Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Proof Handmade Bagels

    4.9 (48 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Proof Handmade Bagels Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    More like Proof Handmade Bagels

    Recommended Reviews - Proof Handmade Bagels

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Menu offering from Proof for Jan 31, both the classic selections as well as the specials
    Stephen S.

    This place is so good it's become a ritual for me. On a weekly basis I'm putting in my pre-order and enjoying delicious bagels all weekend long (about as long as they can last without getting gobbled up). These are the best bagels I've had outside of New York in as long as I can remember. The everything bagel is outstanding, I've always liked many of the weekly specials including the French Toast bagel, which is definitely sweet but totally my type of jam. Definitely follow them on Instagram to check out their rotating weekly specials or you can always go with the plain or everything, also delicious.

    Daph H.

    If you're reading this wondering whether to get Proof Handmade Bagels, the answer is a resounding YES! These are the best bagels in OC, thick and chewy and everything you could possibly want in a bagel! I'm updating my review because I tried their French Onion bagel and OMG it was AMAZING! It tastes just like French Onion soup but in bagel form. Sure, it's a little pricey at $4.50 but it's totally worth it! My daughter bit into their French Toast bagel and said, "YUM!" She was half-tempted to eat it with maple syrup because it tasted just like its namesake. Another winner! Their blueberry bagel is good, but not the flavor bomb that these two are. Their plain bagels are also perfect too! Definitely order ahead so you can skip the line and ensure that you get the bagels you want! Plus if you preorder, they have a buy five, get one free deal (at least at the time of this review they do). Proof always sells out so preorder! You won't be disappointed!

    Everything Bagel, French Onion Bagel, and Aglio e Oilo Bagel
    Kimberly N.

    Rosa and Rich, you've changed my weekend AMs for the better! Proof Bagels have touched down to the Irvine Farmers Market scene, and I can frantically run two blocks from my apt every Sunday morning to get my bagel fix in now. (I've been following Rich's bagel development from its Reddit days and haven't gotten the chance to try them for myself until the Irvine landing.) These bagels are the plumpest, fluffiest, and most well decorated bagels I've had since... probably ever. Proof is worth the AM detour, and if you're worried about the bagels selling out (which they do), use their website and order ahead! Ordering ahead allows you to skip the ordering line and guarantees you your chosen bagels.

    Bagels are great! I am a hobby home baker, but this is the real deal. And the scallion cream cheese is great. We ate these bagels at the Old Towne Orange Farmers Market on Saturday mornings.

    Everything Bagel- $3
    Mary D.

    I came across Proof Handmade Bagels at the OC Great Park Farmer's Market, and they were delicious! They are Asian-owned and very friendly and welcoming. I got an everything bagel in the morning and it stayed fresh all day, and was still soft when I ate it in the afternoon with cream cheese. Yum! I can't wait to get more bagels from these guys. They are located at the Great Park Farmer's Market, which has recently moved to Stonegate Elementary at 100 Honors, Irvine, CA 92620, every Sunday from 10am -2pm. Happy eating!

    Alice S.

    OMG these bagels are so good. I tried their French Onion, French Toast, and their Rosemary and Sea Salt and they were all so chewy and delicious. You have a customer for life now! And the owners are so nice and provided amazing customer service at the farmers market. I definitely recommend you pre-order as they will have your order ready for you so you can just pick up! They sell out fast so this is a great way to make sure you get your bagels. Their specialty cream cheese is also very good and tastes so fresh.

    Rosemary and sea salt w/black garlic  cream cheese
    Shruti T.

    These handmade bagels are AMAZING! If you are in the OC they travel to different farmer's markets. I pre-ordered and picked mine up in Irvine. We are a bagel loving family and these are so soft and fresh tasting! @proofbagels - so yum!

    Bagels (individually wrapped)
    Emily N.

    I'm not one to review many places, but these bagels take the cake!! I've been far and wide across the nation eating bagels, and this is one of the best I've eaten so far. I've tried their blueberry, everything, french onion, french toast, jalapeño asiago, and sea salt bagels. Every single bagel is delicious, crispy, (but also amazingly) chewy, and perfectly fluffy! They also sell amazing cream cheese options, including smoked salmon and chive cream cheese. I always order online (find them on IG @proofbagels) and am greeted with a smile every time I come pick up. It's part of my biweekly ritual, and I love sharing with my coworkers at the hospital too who love their bagels!

    Richard and Rosa in action :)
    Jason C.

