Like many of the other reviewers here, I'm a SB Pizza fanatic. Although I am echoing many of the below sentiments, I just have to say this is DAMN GOOD PIZZA. Good pizza for Michigan. Good pizza for Chicago. Good pizza, period. Whenever I'm in Southwest Michigan, SB Pizza is always a pit-stop. The Garlic Greek pizza is my favorite, and it's just about perfect, from the chewy crust to the spicy red pepper. Just, MMMMM. [Side note: I'm a bit confounded as to what is Greek about this pizza, since its toppings consist of pepperoni, red pepper, and garlic.] The salads are also quite good and usually are served in hearty portions. The cat has clearly been out of the bag about this pizza joint for awhile, because it's always packed. On my last visit, we sat on a picnic table outside the restaurant, which was great, because we had our dog with us. Just be prepared to wait, especially in peak-tourist (summer) season in St. Joe's. Alas, it is worth the wait. read more

This might be the best pizza I've had outside of Chicago. Love love love it! Thin style, not super thin though. The seasoning on the pizza is delicious. HUGE menu so not just pizza. Love the beer selection and decoration. The location is awesome, near the beach and on the train tracks. I love the garage theme. Try to sit outside or with a view of outside. The inside area is kind of dark and not as fun. Seems like a good place to watch a game too. I'm having my wedding next month in Benton Harbor and I talked to the owner of Silver Beach Pizza a few weeks ago. He agreed to keep the kitchen open later than usual if I bring my crew after the wedding for the "after party". So nice and so excited for that. I can't wait to bring people here, they will love it! read more

Great food! The calzones were awesome. The lettuce wedge was also really good. Prices were good. Our server was friendly. We had a large group and wait time for our food was not bad. My family and I will definitely go back. read more

The best restaurant in all of St. Joseph, hands down. Consistently a good meal, good service, beautiful location. Try the Garlic Greek. Beats any other pizza I have EVER had. read more

We love silver beach pizza! Whether you want classic toppings or to try something different, you will find it here! The atmosphere is fun and during the summer there is always a wait so put your name on the waitlist either though Yelp or in person and then just enjoy the cute town while you wait. The drink selection is varied and delicious read more

YUM! A friend recommended this place and I'm glad she did! The pizza was not like most, the crust was a bit thicker but could be considered thin. The wait was great as well. My favorite thing about this place is 1. the view of the beach and how it's located along the train tracks and 2. The schooners! I had a $5 Pear Ale Cider and it was amazing. Regular 16 oz were around $3. AMAZING! read more

Just when I thought nothing could top my long-time favorite - the Palladium multi-cheese pizza, along came a new creation with asparagus and other summer veggies. Out of this world delicious! read more

Great unique pizza, great service and drinks! Always a favorite to bring visitors from out of town.

My husband, son and I were in Michigan this past weekend and decided to go into Saint Joseph for dinner. I read some other yelp reviews and decided on Silver Beach Pizza, being the huge pizza fanatic that I am. Much to my disappointment, there was about an hour wait. (We went at 7pm on a Saturday night, so were there during prime dinner hours.) They gave us a buzzer and we headed across the street to the Merry Go Round. (Great distraction for my 1 and a half year old as we waited.) After riding the Merry Go Round, we headed back and much to our delight, were seated. Once we were seated we were promptly served. They have a system where they give you a big chip for your table that has a red side and a green side. When you need service, you leave the green side up. This made service very quick and was nice because the waitress was not bugging you when you didn't need help. Since I had read some Yelp reviews earlier,we decided to try the popular choice and have the Garlic Greek Pizza. It was delicious but next time I would ask them to go a little lighter on the Garlic. We also ordered some mozzarella sticks and a few schooners of beer. The beers were HUGE ( I think 32 oz) and only $5. I thought overall, the restaurant was a great value since it is clearly a popular place and they could have charged any price for the pizza and beer that they wanted and people still would have paid. Additionally, Silver Beach was very child friendly. They have these highchairs that are really tall so a baby could belly up to the bar, too! Pretty funny. They also had dum dum suckers for the kids which kept my sucker- loving baby totally happy, making for a totally happy Mom. We will be back- again and again! read more

