I really liked the ambiance. The music was good and not too loud. I didn't even need to wear earplugs, as I often do these days to protect me from getting much worse migraines. I sat at the bar, since it was only me, but tho the bar wasn't busy and service was friendly, it was very slow. The food was wonderful! I'm glad I made the choices I did, tho of course nothing I wanted was included in the happy hour specials. The fried calamari was some of the best I've had tho it was observed with a little bit of cocktail sauce and a huge thing of tartar sauce. I'm sure I could have gotten more cocktail sauce, since I don't like tartar sauce, but it wasn't necessary. The calamari was so good. The lobster bisque was delicious and the picture can't show you that it was full of lobster. There was a LOT more lobster than a lobster bisque normally contains and the price was about normal for a lobster bisque with one tiny piece of lobster. The iced tea was a bit out of control. If I'm going to be charged $5 per glass of iced tea, that glass should be larger than the ones they use AND not 90% ice. That much for a glass of ice with a splash of iced tea is extreme. I'd still return, since the food was wonderful and hopefully I just got unlucky with the service. read more

See all

My group and me order meatballs, the classic burger, and the fillet. Everything was deliciously buttery but never too over powering with its flavors. Everything came out in a couple minutes or less. The size of the restaurant created a cozy and comfortable environment along with that the light created a soothing atmosphere. read more

Prime Catch - The filet - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

My team and I ate here after work today since it was nearby our client's office in Times Square. It was a very mediocre dining experience overall and I left hungry because I didn't really enjoy any of the food we ordered so I didn't eat much. - cesar salad (3.5/5) - standard cesar, nothing to complain about or write home about. - tomahawk steak (3/5) - asked for medium rare and it came out rare. decent crust but otherwise it was mediocre. - lobster vodka pasta (2.5/5) - good vodka sauce, but there was barely any lobster... - chicken parm (3/5) - chicken was soggy and pasta could've used more flavor. - mac & cheese (4.5/5) - we actually liked this. it was tasty and cheesy without being too heavy. - mushrooms (3/5) - average and boring. - asparagus (3/5) - very average and bland. The service was also underwhelming. Nobody smiled at us the entire night. The server looked annoyed when I mentioned that we would be doing family style. Nobody refilled our waters the entire dinner. None of the workers looked like they wanted to be there. Definitely would pass on this place if you come across it on Yelp. There are much better restaurants and steakhouses in the city. read more

Prime Catch - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

prime catch is one of the best seafood restaurants in south Florida. The lobster was incredibly fresh . The swordfish was excellent read more

It's just OK. Soup was lukewarm, pasta with clams was fairly tasteless and the bread was so hard and stale it was uneatable.

Went here before seeing a show (Moulin Rouge), on 5/17/24, and have to say I was impressed. The staff was very warm, friendly, and attentive. The dishes were very well prepared. Of particular note was the fillet mignon. Excellent. I would recommend this place without hesitation. read more

Prime Catch - Excellent steak - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Classic American dishes done well. From service to cocktails, nothing disappointed. The spring rolls are to die for and the mozzarella triangles with marinara hit the spot. Each dish was delicious and classically prepared, a great spot for a night out read more

See all

Stopped in a for light dinner before taking my son to a show. The tuna tartare was fresh and well sauced accompanied by a creamy avocado mold. read more

Underwhelming. We stopped for lunch. Thought that we were in for a treat considering the lobster bisque was yummy and the oysters were perfection but sadly that was not the case . Ordered steak medium , had to send it back because it was over cooked and when they brought it back to me , it wasn't the best tasting . He got the ny strip , which tasted so much better than mine . They only offered 1 cabernet sauvignon by the glass . It was ok I guess. We ordered mushrooms and lobster mac . Everything was just "ok" Upside- the bartender was A1. Those old fashioned helped BIG TIME . Just go straight to the bar next time. read more