    A big fan of this brand since day one at the market. For all you bread lovers out there, you NEED to try proofbagels! Bagels - THE BEST!!! All bagels are prepped days in advance and freshly baked right before each market. These are hands down some of the best East Coast-style bagels you'll find on the West Coast. The quality is unmatched. Cream Cheese - In house made cream cheese is a must try. From the classic scallion cream cheese to other special flavors. Ever since they introduced the pre-order/pick up system, the lines have become much easier to all customers and they move very quickly Really grateful for this preorder/pick up system!! Let me give you a PRO TIP here... I HIGHLY RECOMMEND ordering from their online website because their products often sell out at every market. Plus, it makes the whole process smoother. Your bagels and cream cheese are pre packaged and guaranteed to be ready for pick up. The two owners, Richard and Rosa, are always there, working hard to make sure everything runs smoothly. They've been continuously improving the menu and operations since day one. Their kindness and dedication are evident, and they always greet you with genuine smiles while serving up the most delicious products. GO VISIT !!!

    Proof-Sesame Bagel

    Finally--a real bagel in California without having to travel all the way to New York! Look at this beauty: perfectly crispy on the outside and wonderfully chewy on the inside. The cream cheeses are to die for--we got the scallion and the salmon, and both were incredibly flavorful and delicious. I'm so glad we finally have something this good locally. Thank you so much Proof for sharing your delicious bagels with us!

    See all

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 3
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 2

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Bagels and service both deserve five stars. Great people, great bagels. Pre-order makes it easy. No bad flavors.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    OMGosh these bagels are sooo good. Garlic, parsley and parm. It's a mean on its own my weekly farmers market treat I look forward to!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 1
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 2
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Proof Handmade Bagels Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Proof Handmade Bagels

    Review Highlights - Proof Handmade Bagels

    I've tried their blueberry, everything, french onion, french toast, jalapeño asiago, and sea salt bagels.

    Mentioned in 8 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    East Coast Bagel - the west coast bagel

    East Coast Bagel

    4.4(1.2k reviews)
    5.7 mi
    $

    Best Bagel in Town! Hands Down! The texture honestly…read moresurprised me, it really reminds me of NYC bagels. It's not as fluffy, but it's perfectly chewy, and the ingredients inside taste so fresh. My favorite part? You can grab fresh bagels to go along with your favorite cream cheese! The workers even handed me a bagel fresh out of the batch, you just have to ask. Best service ever! It's super kid-friendly with tons of seating both inside and outside. I came on a Saturday at 10:45 AM and got through the line pretty quickly. The bagel sandwiches are amazing, if you're a cream cheese lover, you can add it right into your sandwich. I loved mine with egg and cheese, and I can't wait to come back!

    Couple things, this is what I would imagine bagel shops on the east coast operates. You walk in…read moreand it's a line next to a bunch of tables cramped and it smells amazing AND you can't wait to order ALL the bagels because the flavors!!!! BUT I would suggest to get the bagels home and prepare the meal yourself. Because I forgot to ask if the huevos ranchero & cheddar has meat in it and it was loaded with ham. And I had to watch other people get their delicious single bagel first before mine was ready and I was so hungry!!! But I digress. The egg & cheese was good though but cream cheese smear was not enough. Overall super cheap fluffy delicious bagels I would come back for but I'll load the cream cheese me self next time.

    Photos
    East Coast Bagel - Bagel selection

    Bagel selection

    East Coast Bagel
    East Coast Bagel - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    2.9(654 reviews)
    3.0 mi
    $

    - Disappointed that Costco's gift card offer for Einstein Bros. Bagels splits into FIVE $10 cards…read more Already inconvenient enough to have to scratch the PIN cover off 1-2 cards, but FIVE?? - Late to realize ordering online doesn't take gift cards. That's new. Other chains, can use gc to order online. Had to pause my online ordering, drive in-store, then place my order from the beginning, use the gc's in-person. + Pleasant ambience. Nice, helpful, accommodating staff. . Carb-heavy, but guess it's in the name. Short on protein (meat/seafood) and fiber and other nutrients. Gotta add on more and more (like the $5.49 Lox salmon) to meet your nutritional needs. + Ample interior seating. + Ample but somewhat crowded parking. - Slow traffic. Thanks Costco for teaching me yet another don't-frequent gc spot. That makes 6: PF Chang, CPK, Lil Sis, Honey Ham, Fogo. And one yes: Lucille. I had: $13.99 Brunch-2 + $8.99 Bacon&Ched Brnch Spec + $6.99 Garden Avocado + $5.49 Lox + tax = $37.78

    0 star for In-Person purchase- after paying for my order, the host said we don't slice or toast…read morebagels here because this service is ONLY offer for online purchases. Interesting! I'm assuming this rule only applies to this host and/or location. Why was my in-person order different from last week? 5 stars for Online Order- coffee and bagel we're ready for pick-up. Coffee was freshly brewed. Exactly as I ordered it. Toasty!

