The filet mignon Pittsburgh style was so tender and perfectly cooked complimented by garlic mash and asparagus I was truly in fat guy heaven . The next best part was the salad that comes with had creamy garlic and all their other dressings are homemade. And I apologize no pics of my steak because I have to admit I was so hungry my phone was just getting in my way. I finished off with a piece of tiramisu which was perfect not too sweet and a great coffee taste and washed down with a delightful coffee. I did get a pic of desert because I was full. Kaila our server was so happy and just a pleasure to enjoy a meal with. The restaurant is very pretty and comfortable. Actually not bad on my wallet either. read more

See all

Went with my girlfriend who recently moved to the area. We sat at the bar and this non-busy midweek evening and was cared for by Alissa, who was really spectacular not only as a bartender and server, but clearly as a human. She added to our enjoyable evening at Prime. The surf and turf my girlfriend had had such a great presentation and equally good quality taste. I had their shrimp with were perfectly grilled. The wedge salad was on point and classic. And then layer on Frank Sinatra tunes in the background while sipping the well made martinis made by Alissa...a great evening. My only negative would be the calamari I thought would have been better, not hot. Maybe not a 5 in the options of a large metropolitan city, but for the square on downtown Crown Point, an absolute 5. Look forward to enjoying again when in the area. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Surf and Turf - Seafood Near Me - Crown Point, Indiana

A small, cozy atmosphere; everyone was very friendly and attentive. We were seated right away by the owner, who was warm and welcoming. We started with the crab cake, which was very good and had a little spinach on top. We then had the lobster bisque, and to me, it tasted like tomato soup. The bread was just sooooooo good, my husband kept asking for more. The medium-rare filet mignon was cooked perfectly, accompanied by garlicky mashed potatoes that were incredibly good. My husband had the New York Strip, which he said was very delicious. Our desserts were the carrot cake and the turtle cheesecake, both of which were delightful. Our waiter was lovely and attentive. read more

See all

Stopped in for a midday dinner with my family today. The restaurant is right on the square, and luckily we found great parking even with Oktoberfest happening at the pavilion. We started with the fried mash balls. Super tasty, though the plating was a little unusual (they came with some lettuce and what seemed like an Italian island style dressing?). Regardless, everyone at the table enjoyed them! They do serve bread and a herb butter - we LOVED IT. For the kids, we ordered the Alfredo with chicken and the chicken tenders. The Alfredo was delicious but a bit pricey at $17 for a kid's meal ($6 to add chicken). The chicken tenders were solid and came with wedge fries for $9. I shared the New York strip (medium rare) with mashed potatoes and asparagus with my husband. The steak leaned more on the rare side but was still flavorful and tender. It does come with bone marrow which was a nice surprise. The mashed potatoes were delightful, creamy and seasoned perfectly. The asparagus, while nicely flavored, was a bit firm and there were only about five spears, which felt a little light on portion. However, the steak was a great size although a bit fatty in some areas. Also, the salad that comes with this steak meal was a great size and very well prepared. Our waitress was wonderful! She even brought out what looked like the restaurant's own seasoning blend (in the plastic bottle and all) for us to try at the table, something I've never seen at a nicer spot before, but honestly loved because it added great flavor. We also ordered the lobster bisque, and it was rich, flavorful, and presented nicely. Definitely a solid 4/5. To drink, I tried their apple cider margarita as a mocktail, and it was delicious, the perfect fall inspired drink. All in all, a really enjoyable meal with great service and cozy vibes. Would definitely come back to try more! The only downside was we asked for a porterhouse but were told they were on the way to the restaurant which is why we went with the strip. We will have to try that next time we come! read more

See all

Everything food was amazing. Wednesday special 9 Oz filet is a great deal. Will be coming back most Wednesdays going forward

Ate here for the first time! Amazing atmosphere! This place is so pretty inside! Food was delicious and the martinis were so good! Our waitress was so kind and helpful with ordering! read more

Went here for the first time. I was a little hesitant after reading some not so great reviews. Service was great. They have fun drinks. I ordered the filet and it was excellent. Will definitely go back. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Oopa - Seafood Near Me - Crown Point, Indiana