I'm in the minority here, because I didn't enjoy the pizza. Leftovers was even worse. I just ate the toppings. Parking/location is definitely a hassle, and I arrived late, around 9 pm. :( read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Leftovers! Didn't enjoy this pizza. Even worse on the second day. :( - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan

After a long day on the dunes and at the beach we again took in a local favorite. We went early as all the reservations were booked for the night. We arrived at 4:50 and were seated immediately. The red dot green dot (stop for service or keep going) worked well. Our server was prompt and polite. We ordered a salad and a half and half large pizza. The salad was served in under 5 minutes from our order being placed. The pizza was delivered to our table at around the 15 min mark. Everything was as we ordered it and we couldn't have been happier with our meals. Black olive and chicken on one half, black olive and mushroom on the other. The sauce was little sweet and it really hit the spot. The cheese was a combo that had a little more cheddar flavor than we usually like. The decor was up to date and the restrooms were done well with music and even a mouth wash dispenser. Great time with the family for an easy delicious dinner. read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Couldn't wait for the photo - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan

The upper deck is awesome. Great views of the beach and lake. Bartender was accommodating to my mods for my Cadillac Margaritas. Pizza was also great. It gets busy on the weekends! read more

I'd love to give this place a one star rating if only to scare off those people that really take reviews like this to heart. I just can't do it. My only complaints about Silver Beach Pizza is how long I have to wait to get a table during the warmer months and how long it takes to get my food when they're packed wall to wall with customers. But those aren't really complaints if you even vaguely understand the restaurant business. I love the food, service, ambiance and view of Lake Michigan. read more

Being from Boston area may make me bias but this was just blah pizza. Our expectations were peaked after hearing people on street talk about how good it was and a retailer in area strongly suggested we don't eat any other pizza. We went to eat about 7 pm and we were told we had a 3!!!!! Hour wait. So we ordered take out at take out window where girl taking order was clearly not happy with her job. I asked if onions and peppers were put on pizza raw and she said "I don't know" offered nothing more. The taste of pizza was as bland and uninteresting as the girl at the window. Not to mention the whacky way they cut it?!?! Square pieces on a round pie?!? Pizza with no crust?!? Will not go back. read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan

I've been going to this joint ever since it opened. Every year around Christmas, a group of 4 high school friends and I meet here for pizza and drinks. I always go here when I visit home, which is not often (sometimes twice!). My favorite is the palladium. Lots of cheese, but super tasty. I eat it with red pepper flakes. Second favorite is garlic Greek. I just had carousel decently and it was tasty as well. Frozen margs here never disappoint. I also like the dark and stormy. DO try their infused vodkas! I like strawberry with club soda. All these new additions they're doing are well worth it for cutting down on the wait! I can't wait to return with my high school buds for Christmas :) read more

It has been a while since I sat out on the patio and this place has really upped their game. The atmosphere is awesome and they are extremely well staffed. We specificaly went for the Berry Margaritas served in a schooner and were not disappointed from the service to the margaritas Love this place! read more

Love love this place . Favorite go to for best pizza ever! Never disappoints us. Can't beat that lake view either! Offer call ahead wait list too . I Iggy recommend this . Does closes during winter months . Make sure you call ahead to find out what timeframe this is for closing . We live in South Bend but make the trip as often as we can . My husband actually proposed to me there just two years ago. Couldn't have been more appropriate place for me to accept ! Thanks Silver Beach Pizza! read more

First time bringing a friend to this establishment in St Joseph, MI. I am paying for all of the food, "a large pizza and 4 corona beers" I got bitten by the bartender about hitting my ecig 1 time. From what she told me anyhow.. I didn't realize it until she said I did it a second time "according to her". The third time "according to her" she was kicking me out, with vulgar language. I admit I forgot not to hit my ecig the third time "not required by law" only "private entity". I should have taken back the $20 tip for service before I left. Be prepared for attitudes. I'll never go back and I'll be sure to never recommend this place again! Pizza is horrible anyways for the price. Little Caesar's is better tasting by miles. read more

