Came here on a random Saturday afternoon for a late lunch. We ordered the same traditional lobster roll, however with different sides of fries and sweet potato fries. It was absolutely fantastic. And here's why. The roles came out nice and warm with ample butter all over that perfect brioche bread. The lobster filling had no additional filling like vegetables or stuffing or breading in order to fill it up. It was 100% pure fresh lobster and it was amazing. What was also incredible as the depth of the menu and all the different choices. We also got a shareable plate of lobster tater tots, which is basically a lobster hush puppy and this was amazing too, and the sauce that came with it was out of this world. It was also so nice to see alcoholic options, however, more alcoholic options that were on draft. This place you walk into go up to a counter, put your order in and then they bring the food out to you and they even clean up your table after you so it's a little bit of service The place was super clean and the staff was super friendly. I have to come back to one of these in the near future. If you're in the area and there's several locations of this available throughout Carmel and fishers this is definitely a place to stop by. read more

Slapfish - Traditional Lobster Roll - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

A new restaurant has taken over the space connected to Market District. Hopefully, Slapfish is a well-enough established brand that locals will patronize it and keep it open. From what I saw, that seems to be the case. If you have been to any other Slapfish, then you know what to expect here. Order at the counter. Expect fresh and tasty seafood to be delivered to your table in a timely manner. read more

See all

Slapfish is the best seafood restaurant in town. This new location in Carmel is upscale and convenient. I met friends for lunch this week. I ordered the Power Bowl because the bowl comes with three types of fish. The bowl came out quickly and service was friendly. The Power Bowl is topped with perfectly grilled mahi mahi, salmon and shrimp. The fish is on a bed of mixed veggies and rice. Avocado and egg add additional healthy factors to the plate. And I love the pickled onions. The dining room is comfortable and easy to have a conversation with friends. read more

See all

I've visited slapfish quite a few times, but this was my first visit to the Carmel spot. It's located inside the market district grocery store, and has plenty of seating available. I decided to start with the lobster tots, which were not anything special. They mostly tasted like a hush puppy, and I did not taste any lobster. For $12 I would not order again and would rather get the lobster dip. For my entree I got the clobster grilled cheese. I really enjoyed it and it had a wonderful toast on it. My friend commented she thought it could have used more cheese. The seasoning on the fries were delicious. The special sauce has some spice to it. The restaurant was clean and the staff was so friendly. I would definitely return and try some different dishes. read more

See all

This Slapfish location is huge with lots of tables and booths. Ordering at the counter was friendly and quick. The clerk recommended the Power Bowl. The Power Bowl is amazing. The three types of fish were cooked perfectly, hot and flavorful. The Mahi Mahi had a lemon butter flavor. The shrimp are lightly breaded with a spicy garlicky seasoning. The salmon had a spicy seasoning. There is so much going on in this bowl! Avocado, pickled onions, egg, spinach, radishes, pumpkin sto name a few. Every bite was super fresh. I didn't want to eat the whole bowl, but I did. I didn't even need the dressing because there were so many flavors. The Power Bowl is a must try! There are a couple of separate dinning areas, including an outside patio space. The booths are comfortable. Classic rock plays gently over speakers. There is a subtle mix of nautical decor. Yes, I felt like I was at the beach. Oh, they have booze! Beer, wine and a few select cocktails are available. A manager walked around and checked on customers. Nice touch. I'm so glad to have a Slapfish so close to home. I'll be a regular because I want to try everything on their menu! There was plenty of parking at noon on a Friday, but I'm guessing parking is harder to find during the dinner hour. They do a robust carry-out and you can order ahead. read more

