We received wonderful attention from Jerry and Jose in planning a repast luncheon. They were patient, kind and accommodating. The food was excellent and plentiful and helped to make a memorable time. read more

Awesome Southern Italian food at it's best First time there as we went for the prix fix. We ordered the mussels and the mozzarella/ tomato for appetizers. Had the osso buco and sole over spinach for our entree, with two glasses of wine and canoli and Italian cheesecake with two espressos for $57.90. Great value and exceptional food. Our waiter, Giancarlo was knowledgeable, friendly and made it a special night. Will definitely return. read more

We had a wonderful lunch at Sergio's. We were not sure how big our party was going to be but the staff was so accommodating when we arrived with less people than we had first told them. The service was superior and the food was delicious. We had salad, penne vodka and main entrees. The chicken francais was delicious as was the filet of sole (really good sauce) and the pork. Desert was also yummy. Most of us took it home and they were happy to wrap it for us. The eclair cake and cheese cake were excellent. We so appreciate how accommodating the staff was to our family. read more

Traveling for business and stopped here for lunch. Lovely place. Really good food. Wooden floors with cloth table tops and nice Italian music in the background. They have a lunch menu for 12.95 that includes soup or salad, main course with veggie and potatoes and includes tea or coffee. Amazing price for delicious food. I had a really good Caesar Salad, Chicken Martini (Parmesan crusted chicken breast in a lemon wine sauce) with Julianne veggies that were cooked perfectly, a little al dente. Service was very good, attentive staff. Very enjoyable. read more

I've been to Sergio's for lunch a few times and it's always consistently good. I tend to order from the lunch special menu, and the veal dish is perfect. Yesterday I broke from tradition and ordered the chicken scarpariello which was a bit disappointing. The dish came with several small pieces of very well seared chicken breast, which were completely dry. The flavor of the dish was good, but the meat was overcooked. I had the chicken martini once, which did not suffer from that issue and was delicious. I like this restaurant, and the service is always friendly so I would return. read more

Came here with a group for a work event. Friendly staff, we were seated in a private room upstairs. Did the 3 course prix fix, started with crab cake, which was OK, not great, but certainly not bad. They were tiny, so certainly not sharable, I want to say 2-3 tiny tiny crab cakes...maybe equivalent in total to 1/3 of a normal crab cake. Main course I got the papparadelle with veal osso buco. The pappardelle was homemade according to their menu, but didn't taste like it. It was even a little cold by the time it reached me too. The osso buco was OK, lacking flavor big time. For dessert, I got vanilla ice cream, which is tough to complain about. Overall, there are far better options within 5-10mins down the road in pleasantville. read more

Just recently we noticed how filthy dirty the wood floors in the restaurant looked. We have been going to Sergio for years now and enjoy the delicious food , good service and fair pricing on all their entrées however was a bit uncomfortable during dinner. We hope Sergio's would remedy this situation because we enjoy the restaurant. FC read more

Plenty of parking, comfortable setting, very good service... the food was excellent and the prices were reasonable. Only issue was the portion size of both of our entrees, they were really kind of small, we were both still hungry after dinner so we ate the bread. Honestly, we don't eat that much and usually have to take leftovers to go, so the portion sizes were definitely small. Bummer, it would have been an excellent find. read more

Recently enjoyed an appetizer of mission figs wrapped in prosciutto over goat cheese and drizzled in a tasty balsamic reduction...delicious! The home made pastas are as good as it gets. Can't wait to go back. read more

What a find. Too bad it is so far from where we live. Loved all the appetizers, the homemade pasta and the great service. Try the Veal Gorgonzola! read more

Went on Valentine's day. They changed a lot on the menu. I had scallops in a citrus sauce and they were pefect Main course was tuna steak in ginger and orange sauce.. It was wonderful! Cooked just as I had ordered . Sushi quality tuna without any imperfections. And a good portion. Service was excellent. They are very personable and make everyone welcome. read more

Sergios is wonderful! Home-cooked style, melts in your mouth. While very popular with locals (I don't live in the area), the staff and folks at the bar welcome you like you are a regular. Very reasonable prices. I also have to say - there are two recent posts complaining about being rushed. I was at Sergio's on 1/26 when the two were encouraged to give up their table. They are correct, at that particular moment, there was not a wait for a table but it was 7:00 on a busy Friday night; the second wave of diners was making it's way in. Sergio's is comfortable but not a huge restaurant; when I've been at a table with a small party and long-stopped ordering food or drinks, I make an effort to be aware and courteous and make the table available for others to enjoy. So, for the two who said they won't be back - my guess is they won't be missed. read more

went here for a party bread was stale salad dressing was wishbone can't stand the woman owner she's snotty and walks around proud of it lmao she should b ashamed and humiliated serving that especially at a party the entrees were terrible the pork ossobucco disgusting wasnt even ossobucco style instead loaded with lots of jarred bbq sauce lmao no surprise considering the salad dressing the sole was terrible it was tilapia shame on them the vodka sauce watery bland just terrible worst i've ever had and i've had pretty bad ones terrible terrible terrible all around not to mention the dust everywhere very dirty place and had valentines decoration and still had the xmas ones up bahahaha double 00 stars if i could read more

