Hello everyone, just visit this place Prime Catch tonight and was disappointed. We are was standing in line and was waiting to be seated,and they was have an table , and group of people walk from the street and just seat on that table, I did talk to the manager about it, the answer from the manager was shocked, he said he can't do anything. My apologies but this is not good at all. read more

The owner was a very welcoming person. He treat us with free shots. Love the ambience. Best location. They are just across from time square. Amazing drinks and fun musics. Highly recommend :) read more

Prime Catch - Amazing bar and atmosphere - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Good food but totally overpriced ! But that's New York. Only 3 stars because of price and they directly take 22% tip without asking. Service is ok but not 22% service. read more

Always come to New York and every time we come they are so inviting and friendly. The vibe is calm and cheerful, food is wonderful, even sitting at the bar having a drink we have a great time. Owners and staff are amazing!! read more

I have to say I thought the food was excellent. Rib eye on the bone was definitely aged prime and hash browns were also excellent. No issues at all with food. Fair price. Service was disorganized and spent a lot of time cat calling people for a table. I know it's touristville but at a nicer place it really is uncomfortable to watch. And please please pay attention to the bill. Gratuity is INCLUDED! You're welcome for that "tip." read more

Prime Catch - Bill - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Stumbled across this hidden gem and had such a pleasant experience! Service was great, wait for food was average, food was delicious and so was their jack and coke! read more

Prime Catch - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

This was the best steak i've ever had! Amazing service, food & drinks. Definitely would recommend. read more

Prime Catch - Bone in NY Strip Steak Mashed Potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Went there this evening for dinner. Had shrimp and lobster avocado, which was very good. Had two dinners from specials of the day. They change one special to my sauce and second special they took back, no questions asked, as my wife didn't like it and asked her to place order for something different from menu. Food was good to great but service was exceptional. Worth a visit. read more

Worst experience ever server forgot to put our food order in and even had the audacity to include tip of 25% for a party of 2, the mussels were cold apps took 1 hour to come out read more

This place is amazing! The food was delicious and the service was incredible. Everyone was so friendly and accommodating. Highly recommend!!

First time visiting, never even heard of it. Came for a birthday dinner. Service was on point, server was super patient and made sure everything was accurate. Food was yummy, we ordered some of everything. Lobster & Avocado was AMAZING! Calamari too. Perfect start to dinner. Lamb chops were small but juicyyyy. I would come back here for sure read more

When to this restaurant for lunch. It was so delicious. My husband had the oysters and said they were some of the best hes ever had. Even ordered a second hoping.. The service was very friendly as well. read more

This spot is amazing! Food and service was out of this world. We ordered the bone in ribeye with mac and cheese. The mac and cheese was beautiful! The presentation was amazing. Let's not forget the service. Not one second we're we left without water nor more sangria. Thank you Prime Catch!! read more

Prime Catch - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

Beautiful place, friendly service, and delicious food/cocktails. We would definitely go back.

We went here for a late dinner as our first choices were closing. The food is expensive and mediocre at best. My friend has a salad and was charged $4 per shrimp on top of the salad price, that was a new one for me! And the shrimp were not particularly good. read more

In a city where everything is becoming fast food you learn to appreciate the good stuff great drinks a better atmosphere and a very good steak cannot ask for anything more ! read more

You can find great food and service all over New York City but this steak and seafood place tucked away near Times Square is a hidden gem. First rate ambiance, friendly waiter. My dinner-mates had the fish special, branzino, and I had the vodka lobster pasta- that speaks for itself. A strawberry martini and a glass or two of Woodford and we felt mellow happiness. Then, just as we prepared to leave the lovely bartender surprised us with a shot of lemoncelo, gratis. Perfect way to end our dinner portion of the evening. Off we went to savor the sights of Times Square. If you're looking for a great little place for good food and service, don't miss this one. read more

Excellent Food, we had the branzino and NY Strip with sautéed spinach, asparagus and mashed potatoes. Excellent ambiance, music , drinks everything. Loved the quaint hometown NU feel. Staff and manager warm and friendly. read more

