Freaking brilliant. Best strawberry rhubarb pie I've ever had, and I've never been huge on dessert pies. It was perfectly balanced between tart and sweet, and the crumble was such a good addition. Chicken pot pie is also pretty darn delicious and seasoned well. The meat was tender, avoiding the downfall of most chicken pot pies. I wish this was the average standard of food around here. We stopped by after being completely disappointed by Wildland up the street. Pop Pie was a significantly better value and taste with no frills. Stella Jeans is right next to it so you really can't go wrong. This little plaza is quickly shaping up to be my favorite place in Carlsbad Village. read more

I got a vegetable pot pie and creamed corn! And they were both so delicious! Crust is very buttery and flaky, and cooked to perfection! Filling was very flavorful and it hit the spot on the cold morning. I don't know how they make it, but the creamed corn was so good! I actually wasn't expecting it to be this good for a corn lol Service was very friendly and I like how they open early in the morning (at 9am) Plenty of parking and outdoor dining tables but both get really crowded on weekends. Overall, this place is so good!! I'd like to try other items on the menu next time. read more

Pop Pie - Vegetable pot pie: after I took a bite lol - Desserts Near Me - Carlsbad, California

Love the food! I've been craving a chicken pot pie since Pop Pie infiltrated my Instagram and I was not disappointed... This would be five stars if the staff person who helped us didn't seem miserable. Being excited to try the place out, I would have appreciated a warmer welcome. (Also, giving folks some grace right now because 2025.) read more

See all

I'm a big pot pie enjoyer so I was delighted when we stumbled upon this place. My friends and I got the chicken and aussie pot pies and picked up the salted apple caramel crumble and the lemon curd and mixed berry hand pie. The chicken and aussie ones were very flavorful with a perfectly flaky and buttery crust. I think the only thing is that most of the pastry must have soaked up all the juices so it was a tad bit try but it honestly didn't bother me. No notes on the apple, what I wanted for an apple pie and the lemon curd and mixed berry one was exactly what I needed with a lemony tart flavor and the sweet berries. Everything was so delicious that the next day I went back and picked up a steak and ale pie to try with a side of creamed corn and mashed potatoes & gravy. I couldn't finish it so I left it in the fridge and brought it back with me to the Bay where I stashed it in the freezer. I had it three weeks after I initially bought it and it was still fantastic! I was surprised by how incredibly tender the steak was, the meat was more tender than dishes I've had where the meat was supposed to be "fall off the bone". If you enjoy pot pies, please go here. I'm still dreaming about this place. Next time I go down, I'll make sure to order more to take back home with me to the Bay. read more

The lies are tasty! But deserts are even better! Apple pie in a cup with vanilla ice cream!

Best pot pies! Chicken pot pie. Pork pot pie. Service is great. Though it's grab and go so not a place you can totally hang out to eat. Good to take home on the way back from work. Given the grab and go type of arrangement wish they had a drive thru. read more

I normally don't write reviews, but after this culinary experience, I have been compelled to share the good word. I didn't even intend on coming to Pop Pie Co at first. My bf and I were actually going to the ice cream place nextdoor, but, Pot Pie Co caught our eye and, LET ME TELL YOU... In my 30 long years of life, I have had many pot pies-- chicken, beef, you name it... I've had it. And, I'd consider myself a bit of a pot pie connoisseur. When I say, this was the BEST chicken and beef pot pie me and my bf have ever had, I mean it. If you haven't tried it yet-- you have to. We took our pies to go, popped them in the air fryer at home, and they were perfect. 10/10 would recommend and will surely be coming back for more. read more

the savory pies are so satisfying. hot, filling, good balance of flavors. still need to try the sweet pies but I'll bet they're good as well. so far I've had the breakfast pie, steak & ale pie, and the quiche. can't go wrong with any of them but the steak & ale is my #1 pick, the combination of the tender steak, flavorful gravy and crumbly pie crust is addicting. definitely have to be in the mood for it though, not something I can consistently casually opt for. not much to say about the service, not super fast but not too slow either read more

Had the steak and ale pie and it was delicious along with the creamed corn. Only knock would be the steak was a bit dryer that my preference but the flavors were on point. read more

The pot pie was very good, but took awhile to get it. I would go again. I would recommend a try

Great pies. Please bring back the Aussie pie! It was the best one by far. We were sad to see it had gone off the menu.

