Great perogies and corn beef sandwiches. Drinks were strong and fabulous and Anna my waitress was perfect.

Ask For Maggie at the bar at night, I wish management would do something about the sticky bar, food is good, wish they offered sides for free but the service and the food are fantastic read more

After eating a corned beef from Slyman's, all other corned beef sandwiches i've ever had seem sad. This meal was soooo good its almost hard to find words. Their regular corned beef sandwich is so large, it could honestly be two meals/split between two people. You cannot go wrong with the corned beef sandwich, which is super lean and juicy. Slyman's also has a super generous Yelp check-in offer. If you check-in on your Yelp app, you get a free order of Slyman's fries, which are basically a huge helping of delicious goodness. The gravy is an A+. Between the fries and the sandwich, a food coma is surely on your horizon. My mouth waters just thinking about it. Slyman's is decorated beautifully for the holidays, which naturally accents their stained glass-esque detailing. The inside is way more spacious then I anticipated, and the Tavern as a whole has 10+ TVs lining the walls. We counted. If you're dining here, its impossible to miss any game. The inside also has a huge bar area. If you come to eat (or drink), you won't have any problems finding a seat. We will definitely be back to Slyman's! read more

See all

Was looking forward to the same pastrami sandwich I had at the Cleveland location, but it was not to happen. We were seated and ignored. We left while the hostess was running around trying to find our waitress with not much success or the promise of finding one. While carry out business looked brisk, there were not many patrons, so this was surprising and disappointing. read more

So in the area after the 2pm closing time for the Original Slymans, I opted to try one of the New Slymans "Taverns". All in all it was a very good experience. Service was considerably slower than at the original, but not too bad. The corned beef had the same great Slyman's taste, but was cut much thicker than the original, which made it slightly tougher than what I am used to at the original. All in all it was a good experience, but as with most things...especially restaurants, there is something lost once they franchise out. Overall I'd give the food here a 3.5 rating, but since I can't give it a half, I rounded up. Forgot to get a picture. Lol. read more

Tasty, .but very overpriced. We went in for lunch. Got 2 sandwiches (Reuben and a pastrami), one iced tea, and one order of fries. After tip (our server was wonderful and funny), our bill came to 62 dollars...for 2 sandwiches, one drink, and one side of fries...for LUNCH. The sandwiches have fairly generous portions of meat, but still an outrageous cost for lunch. Fries were skimpy on portion size for the price. We went to Melt across the road the next week for lunch and we both got delicious sandwiches, drinks, and we each got our own huge portion of fries (instead of one skimpy portion) for half the price of Slyman's. read more

I had heard about Slyman's and how good their deli sandwiches were so I was eager to give them a try. I ordered a pastrami on rye with no cheese or sauce (I'm a deli purist). They brought my order out and it had cheese on it but I was able to pull it off without losing any meat so I won't dock them for that. My friend ordered his with cheese so it was a simple mistake. The pastrami was good, not NYC deli ala Katz's quality but still good. It seemed machine slices pretty thin and I prefer hand cut or at least cut a little thicker. There isn't any deli mustard just regular yellow so if you want something fancier you're out of luck. I like regular yellow mustard with my deli sandwiches. All in all the sandwich was good. The pickle that came with it was an ordinary kosher dill. I'd like to see maybe a plate of pickles or half sours on the table instead of just one with a sandwich. I also wish the sandwiches came with fries or chips or something instead of all sides being extra. I will be back as I can't turn down a decent pastrami on rye read more

Great food good service and enjoyed the atmosphere they really have a nice variety of options on the menu something for everyone

I was foolishly thinking that I was going to walk into a place that resembles the Slyman's in Cleveland. I was greatly surprised to see a great looking, welcoming, and spacious restaurant with so many TVs. And the food is awesome like the original! The table shared the Slyman's fries: corned beef shavings, melted swiss topped with green onions. I got the Turkey SLIMs: melted swiss cheese and cole slaw on toasted pretzel buns. There was so much food and it was all delicious even the next day as leftovers. I already have plans to go back next week. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Slymans fries - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

