Hands down best pizza and subs. Been going to Rose's for decades. The Sicilian pizza is out of this world.

Amazing place! We drive 25 min for their sandwiches. Best ever!! I haven't had their pizza but heard it is really good as well. Very friendly place with amazing food. read more

I have been coming here since 1985. Their hot sandwiches are my favorite. The bread comes from a local Garfield bakery and is crisp on the outside and the inside is perfect. They have a Cold Sub Parmigiana that is an amazing sandwich. Their Veal and Chicken Parmigiana sandwiches are made with expertise, and the sauce is delicious. They keep their ovens nice and hot and the pizza is tasty, too. I am remis in not posting something about them years ago, but here it is now! read more

Ever since moving to NJ many years ago, I've been in the search of that deliciously cheesy, crispy, and oh so good New York style pizza. I think I've just about ordered from almost all local joints that deliver to my area. Based on the reviews, this place seemed like the next candidate in my hunt. Not sure about others, but pizza isn't pizza without the spices for me, and my must-have's are oregano, crushed red pepper, garlic powder, and black pepper. So when placing an order, I always put on the notes to please, please, put those spices on the side. On this order, to my surprise, none of the spices were present. So I called up the restaurant, NOT to have them send it, but to make sure to check the notes in the future as there was nothing that can be done at that point. The person on the phone interrupts me and starts telling me (with a bit of an irritated tone) that they were busy and didn't have packets. I told them that maybe they could have put them in those small plastic containers (like most places do), and he continues on with the whole busy thing. A restaurant being busy is not my problem. I'm a paying customer as well. Are delivery orders less important than eat-in orders? I'm not sure what their stance on it is. But one thing for sure, I won't be ordering from this place ever again. Oh and the pizza itself? Mediocre at best. read more

Great Pizza. Great Sandwiches. They are my local go to place for take out!! I cannot recommend them enough. The pizza has just the right amount of sauce, cheese and oil. The sandwiches are loaded. read more

Marinara pie is amazing.. Garlicky with a nice a oiled crunchy crust... 9/10 The italian hero was on toasted italian bread which really stood out among others... 9/10 read more

Rose's Pizzeria - italian hero - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Definitely can't go wrong with their pies, tuna sub, or their chicken cutlet sub. One of the better pizzeria's from around the area.

Ordered a plain slice and a Sicilian slice. Both were given to me overcooked. I don't think the guys behind the counter wanted me there. Here's the breakdown: 1 - They give my original order to someone else because they forgot that I had ordered. 2 - The second order was super well done. Like crust as crunchy as Stella D'Oro breadsticks crunchy. 3 - Guy forgot my soda 4 - I hand the guy my money to pay for my order and he throws my change on the counter. 5 - No "thank you" or "come back soon" from anyone behind the counter. I normally don't even care about service so long as the food is good. But this place is probably the 3rd best pizzeria in Garfield. Definitely not worth the drive or trying to negotiate a parking space in the private lot. Every single person in here but me was eating an Italian hero. The place is a friggin pizzeria, they should be known for their pizza right? And if I put money in your hand you better put the change back in my hand, that's just common courtesy. Maybe they were having an off day. Or maybe it's because I'm Asian. Who knows? I've definitely had better... read more

Rose's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Hands down, this is the best pizza in town, or around! Sicilian is a must have, regular pizza is just right & their subs will rock your world. The guys who work there are just as awesome. Funny, welcoming & loyal (they've all been there for years). And they never forget a regular customer. read more

ive been coming here for years ordering their pizza for lunch. They make a very good regular cheese pizza. Yum! the workers are very friendly,and since we go in there quite often, they always remember us. Prices are good. THeir turkey sandwich is always quite good also! We have also called ahead of time with our orders, and they have it ready for us. read more

I've been coming to Rose's since 1978 and still have cravings for their Sicilian pie. In addition to their unique Sicilian pie, their cold sub parmigiana is great but eat it in while the cheese is melting and hot on top of the cold cuts. I hope to continue going to this spot for another 30+ years . read more

Worse pizza iv ever had . Soggy soupy absolutely discussed. Called to let them know and was disgarded. Do yourself a favor and order dominos. read more