For a second year in a row, I made reservations for my annual birthday dinner. Just a group of 4 women getting together to celebrate another year. Unfortunately this will be our last year visiting this restaurant. The service we received from the owner was less than desirable. We arrived for our 6:30 reservation and was told we would have to wait since we were 30 minutes late for a 6pm reservation. Confused, I pulled up the reservation confirmation text from the restaurant and showed the lady at the front as well as the owner. The owner shrugged her shoulders and said that not what we have. I looked at the paper list they had and pointed to my name and they had written in 6pm instead of 6:30. I told them I'm not sure why, but I have the confirmation in text. I asked the young lady at the front how long and she said she wasn't sure, maybe 10-20 minutes. I asked what was the point of the reservation. I also let her know that I wasn't upset with her, I just didn't understand where the confusion came in. I asked the owner could we at least give them the birthday cake to keep in the kitchen and she made sure to let us know there was a cake fee. Considering the fact that our reservation was delayed due to their error, they could have not charged fee since we were inconvenienced. My group began to wait in the small waiting area that they have along with maybe 6 other people, all waiting to be seated. There were so many people in the small space, they were lining up the stairs. Which in itself was a hazard. A couple of us decided to go upstairs to their other restaurant to utilize the bar while we waited. A couple of us also went to their enclosed outside area to wait. There was a heater present but it wasn't even turned on. So we joined the other ladies upstairs at the bar. Making the best out of the situation we enjoyed drinks and sushi while we waited. 45 minutes past our reservation time, the hostess came to tell us our table was ready. I immediately went down stairs and stood at the hostess stand. She seated two other parties while I stood there waiting. The owner then came over and I let her know that the hostess had said our table was ready. They both at the same time said it was ready and pointed to a table by the window. No one walked me to the table. They didn't even give me menus. Which I felt was weird considering I had just watched her seat other tables by walking them to their table with menus in hand. I sat and waited for another 20 minutes before our waitress came over. Kerri was amazing, attentive and very apologetic for something that was out of her control. She noticed we didn't have menus and went to get some for us. Our actual dinner experience was great. Our waitress Kerri made my birthday dinner enjoyable. The lack of accountability from the beginning is what disturbed us. The hostess stand is a very important role to have and it was very unfortunate that the hostess was not knowledgeable in her own. At no fault of her own, it seemed as if she was new and had not received the proper training. During a busy season such as the holidays someone should have been with her to help her answer questions instead of her having to find someone each time we needed information. When we were finally seated, I asked for the manager on shift and that is when I was told that the older lady I had been speaking to whom I assumed was a manager was in fact the owner. That was surprising considering the treatment she was giving. Having a birthday during the holiday season has prepared me for wait times and having to make early accommodations for dinner. But I was not prepared for the lack of accountability that was shown and from the owner at that. While my family and I have patronized Prime Steakhouse and Theo's over the years, this will be our last season. Thankfully we had a phenomenal waitress and that I have amazing friends who worked double time to ensure that I enjoyed my birthday dinner but the experience should not have been ruined in the beginning by the owner to begin with. read more

Treat your customers with decency and respect when they're standing there for over $100 for two people. Haven't been there in two or three years because of the rude owner read more

The entrees, especially the steaks, are expensive. We had the lunch special which was a hamburger and potato. The hamburger although obviously a frozen patty from Gordon's was decent. My friend asked for pickles and lettuce. The bill included a dollar each charge for the pickle and a dollar for a piece of lettuce. At their prices the condiments should be free with the meal! read more

Prime...the place is nice, the decor tasteful. The service is top notch. The steak is the best I've ever had. I only have a few minor critiques, first the menu was a laminated piece of card stock. While it lends itself to a tacky cheap feel, the real downside is the colores. It was a light blue with yellow or gold writing. This was nearly impossible to see in the provided light. I had to use the flashlight on my phone to read the menu. Second, I ordered mushrooms and onions on my steak. While they were very flavorful they were very sparse, just like a very small spoonful. I would expect that for the money, the steak should be smothered with them. All in all I will definitely be going back. read more

I think 3.6 is a correct rating for this place. Food was excellent. Staff. Meh. Bartender stays on her phone texting someone. And she's a bit crass. Waitress goes behind the bar and cursing about something. Oh and it's a shame you can't afford heat. Seven out of the ten people ate dinner with their coats on. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Crab cakes were excellent - Seafood Near Me - Crown Point, Indiana

See all

My wife and I decided to try this place as we heard good things about it from multiple people. We decided to try the East coast oysters and that was a mistake. They came out dry with no brine and tasted old. When we sent them back the waitress responded "they are fresh they shucked them at 4:00" when we were eating dinner after 7:00. Next we ordered the seared tuna appetizer which was another interesting item. The seared tuna came out with wonton chips, topped with bruschetta tomatoes and a balsamic glaze. The bruschetta overpowered the tuna and was a unique combination (there is probably a reason nobody ever does this combo). From there my wife ordered the fillet and I ordered the ribeye which came out cooked correctly and tasted good. The steak portions were massive and you get a salad with 2 sides with the steak so it was priced okay. The drinks were on point so that is the one thing this place has going for it. All in all we don't plan to go back to this place but it could have just been an off night for the joint. read more

