We live in Deerfield and have enjoyed the food at the Highland Park location (we mostly get takeout). So we decided to give the new location a try, even though the ratings have been so bad. Well! I learned my lesson! Always trust your fellow Yelpers!
We had a pretty bad experience there tonight (a Wednesday). I first arrived there by myself, while I waited for my husband to drop off our 3 year old son, so that we can have a mother-son dinner date. (My husband had another engagement.) The host informed me that they are "booked" and to just let him know when my dining companion arrived. So I asked him whether we can just sit at the bar and start ordering (you maximize your time when you are visiting a restaurant with a toddler). He said yes so I took a seat at the bar and ordered my food with the friendly bartenders.
As the food arrived, and as I ordered a kids' milk for my soon-to-arrive son, the bartender realized that my companion is three years old, and informed me that it is against Illinois law to sit at a bar unless you are 21. I was surprised about that but was willing to move to a table if they had one. The bartender proceeded to notify the host of the situation. At this point my son arrived and so we just stood next to our food at the bar, and waited. Another waiter saw us standing there looking at our food, with my son squirming and eager to start eating, told us to just go ahead and sit down, that he will tell the host that it is ok, knowing it won't take us long.
Two minutes after we started eating. The host came up to me, and basically said in an accusatory tone, that I did not tell him my son is 3, and it is against the law to sit at the bar. I explained to him that I had NO idea there is such a regulation, that no one asked, so i just did not think I needed to tell him, but I am willing to move. Since the restaurant is extremely loud, I had to raise my voice to be heard. The host then asked me to "calm down", and told me that I have "elevated this to an unnecessary level". I wasn't even remotely angry before he said that, and was simply attempting to defend myself, so it was just really unpleasant to be told by the host that somehow I am losing my cool, when I was not.
After this interchange, they placed us at a table. At one point, an older man who works there next to the host came up to us to see how we are doing. I explained to him what happened and he merely semi-acknowledged the situation and acted like he was really not that interested to find out why I was displeased. The only person who showed concern was the first bartender who took my order.
So, if you want top-notch customer service. Forget about this restaurant.
OK, the food: we only ordered the Fusilli Carbonara so can only comment on this dish. Carbonara in general is NOT a difficult dish to execute: you have the bacon, the peas, the mushrooms, the cream...how can it be bad? Unfortunately, they delivered a truly lackadaisical dish with a watery sauce...and that is BAD for fusilli because that means the sauce is not clinging to the noodles. The result? Bland noodles, semi-tasty sauce.
Also, everyone was completely correct in that it is EXtremely loud in there. There is NO way to talk to even a dining partner across from you without yelling. As we were leaving, other patrons who were also walking out were saying how much of a relieve it was to leave the restaurant and be out of the noise.
Too bad! Deerfield is in general super pathetic when it comes to restaurant offerings, so we had high hopes. ...Sigh... Back to cooking at home... read more