Pop Pie did not disappoint. I got the classic chicken pie and the crust was buttery, flakey and delicious. Chicken was tender and the inside was very flavourful. Would recommend. read more

Pop Pie - Classic Chicken - Desserts Near Me - Carlsbad, California

Amazing pies!! Deserts are yummy. Whenever I'm in an area that there's a shop, we stop in and grab a handful and freeze them!!

Overall, expectations met. Good food, reasonable price, friendly service, and yes, chill location. I had chicken pot pie and apple pie that is one of the best apple pie that I tried. read more

I'm not really a pie person. Or a pot pie person. But this place will change your mind about that. Get the chicken pot pie with a side of mashed potatoes. You're welcome. The crumb topping on their dessert pies is magical, especially with vanilla ice cream. Staff is very friendly and polite too. read more

I found my pie ( beef and ale) very dry. Maybe it's meant to be like that but I wouldn't order it again. I like some gravy in my hot pies.

I got the classic chicken with a side of mashed potatoes as well as a sausage roll. The "pop" pie unfortunately lacked a lot of flavor/seasoning. Specifically the pieces of chicken. They were fairly dry and unseasoned and a little over cooked. The pie crust on the other hand was phenomenal. Extremely buttery and flaky. Not sure if my pie had just been sitting for too long or they messed up the chicken but it was a solid 2.5/5 as far as flavor. I would try again to see if I had a bad batch. Also added hot sauce which made it much better. The side of mashed potatoes were really rich and tasted perfect- 5/5 no notes. Highly recommend. The sausage roll was interesting. The sausage mostly just tasted like rosemary and maybe sage? Kind of the only seasoning and only flavor you taste. The meat itself was slightly dry. I topped it with the mashed potatoes to make it not as dry and make the rosemary less over powering. Again the crust was great. I wouldn't get again but some people may like it. All in all it's good not great. May need to try other options. read more

One of 3 small cottages..all with outdoor seating only (with heaters & lotsa decor lights). Not your typical Banquet pot pies. Approx 5 savory pies, quiche & lotsa desserts. Our chicken had lotsa chicken pieces, good gravy & jazzed up with some spices. You can add mashed potatoes/gravy. Wonderful experience! read more

Delicious selection of pies and sweet treats. Excellent service and staff too. One of our new go-to spots in Carlsbad Village

What a pleasant surprise. Went on a Friday mid day and the service was fast the food was great ( don't forget to add the kale salad to your pot pie) They are more filling than they look. Got a beer from shoot next door too and a ice cream for dessert. What a cute little collection of stores in the cottage. read more

We buy the veggie curry pot pies all the time as they are delicious! And the customer service at Pot Pie Co is equally as good. After a question about my receipt, Elliott handled it like the old days, amazingly!!! Just like managers should be. Not only is it a great place, but you can collect points and get free food at Pot Pie or the ice cream next door. I highly recommend Pot Pie Co. read more

Everything about this place rocks! Great service, AMAZING pot pies (I had the absolutely delicious chicken pie, and my friend had the British one) with the most wonderful crust and flavor! Wow! read more

Absolute must. For $12 you get the most delicious single-serve pot pie that will leave you satiated and satisfied. I've tried both the standard chicken and veggie and can attest they are both fantastic. The mashed potatoes are meh and the drinks are artesanal and over priced. But the pies read more

I went here today with my sister for lunch. We both ordered the chicken pot pie with white meat. Let me tell you they are not being honest about white meat, there was definitely dark meat inside. The pot pie had a strange spice in the crust and sauce. We were very disappointed with the food. I was hoping for a delicious homemade pot pie. read more

My entire family loves these pot pies. The sweet and savory pies are delicious. My favorite sweet pie is the Guava Cream Cheese and for savory we love the Classic Chicken and the Green Hog & Cheese, but all of them have been great. read more