I'll never eat here again. I paid over 50 dollars for an incomplete order. On top of that, a lone sandwich was $17.45? (Cold, no sides) Is that correct? When we called to resolve the situation they hung up on us. Called back to management only be let down. Unfortunately this place is completely over priced for what it is. 0/10. read more

I don't usually eat red meat, but I had to. I just had to. Had to get the corned beef and it was the BEST corned beef I ever had melt in my mouth. My husband and I split the big sandwich and he ordered extra bread for the mound of meat. A free fry appetizer posted when I checked in, and I didn't expect what we actually got...fries loaded with corned beef, cheese sauce, and herbs. It was so much that five people couldn't finish it! We also ordered the sauerkraut balls which I highly recommend. But the pierogies seemed like they came from a frozen package. The service was slow and not too attentive, but the corned beef is enough to try the place out. read more

I have nothing but positivity towards this place. The food, the atmosphere, and the staff are all top notch. I'm a big corned beef fan, and this is by far the best corned beef sandwich I've ever had. Sliced thin and piled high, exactly the way I like it. It's seriously amazing, the best in Cleveland. Heck, it's the only place you should go for corned beef. The staff is wonderful, everyone has a smile, everyone. It's a nice touch. The restaurant is decorated quite nicely, It doesn't feel crammed even though the place is always slammed. It's busy, but comfortable. I've seen several complaints down below of people commenting on the price, what they fail to recognize is that GOOD corned beef does not come cheap, it is a little expensive, but Slyman's corned beef sandwiches are the epitome of "you get what you paid for." I love this place, I hope they do well. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - The stooges! - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon for lunch as a party of 5. We were seated at a high table, which would usually be ok except that one of our group was a toddler. Not a deal breaker, just had to pay a little extra attention to make sure he didn't fall. They had run out of kids' menus, and we didn't know they had smaller options until we asked. (It would've been nice to hear from the hostess that the children's menus were available.) We ordered drinks, which took awhile to come out. Apparently the bar had a hard time finding the beers we wanted. So, inconvenience, but not a deal breaker. Our entrees came quickly after ordering. However, the kitchen messed up the kid's meal by forgetting the fries. We had the sandwich only, which they placed in front of our son AND THEN TOOK AWAY. We had manage him to avoid a meltdown and then wait until his food was remade. Once everything came out it was really good. Corned beef is as good as it had ever been at the downtown location. The onion rings were perfectly fried and weren't greasy at all. The food is not the issue. Cheryl was fantastic and worked very hard to make everything right for us. Had it not been for her, this review world have likely been 1 star. I hope the kitchen gets its act together because they truly have some great food based on the Slyman's name. Unfortunately, I refuse to eat my corned beef with a side of confusion and frustration. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Original corned beef. - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

This is not a cheap place to grab a sandwich. Our family of five spent about a hundred dollars on fried pickle chips, five sandwiches, 3 soft drinks and two orders of fries. I lead with this because cost is important, but also: it was good. The portions are also enormous, and we brought home fries and two half sandwiches, enough for two lunches. If you are familiar with Slyman's in Cleveland, and you've never been to the tavern on Rockside, you'll enjoy the differences - much roomier, full bar, spacious seating area and the same great corned beef in huge portions. Sandwiches come in original size and light size. The original will give you multiple meals. The deli meats were all good, the bread fresh. Superior sandwiches at a premium price, a great place to gather. The pickle chips were really good and the fries were perfect and delivered hot. We go to Slymans a few times a year, always knowing we're going to pay...but it's always worth it. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - The Reuben - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Surprised to say the least. Staying overnight in the area took and chance and hit the jackpot. Nice laid back place with huge portions and quality food. Friendly staff. read more

A bit expensive, but Really good roast beef sandwiches. Tons of meat. Not too greasy.