    Photos
    Einstein Bros. Bagels
    Einstein Bros. Bagels
    Einstein Bros. Bagels

    See all

    Oliboli Donuts - Spring box

    Oliboli Donuts

    4.7(2.1k reviews)
    7.9 mi
    $

    wish i could gatekeep this place, but i just can't help but…read moredeclare my love for this establishment the freshest fluffiest "real" tasting donut i've ever had, blows krispy kreme out of the water, husband even said "these donuts make others feel like prop food!", such an exceptional donut, dare i say best in orange county? the sourdough leavened dough is not only more gut friendly but has a depth of flavor that one can only describe as "wow!" maple glaze and plain glaze are life changing, cardamom bun for middle eastern flare service is above and beyond! they let me know they didn't have one of the glazes for their donuts and gave me a donut for free just for the inconvenience! the young brunette man and young blonde gal were super sweet polite and helpful! a true family establishment, cute decor and whimsical aesthetic!

    40 hour sourdough fermented donuts that are made fresh to order and change monthly?! What more does…read morea person really need?! The seasonal drinks are just as divine and inspired by California seasonal offerings. I have managed 3 donut shops in my lifetime and make donuts for fun at home, so to say I'm a donut enthusiast would be an understatement. I know a good donut when I have one and these are spectacular. You can taste that everything is homemade in house and it truly makes a difference. The decor is always cute and the staff are always friendly. Though their regular/non-rotating donut flavors are just as good (the butter pecan, plain, chocolate glazed and bumbleberry), if I'm making the drive all the way out here, I prioritize their monthly flavors first. Next time you find yourself in the OC area, swing by and grab a dozen or two to share with friends.

    Photos
    Oliboli Donuts - These are my people! "Carpe donut!"

    These are my people! "Carpe donut!"

    Oliboli Donuts - Peche Frache

    Peche Frache

    Oliboli Donuts - Croque Monsieur with ham, Gruyère cheese, and mornay sauce

    See all

    Croque Monsieur with ham, Gruyère cheese, and mornay sauce

    Cream Pan - Azuki creams  IG: @chow.witme

    Cream Pan

    4.5(7k reviews)
    7.5 mi
    $

    This place is such a mystery. How could someplace so…read moreunattractive and run down produce the very best bakery items in Orange County? The old adage "You can't judge a book by its cover," is true here. This place looks forgotten, ignored, unassuming, but produces the finest bakery items in Orange County. You enter and have to immediately get into a line. Inside, it is like a aged cafeteria of your childhood. You have to wait for a young lady who can't even look over the top of the counter because there is so much stuff piled high. She stands on tip toes to see you and you have to shout at her and point what you want. The problem is when she sees you, you are near the cash register, so you must say excuse me and walk in front of a line of people to point and shout out what you want. It is so poorly designed and complicated to order. We all endure because like the Soup Nazi on Seinfeld, the product is worth it. They sell the world's best Olive bread, scones, and strawberry crossants. If you survive the line, you make it to the cash register, pay, get a bag and leave. There is no where to sit. There is no internet. They shuffle you through and on to the next one. The pastry items are incredible and worth the trouble.

    I tried Cream Pan recently, and enjoyed their bread a lot. They serve a wide variety of pastries…read moreand breads. They also have some sushi on their menu. Food: My favorite bread is the olive bread It tastes fresh and incredibly delicious. It had a lot of olives on it, which I liked. However, the onigiri was just okay. It was almost all rice and had very little mentaiko in it. Service: The service here is good. Ambiance: The decor outside is a bit outdated.

    Photos
    Cream Pan - Raisin bread ($4.80). 8/11/2024

    Raisin bread ($4.80). 8/11/2024

    Cream Pan - Strawberry Banana Croissant, Strawberry Croissant

    Strawberry Banana Croissant, Strawberry Croissant

    Cream Pan - It's called epic

    See all

    It's called epic

    Proof Handmade Bagels - bagels - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...