See all

Our first food stop when we arrived in New York! We were three of about 10 people total in the restaurant. They had a great lunch menu with a variety of choices. We had the lobster bisque, Caesar salad with chicken, and steak sandwhich. The food was AMAZING. One of the best Caesar salads we've ever had. Only complaint was our server took a while to come back after we had finished eating. We wanted to get walking and he was nowhere to be found for a while. read more

Prime Catch - Lobster Bisque - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great service, quiet place to go post theater. Bartender lady is lovely. I go there when I'm in New York City

Very pleasant late afternoon/early evening dining post Saturday matinee. Sat at the bar first and had some powerful Happy Hour apps and drinks. The drinks were strong or at least my Classic Martini was. Just beware that not all drinks are Happy Hour priced. Sitting down we started with tasty and fresh Caesar and Wedge Salads. For our mains we had a strip steak and a boneless rib eye. Both were of steak house quality somewhere in the middle of the road for taste. The fries and creamed spinach as sides were excellent. The mushroom were kind of bland and pale looking. Service was outstanding. Major plus was no charge for using credit cards. read more

If I could leave zero stars I would. Very overpriced for the food quality and portion sizes. Service was slow and mediocre. My husband and I considered dine n dashing because it was so bad, but for the sake of our own conscious we didn't. Please don't waste your money here! All the good reviews are probably from the restaurant because there's no way... we should've known not to eat here as there were no other people in the restaurant. Don't get scammed like we did!! read more

Greetings and salutations yelpers. My first review as an Elite Yelper..yay me! Ok, this spot was on my spreadsheet and last minute dinner with an out of town friend decided to dined. I was so looking forward to an amazing meal and sadly that was not so. Our waiter, not the most engaging, a bit stand blunt. No engaging conversation, recommendations etc. To start the bread brought to table seemed like dinner rolls one would purchase in the supermarket. Appetizers: we ordered the baked clams and baked shrimp. Both very bland and needed some form of seasoning. As a new found baked clam lover I was very disappointed. Avid shrimp lover disappointed once again. Main course: Shrimp Milanese, once again lacking in flavor. It felt like something to be served in a pizzeria and not worth the $34. So much breaded didn't recognize it was shrimp and wondered if they gave us chicken instead. Lobster Vodka Pasta: the saving Grace which made my rating 3 instead of 2. It was delicious and flavorful and made me wonder how the other dishes were so bland. Another reason for the low score was the constant interruption from various staff asking how are things. I get it you want to be attentive, but it was overkill and it really curtailed the ability for my friend and I to catch up with what is happening in our lives. After a while not to be rude, it was annoying. All in all I really had high hopes and was looking forward to a great dinner but sadly it was just mediocre. The wow factor I was expecting was not to be. read more

See all

We came here first dinner tonight, to celebrate my birthday. The food was amazing. The drink list was good, and the staff was incredible! I highly recommend them for dinner. Either just casual or for a special occasion like mine. read more

FOOD WAS TERRIBLE AND PRICEY Do not waste your time or money coming here, this was so overpriced and bad food! And they have a 25% surcharge . We ended up paying 100$ for a burger and a pasta! When asked about it they said it was part of the system and still aked for a tip. The lobster pasta had not a single piece of lobster. The burger was 3/10 and i couldn't finish it, and the fries were bad. They also charged 10 dollars for still water that was just tap water! Im sorry to say this was a complete waste of money and i would highly recommend to not eat here! I love good food for a good price! read more

We popped in for Happy Hour. We sat at the bar and were served in a very timely matter. The bartender was very friendly. Nice Happy Hour Menu. We had the Baked Clams, the Mussels (in white wine sauce), and the Mac and Cheese. It was all excellent! The bread they served us was really great. Especially dunking it in the "juice" of the mussels! The mussels and the clams were perfectly cooked and both nice and small. They weren't Huge clams or Mussels like they were on steroids!! Drinks were good! Price was extremely reasonable. For happy hour we had 3 small bites, and 3 drinks, $65.00! And it was all great! read more

