I'll start by saying I did not like the tomato sauce. It has an acidic taste to it, I just couldn't get past it. The dough itself is really good, the Sicilian is so soft and spongy it almost felt like a puff pastry it's oil stayed on the sauce never dripped off. I had the spicy pepperoni and a regular slice of BBQ Chicken that comes with jalapeños. The bbq didn't taste like bbq at all tho. I enjoyed the toppings as well on both. You can tell everything is fresh and good quality. Like I said I couldn't get past the sauce. read more

Let me begin my saying I am NOT a big pizza fan, however this pizza is unlike any other. I think I could demolish this whole thing it's that good. You HAVE to get their Spicy pepperoni pizza and I also really enjoy their bbq chicken pizza but the true kicker is the RANCH! You just buy a bottle of their ranch because it is that good. Highly highly recommend read more

Prime Pizza - Spicy pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

The Caesar salad was a joke/rip off! We ordered the veggie pizza, and the crust was soggy and doughy.

Ordered this on Sunday at the pizza came burnt and the wings were dry. Unfortunately will not be ordering from there again. read more

Excellent pizza with a number of great choices. Terrific crusts in both the regular thin crust and more of a Detroit style. Quality toppings. The chocolate chip cookies are worth saving some room for. Nice, fast service. Nice sitting area outside, too. read more

Oh my gosh! We happened upon Prime Pizza and decided to go this afternoon when we saw that they had gluten free pizza (and not that cardboard, premade crust, but homemade crust.) We hoped for the best but expected the usual mediocrity. When we opened the box, we almost cried from pure joy and we knew it was going to be good. It was absolutely amazing. The BEST gf pizza hands down that we had ever eaten. The slices were square, and thick, with a delicious crispy crust around the outside. It was perfection and we left talking about our next trip back. Also, the staff was all smiles, and amazing. Can't wait to return! Bring all of your gluten free friends. They'll be so happy! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

Love the pizza quality at Prime. Staff service at this location is on point as well. Today I was eating a slice and as I was eating they noticed it was slightly burnt on the bottom and brought me a completely new slice, without me even asking for one. Much appreciated! Favorites: White, Vodka, Spicy Pepperoni, Sicilian read more

First time trying Prime Pizza in Altadena and giving this place 4 stars because the pizzas are just too darn thin. Yes, I understand what NY Style pizza is but pizzas need a few grams more dough. Sauce was also very light but will give this place a second try. Lunch species was $11 for 2 slices and a soda. read more

See all

Omg I got frustrated today. First time there and last time. Waited 45 minutes for a pizza and wings. They even forgot my ranch dressing. My kid was hungry and tired. I should have made her eat while I waited. Got home around 8 and just didn't care anymore. Sloppy honestly. Go to Barones! read more

The food was absolutely incredible and the pizza was insanely big The service was incredible too Overall i would recommend great pizza great service read more

Prime Pizza is so good! We only have a few pizza shops up here but I like this one too! It's a different style than the others and the ambiance is nice! read more

First time here I got a slice of grandma pizza & buffalo wings they wouldn't allow me to get all flats I was going to pay extra, my slice of pizza was cold the flats I ate was ok I didn't eat the drums because they looked as if they injected with steroids, my daughter got the meatballs she said they were good, the service was good the place is so small inside they do have outside seating I won't go back I prefer places where I can get what I like & accommodated read more

See all

Sodium overload- 12 hours later I'm still dehydrated. I wish I could say better things, I really want to like Prime.

Great pizza, great customer service. I just wish that the round pizzas came in a smaller size.

