Parking is a pain, if lucky you might find a spot or double park and block others as I saw customers do so. Nice looking patio with a big tv to watch sports but when you go inside it's a cramped space where others are ordering. Service was ok, nothing but average. Now to the pizza. We ordered 4 slices of different pizza's and they did not taste fresh. How long do they keep them under the warmer before they decide to throw out. Thin crust but chewy. I do not understand the hype of why people go there. It's not worth the price for what it tastes like. I think people go because it's a close pizza place for locals in the area. I would not recommend it. read more

First of all their pizzas are way overpriced !! if their pizzas tasted great and out of this world, I might justify it.

this place is so racist my second time going and still forgot my order the first time i went they forgot my order as well i waited 25 min to ask that they barely put it in the oven to warm up my slice of pizza, i will never come to this location again, they accommodate their white people first read more

Stopped in for a slice while running errands. The fact that they even have slices was a big plus for this New Yorker and the pizza was hot and really delicious. In fact I'm going to go get dinner more! read more

Prime's supreme pizza and lemon pepper wings were absolutely delicious last night! The thin chewy crust was perfect, probably closest to the beloved Jersey shore pizza I've had. Definitely will be a repeat customer for the food, the crew, the guy working the door......it's all great, and it just works! Good job, Prime Pizza! read more

Prime Pizza - Awesome!!! - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Solid pizza and was ready quicker than expected. The salad was also good and fresh. This was a takeout order so the pizza was reheated in our pizza oven once we got home-if you have the means- I highly recommend this step. Delicious pizza. Wine shop close by at Altadena Beverage. Looking forward to trying their dine-in experience. read more

Thank you to Andrew for reaching out, top notch customer service. The prior experience was disappointing because Prime has been the best pizza in Altadena since they arrived, so im thankful that they were proactive in being receptive to feedback. read more

New York Italians know good pizza.... so we were skeptical to start. When we opened the box though..., "Wow, looks good!" But it's more about the taste, right? Again, that New Yorker snobby doubt... But, we were actually pleasantly surprised how much we enjoyed the white pizza with pesto from Prime Pizza in Altadena. Great crust...nice and thin and well cooked. Right there, worth the 5 stars! The topping was also very tasty, with a light ricotta that didn't weigh the pizza down. Maybe just a touch on the salty side, but we did add the pesto drizzle (which we love). We ordered takeout and it was ready in an hour, but I ordered at 6pm, so that's fair, during rush hour and well worth the wait. $35 is on the pricier side, but only by a few dollars really...and again, totally worth it! We will definitely go back to try other varieties. BRAVO Prime Pizza, ya done good! read more

Prime Pizza - White Pizza with pesto added. - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

My biggest complaint is not something that the business can fix -- a lack of parking because this place is too popular. I have ordered here before and a grandma slice as a weekend lunch is just nice. read more

Excellent pizza- great ingredients and a beautiful crust. Get the square pizza-Sicilian is my fave. Order ahead and avoid the wait. read more

I guess this is fine if you live in Altadena with kids. Sort of comparable to Chuck E Cheeses in terms of the crowd and sadly the taste of the pizza. The slices are precooked and conspicuously dry looking. After warming up they still tasted tough. The ingredients seem fine but the presentation leaves much to be desired. The overall vibe reminded me of Krispy Kreme's during the holidays, but it's pizza. Parking is a challenge because the parking lot is V shaped and lies at a busy star shaped intersection with cars traveling in all directions. I got stuck both entering and exiting the parking lot by customers blocking the driveways. read more

Great pizza. Nice place to take the family. Came in on Saturday for a quick slice on my way home. HUGE crowd there because of their one year anniversary apparently. Limited the slices to two per customer. No problem, I get it. Tried to order two slices of cheese but cashier said they're all out. This after I just saw them roll out two fresh cheese pizza pies(one of which was put on the shelf to serve as slices). The guy couldn't even be bothered to look over and see if there were cheese slices available? Nope. He automatically said they're out. I should've just gone to Prince Street read more

I've been looking forward to a great pizza place locally. Prime is walking distance from me and we love it. Line was out the door and the patio has a great ambiance to it. Baseball game was playing and the locals were out enjoying their pizza. They are sold by the slice and by the pie along side a great menu. Pasta and salad are also an option. Solid vibes all around. Keep up the great work Prime team. ‍ read more

See all

We tried a couple of sliced pizza (pepperoni and Vodka) as an after-dinner snack just because we saw so many people there! We love both of them. The place has nice outdoor benches and was crowded when we arrived quite late (~8:30pm). We'll return for a meal and try the whole round and maybe their wings. read more