This is the perfect spot to grab food by the beach during sunset! Atmosphere is great and prices are very reasonable for the location. It is the only restaurant we saw that was at the bottom of the hill so that was convenient. I recommend getting their old fashioned and a corleone, which was an Italian sub with fries. Super good! read more

This is our favorite pizza place. All of the pizzas are great. We just got the harvest pizza and it was awesome! It is our new favorite! The service is super. They are very good at getting customers in. You will not be disappointed! read more

This proves that just because a place has lots of 5 star reviews, it may not be to your liking. Cracker crust. Sweet sauce. Toppings ok. Not my idea of pizza. No comparison to our go to spot in FL. Don't worry Vito, it will take a lot to replace Bella! read more

Delicious HUGE calzones! And the pizza is Joy in your mouth! Consistent GOODNESS! GO! read more

Great place for drinks and pizza no matter where are on the foodie spectrum; vegan, vegetarian, meat lover you name it they will proudly serve it. Yet they will be very busy most nights so be patient for the delicious bites you're about to have hovering over your table(s) read more

Silver Beach pizza is my number 1 in my top ten best pizza list. Upstairs dining area has the best lake view in St Joe and 21+ only is a huge plus. Can't count the number of times we've dined here. Oh yeah, and staff/management runs this joint like a well oiled machine. read more

I miss and love this place. Perfect location with the best service you can imagine. They literally love to work here than anywhere else no matter the pay. Their pizza is amazing and are their drinks read more

I have eaten pizza allover this country and a few over sea's and I can say their Pizza is the best .the sauce is sweet and they have a great thinner crust.fresh ingredeints . Plus Ice cold scooners of Obreon Beer and a big flat screen TV. WHat more could a man want. plus a fantastic veiw of the lake.I will stop in every time I cruise down I94 going and coming from chicago read more

Have nothing bad to say about this place! Have always enjoyed it as a kid when ordering pizza and now as an adult ordering big Bloody Mary's. Pizza is always delicious and drinks have always been good as well. Bartender was friendly and definitely knew how to mix a drink! read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Bloody Mary - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan

Definitely the best traditional pizza place in Benton Harbor-Saint Joseph area. I recommend you to have the whirlpool wonder pizza companion with some Irish fries... don't forget the beer in the big glass! ;) read more

Silver Beach Pizza is very famous in this region. It is so famous, that I doubted it could live up to its reputation. Nevertheless, I decided I must try it. I called the place at 5PM on Friday night. The wait for a party of was approximately 30 minutes, but most wanted to go at 6:30PM. The wait then was an hour. You can call and get in line electronically. We did that and showed up about 7:30PM, upon receiving our text. We were seated immediately. The server was pretty good but very busy. We had some sort of sangria beer, Roundhouse Sangria. It was surprisingly tasty. It did taste like sangria but felt carbonated. It came in a large chilled glass and had too much ice. We had the bruschetta for an appetizer. Instead of a tomato base, it had a type of barbeque sauce along with the expected black olives. Pretty good. And we ordered the UJ's Sunrise: A pizza with aspargus, squash, sweet peppers, cherry tomatoes, mushrooms, and fresh cilantro. Although I couldn't really see many peppers or tomatoes or mushrooms, the pizza was really top notch. The cheese in particular was amazing==not cheap cheeses but real cheese. It seems it was not just mozarella. In any case, they did live up to their 5-star reputation. The large was way too much for two people: We could only eat half o it. So, the $22 price works out okay, because of the quantity. I think the setting is good. There is a bar for those who like such things. There is an upstairs that looks over the area to the lake, and the downstairs where we sat. Durirng the summers, I'm sure they open the garage doors to get the lake breeze, but it was too cold to open those doors and dark anyways. I do highly recommend the pizza. The reputation is well-deserved, and the price is acceptable. read more

I'm not a huge fan of thin crust pizza, but this one is pretty decent. I didn't realize there were more roads over the bluff (it was dark and I don't live around here) and had difficulty finding the place -- glad I finally did. While I took it to go, the building is kitschy and fun... looks like a great place to take the family. read more