See all

12-11-2024 Our party of four ( wife, son and his partner) came in after a show to celebrate a early Christmas dinner since our schedules would not allow for a family Christmas gathering this year. We were in a celebratory mood. Our server (Dara) was amazing from start to finish. She helped make this one of the most memorable events of the entire year. We started with Seafood platters (4) for the table and finished up with Filet Mignon and 15 oz. bone in NY Strip. They were all fantastic. Out drinks were delicious and Dara and her team were so attentive. Thank you for making our trip to NY and the reunion with our son , one we will not forget. Merry Christmas read more

My sister decided this is where she wanted to go for her 29th birthday. Not everyone wasn't pleased with the prices on the menu but I will say if your looking to go here with family and not sure what to get the penne lobster pasta it was so delicious for me. It was so creamy and filled with lobster pieces not as much lobster as I would've liked only because I love huge lobster chucks. But overall this is a great choice if you want good filling food for a decent price. read more

Prime Catch - Penne lobster pasta - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Had the best oysters and mussels. We stopped by after a broadway show at happy hour. Great cocktails and great food. A special thank to bartender Darina. We are going to come back for the steak house menu in August. read more

Ate here on a fall break trip 2 October 2023. Being in New York City after a long day of site seeing I was looking forward to a great dinner. This place seemed like the best from walking a couple blocks. The atmosphere was. Ice and the gentlemen greeting us at the door was fantastic. Super nice guy. Wish I would have caught his name. I'm from the south I wasn't expecting the kind welcome like we get in the south. Entering the restaurant I was pleased with how everything looked and was ready for a great meal. When the waitress came to the table there seemed to be a language barrier, to be understandable for New York and their smashing of culture and my hillbilly accent from Kentucky. Ha. Maybe this could explain the mix up in food preparation. I ordered the 14oz ribeye medium rare and it was served rare. Overall the taste of the steak was very bland. They literally put no seasoning on the steak and the fat rendered no flavor. The cut was very pour and had a lot gristle, making it hard to cut. Was very disappointed in the steak. Maybe I should have expected that from the name of the restaurant; note do not order steak from a seafood restaurant. You will always be disappointed. My wife ordered the wedge salad and was pleased, made comment that the bacon added the finishing touch. My daughter ordered the meatball and spaghetti, my daughter is very well traveled and keeps her on blog on Yelp saod the spaghetti sauce was very cheap and tasted like something from a can at a grocery store. Food 2* Service 3* Cleanliness 5* Hospitality 5* Price 4* Atmosphere 3* read more

See all

Great high end lunch spot in an immediate area without too many of them. Attentive service, warm bread, and surprisingly substantial portions of pasta. It's often the little things that matter, and Prime Catch nailed it for me. read more

We wandered into Prime Catch just looking for a place to sit down and have a cocktail and a bite to eat. We didn't know anything about this restaurant, but what a wonderful surprise. We had the best meatball we have ever had as well as a salmon dish with tomato sauce and also the lobster with vodka sauce pasta. The best! Try it! You won't be sorry and tell Alex the bartender we said hello from California! read more

Prime Catch - Best meatballs in New York City at Prime Catch on 46th! - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Worst food ever. Ordered their "special". Turned out to be a watery (was supposed to be garlic, butter, wine). Tried the tomato sauce. Landed up with a cold jar sauce. 10 strands of linguine and overcooked seafood for $74. No wonder multi people were eating sandwiches for dinner. Didn't allow us to switch to a sandwich or a refund. Horrible birthday dinner (which they didn't acknowledge) read more

Honestly, the best things about this restaurant is the ambiance and the service. The food isn't that great. I went there this evening for date night, started off w. their lobster bisque. It had a sour off putting taste. The waiter kindly offered to switch my soup to french onion, sadly the 2nd soup was no better than the first. It was very bland. For my entree I had the linguine alfredo, it was good and the saving grace of the entire dining experience. Like I said the ambiance and extremely nice staff are the best part about this place! read more