Ordered a grilled chicken panini (lunch only). They didn't even bother to toast or press the sandwich. The chicken itself was plenty pressed - a dried out nightmare puck clotted with off-brand seasoned salt. Sure, it's only a panini, but if they can't get this right, I don't trust them for anything more. Should have been a home run, especially for ten bucks. read more

RUDE, RUDE, RUDE! Owner/Manager (lady) was rushing us from start to finish. We were barely finished with each course before the next one was at the table. We were finally told we had to leave because they needed our table. Meanwhile, there was no one waiting in the vestibule. And, there were at least five other tables available around us. Another table in the corner had been occupied for the same amount of time as ours. When I asked if they were being asked to leave too she said "no because when they made the reservation they specified they did not want to be rushed"(?). Who does that? Food was mediocre. So really, I won't miss much by boycotting this restaurant. read more

Eh....ok...bartender was rude!!! I had a seafood dish which had that fishy taste...Yuk!!!. You get 2 little pieces of bread with dinner, no salad. If your "friends" with the owners, etc, you get treated like royalty, otherwise fuhgeddaboudit!!! Wouldn't recommend. read more

Great low-key lunch spot, price fixe is perfectly portioned/reasonably priced. The free cicci beans are a nice touch. Only issue is the frequent post-funeral groups max out its capacity, so you get dissed at the door. *sigh* call ahead to avoid a wasted trip. read more

It was my son's communion on Sunday. We had family and friends over to celebrate this special day and had it catered by Silvios. The restaurant made the day even more special! It was the first time many of our guests tried Silvios food and no one was disappointed. My wife and I both being Italian, there are many critics to impress! From the seafood salad to the lobster ravioli to the chicken and veal main courses, all of the food was top notch. We were very pleased and look forward to having them cater our next event. read more

We love Sergio's. It's a great local place with a special feel. Have always been happy with our meals, and we have done several family dinners (e,g, birthday, family from out of town, anniversary). Menu options are upscale but pricing is reasonable and atmosphere is casual. An absolute favorite! read more

Always delicious. Down home feeling. Wait staff go out of their way to please. Food is awesome. Looking forward to my next visit.

Love this restaurant! The food is great and the service is amazing. They treat their customers like family. That's the result of a small well run family restaurant. read more

So good! Can't beat the price fixed menu, you get 3 courses for under $25 bucks. My favorite dish is the Chicken Scarpariello. The potatoes are cut so thin and cooked so crispy, like giant potato chips with the chicken, sausage and veggies all swimming in a luscious cherry pepper sauce. Quick efficient service, all equals a pleasant lunch or dinner out. read more

Went for the first time the other night after hearing good reviews. I can say I will def. be back. Service & food excellent. Also a nice price fix menu which includes appetizer, dinner, coffee and desert and reasonable prices. Appetizers: crab cake and polenta with mushrooms, yummy. Husband had osso bucco which fell off the bone and I had the chicken martini. Both were delicious. Gets crowded on weekends so suggest reservations. read more