See all

I want this to be my first review of 2026 because this is one of my family's favorite spots and I'm so happy that they opened a location by their house! It's truly one of the only restaurants that we all agree on and is always a total win. This location is connected to the Market District grocery, so it's super convenient. Order takeout, pick up a few items, and bring it all home or eat inside or in their beautiful covered patio. Slapfish nails the combo of healthy and delicious. Every single menu item is amazing. Every person is always happy with their meal (including kids - they have a great kids menu). what we get. My most-ordered items: - Hawaiian bowl: shrimp, rice, pineapple, and the best herby sauce ever - Citrus salad: also has shrimp and is my runner-up order; the dressing is incredible - Fries: seasoned to perfection My family's favorites: - Power bowl: you get three types of seafood and veggies but again, the sauce makes it delicious - Shrimp burrito: huge, packed perfectly, and again, tied together with an incredible sauce - Lobster roll: no explanation needed The owners are an amazing local family and I love supporting them too. We just visited Indy for a few weeks and got Slapfish three times - LOL. read more

See all

Slapfish is one of my favorite spots and I was thrilled to see a new location inside Market District! I'm already a frequent visitor of Market District so I see more visits to Slapfish in my future. My first visit I went with a friend and we both enjoyed the devour special. The Clobster grilled cheese is my favorite meal. The sandwich is buttery and crispy with a little bit of spice and the fries are perfectly crisp and seasoned well. I love that I can get draft beer or a glass of wine. I will say, lobster can come with a price and my casual lunch was $40+, but it's worth every penny. read more

Slapfish - Clobster Grilled Cheese - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

See all

Friendly service, clean restaurant with great lighting, and the food was made fresh to order. Easy parking. Did I mention the food is DELICIOUS!!! read more

Slapfish - Power Bowl - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Been a fan of Slapfish ever since my first bite at their other locations, so I was excited to have one closer to home (hint hint--put one on the west side too!). This location absolutely delivered the same tasty, high-quality seafood I've come to expect. Did the menu expand? There's pasta now! I try something new every visit and still haven't made it through everything--so far, every dish has earned my stamp of approval. Kids' meals are available, which is a plus. The chips might be a bit spicy for younger taste buds, so I'm curious if unseasoned ones can be requested next time. They also offer a handful of draft beers, along with wine and cocktails. The staff was cheerful, attentive, and genuinely helpful. Parking is free and easy, and the location next to Market District is super convenient--we even walked over to grab some sweets before heading home. Overall, a great addition and a welcome closer Slapfish option! read more

See all

Slapfish consistently slaps. I remember, back in the olden days, when there were no Slapfish restaurants in Indiana. Then one popped up in Noblesville, then Mass Ave, then Fishers, and now Carmel, attached to the corner of Market District grocery store. I welcome ever more Slapfish locations to the area. I love Slapfish. I love Slapfish because every single thing I've ever tasted on the menu is a banger. My go-to is usually the Epic Shrimp Burrito (grilled shrimp, tomato, rice, fries, pickled onion, guacamole, Awesome Sauce and salsa), but I was feeling like something lighter this visit, so I went with the Petite Lobster Roll, which is the perfect size if you want just three or four bites of something delicious. It comes with a wedge of lemon to squeeze over it. We also got the Fish 'N Chips, which is a huge portion -- two large filets of perfectly battered and fried cod, fries, coleslaw and tartar sauce. And a pickle spear, for good measure! Slapfish does have a kids menu! It's not up on the main menu on the wall, but just ask for the kids menu, and they will hand you a paper menu and some crayons. From the kids menu, we got the Crispy Fish, which is basically a huge fish stick. It comes with your choice of side: fries or apple sauce, plus a beverage. Other things on the kids menu include a grilled fish taco, grilled cheese, mac and cheese, hamburger, grilled shrimp with rice, cheese quesadilla and chicken tenders. Coke products are sold here, as well as beer and wine. They have a patio, so I look forward to enjoying some patio seating when the weather gets warmer! read more

This is hands down the best place to get seafood. The food is awesome, love the fish n chips, tasty coleslaw and the BEST customer service! All that at a reasonable price!!! read more

Slapfish - Ala carte 3 Cod fillets and a side of Coleslaw. - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Average - slightly overpriced and food wasn't anything special. Service and staff were good. Decor a bit basic but I suppose that's the way it was planned. read more