Love all of the various pizzas here. The buffalo wings are even delicious. I also love the Chopped Salad. That dressing is the bomb. Love this place. Great service and good to have a good pizza place nearby read more

After seeing Dave Portnoy's pizza review of x prime Pizza, we had to try it, gotta say not what I expected don't get me wrong it was good but not THE BEST pizza in LA, we ordered the peperoni pizza (well done) that arrived just normal baked, garlic knots, and meatballs, like I said all were solid and will order it again, but when you order a well done pie and don't get it, it's a little disappointing . read more

Went here twice. To be fair, I lived in NYC for many years and my taste for pizza runs to the realm of the snobbish, but in all honesty, the pizza here was not that great. What made is worse was the inconsistent level of service. Some of their workers clearly have not had proper training to say "hello" or "thank you" to customers. The times I went, there were two young women at the register area who spent a bit of time chatting between themselves and then barely took the time to get my order. Beyond that, if the pizza quality was better, I might have been able to forgive the subpar service, but it wasn't the best package overall. If you're not used to quality pizza, this place might seem like heaven to you. However, if you want high quality with better service, there are many other options around town. read more

So life is full of monumental moments and with them come monumental changes in life. People don't realize it but adopting a new local pizza joint into your regular rotation is one of them. When Prime opened up their Altadena branch in September we were one of the first ones there and picked up an assortment of food to try. It was good but it didn't move our meters quite yet. But their fabulous location and super inviting patio kept beckoning us so we returned. Still good but it didn't make us quite crave it. Then one day I noticed the Sausage & Kale pizza on the menu and added it to my internal "Try This" list and a few days later I picked it up. This one punched us in the face from the first bite and has made itself at home. We get this pie on a regular basis now and only took a small break from it when Prime did a collab with Jitlada a few weeks ago, and I gotta say that Curry Panang pie needs to be on the permanent menu! Anyway, pro tip for those ordering the Sausage & Kale: get it "well done" and half sliced. It makes the crust crispier, the kale more caramelized, and the extra cutting makes the slices easier to handle. Oh and get there early or late because parking is very limited. There's parking on the street but it's hilly and dark at night so don't wear the high heels. read more

See all

The bottom of the pizza was burnt, the sauce tastes like chef boyardee, they skimp out on the cheese

Heard a friend of mine talking about this pizza place, I decided to give it a try... Their pizzas are stoned baked and thin crust. I ordered the chicken tikka. The pizza was delicious, But based on the size and number of pieces of chicken on the pizza, I had to say the chicken was only for decorating, despite that it should be the main ingredient. I ordered a pick up and was charged a 15% tips which u didn't know why. I don't think I will go back again. read more

I've been here a few times. I was recommended by a good friend, Mr Aiden, a local of the area and big pizza fan. Always good service, good food and good times. read more

Consistently great product! Can never go wrong with the grandma sicilian. Just tried the vodka pizza yesterday too and it was delicious. Never a soggy pizza from Prime. Highly recommend! read more

I've been gluten-free for well over 10 years. This is by far the best gluten-free pizza I have ever had,like bring a tear to my eye delicious. I ordered through Postmates and it got here 30 minutes earlier than expected, everything piping hot. I got a gluten-free grandmas and added pepperoni and black olives My kids tried the regular spicy pepperoni rectangle pie, a chicken Parm sub and Caesar salad. They said the spicy was quite spicy, but delicious, and the Caesar salad was excellent The ranch was quite good. You can tell it's homemade. I'm not sure I will order pizza from anywhere else at this point moving forward! I have literally texted everyone in the area asking if they have tried it and suggesting they do so the next time they order pizza. read more

Prime Pizza - Gluten-free grandma's pie with pepperoni and black olives, five stars! - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

BEST. PIZZA. EVERRRR. We regularly (like weekly) drive from Whittier to Altadena for the pizza AAANNNDD the Ranch dressing! Every time we buy a pizza, we buy a bottle and it goes SOOO quick! Nothing but love for this spot. One bite.. you know the rules. read more

My kiddos love Prime Pizza so I was grateful to be able to pick dinner up after a long day today. Solid customer service isn't easy to find but Prime has my gratitude for going above and beyond and helping a mama out. We'll be back! read more

Wonderful pizza, especially the grandma style! amazing offerings- the chopped salad was also great. Super packed in its first week, look forward to coming back soon. read more