DON'T JUST DRIVE ON BY!! Dining at Sergio's is a great experience! I came here for a Saturday afternoon lunch with my brother and other family members to celebrate a birthday. Sergio's was selected as the venue by my mother -- and probably wouldn't have been my personal choice -- but I came away very happy and impressed!! On Saturday afternoon at 2pm they were of course serving off of the lunch menu. There were many nice selections and the lunch prix fixe menu including appetizer, entrée, and tea of coffee for $11.95 (dessert with a $3 supplement) cannot be beat for value!! I had the delicious Caesar salad as did two other of my companions. The mixed greens salad with beets and apples was also reported as good as was the minestrone soup. My entrée, "Chicken Martini" was a baked/fried (?) chicken breast coated with a bit of Romano cheese. It had very nice flavor and the meat was juicy. It was accompanied by mashed potatoes and steamed veggies and which were also good. Two others had the chicken scarpariello which the kitchen graciously agreed to modify from using hot peppers to sweet pepper for the diners more sensitive palates. I love chicken scarp myself and have had it quite often elsewhere and this dish looked wonderful and was reported as very good. The usual potatoes that are included are thin sliced, more like potato chips, at Sergio's and were an interesting update to the dish. My aunt had rigatoni with meat ragu and cream which she said was very good. My brother had penne vodka which he said was only "ok". He can be a tough (and sometimes inconsistent) food critic. In all the Fixed Price lunch included 9 entrée choices! Pasta and chicken dishes and one veal (veal Milanese) and one fish (filet of sole) dish. For value AND quality it just can't be beat! We did not partake in coffee or dessert since we were continuing the party back at the house where we planned to have dessert later in the afternoon. Two in our party had glasses of wine and the pour was quite generous! The service was very efficient and accommodating. One slight negative is that the room is on the small side (perhaps 12-14 tables, of which 4 or 5 were occupied during our lunch). There was one larger group of about 6 or 7 dining and I will say the room was fairly loud even on our visit! I can see how the room would get quite loud during dinner. Finally, since there are even fewer large tables which seat more than four, I would recommend calling ahead for a reservation! Overall, the experience at Sergio's is very nice, the food very good and the value excellent. While there are so many choice in Westchester, I am already looking forward to my next meal at Sergio's! read more

I come here 3-4 times a year. Always have a great meal!! The staff is friendly and the food is always on point. Usually order off the pre-fix menu. Great value and wonderful food. You will not be disappointed read more

This place has great food, esp the salmon and the mussels appetizer; also it is a good choice as a business lunch. and excellent for a group of friends. read more

We consider Sergio's our go to and favorite destination for a great time and great dinner. Their food is as fresh and good as it gets. I think their penne vodka is sinful and best I have ever had, as well as their variety of choices and seafood dishes. The staff is very friendly and the ambiance is very cozy.. We always love coming and always leave happy. read more

Great food and drinks very reasonable prices Good for the family or friends plenty to eat delicious dinners and dessert A reservation is a must almost every night read more

OMG Sergio's is unbelievable I've been there for at least 5 times and the service everyone is happy and kind. Also the food is a great price for such quality food the chicken Francese was out of this world. Dessert is just you have to save room for it. read more

It was terrible! The service is incredibly slow especially for a restaurant that only had only 4 other tables. I ordered chicken francese. It was the worst francese I've ever had. Absolutely no flavor and the mashed potatoes were soupy. I swear they were instant potatoes. My bf had the ossobucco and he didn't like his dish either. The ossobucco came out with a red sauce rather than the typical brown gravy. How was the dessert? Well, the server who brought it out tipped my plate with the dessert and decided to put it back on the plate with his bare hands! NASTY! I didn't bother asking for another one considering the service was so slow and I didn't want to be stuck there another minute. Not only does their food stink, they're not up to food and health codes. read more

Had the ossobucco was simply amazing very tender flavorful and moist accompanied by the rizzotto again perfect Sergio visited the table to make sure everything was fine. Definitely going back again and recommendations to everyone read more

Had price fix--was reasonable ---app--dinner and dessert 22$----app was great dinners (rigotoni) was very fillin and dessert was good also. comfortable --service was good ---all the way around good experience--one negative carefull in parking lot ---needs attention read more

The lasagna is incredible. Don't judge this book by its cover! If you are in the area you must have dinner here.

Rich P. 3/19/17 I love this Restaurant. The food is great and the people are very friendly. The price fixe menu is great. There regular menu prices are reasonable also. They give a generous portion of food. If you go you will not be disappointed. read more

Had the eggplant rollitini, ossobuco and homade apple pie All was delicious! A great price too!

Today we had the a family gathering and decided to go to Sergio's .. Party of 10 so as for the menu we had chicken martini and veal and fish all the meals were perfect ... The food the service and price was on point I recommend this place if ever in the area .... And thank you Jim bartender/waiter was the best .. Definitely goi g back and they also have a private room upstairs for 40 people ... read more

great restaurant with good food, reasonable prices and nice menu. great bar tender with reasonable prices for both food and drink. worth the trip for a very nice evening out. read more

Arrived here on a Sunday night at 8:15 to eat and we were told they were closing up. Please get your hours right on your door and online.

Sergio's goes above and beyond with your quality of food and service. Portion size is perfect. The entrees are so tasty and full of flavor. The price is on point. The atmosphere is class and very comfortable.The restaurant tends to full up quickly so be sure to make reservations! read more

Love the food here! Visiting from out of town but I found the prices exceptionally reasonable. Service was wonderful. Had the pork osso bucco . Very tender and very flavorful. The pasta was so fresh -Melted right in your mouth. A real gem! read more