I am not one to review a place twice buuuut I did try another location and it was amazing again. The location next to Market District in Carmel is the perfect location, phenomenal fast and friendly service and as usual delicious food. If you haven't tried Slapfish you are doing yourself a disservice. Wonderful atmosphere to enjoy great food. ‍ What more can you ask for? read more

See all

Fresh, amazing food with more space than their carmel location. Sarah (our server) was sooo amazing and kind and welcoming! Nothing negative to say! We got the poke + chips, lobster taquitos and side fries....chef's kiss! read more

Slapfish - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

The new Slapfish at Market District did not disappoint. The fish tacos were delicious as was the fish and chips. After ordering in line and finding our seat the waitress was there with our order in less than a couple of minutes. The ambiance is OK for this type of restaurant. If you enjoyed the east side Slapfish, this location will have you coming back for more. read more

This restaurant is a wonderful place. Had a late lunch here and it was as good as any fine dining restaurant. I had the Hawaiian Bowl with shrimp. Shrimp was perfectly cooked. The sauce that came with it could change your world. My wife had tacos and loved them. Service was excellent. Clean. Bathrooms super clean. So many more menu choices that I will try based on how great my first time here was. Located in a huge supermarket but it is independent. Plenty of parking. I will gladly return. read more

Slapfish - Happy customers and outstanding food. - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

Lovely atmosphere, good costumer service the food came quickly and was very well done. read more

Slapfish - Lobster roll petit with slaw - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

What a fantastic atmosphere and incredible food! It's evident that Mark and Lauren poured their hearts into this location. They were both present during my visit and ensured that my experience was exceptional. If you are unsure about what to get, the trio rolls are a great choice; you won't regret it. Thank you for bringing Slapfish to Carmel. read more

Slapfish - The trio lobster roll! - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I'm consistently blown away by Slapfish, and this new location absolutely lives up to the hype. I usually go to the Fishers spot, but as soon as this one opened, I had to try it--and it did not disappoint. Ordering at the counter is quick and easy, and then the staff takes care of the rest, which makes the whole experience feel effortless. The menu is a total win. Honestly, I don't think there's a single thing on it I wouldn't eat. There truly is something for everyone--gluten-free options, a well-rounded kids menu, and even great choices for people who aren't big on seafood. That kind of inclusivity is rare and really appreciated. Now for the food: the lobster tots are a must. I get them every time and they never miss. For my main, I always go with the grilled fish bowl with salmon, and it's consistently perfect. The salmon is cooked just right every single time, and that herb fish oil on top is next-level--it completely makes the dish. If you're on the fence about trying Slapfish, don't be. Whether you're a seafood lover or not, this place delivers on flavor, quality, and experience. I'll be back again and again. I'm including photos of other items I've tried in the past and love! read more

See all

What?!? There's a Slapfish under same roof as my favorite grocery Market District?!? Nice surprise. Very clean. Plenty of seating and parking. Along east side of building so little overlap with grocery traffic. Super friendly staff. Same great Slapfish menu. And you know the produce is fresh! Power bowl with salad is delicious! read more

Slapfish - Power Bowl with salad - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

I'm dietary specific (allergies) & Slapfish has a large, well designed menu full of fresh ingredients & amazing sauces that fit into my margins. Every bite was accompanied by a "yum", & I mean every bite! It's not table service (no order taking at the table) you go through ordering & paying before going to the table. You get your own drinks & the food is delivered according to the number you receive at ordering that you put on your table. I'm fine with that. Your food is delivered with a smile. There is a tip jar if you are so inclined. It's so good & I appreciate real good food. It's located in the Market District grocery store in Carmel. It's worth the trip to experience freshness with a "yum" in every bite. read more

Food is ALWAYS amazing! Favorite is Ultimate Fish Taco. Blackened. Service is OUTSTANDING! Great place to eat on a date or with friends. Don't forget a glass of wine! read more

Loved everything about this restaurant!! Soup..Salad..Fish Tacos..Grouper Sandwich ALL excellent!!