--I love this place!! Lunch, dinner or later its always amazing, usually packed out to the brim especially on the weekends, but if you can go at sunset and sit out in the patio it is worth it, such a great view of the beauty of God's creation --Start off with the Irish Nachos so good, not good for you but who cares your eating out, or if you really wanna be healthy get the hummus they have a few different flavors all of which are splendid. --The pizza is incredible, I would suggest letting it cool down for a bit because it comes out steaming hot every time, we have eaten here quite a bit so my favorites are the 1) BBQ Chicken 2) David's pizza 3) The Carousel 4) Chicken Alfredo --If you are to hit any restaurant in downtown St. Joe this is the one to check out first. read more

First time checking this place out.. What a great spot this is. The food is amazing.. best pizza i have had in quite some time. We got a simple garlic, pep cheese pizza and it was amazing. Perfect crust and just great all around... We tried the gluten free crust and it was honestly fantastic to my surprise. Decent beer selection however I decided to have a giant bloody mary and it was fantastic. They even have jalapeno fused vodka.. NICE! read more

Make reservations. Even in the winter this place has 30 minute to an hour long wait time if you just walk up. The location is extremely convenient if you're near the St. Joe bluff or Silver/lions beach. The food is decent. The pizzas take forever to come out, but use good ingredients and have a homemade crust if you like thin crackers (haven't tried the gluten free). It is a little greasier than I prefer, but that's easily handled with a few napkins to mop it up. Service has been awful every time we've gone - 30 minutes without a water refill? read more

This place is a must if you come to the St. Joe area. Great pizza and good prices, you can't go wrong. Being from Chicago, I would consider myself a pizza snob and I'm very picky about good pizza. But this pizza is actually amazing. I usually get the Margarita Pizza and add chicken. read more

This place is probably the best pizza in town. Ice cold beer, great staff, super salads, and AWESOME pizza. I especially love theor thin crust... But get the XL pizza, cuz you won't want to stop eating it! For those looking for salads, they have one of the most delicious and unique salads called the Cheryl's Salad. Unusual ingredients that really work well together. read more

Just moved to St. Joe from the east side of the state. Looked for a great pizza place to match that from what I used to eat back in Frankenmuth #tiffanys So we heard the buzz about Silver Beach Pizza and decided to check it out. I think we found a great pizza replacement while we live here for the next 3 months! The pizza is thin, and comes with excellent toppings, sauces, and herbs. Some that caught our eye (and tongue) were the greek #olives/feta, sicilian #basil/italiansausage and the popular chicken bbq #selfexplanatory. Luckily it has warmed up in town and was 85 degrees when we went a couple of days ago. So the back patio was open and the sliding garage doors were open. We were able to eat and watch the sun dip into the lake. Quite a great experience! Only reason SBP is losing a star is that the service was so-so. We will see about it next time. read more

ABSOLUTELY the best Pizza in St. Joseph! Our wait was a bit long, but I love their call ahead seating arrangement. You call in, put your name on the seating list, give them your phone number and they text you when your table is ready, then you have 5 minutes to get to the restaurant. Their pizza is one of a kind. Their seasoning is just right! I would definitely return and recommend them to my friends! read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Yummy pizza! Pepperoni and sausage. - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan

The food is great - the staff is excellent - the location is perfect! Only problem - too busy, which I'm sure they love! Call ahead for a pick-up pizza is the go-to in the summer months! read more

I am not a five star reviewer. Let me just start there. But in the town of St. Joe...this is about as good as it gets. The pizza is DELICIOUS and the drink menu is great. The wait staff is friendly and helpful, the bartenders are quick and the food is always delicious. I recommend this place wholeheartedly. Favorites are the Conductor's Choice and the Garlic Greek. A don't-miss spot if you're headed to St. Joe. read more

My new favorite! I took the kids and a week later brought husband and kids. I will ALWAYS order too much. I love leftovers from here. The kids were well entertained outside and inside. They love the dough for playing and the Tv's . We got to see a train pull up and watched the fountain while waiting for our pizza. Great prices and service. read more

Silver Beach Pizza - Irish nachos, yum!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Saint Joseph, Michigan