Stopped in at 11pm on a Tuesday night. I live in CBUS, so whenever I am in Cleveland (usually for a show or a game), I can never make it to Slymans because of their hours. So, this place is a godsend for that reason. They are open late AND! is on the way home to Columbus from Cleveland. Double-score. Now, onto the food. I hold the reuben at the original Slyman's on a very high pedestal. In fact, I rate it the #1 reuben Ive ever had -- and yes, Ive trid Katz's in NYC, just my personal preference. I prefer it sliced thin and piled high -- and that moist corned beef! Oh! Its heaven! LOVE Slymans. THIS PLACE -- the corned beef was NOT the same. If it was the same, it was cooked slightly differently. It was still very good, but very good does not match the original Slymans. Slymans is beyond excellent. Some say it was dry, and yeah, I guess you could call it that, but the taste was a tad bit off for me. The portion was about 15 to 20% smaller than that of the original location and was priced exactly the same. I know, $15.50 for a sandwich is ridiculous, BUT Slymans is worth it. This place, I dont know. Maybe if they included a side. The reason I know? I was still hungry after eating it. I was eating off of my gf's plate including her french fries. The original Slyman's, I never do that. Im stuffed after JUST the sandwich and never need sides, other than a water or can of Coke. My recommendation -- use the same bread the original location uses and use the same portions. If you are going to charge the same, provide the same. Its not fair to the customers. Will I be back? Sure. Will I rush to go back? No. Its not the same. Not yet. I had heard Freddy was working at this location to get them started on the right foot. Maybe its time to call him back. Ill include some pictures. Btw, our bill was $32.55 and included one hamburger, one reuben, one order of french fries, and one coke. Yikes! read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

We've been coming here for about 2 years and have gotten bottomless mimosas and breakfast every time and told countless people they needed to come along with bringing many friends. We came again, only to find out they have taken both away. This is the emptiest have ever seen this establishment. Such a disappointment and it looks like it's going down hill. BRING BACK BOTTOMLESS & BRUNCH!!!!!!!! read more

We were staying right down the road and this popped up as a place to eat. It's located in the back of a strip mall, pretty unassuming from the outside but do not skip over this gem. The inside is really cool. There's a huge mural of the three stooges and a big bar with cool lights and water works. Then on the opposite side, where we sat, there's a whole mural of photos and such all from 1964 the year Slyman's started. They have a decent menu with some good local picks and bar food. I ordered the Pierogi which came fried with a side of applesauce. The pierogis were really flavorful but a tad dry which is why the applesauce paired perfectly with it. The onions that topped the pierogis were also super tender. My mom ordered the corned beef and cabbage platter which came out and shocked the whole table because it was so large. No skimping on the meat at this place. Same with the turkey entrees our friends ordered- massive! I tried some of the corned beef and it was honestly heavenly. So tender and packed with flavor and it paired so perfectly with the cabbage which was shredded really fine! Definitely the best corn beef I've ever had. He food will not disappoint especially the amount you get for the cost- talk about bang for your buck! Our waitress was also super nice, which always makes for an even better dining experience! read more

See all

Nice atmosphere. Cool posters. In a strip mall. Beer served properly. Clean lines! Really enjoyed my draft beer. Nice selection. Service prompt and attentive. Very friendly. Fries from a bag. Wasn't in mood for a sandwich so got fried fish. Meh. From a box I would guess. 3 small cod pieces. Don't do it. Fried pickles good. Potato pancakes really boring. Ate half of one with my wife. Wife got a Reuben. Reuben cold, just a hint of Swiss (with upcharge) not much slaw. Go to Corky and Lenny instead. Disappointed. Would go back for a beer and fried pickles if in the neighborhood. Would not come here otherwise. Too bad. Iconic name. read more

I have returned several times and they corrected the annoying crashing sounds of the dishes. Their deli sandwiches are first rate second only to their St. Clair location. When I am in the mood for a deli sandwich and in the area, this is my go to place. read more

Awesome food, staff. Not one single thing to complain about. Well worth going out of our way for a great lunch experience.

Food and service were good. Way too expensive for what you get. If prices were reasonable I would up this to 4 stars.

