh tasting and the bread toasted perfectly. The drinks were great. I never would have thought to make a mule with whiskey but dude- delicious. I don't like gin- Toni enjoyed her fizz. The service was amazing, waters kept filled, check back timely but not while my mouth was full. Check this place out. Vaccine required, cards checked. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Grilled shrimp - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Walking around Time Square, my co worker and i were looking to get buzzed (just a little) and decided to try this place. The coconut shrimp was amazing! I really liked it and it paired up really well with my drink Mai Tai. The Nacho Fries were fantastic too! Every fry was crispy and was fried to perfection. The service was good too and I specifically liked the accent of our server. Hahaha 4/5 just because I'm saving my 5s to places that I will definitely come back again. If you are in the area, it is worth it to stop by at this place. I highly recommend. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Nacho Fries and Coconut Shrimp Mai Tai Watermelon Vodka - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Surprised how delicious the food at this restaurant was. We dined upstairs and the light Cajun salmon entree was cooked to perfection atop the mango salad. We also enjoyed the Grafton Street salad with Brie, cranberry, & walnuts with chicken breast. After the Broadway show the downstairs pub was busy & energized...but we appreciated the nice upstairs part of the restaurant where we could talk and enjoy our meal. The food is delicious-wasn't expecting this when we walked in. Friendly hostess/quick service. (We did come around 10:30p-after show.) Will be my new go to after a show! read more

This is an absolute must for Broadway lovers! Located right on the same street as a few theaters, this hidden gem features four floors (including a really lovely rooftop bar), a cool atmosphere, and delicious traditional and not-so-traditional meals that nod to the "Celtic" in Celtic Pub. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Cilantro & Lemon Salad (f. Left), Sausage and poptatos (back), and Caesar Salad with shrimp (f. Right) - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We were in NYC for a 2pm play. We figured we would grab lunch before the show. Thinking that we couldn't go wrong with an Irish Pub for lunch, in we went out of the cold. I asked for a table for 7 and was told that we would have to sit at 2 separate tables. I said that would be fine and we were seated right away. The overall service was quick and cordial. The food was exactly what I expected. Good but not over the top great. It was definitely a good overall experience with solid food and service. It's definitely a good choice when in the Theater district with limited time before a show. By the way, the Phantom was exceptional! read more

Great pub food a short walk from the theatre district. Burger was delicious and juicy, fries really fresh. I also had a couple of mixed drinks. read more

Located on 8th avenue, right around the corner from the Majestic, this easy access pub has multi floor seating and a rooftop bar (it was cold.... We didn't venture up). Quick service, tasty food and reasonable pricing make this a solid choice for theater dining. read more

See all

Food and service was very good. Ambiance was fine. Conveniently located near Times Square and Broadway theatre district!

Average casual midtown pub. My friends and I stopped in for happy hour on a Monday evening however they do not have happy hour specials. Prices are typical midtown drink prices. Wine glasses were $10/each and cocktails were $13-$15. We sat indoors at a corner table and felt safe and distanced from others. Luckily, they didn't make us order food to go with our drinks. The waitress was attentive and kept our glasses filled. Definitely pricey for what they offer; I felt like this was a place all the tourists go. I wouldn't go running back. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - New American Near Me - New York, New York

This is a really solid pub choice in the Times Square area. We came after seeing a show and there was plenty of seating. Service was quick and friendly. The drink selection was excellent, sex on the Hudson with blue curaçao tasted particularly great after seeing The Shark Is Broken. The fish and chips were tasty and loved hat malt vinegar was available for use on the chips. All in all, would recommend if you're in Times Square area for a great spot to relax and eat in. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Sex On The Hudson - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I tend to avoid touristy places, and avoided this place for years. I now see it was a mistake. Large, busy, Irish pub near the theater district with good solid food and drink. Really enjoyed the Celtic Salad, flatbread pizza and fish and chips. Beers are good, but I wish they had a larger draft selection. They showed the GGD-Canelo fight without a cover and even turned the music off for the duration, which was great. I'd love to come back. Prices are not bad at all for an NYC tourist area pub. read more

place is a dump. Bartenders weren't friendly. They were doing shots behind the bar (sneaking them) and eating while serving the patrons. place is gross and highly over priced even for NYC . Yuck read more

We were only in the city for 2 hours. Got dropped off in Times Square and were looking for a place to eat. Saw Irish pub. Kinda weird but I guess because of Di Blasio you can't enter a restaurant without a vaccine card. So we walked up three flights to go to the rooftop and it was beautiful open air and cool weather. Service was good and food was better. We had bangers and mashed and Sheppards pie Food was great !!!! read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Bangers and mash Shepherds pie - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Decent food and drinks at this charming little watering hole. I was happy to find that they carried my favorite whiskey (Jameson Caskmates Stout Edition). I had quite a few of those while catching up with an old friend. I appreciated that the bartender was mindful not to check in too much...just enough to make sure we were sufficiently libated and fed. Later on in the evening I ordered a corned beef sandwich with fries. The sandwich was okay, but not the best I've had. I expected something akin to size of those legendary New York deli sandwiches, but despite it's unimpressive size it was enough to keep all that whiskey company, and that's what was important. read more