Rose's Pizzeria - Gross ! Ugh worse ever - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Get a sandwich!!! Best decision you'll ever make. The guy that owns the place is always there and hes super nice. I got there frequently so he kind of knows my friends and I and he jokes with us a lot. The pizza is delicious, but i always get a sandwich. They are AMAZING. What makes their italian sub better then anywhere is the bread. I dont know where they get it from but its delicious!! they heat the roll in the oven first , then put your meats and other sandwhich accessories on after and it makes for this hot/cold combo that is amazing. Deff worth checking out. read more

This is the best Italian hoagie I ever had. The entire sandwich is fresh right down to the bread. A perfect mix of red onion and banana peppers. I absolutely recommend this sandwich. read more

My wife and her family have been coming to Rose Pizza for 20+ yrs. The place is clean, the owner is cool and the food is always good. We usually get a few slices and share a #10 hero. IMHO this is the closest to NY pizza... read more

No that a great chicken sandwich and was made fresh and fast great place to pickup or eat in and service was great will come by when I'm this area read more

Rose's Pizzeria - Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

Place use to be the best around you can find, old school no frills l, just good pizza and sandwiches. In the past year the prices have surged (which is fine as long as it's the same) but the quality and the service has turned to "crap". They care about getting out the orders quick for Uber eats and really could care less about the regulars and the patrons that kept this place afloat for years upon years. Guys need to get back to the basics when this place use to be a staple please! read more

I've been coming here since I was a child. Best Sicilian pie around! If you are not in the mood for pizza try a #8 cold sub on toasted bread with the works! They don't deliver which is a shame, however, I don't mind traveling two towns over for quality pizza. read more

Rose's Pizzeria - Plenty of seating, very clean! - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

See all

A while back My dad and I got really really sick from a chicken sandwich from disgusting dive, so sick he almost died. He was in the hospital for 8 days. Bacteria infection and salmonella positioning. When I confronted them about it I was told to go fu_k my self and my father too . Now I tell everyone I know not to ever go there. happy holidays rose's I don't forget how nice you were. read more

I really enjoyed them. The prices were decent and their food was good. We ordered the garlic knots, sandwich, and pizza. The only thing is that the pizza does not stay together whatsoever. We ended eating the pizza with a fork. read more

A special shout out to roses pizzeria .. keeping everyone safe during these times.. I picked up dinner last night 3 hero's and a couple of marinara pies.. food is awesome!! Another thing is the professionalism of the entire staff taking control and guiding their customers.. and making me feel a lot more comfortable with this entire take out and social distancing process. read more

I just had a slice and it was really good . The owner is nice . They have a lot of parking depending on what time of day you come. It's a strip mall. read more

Great pizza! The pizza brings back fond memories I have of eating at old school pizzerias as a child. Nothing like a fresh, hot pizza out of the oven. They don't deliver but you can order through Uber eats and have it delivered. The toasted Italian sandwiches are pretty good as well. read more

This is the BEST pizza I have ever tasted hands down! The sauce is delicious! Most of the other food is high quality as well. The hero's are awesome and the bread is toasted! Mussels are hot and sweet. I prefer the hot. There is nothing bad to say about this place!! read more

They are just the best. I drive to Garfield just to get their Italian sub and Pizza.

Very good pizza. But also very good sandwiches. The oven hot Italian is very good as well as meatball or chicken parm hero. Can't go wrong here read more

Stopped in for a slice based on a recommendation from a friend in Hasbrouck Heights. Never been. Best slice of regular cheese pizza I've had in probably 30 years or more. Obviously I have a certain style that I like. Thin, crispy crust, folds well, a crunch, etc. Perfect mix of cheese and sauce, awesome. Another sign of a great place, the door never stops swinging with people coming in for pies and slices meanwhile there's 150 pizzerias within a 3 mi.² radius. Just figured out that on a conservative basis I've had over 9000 slices of pizza in my life and this slice was definitely in the top 1% or better. I'm going back immediately. Also when I told the owner it was a great slice of pizza he stated of course it is It's the best. read more

My husband and I moved to the area 12 years ago. Since then we had been trying to find a close local pizza place we could call 'amazing', not merely just good or ok. Roses pizza is certainly amazing. Our kitchen is being renovated we've had no working kitchen to use, so decided to try Roses for the very first time last night. Friends had recommended we try the Sicilian pizza here, we gave it a shot. Needless to say my husband and I have finally found our amazing pizza, it deserves every one of the 5 stars. Everything about it is perfect for our taste, and what we consider to be perfect pizza. For us to call it that, it has to have the following attributes: a great yeasty crust with some crunch on the outside, elasticity inside & lots of flavor in the crust, tangy flavorful herby sauce & delicious 'real' cheese, and quality pepperoni. Our first time we bought a 1/2 pepperoni & 1/2 regular Sicilian pie. The peperoni on it was the best peperoni I've ever had on a pizza-- yum! That's saying a lot after 50 years of my husband and I trying different pizza throughout NJ & NY. Now we finally have a place to order from when we want great pizza!!! It took years to find this place but was worth the wait. read more