I specifically went to get a lobster for my birthday and was utterly disappointed with my $72 dried out -over cooked ancient looking lobster Butter sauce barely tasted like butter - had to beg for a wet towel to clean off my hands - Tons of places for lobster in NYC - this one comes with nothing no corn or potatoes or any side dishes Huge letdown - Never go there again - don't go for lobster :( read more

So this is my first time at prime catch, my best friend came from NC so this was BOTH of our first time at this restaurant. We arrived at 8:30pm without a reservation for 4 and we waited about 10-15 mins before we where seated upstairs. It was weird as I was following the hostess how they seated all the people of color upstairs . The guy Jimmy who served us was very nice and made our drinks nice. We ordered an appetizer, surf and turf, seafood tower, and the salmon. We received the appetizer and our drinks and time went by and we noticed that we never got our entrees. LITERALLY 2 1/2 hours went by before we got entrees! The manager came by to offer us free drinks due to a system error and they "just opened" and at this point we are hungry and irritated that we waited this long to get our food so of course we took the free drinks but then we still didn't get our food. Our food looked like it was made already but sitting under the light to be picked up and got cold along the way. Both The salmon was cold, the filet mignon in the surf and turf was overly cooked (see the picture) and the shrimp in the seafood tower was not fresh and all you taste was frozen and aluminum foil . We spoke to the manager and had to basically tell him we was not paying for our food. The table next to us which had a party of 8, one of the ladies said they messed up her order twice and then charged her a $40 gratuity for a ticket of TWO PEOPLE! Like what place charges 2 people on the check $40 for gratuity if we split the bill. You DONT deserve a $40 tip when I can give $40 to Uber eats for them to follow my directions to the T! I will NOT be coming back here at all. I understand we are in a pandemic but at the same time I'm trying to give support to those who have been out of work for MONTHS. I'm a great tipper when you give me outstanding customer service, I did not get that at this place. Still had to pay $67.50 for the 4 drinks we had to begin with! We had 2 amaretto sours, a cosmo, and vodka cranberry did not end my night well read more

See all

Had the Caesar salad, shrimp cocktail (4 nice sized shrimps), ribeye ordered medium rare with fries. All excellent and cooked to specification. Great service as well and enjoyed the perfectly made patron marqueritas. Loved it. read more

Food is externally mediocre and over pricedBad experience in seating. Management has not clue how to take care of the customer. Even servers mentioned they are planning to leave. Avoid this place read more

Great food excellent service leli was fantastic! I had tomahawk and nice bottle of Bordeaux wine! Definitely I'm coming back! read more

We visited from Georgia right after New Years and came to this restaurant as it was the only one we could find with outdoor seating. The waiter was hard to understand but nice. The prices are very steep and the food is very bland. The presentation of the food and price gave me high hopes it would be filled with flavor and I was sadly disappointed to say the least. I travel frequently and have never in my life been charged $9.00 for flat water until this place. This is a place I will not be revisiting. $100.00 for pasta, appetizer, and asparagus. read more

We ate here just a couple nights ago because it was the only sit down place we could find in New York. It was way to expensive and the food was awful. Honestly I would starve myself before eating here again. Also to top it off we have to pay $9 for "voss bottled water" which was really just a voss water bottle filled with tap water. Save your money and spend it elsewhere because this place is a waste of time and money. Also I only gave it a one star because it wouldn't let me do 0. read more

At at Prime Catch on Friday 4/21 at midnight after enduring a 10-hour bus ride from Providence, RI due to major accident on Rout 95 in CT. The restaurant was very accommodating and gracious in serving us so late. I had the Lobster Penne Vodka and my wife had the grilled salmon. Both were delicious and plentiful. We even had time for dessert. My only complaint was $20 for a gin martini which, even by New York prices, was steep. Overall a very good experience and would dine here again next time we visit New York. read more

Our new favorite Italian place. Don't let the name mislead you. Yes, it has steaks. Yes, it has seafood. But that's far from all. Our waiter, Arian, is the face of a universally efficient, pleasant and personable staff. read more