The heat level inside the restaurant is absolutely insane.I stepped inside expecting to get a slight break from the hot sun,and instead I was met with a WAVE of heat. Thankfully, I only had to endure the heat for a couple minutes while waiting for my pie but all I could think of was the poor worker.How does a chain restaurant like this expect their staff to work in these horrible conditions? The owners should feel ashamed for not providing their workers with workable conditions.Despite this I want to acknowledge the staff.The sweet girl provided an amazing experience despite her disadvantages.Pop pie be better to your staff!! read more

I originally tried Pop Pie at one of their locations in SD a few years back and while the experience was fine it certainly wasn't memorable, so I wasn't expecting anything different from trying this one but was pleasantly surprised by how good the pies I tried were. The location is in the small cute shops in Carlsbad Village square. We tried the Chicken Pot Pie, the Creamed Corn & Mashed Potatoes (which was not a menu item that was available when I visited the other location), the Guava and Cheese as well as the Lemon Curd and Blueberry dessert hand pie. The Chicken Pie was meaty and had a nice balance of veggies and gravy but if there was one minor complaint, it would be that the seasoning used had a bit too much bay leaf flavor, otherwise it was very good and the pie crust was buttery and flaky. I especially enjoyed the mashed potatoes and loved the creamed corn. It rounded out the meal very nicely. The dessert pies were equally delicious as well, with the guava and cheese being a warm dessert and the lemon and blueberry pie being a cold one. Service was quick and easy, ordering online and picking up. This is a great addition to the terrific food options in Carlsbad. Will return for sure. read more

Ok, wow. We are instant fans now. Went for the first time about 5:30 tonight and the line was slightly out the door, but the two employees working did a great job managing the volume of customers and making sure more pies were going in the oven. We tried the chicken and the beef and ale pot pies. We also got the large side of mashed potatoes and gravy and the lemon curd/berry hand pie. The flaky crust is amazing. Both savory pies were great and we loved the mashed potatoes & gravy. The lemon curd hand pie is soooooooo good! We will be back to try all the other savory and sweet pie options soon! read more

The best pot pies ever. They really have the pastry and the filling down. Fast service. I took some frozen ones home for emergency lunches or dinners read more

I have been here a couple of times and have had great conversation and good service. But today the girl and guy cashier enjoyed to chit chat more than give good service. The guy cashier also has a bad attitude, won't be coming back after this experience. read more

The guava cheese pastry was very dry and had barely any guava or cream cheese. Service was friendly, hence the two stars.

The food is so tasty! Everyone is friendly.. great place for children & pets. I highly recommend

The Chicken Pot Pit was warm and so delicious! It also goes well with the Vegetable Pot Pie, also.

NOT vegan-friendly, highly recommend to AVOID this place. I ordered the "vegan" pot pie (vegetable curry) and they gave me one containing chicken that had been mislabeled. It is truly a shame that The Plot was replaced by this subpar restaurant. I am very disappointed and will not be returning. read more

Good selection of savory and sweet pies. I enjoyed the pie crust which was nice and flaky as well as tasty; a good crust. Service was friendly and efficient. read more

1st time p/u. Got chicken pot pie for me, great flavor, crust and plenty of filling but it was way too dry for me. Husband got the Aussie and loved it. Corn side was tasty but corn was mushy. Also got a Guava/ cream cheese hand pie and strawberry/rhubarb hand pie. My Guava one was big, filled well and crust was yummy. It was way too sweet....so, just brushed off the pretty sugar on top, and it was yummy ! I will try different pies next time. BTW.... large portions, rich buttery pies. read more

I've been to pop pie about 10 times since it's opened in Carlsbad and every time it's been a 10/10 experience the pies are always hot and each flavor is amazing the staff is extremely friendly I've had the pleasure of being served by justice several times and she is the friendliest hardest working employees I've ever met. The amazing food pairs perfectly with the amazing ambiance from the out door patio. This is a place that intend to go back to time and time again for years to come! read more

omg!!!! i just had the salted caramel apple pie a la mode -- best ever!!!!!!!! period!! no cap. amazing!! flawless!!!

Tried the New CARLSBAD store... & Their chicken pies are REALLY GOOD ... you have to check this place out !!