Pizza crust tasted old and moldy.. first time ordering from here. Tired Also of trying to order online with poor services vs expensive fees. What about a great tasting crust and pizza instead of everyone making shit pizza more expensive? read more

I lost my virginity and had Rose's for the first time the same day about 15 years ago. The #7 was easily the best thing that happen to me that day.. The crunchy toasted hero.. sweet creamy mayo .. tangy banana peppers ... YUMMY SIDE NOTE: I asked my ex gf is I could serve the Sicilian pizza cut it bit sized and serve it at our wedding.. cool and funny dudes read more

Have been coming here for YEARSSS and the food always tastes the same - great!! Theirs pizza is the best in the area, all subs are really delicious from cold to hot. Owner is awesome and very friendly. Big con is that they dont deliver and parking is sometimes an issue there. Otherwise A+ read more

Food is really good! Nice,rich taste for the price! Serves a huge portion as well. Place is a simple pizzeria, people are nice and friendly. Very attentive as well. read more

Order lunch to work today and let me say this... DEFINITELY a great choice. The cheese was cheesy and had lots of great garlic flavor, We also ordered garlic knots ( which they forgot the marinara sauce ) but it was also delicious. We will definitely order again! read more

Rose's Pizzeria - LARGE CHEESE PIZZA - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

We ordered two large pies, one with pepperoni, and the chicken salad and antipasto. The pies where super fresh, but only a little too well done on the bottom. I had some of the antipasto and enjoyed it very much. This was on a Saturday evening and they had enough workers to bang out the orders. read more

Rose's Pizzeria - Chicken salad and antipasto. - Pizza Near Me - Garfield, New Jersey

I love this place! Number 8 is my to-go sub! I have been coming since I was in middle school. The place is so clean and the workers make you feel like you are family. They are so nice! read more

Great Owners Nice Pizza Clean Store Parking Lot Sucks I lived nearby before the renovation of Rose's and was a regular here. After moving I get the craving on occasion and drive over to scratch my Itch, always good. Cant go wrong here very solid Pizzeria! read more

Great pizza especially the sicilian slices and the cold antipasto salad is awesome. Sandwiches are great too.Great prices.Owners and workers are very friendly ! Definitley recommend!! read more

Not as good as it used to be. By a long shot. I was looked over constantly as I waited. Anywhere from 7-12 people got their food before me..when I placed an order way before any of those people walked in (it was ONLY 2 sandwiches!) Then after of 20 minutes of standing, watching everyone get the same amount of food or more, I finally get the sandwiches and it's time to pay. It takes additional 5 minutes to flag someone down to pay for my food. It seems like they didn't even want to serve me to be completely honest. The sandwiches were OK, but I think this was my last time taking my business here. read more

Rose's Pizzeria is located in a Garfield mini-mall type area with plenty of parking. Price is fair and plain slice are just plain with thin crust/half black burnt buttoms. This is the place to go if you want a quick bite to eat with your friends. Like the other reviewers please try the Marinara Pizza with garlic or if you do not prefer dragon-breath then go with plain personal pie. $$$ Ordered 3 plain slices, 1 garlic pizza +2 bottle coke came out to 12bux. Pros: Fair price for slices, parking was no problem. Cons: Fresh slice was actually burnt, they did not accept credit card last time I went. read more

It's so hard to review pizzerias in this area because we are blessed with so darn many good ones. So an excellent one might suffer because there is an even better one in the reviewer's mind. That's where I am with Rose's. Rose's is an excellent pizzeria -- you won't regret coming here. Of course, there are a few places in the area with better pizza (e.g., Lodi Pizza or Nino's in Garfield). But does Rose's have anything on those other guys? Yes, it does. First, the subs. The subs are absolutely the best around. Fresh bread perfectly crisped in the pizza oven every time. No better place for subs, hands down. Second, the service. The guys at the Rose are friendly, even when they're darn busy on a Friday night. I know folks who declare this place as their favorite -- I don't blame them -- it's definitely a solid choice. read more