Was good the first visit, the second time around the pizza was super burnt. I would just say I guess the quality depends on the day. read more

Prime Pizza - Was good the first visit second time pizza was super burnt, I would just say I guess you have to be careful on the days that you go. - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Ok no more slices for me, they don't taste fresh. It would be nice if they offered a small for us single folks who still want fresh pizza but don't want a massive amount of pizza. Just a thought. For now no more slices. read more

Thought I would give this a try, since it replaced the bakery that used to be in their building. It was okay. Nothing remarkable about it. Very average in my opinion. I may go back occasionally, but it is not my favorite by any means. read more

Very happy with this Pizza spot in the Pasadena / Altadena area...i cant really say anything bad about it...service very good...pizza specs all on point maybe abit rich but didnt matter. Fried wings awesome area clean tables clean but can get very packed...cant forget about the affordable lunch specials too. read more

amazing pizza, best i've had in a while. great price. nothing else to say about this place. love it! :) read more

Prime Pizza - sicilian square pie - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

It would have been 5 stars if they had a restroom, and had more reasonable parking. Pizzas are amazing when you order a full pie; beware, the lunch special pizzas are pre-cooked and warmed up not-to-perfection when ordered by the slice. read more

PIZZA IS SOOO GOOD. Ive had the Sicilian pizza twice, and I must say it is SOOO good, lots of flavor, good crust, and amazing topping. Garlic knots are also fire, they are PACKED with Garlic, and the blue cheese is SOO GOOD! Best blue cheese Ive had in awhile. They also had a wonderful selection of ready to slice and eat pizza's, but watching the steaming Pizzas go to the customers too was just so mouth watering. I will be coming back. Also, staff was very nice, and definitely get the job done, and seem like they know what they are doing, with confidence. read more

With out a doubt the best pizza in the area. The pizza place is a vibe and I'd say they are quite organized for just opening and how busy they are. Check it out you won't be disappointed! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

i think this is the cutest place, and the staff is very friendly, so I give it 3 stars for that. However, the pizza can use some improvements. I've been there twice now and ordered two pepperoni pizza slices. Much to my disappointment, the bottom of the crust was burnt. I've gone twice now and both times it was burnt. This last time I decided to take a picture and post it. Please Prime Pizza, tell your staff not to burn the bottom of the pizza. The flavor is good, but tasting the burnt flavor in the crust ruins it. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

We usually order the Pepperoni Pizza (round), but this time, we decided to try the Meat Lovers Square Pizza. I'm not sure if it was the sausage or meatball that tasted rancid, but we picked them off and ate the pizza anyway. read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Little Ceaser's is wayyyy better then this garbage Over priced wings $13 for 6 wings that were soggy and bland Pizza was good but no worth it Service was very bad read more

I ordered a slice of mushroom, black olives and pepperoni but we also tried the pepperoni and the spicy pepperoni square, not pictured cause it was gone before I could take a pic. All three were delicious and the whole staff is friendly and very helpful. The cute outdoor seating gives you the feeling of hanging out in a friend's backyard. I Strongly recommend stopping by and trying a slice or 2 read more

Prime Pizza - Pepperoni, black olives and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

Fast service, delicious food, and nice ambiance. May be my new pizza joint, and I am looking forward to coming again!!

Great place the pizza is a little pricey but very good. The staff were nice and our order was ready when promised .

Amazing Sicilian pie. Regular cheese pie was incredible. Great crust. Service was excellent too. Casual atmosphere.

Had the vegan cheese pie added mushrooms and olives. 32 bucks plus tax. Big pie. 8 big slices. Mushrooms were legit, roasted and delicious. Vegan cheese was best I've had. Def NY style. Crisp enough tho so tip doesn't flop when you fold it. Dudes were nice. Recommended. read more

First let me say... This was a great tasting pizza! Unfortunately... My wife and I ordered a pizza, I arrived a few minutes early. Order was soon ready, paid for and I was on my way. Arrived home in 6 minutes with a room temperature pizza and garlic knots. So close in so many ways! read more

Pizza with vodka sauce. Say no more! Delicious. Had delivered and still fresh and amazing even though DoorDash picked farthest location from me. read more

Im glad to have this at the corner of my house; super cute patio area that you can hang out at. It's definitely busy and can be hard to find seating but hopefully the hype will die down. The pizza itself was okay (we ordered to-go slices). Taste was as expected but none of the slices were heated up enough so it felt kind of stale. Had to give them a pop in the microwave at home. Please increase the temp or time that slices go in the oven! read more