Response to owner: The manager never apologized and just tried smoothing it over with an appetizer but my party is gluten free and could not eat it. I have never had any problems with any other restaurant when making reservations. You overbooked. Take responsibility instead of coming up with excuses fit for a child. read more

The manager insulted me, insuated that my palate was limited, was stereotyping, was rude, and unaccommodating. I would hate to think that she was racist but she left me no other way to feel. I would like for someone to resolve the issues at our visit since the manager on duty wasn't capable. Its a shame. That was our first time there and we will never dine there again. I expected so much more from Prime Steakhouse. Its disappointing. read more

I had the fillet and it was delicious. It was seasoned perfectly and I had a salad, asparagus, and a baked potato. From my understanding I was told that on a Wednesday night they have a special where you get that for $30 and it's half-price wine (bottle not glass). I went on a Saturday. The place does get very busy and I would suggest making reservations. Also note that if you take a booth in the far right corner near the bathrooms, you were also near the kitchen it's kind of loud over there. If you're looking for a area to have a nice day, I would say to try to avoid that spot. The other seating areas are very nice. They do have an upstairs where you can be seated, but it is a very steep climb so if you have anyone with mobility issues, make sure you don't get put up there. Just a heads up, I do have a heart issue and problems retaining water due to sodium intake. What I ordered seemed to be fine. When I went and weighed myself the next day, I did not gain any water weight. Typically when I go out to dinner anywhere I can gain up to 14 pounds overnight. So if you have anyone that has sodium restrictions in your group it seems to be OK.. read more

Poor customer service and unspecified restrictions on gift cards. Inattentive wait staff that constantly seem annoyed to help with anything. Subtle and not so subtle hints of racism. I'm not sure if the alleged quality of the steaks match what they claim. read more

Prime Steak in Crown Point was horrible! I used to enjoy this place but I don't think they value their loyal and regular customers anymore. The owner is in Florida allowing a little girl to make the rules up as they come along with gift cards. When I purchased the gift cards, it did not have an expiration date. The manager cut them up and disposed them. It was very rude and embarrassing. I will not and can't support businesses that treat customers like this. read more

I guess today was not the day to go. After waiting for more than an hour or our two meals (burger and steak sandwich), we still didn't have our meal and left without getting our meal. Staff was apologetic enough, but there was an apparent issue with kitchen staff that was effecting everything. Had they been upfront about wait times, we would have gone elsewhere and would not have had a negative experience. Drinks were fine and our appetizer generally came out in a reasonable time. read more

Twice now i have been here and both meals were horrible. Never received such terrible service! Perch was cold, potatoes burnt taste and it was so expensive. Another time i went and received the wrong steak and it was well done not Med. i will never go back again. Should have learned my lesson the first time! Ugh. They lost a good customer. Go to Kelseys. read more

our server Amber was great however they charge a 23 service fee for cutting our cake and never said anything about it and when I made reservations they never said anything and when I gave them the cake they never said anything. Management would not take it out for the bill read more

It was our first time to visit but Unfortunately we had the worth unprofessional experience in this restaurant, very bad Management team. I made a reservation for my wife Birthday and requested a Birthday dessert at the end of our dinner but It didn't happen, and when I questioned the GM, his answer in very arrogant way that restaurant is busy, plus what the menu is offering as USDA Prime Steaks, are not, quality is very low. not recommended read more

Super yummy! Cooked perfectly! Very friendly and happy environment Crab Cakes = awesome read more

Prime Steakhouse - Yummmmm - Seafood Near Me - Crown Point, Indiana

The food was great even though my order was not as ordered. I ordered the dry aged fillet but the steak that was served to me was not dry aged. If not for that small issue, I would have left a 5 star review as the regular fillet was still delicious and cooked to my specification. read more

Tuesday burger special with senior citizens discount. Burgers were wonderful. Had to go back for more the following week.