Nice restaurant, terrible experience. We got sat right away . They said the wait for the food will be 30 minutes but our food didn't come until a hour and a half later. We didn't get our drinks until we all finished our meals when we were continuously asking about our drinks which were Shirley temples(doesnt take long to make) It seems like our server Arian was ignoring us. We sat in like a hidden area but he continuously walked passed us when we tried to get his attention , made eye contact and he went on to doing something else. After receiving our food one the lamb chops that were served were insanely salty as if the salt fell over. It made no sense to order another one because of the wait time so one of guest never ended up eating . Arian said he would take it off the bill and the bill was still returned with it on & had to wait again for him to fix it. We also sat next to a fire place that was off so we asked if they can turn it on because it was freezing & they never turned it on until we were just about ready to go. I will not be coming here again read more

My fiancé chose this place for our family to celebrate my birthday! One of the best experiences I've ever had! The hospitality, the excellence, the quality & food was Amazing ! From the seafood to steak plates were absolutely exceptional! And the espresso martinis are out of this world! I highly recommend this place! I will be coming back! read more

This was the most disappointing meal we had while in New York City. We were taken upstairs to a room with bare walls, folding tables, crackling speakers (another patron unplugged it) and folding chairs. There was one waiter for the whole floor, and the poor guy was overwhelmed. It was nearly 20 minutes after sitting down that we finally saw a waiter. The food was mediocre at best. Our baked potatoes were cold, my fish Luke warm and the bread very hard I would not mind if this was a Bob Evans but when you pay over $100 per person you expect something better. read more

Unassuming from the outside, surprisingly warm, inviting and cozy inside. Toli, the maitre d', was very accommodating, friendly and on top of his game. He and his staff checked in often on us and ensured we enjoyed our food and dinner experience. They also seemed to enjoy working each other which made for a very funny evening. We ordered the filet mignon and grilled salmon. The filet was cooked perfectly, lightly seasoned with a crisp fatty sear on the outside with a pink, juicy, buttery tlexture on the inside. The salmon was also very tasty, smooth and flaky. They topped the broccolini with roasted, sliced, seasoned garlic in oil that added an amazing savory flavor to the veggies and dish. Also ordered the lobster bisque which was absolutely delish and perfect on this cold, rainy evening. The creamy, rich lobster base contained several visible lobster chunks that clearly were not overcooked or chewy. Topped off dinner with a generous slice of creamy New York cheesecake. Enjoyed the chocolate decorative swirl on the plate that gave each bite a hint of chocolate as we scooped it up. Will definitely hit this place up again before we depart NYC! read more

Very rude staff I can't believe what passes for customer service these days. I will never patronize this business! read more

Food was great!! The whole staff was very welcoming! The owner and the server were checking in on us frequently and they made sure that we had everything that we needed! It was very pricey but it was worth every penny! We didn't try the steak, but the Prime Catch Seafood Pasta was to die for!! read more

Prime Catch - Prime Catch Seafood Pasta - Steakhouses Near Me - New York, New York

We made a last minute reservation here last December to come after seeing the Christmas spectacular and we were very happy with everything so we decided this year again after seeing the show we would come back. Made reservations in advance online this time. This place is a great spot in the city close to time square and the radio city music hall. Everything was perfect, food was great, service was good, and prices were reasonable for the city. If your looking for a great place for dinner in the city this is it! Will definitely be back! read more

Steak was as dry as the Sahara desert. Mussels made my friend gag. Service fee? For what the extra fuel yo overcook my steak?!

The ambiance was ok, location great! Wait staff had no personality. food had absolutely zero flavor. please Dont waste your time or money in this place. Also, they will put a 20% tip on your bill even if everything was sub par For a party of two. These people are thieves! read more

Amazing Steak, and delicious drinks ! Thank you guys for creating the best experience to bring me back . I highly recommend the tomahawk dry aged 65 days the best i have ever had . read more

The Happy Hour specials can't be beat! Service is fantastic and they're just seem to be glad to have you there, unlike a lot of other places in Manhattan these days. read more

For one it's very expensive I had the shrimp with penne pasta the sauce was almost water and tasted like tomatoes out of a can. Don't go there for the food. read more

When ordering, told the waiter we needed prompt service as we were going to a show. Waiter said fine. However we waited and waited for our main course ( steaks). Finally called for the manager and told him the situation. Finally got our food and finished on time, but felt rushed. Manager didn't seem to care and did not apologize. Just wanted his money. A good meal turned into a not so good meal. I see other comments about poor service. Could have taken $5 or $10 off the bill to show that he cared. Never going back. read more