I'm not going to lie - I ordered online and was surprised at their prices - but all that doubt went away right when I walked in the door. I was greeted by genuinely happy and caring staff who actually enjoy their job. Pretty much the Chick-Fil-A of pizza. There are no dimensions of the square pizza online, so I was shocked when I saw how large the box was. This pizza can easily feed 3-4 people. 2 square slices filled me up. The flavor was delicious, portions are huge, and it's finally a no-nonsense pizza in the Pasadena area. It's well worth the price and if you'd rather not buy a whole pizza, they also serve single slices. Very impressed and Prime will be a new regular stop, especially during football season! read more

Prime Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Altadena, California

See all

This place is WHACKKKKKK AF Walked in all pleasant-like excited to try this place, and "Andrew" was behind the counter with a sour look on his face and doesn't greet me at all. I said "Hey there! It's my first time here, so I'm taking a look at the menu and the pizzas you have displayed to get an idea." He doesn't say "oh hey thanks for coming in" or "welcome, lemme know if you have any questions", or anything. Just walks away rudely. So I have to deal with a garlic allergy, and wanted to try one of their square pizzas, cuz i love a chewy crispy oily crusted pizza. Keep in mind these are $30+ for a pizza, not counting tax and tip. This isn't a cheap joint like little Cesar's where they just sell ready made pizzas, but even Little Cesar's is willing to customize a pizza if you're willing to wait. Prime pizza makes everything fresh to order. They informed me that their regular tomato sauce is the only sauce that doesn't have garlic. Perfect, right? Nope. The manager named "Andrew" flat out refused to sub the garlic tomato sauce that they use for the square pizzas, for the non-Garlic tomato sauce. His reasoning was "oh it's policy because pricing is different blah blah." BULLSHIT. I said "no worries I'll pay $10 extra for the other sauce." After i offered to pay well above and beyond the price difference between the 2 sauces, his reply contradicted his first statement of pricing being the issue, and said "No we can't do it, it's against our policy." Like, what? Ridiculous honestly. I even tried joking around with the guy saying like "hey, I won't tell anyone, just "accidentally" put the non-Garlic sauce on it by "mistake"! The dude has the worst customer service etiquette I've ever seen, and has let the minuscule amount of power he has managing a pizza shop, go to his head. What a power tripping idiot. I told him it's a stupid policy, and left. I even called him back after I left, thinking that maybe this guy thought I was asking for a slice sized piece with different sauce, since I was looking at the pizzas sold by the slice. His reply? "No, I'm aware you were willing to order a new full pizza to take home. We don't care, it's against our policy." I've never heard a more asinine policy. read more

Sorry guys. I wanted to like it. I tried it twice. I just don't like it. None of the parts stand out. The sauce to me was bland. The people are nice tho! (Sorry I'm from a place where you trip over delicious Greek pizza in every shopping plaza so I shouldn't compare) read more

Pizza here is as close as you could get to an East Coast slice however, I only like their square pies, the crusts are crispy, and the sauces are more tangier than their classic cheese pizza, I think they classic pizza lacks salt and tanginess from the sauce. Overall, I'll give this place a 7.5 outta 10 read more

5 Stars. Maybe 6 Stars. Does not get much better than this. The hype is real. Great ownership, great management, unbelievable product. Consistent and authentic pizza. Wings are excellent, meatballs are the bomb and the salads are great, too. Doesn't get any better than Prime Pizza. read more

Pizza was absolutely delicious and our order was ready in no time! Their homemade ranch, however, did taste like hidden valley. I'd pass on that! Otherwise I'd definitely be back for their pizza. read more

It's a bit overpriced but that's not why I'm giving them 1 star. They have some Asian guy there who's the rudest person working at a restaurant I've ever seen. He told me to park somewhere else because he had more important customers though he didn't say that to anyone else. Then I see him again months later just a few days ago and I was working picking up for a customer and he told me I couldn't park there and I've I don't move my car they won't allow me to pick up the food, most ridiculous crap I've ever heard. Never buying anything from that place again and you have this guy to thank. This was at the Pasadena location. Response to Andrew: Well this isn't the first time you wanted me to move my car. The very first time I came there as a customer months ago you did the same thing, when there was no parking available you wanted me to move my car saying everyone is going to copy me but you didn't ask anyone else there to move theirs doing the same thing. No one else has given me a problem there besides you. As for picking up It's still a customer ordering whether it's being picked up for them or not so to treat a driver like there just taking up space is ridiculous, there are customers parked there that are ordering take out. If someone was camped out there that would be one think but either way I'm done with that location, trying to force someone to park a block away to pick up an order for a customer is ridiculous. read more