I cannot describe how DELICIOUS Slapfish is!! It's my favorite restaurant ever. My family all loves it! They have something for everyone there, even if you don't like seafood. Their mac and cheese is so good, they have the BEST seasoned fries, and their Awesome Sauce is awesome!!! Their service is amazing!! We always get our food in LESS THAN 10 MINUTES!! The stores are always beautiful decorated for seasons. The tables are always clean! Totally recommend for anyone with kids who wants to got to a family friendly restaurant! We love Slapfish! read more

SlapFish is always the best and we were really excited to try this new location. It didn't disappoint! The new space is amazing and the service and food was just as great. They always know how to do it right. The Ahi tuna is the absolute best and the lobster roll was incredible. Added bonus I was able to pick-up a few things at Market District while we were there eating. One stop shop, doesn't get better than that! read more

Slapfish - Seafood Near Me - Carmel, Indiana

New location, same great taste, with a few familiar faces. Lobster's my go-to, but I can never tell with my son's finicky food preferences; today it was the chicken tenders. There's a great kid's menu, so I was able to enjoy the Lobster Avocado Toast again. Peaceful setting (awesome indoor patio), but if your kids are loud nobody cares. They play good music. Service is always quick and friendly. I highly recommend SlapFish and this huge, new location in Carmel. read more

Great seafood. Fast and friendly service, along with a convenient location. I will definitely be a regular.

This is the best lobster roll I have ever had! Friendly & helpful staff that has the coolest atmosphere! Recommend 10/10!

Slapfish never fails! Their food is amazing top-notch, hands down the lobster roll is a must !

We love Slapfish! We got takeout from the new location at Market District and tried something new tonight....the firecracker fettuccini with Salmon. It was fantastic! Our typical go to entrees were great as usual! (Grilled salmon and the grouper sandwich). The new location is beautiful inside and has a very nice enclosed patio. Great location, great food and friendly service! Way to go Slapfish! read more

Simply AMAZING food and just down right friendly people all around. My kids are tough mac and cheese "critics" and they proclaim Slapfish "the best!". The portions are very generous and the food was very fresh and presented well. Honestly, the food presented more like we were at a fine dining establishment vs. a fast/casual spot. Highly recommend the Lobster Roll and Fish Tacos. A Family favorite, we will be back! read more

What an awesome experience at the new slapfish in Carmel! Great food, lots of room, and the staff is great as always! Try the power bowl or firecracker fettuccine they were both excellent! read more

Food, service, and atmosphere! This place has it all! We started with the lobster taquitos and ceviche and were blown away by the quality and taste. My wife got the power bowl and myself the lobster roll. Unfortunately we weren't early enough for the grand opening to receive one of the free 100 lobster rolls they were giving away. Let me just say, I should have ordered 3! At the price of 26$, I can't believe the quality and freshness of the lobster. Reminds me of our trips out in Maine! The roll itself is unique. They call it a New England style roll. It's buttery with a hint of sweetness! I had a few bites of wife's power bowl and every single bite left me yearning for more! It's refreshing to find quality fish and a unique menu that isn't burgers or pizza here in Carmel! Definitely will be back again soon! read more

Great food and very affordable, great atmosphere on this new location, love Slapfish, highly recommended

Food is super fresh! Amazing oysters. Friendly staff. The restaurant looks amazing. Lobster roll is to die for. Never disappoints.

We went for the soft opening and normally restaurants' service is a little slow when they first open. Not here! Service was impeccable as it is at all other Slapfish locations. Food was equally as delicious and they even accommodated our picky children's requests! I dream about the lobster rolls and the shrimp burrito (which is enough for about 30 people!!). The fish is always fresh and delicious and the fries are amazing. So is the mac and cheese and the bowls and the grouper sandwiches and pretty much everything!!! And their special sauce is truly special. Oh, and the inside ambiance is super fun....cool vibe. Plus outdoor seating for warmer months. We will visit this one regularly just as we have the other Indiana locations!!! read more