This was my first time ordering from here so I was looking forward to my meal. It was dinner for our anniversary. I placed my order online for delivery. I ordered the calamari and stuffed meatballs for appetizers. I also ordered the 26oz steak and the filet mignon topped with crab meat. The manager called to advise that they forgot to send my appetizers. The food I did receive was good but I don't think it was worth the price. read more

See all

The hostess and waitress were polite. The food was terrible. My husband and I each ordered a 26oz dry aged ribeye which was, as you can imagine, not cheap. We love steak and enjoy trying new steakhouses. This was the least tender ribeye I've ever had. I could've gone to Applebees for quality this low. I was shocked that this is considered to be a high end steakhouse. To top it off, my husbands steak was not seasoned. Honestly, someone forgot to season it. You could clearly taste the seasoning in mine yet his was very bland on top of it not being tender at all. When we told the waitress she didn't seem to know how to handle a complaint. We weren't asking for a refund. But a replacement steak could've been offered. Especially considering the price of each steak. What our waitress did instead was bring out the seasoning for my husband to add himself! What kind of steakhouse does this?! And lastly, we ordered dessert and were equally disappointed. He ordered the banana cheesecake. It had a very artificial banana taste. I've never had a banana dessert taste so poorly from artificial flavors like this. I got the turtle cheesecake which was ok. I am so disappointed in the quality of the food and the staff's lack of effort to rectify the situation. I will never come back here or any other establishment owned by Theo. read more

Prime Steakhouse - Seasoning the waitress brought to be added to this poorly made steak. - Seafood Near Me - Crown Point, Indiana

See all

Food was good but could've been better. Order shrimp cocktail and one wasn't deveined?? Love the restaurant scene in crown point.

Traveled in from New England to visit the in laws at Thanksgiving. So excited to see this restaurant online for both the ambience and menu. The vibe of the place was great, service was fine, but the food was sub par for regular prices, let alone the prices on this menu. Couldn't even eat my meal it was so bad. Will not return when we're back in town. read more

Food was delicious and atmosphere was great. We were a group of 6 for a friends bday and we had a great time. I think Scott was our waiter and he was very attentive and friendly. I highly recommend this place for a nice night out. read more

We had a recommendation from the coin shop around the corner.. We started out with a sauteed calamari. Some of it was rubbery, but the overall it had a good flavor. My rack of lamb was the best I've ever had! My husband and DIL had the filet mignon, and my SIL had the bone in rib eye. We were all very pleased with our meal. For dessert, my husband and I split the carrot cake.. As did my SIL and his wife. read more

See all

Food was nice, service exceptional and ambiance very much upscale and classy. I would definitely go again

Good experience overall. Steaks were very good but a bit on the higher side in pricing. Wine selection was good and sides/apps were all on point. Was a touch crowded and we had a large party so it felt a bit cramped. Had to put down a reservation deposit for a group of 8 which seems odd for the area. Never had that experience before. Again I would recommend a visit and would definitely return read more

Outstanding Christmas Eve dinner. Very accommodating, service was good and food amazing. We had a larger party of 9, the food all came out on time and did not disappoint. Steaks and salmon were cooked perfectly, ribs melted off the bone and the chicken marzleus (sp?) very tasty. We will definitely be back... CB read more

$100 per plate, lobster tasted like it was cooked with broccoli or rotten, 1lb of crab legs was $105, you may still be hungry when you walk out of there. Not impressed at all! read more

Over-priced and food was not as good as i expected. Service staff was great.and nice ambiance. read more

Great place to dine in.nice atmosphere here service is terrific like any were else little pricey,but who cares when you want a great meal.luv this place which also has a great bar. read more

My daughter ordered a gift card/certificate from this place before Christmas for a gift, and as of 1/7/2024, it has NOT been delivered. We do not live in Crown Point, so it needed to be mailed, and this place keeps giving her the runaround. First they said they would mail it, nothing. Then after about 10 days she reached out to them and they said, oh we thought it was an e-gift card and we'll send it to you with tracking information. After about 10 more days, no gift card and no tracking information. But they sure took the money in a hurry! read more

Did not honor our reservation made through the Resy app that they suggest on their website.

Went for late lunch with my husband on a weekday afternoon. They sat us in the window at a table for 6 (?) but did give me the chance to opt for a diff table. I figured why not sit in the window but I should have went with a diff table. Mainly bc I don't like feeling like I'm literally in the midst of staff convos at the host station. It was fine tho and I understood. Our server Leslie was good. No introduction of herself when she showed up to the table and also no offering of the dry aged special. Not super warm but I'm ok with it and she was a good server. Food: bruschetta app = good. It's our fave, we get it everywhere and Prime knows how to do it. Main: I ordered "small plates" and wanted my side salad + stuffed meatball app to come with my husbands meal and I mentioned this when i ordered. My side salad was brought with my husbands salad but I went with it. Salad - eek. Was for sure yesterday's "Salad in a bag" situation. GOOD homemade dressing tho. Meatballs: good, nothing noteworthy. Steak: my husband ordered the porterhouse (I'm not a steak eater) and confirmed it was well seasoned and a great cut. This is a steak house so super glad for them they got The steak right. read more