Excellent pizza despite the crazy opening weekend wait (so worth it). The Abriatta was delicious and loved that the spice was the end. Dough had a great chew factor to it as well. Yay for local, yummy pizza. We will be back and appreciate having local pizza joint to call our own in Altadena- the owners live in Altadena area as well. Pro Tip - they JUST opened - go at lunch or go for a slice to get quicker service. read more

Superbowl night, so busy kitchen. But still, the veggie pizza barely had veggies other than a few mushrooms and some kale. There were globs of pressed garlic in random spots. Also, almost no cheese, like comically little. So, just fairly dry crust and sauce. For $40 I expected more. read more

Oh boy! buckle up Altadena we have lift off! We are the home of JPL after all. And NOW the home of some the best pizza in all the land. Owner operator has opened up a gem in his own backyard and it shows. He's been hard at work to make this location extra special and it is... this will forever change Altadena in a very positive way. The outdoor picnic style communal tables are great along with a big tv playing the game. Every kid born in Altadena from this point on will have a memory here. It's an instant classic! Enjoy Altadena you deserved this! read more

See all

Great grandma slice and regular slice. Sauce was so tasty, dough and crust prepared perfectly. Thank you!

Great portions. Perfect for sharing. Service was on point. It was packed when I went. I love the white and also the Sicilian square

Just ordered a meat supreme pizza and there was literally 4 tiny pepperoni slices and even less sausage on each piece. Not worth the money or the hype read more

Very good pizza. I've enjoyed it several times now. I placed a delivery order using their web site today. Terrible website, practically impossible. I mean I guess I figured it out now, so it won't be as agonizing g next time, but if I hadn't promised my daughter and her friend pizza, I would gave bailed. Tried to place an order over the phone (my husband thought that they would take orders that way), but nope. I still like the pizza a lot. read more

Good pizza!! Lots of outdoor seating with TVs if you like to watch sports while eating Za. I've ordered takeout and dined in for a hot slice, both times really good food! I was a bit disappointed to get a Sicilian slice smaller than my palm that was $7. Otherwise, nice staff and pretty quick service! Ooh plus there's a cute coffee cart with pastries in the AM. read more

Prime is "okay" the photos look good, There's lots of people in line outside, they got great Dodger memorabilia on the walls. They're super efficient about getting you out of their quick. But def it was "ok" probably wouldn't go back. Something dry and bland about it.. read more

I don't know if the pizzas exactly New York style, but it is totally delicious! We love the Sicilian and the White pizza. The White is incredibly garlicky and just wonderful. The crust on the Sicilian isn't doughy, it's actually light and with a wonderful crunch. The mix of flavors on their pizza is truly unique and definitely makes you want to come back for more. Totally recommend Prime Pizza! read more

Prime Pizza - Prime Pizza Altadena outside seating area, and front entrance. - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

So glad Prime came to Altadena! The pizza is as close to NY as you can get and I'm so happy they're right here in the neighborhood! The square pies are delicious! Not too doughy and perfectly crisp on the outside. They're working out the kinks with pickup, especially on the weekends, but that doesn't stop us from getting our Friday night pizza night fix! read more

Ate cheese pizza here about 8 months ago, was good. Today cheese pizza was tough, little taste, barely could bite and chew. Maybe overcooked when warming in pizza oven? Should have sent back. Service fair. Ambiance was okay, flies in window by counter. Highlight was watching Olympics on their TV. read more

Delicious pizza and great vibes! Check out the Sicilian whole pie that we got. 'Twas a thing of beauty. Chewy, crunchy, focaccia-like crust and deliciously sauced with pesto, tomato, and ricotta. It's a nice big portion, so bring your friends! :) read more

Prime Pizza - Sicilian pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

This place is the best pizza joint in Altadena by far. I love that they sell pizza by the slice, and it's good too! I usually don't care too much about the salad or wings of a pizza place but it's SO good here. I love the buffalo wings and the dressing for their salad is good too! There's a cute outdoor area for sitting and enjoying your food. Love this place! read more