We got the Sex on the Hudson and an Ameretto Sour, both great drinks. The desserts however, stole the show. Creamy Salted Caramel Cake and Bread and Butter Pudding with a Coconut Drizzle, both served with a Raspberry Coulis. Flavors were bright and the combination of creamy and tart kept eat bite light enough for us to keep wanting more read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great bar to come to before a Broadway show! This multi level Irish bar is a great spot for groups of any size Their menu has a little bit of everything so if you come with a larger group, there's something for everyone I definitely recommend it read more

Amazing food, drinks, and the BEST bread pudding chocolate chip cheesecake of my life. The food is awesome! read more

See all

Came in for a quick bite and some drinks before a matinee. Had some vodka drinks and a "small medley" from the menu. Food was good, drinks were great. Kathy was an amazing bartender! Friendly service, good conversation, and great drinks! Will be back for sure! read more

Stopped in after living nearby for a couple years. Wasn't great. The first beer I ordered had that classic "bacteria" tap taste of butter. Gross, had to go for a bottled beer after. We ordered a club sandwich and a buffalo chicken wrap. My club sandwich was pretty miserable. Packaged wet turkey, old lettuce and old bacon. My wife enjoyed her wrap however. The bartenders were friendly and the atmosphere wasn't bad. But an Irish bar should have good taps and a decent club sandwich with fresh ingredients. This did not. Won't likely be back. read more

The bar tender Danny was awesome! He kept conversation going and kept the bat running! He told us about some interesting things places here in NY and was an awesome bar tender! Really enjoyed sitting here drinking at this local bar down the street from our hotel The Pearl! The signature drink was Raspbreeze very good! Had a great time here! read more

See all

Great service and great vibes! Had really good beef stew and potato leak soup! I did the pre fix menu for $35 and I'm getting apple pie with it. Love places like this! It's also a much bigger location than it looks from the outside! read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Signature cocktail menu - New American Near Me - New York, New York

Outside Seating and food was good! Surprised how fast the food came. Bathroom stall didn't lock though.

This was my first visit to Playwright Celtic Pub. It was a Saturday at 1:00pm before a play. There was no hostess so I took a seat at the bar. After 10 minutes of no service, I left and pondered going upstairs since there was still nobody around to ask. Eventually, someone came around who led me upstairs. I was a bit concerned about the time I lost since I had a 2pm deadline. Jose brought out my Bangers & Mash fairly quickly. I enjoyed my meal while listening to faint hints of dance music hidden behind the extremely noisy chatter and watching Mets news on television. My meal was much more succulent than I had expected. It's great food but in a chaotic environment. read more

We stopped in this bar for a quick drink on a Saturday evening before heading to our Broadway show. The place was packed. My friend who is a big time drinker didn't care and wanted to get her drink on. We stood for awhile and was luckily able to get some seats at the bar. We didn't venture to their upper floors. The vibe was cool and nice. They had reserved bar tables if you were ordering food. I would hang out here again when in the neighborhood. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - New American Near Me - New York, New York

My mom and I chose to go to Playwright Pub for a late lunch/early dinner before seeing a broadway show this past weekend. We showed up to where we thought we made the reservation, and were told that it was the wrong Playwright location and that the mistake happens all the time. When we finally got to the right restaurant (about a 5-10 minute walk away) we were again told that this is a common mistake - so I was surprised that the hostess didn't say something when I called earlier to make the reservation. Nevertheless, we sat on the top level and snagged a rooftop table. The rooftop is relatively small but it was a nice day to sit outside and hang out. Our waiter wasn't amazing, I think he was the only waiter up on our level but he seemed to be easily annoyed and bothered - not a great attitude. For an appetizer we ordered potato skins which came as an order of three. I thought this was a weird number for an appetizer and for $13 there should have been 4-6. For my main course I had a traditional burger with cheese and a side of fries. The burger was good - nothing amazing but I was happy that there was vinegar on the table to put on my fries! I didn't have an awful experience but the service and food was just average. Nothing specifically impressed me or made me want to come back. FYI - when you check in there is a Yelp offer for a $6 irish coffee in the month of December. read more

See all

Loved the god and atmosphere soo much that we visited twice the weekend we were in NYC.