I've tasted their Caeser Salad and Baked shrimp which was unexplainable. Their taste quality and price was juist unforgatable. Customer service exceptional and froendly. Highly recommended! read more

Of course I have to rave about prime catch they do an excellent job hosting events, great service steak and atmosphere. I tried to the muscles and they were delicious, located right in time Sqaure a nice escape from all the business. read more

Prime Catch - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The atmosphere at Prime Catch was amazing. The service was A+. While all of the items we had were cooked properly by temperature the flavor and portion sizes were not impressive at all. We thought trying the preset menu would be good and help us to be finished on time to make it to our play the flavors weren’t there and the size of the steak was very small and the potatoes tasted like box potatoes. The salad was good and the wine was excellent. read more

See all

I've been here countless times already. It is in the heart of Times Square on 46th between 6th and 7th avenue. Everything here is simply excellent. Right now I eating a meatball appetizer and having a strawberry lemonade drop martini. It's calm vibes and a great environment. Come down and enjoy. read more

our waitress Dara was AMAZING she gave us the best rooftop bar recamendation it was a great vibe they put us by the window and Dara was attentive personable and a great conversation. I had the bone in bone and it was a great steak. calamari was 8/10 read more

I was looking for a place to have dinner on my way home from work and ran into this little hidden gem. I sat at the bar and the service was great. I got my food quickly and it was very tasty. I'd highly recommend the Chicken Milanese. read more

In my 31 years of walking this earth, the porterhouse served at Prime Catch is the the closest I have come to the perfect steak. What started out as a presentation that would leave Lumiere envious, I fealt like royalty as they served me the porterhouse of my dreams. I Gazed at this beautiful slab of beef served carved and sizzling hot flanked by my asparagus and spinach. Every bite seemed to take me to a new level of bliss. I am writing this review as I wait for my dessert. Its coming out now so you will have to try that for yourself. I cant wait to come back here again. read more

See all

We were walking, and were greeted by hostess Olga, who explained the menu to us. We ordered amazing food, drinks and $1.50 oysters because it was happy hour! Our server was great, he is from Albania, with a gorgeous accent. Very delicious food, clean place, not too pricey. Will come again! Try this place out if you are visiting New York, you won't regret it! read more

Prime Catch - Oysters , salad , bread - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Great little restaurant near Times Square. Wonderful staff. Very helpful! Will come again! read more

Always delicious food, attentive service and a peaceful, quiet, not crowded ambiance.

Had the pleasure of going to Prime Catch several times during a long work trip to NYC, and it made the whole experience better! Great food and ambience, terrific happy hour specials, and friendly staff with excellent service. You can't ask for much more. The steak and lobster pasta were both great, and their lunch special steak burger and prime dip were just as good. Highly recommend read more

Excellent eating experience!! Great service and very delicious drinks . The best Dry Age Steak that I have try i NYC. read more

Prime Catch - a bar with a variety of cocktails - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

As other reviewers noted this place is small and cozy and quite romantic as well. We entered for a late supper just before closing and when they heard we had seven people they gladly seated us. Our server was efficient and attentive. I had the cheeseburger which was terrific. It was a big, juicy patty that was only slightly pink. The fries were really good as well. For under $20 this is a tremendous value for Shubert Alley. We asked for separate checks and the waiter effortlessly processed them and returned our cards within minutes. We had been to several other restaurants and this process took a lot longer with much back and forth. This guy nailed it! read more

The filet mignon is large enough for 2 people. The lobster was very flavorful. I left 3 stars rather than 4 because the food items do not come with sides you have to order the sides seperate. Very pricey but I had to eat at a nice steak restaurant in New York. read more

See all

The food here was AMAZING! I had the best eggplant parmigiana ever! And, that is what I always order at any restaurant that has it on the menu. My son, ordered the lamb chops medium rare, and it was so tender and cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the seafood pasta and it was delicious! The seafood was not over cooked. The service was amazing! Everyone was so friendly and attentive. Our water was filled before we even thought about needing more. I'm SO glad we came here for dinner! read more

See all