Went to this pub last night after a Broadway show. Got a good table. Ordered food and drinks. For some reason our waiter kept returning to say the kitchen was closing (it was after 11pm on a Friday but fair enough). He kept returning to take plates as we were eating. I had to grab back my dipping sauce. Then he reached over us to turn off the light directly over our table, despite other tables being occupied and the bar being full of people. We closed out our tab but still felt rushed out, and we weren't rude or loud. The website said the bar was open far later. I can never recommend this establishment due to this poor hospitality, and I work in the area on Broadway. Staff needs a retraining session STAT. Upsetting end to an otherwise wonderful evening out. read more

After a long day I thought it would be nice for my girlfriend and I to sit down and have a tasty Irish meal. When we first arrived I didn't realize the stumbling woman with a drink in her hand was the hostess and I almost ran in to her when trying to enter. We were seated upstairs in a nicely decorated room and ordered. I got the French onion soup she got the truffle fries. The French onion soup was everything I hoped it would be, very very tasty. The truffle fries on the other hand, well let's just say half a bottle of truffle fries and unmelted giant shavings of cheese on supermarket frozen fries is too much. The smell of truffle oil was so strong we had to ask them to take the fries away before continuing our meal due to the headache the smell was causing. The chicken pot pie I had to try because if you are gonna lend your restaurant's name to the food, it's gotta be good right? I was mistaken. While it was decent, it seemed like the puff pastry, which was pretty thick, seem to be just placed over the pot pie which was under seasoned and difficult to eat. My girlfriend had the winner however because the shepherd's pie was delicious. Top top it all off, even though we were a party of two, they automatically added a $15 gratuity with no notice and still expected a tip. With so many places to eat near Time Square, there are better ways to spend 109 dollars. My advice, go elsewhere. read more

See all

Great spot in a busy area. Three floors. I returned after enjoying crab cakes over salad to enjoy the brunch special pork cutlet. Second floor is best for dining,service is quick, bathroom is nearby. There's a rooftop area as well. The food is varied enough, and the brunch is a great deal for a lot of food, dessert is included, but I had no room left! A very nice experience. And the waitress remembered me! Recently returned after a matinee of the Irish play "The Ferryman!" Perfect choice! And it was just as good as last time. My friend was very happy with his bangers and mash, and I once again succumbed to my yearly treat of porterhouse pork chop! This time, I also ordered the beef stew to go and took my dessert, apple crumb cake, home! Excellent quality all around. The staff is very accommodating and although the first level is a typical crowded bar, there are two more levels upstairs that are comfortable for conversation and meals. FYI, I did notice that the potatoes are now a light green, but tasted no differently. Maybe it's a nod to "colcannon?" You will be happy with quality, service, price. Go now! read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Brunch menu. Something for everyone! - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Shout out to the friendly staff here - they're great. This pub has affordable drinks and plenty of yummy comfort foods, perfect to contrast the expensive Times Square area. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Rooftop! - New American Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here for drinks, and they were just awful. Overpriced and way watered down. So many better drinks in the city for the same price, or a few dollars more. Service was fast and friendly, so that was nice. read more

See all

Just stopped in for a quick beer with my wife. Her being a massive Guinness fan and it being an Irish bar, seemed natural. However caution, it's not a true pint. Served in a abnormally slightly small Guinness glass. Not a true 20oz... my IPA came in a standard bar sleeve. Not a huge problem, however still charged $9+ USD for it! So at a cost per ounce, terrible deal. $21 USD for two beers with tip. Service was good, but we sat at the bar. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - New American Near Me - New York, New York

I ate at the bar, the bartender was very nice, and the food was great. I made the matinee in no at all

You come here and you tell bartender Joe that Emma and Jose sent you. Otherwise ya dead ta me, you hear me? Joe is a saint and a gem. Very recommend. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Fat n happy cuz we'll work it out after the holidays - New American Near Me - New York, New York

We needed a place to kill a little time before a Saturday matinee show, and first dropped in at the Iron Bar & Lounge across the street. That place was loud, really crowded, and the guy at the door practically had a conniption fit when I walked through looking to see if there were any open chairs at the bar. So, we went across the street to the Playwright Pub instead. Here is what we noticed: - We lucked out and found two seats at one of the bars on the second or third floor. The place is multistory, pretty quaint, touristy as you would expect, but it was nicely decorated for Christmas. - I ordered the Dandy Shandy (half Guinness and half Ginger Beer)...very interesting, and it grew on me over time. My wife had a Blue Moon on tap...overall, their tap menu was ok but nothing spectacular. Bottom line: We'd go back for the cozy, unique atmosphere....great place to enjoy a cold one! read more

This place has multiple levels to eat, drink and carry on.... very close to our hotel in the theatre district so we went. We ended up on the top floor and the bartender was delightful. We had so much fun with him. It is touristy, yes given the location but somehow it feels like your favorite dive bar/ neighborhood pub. I had a burger which was great, but wished I had explored the menu more as everything that came out looked more enticing and delicious than the dish before! It was our last night in NYC and we had an early flight so we couldn't go to breakfast that the bartender recommended. Next time! read more

They have an actual roof garden! Yep, an actual bar on the roof where you can see the sky. Did I mention there was a roof garden? And, um, there's also a roof garden. They may also have a mediocre beer list and some food or something. It's about what you'd expect for Times Square area...overpriced and middling. If you're a tourist who's afraid of walking a block to 9th avenue for a much better experience, this is the place for you. read more

Playwright Celtic Pub - Rooftop garden - New American Near Me - New York, New York