Great corned beef sandwiches and incredible latkes. All the great food that my wife won't let me eat. The setting is great - love it when they are able to open the bar area in the summer. read more

Awesome experience! I sat at the bar and Brandi served me. I had the Original Corned Beef on Rye and it was simply amazing. Portion to feed 2 regular people. I have eaten Corned Beef around the world and this is simply supreme over EVEN NYC delis! My only comment to the management is about the 'Krinkle fries', really? Step up your fry-game to fresh-cut fries! Anyone can make 'Ore-Ida' at home. They were bland and took away from the rest of the awesomeness that was your sandwich. This review would have been 5 stars if the fries weren't 'meh'. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

The food at Slyman's is INCREDIBLE. I've come before for the excellent corned beef--which has yet to disappoint--but this time I treated myself to the "Sly" Dog - a hot dog bathed with crumbled corned beef and a delicious cheese sauce. OH MY GOODNESS IT WAS GOOD. I don't ordinarily take food porn pictures, but here you go. The service, as usual, was impeccable, and very friendly. Our waitress brought out a small sample of the pasta salad for my seat-mate to try, never let a glass get empty, and was as pleasant as could possibly be. It does not get much better htan this. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - The "Sly" Hot Dog - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Mmmmmmmmmmmm Corned beef mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm I love their corned beef - haven't really tried to get a sandwich on St Paddy's day - I watch that on tv But let me tell you they have THE best corned beef I didn't care about anything thing else Corned beef sandwich mmmmmmm read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - St Pat's coming - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Great corned beef! Large sandwich easy enough to split between two people. Glad I came when I was in town. We were in and out of there within 30 minutes. I will come back next time in Big Cle! Atmosphere is nice so you can hang around but we were in a hurry so next time we can be prepared to spend more time eating and chatting it up . read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Corned Beef Sandwich - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Service was great. Seated promptly. Waitress was polite and very helpful. Let us order quickly because we knew what we wanted. Food was awesome as usual read more

My suggestion is to go downtown or they make your sandwich right and it's nice and juicy I've been to the one in Independence many times I've got my order wrong four times after I got home I realized it they gave me a 10% coupon off big deal terrible service they do what they want to go downtown Saint Clair and get an original corn beef from SLYMANS Downtown night and day difference read more

We used to come to this place often. Unfortunately, it has really gone downhill. You used to get a large portion of food and the service was great. This most recent time we visited, the portions were tiny and the service was terrible. My husband got the light pastrami sandwich. When he got this in the past, it came with a generous portion of pastrami, enough to fill you up and often have some leftover. This time, there was a very small amount of pastrami on some sad looking bread. For the price ($11 just for the sandwich, no sides) I would at least expect a little more meat. The only plus was that he did say it tasted good. Our server was inattentive and very slow to check on us or bring the check, especially considering the place was pretty empty on a Friday night. We definitely won't be back, which is a shame as we used to enjoy coming here. read more

Slyman's Tavern - Independence - Bars Near Me - Independence, Ohio

So I'm not a corned beef fan, terrible for a Clevelander (I know), but I recently went to Slyman's and got an egg salad sandwich and must say it was pretty good. I ordered pasta salad, which was better on my first visit, so I asked for something different and was given potato salad, which was just okay too. However, the egg salad was really good and huge as you can imagine based on the size of their other sandwiches. The place also has a cool vibe and is open for lunch which is awesome! I love eating local and am happy to have another local place. read more

Where to start. I came in and waited 5-7 minutes for the hostess to give me a menu and to direct me to the bar. I waited another 10 minutes for the girl behind the bar to acknowledge me. After placing my order she told me that it would be 20-30 minutes to get my order due to the computer not working well. Having wasted half of my lunch hour already I thanked her for her time only to get a nasty look and a comment that I could not hear. I'm sure that is was not a "please come back" I understand that sometimes things move slow but the rude comments and look will make sure that I will not recommend Slyman's in independence. Downtown it's still make the customer happy but I guess not the case here. Very disappointed. read more

Very poor in take out service. Placed order . Order never read back nor was I told the total price until I arrived. Food not ready ( though I placed order 2 hrs ahead for specific pick up time. ) since order wasn't ready I was running late checked order at home snd yes big time wrong!! No satisfaction with manager. Had out of town guest who requested this place but never again sorry!! Poor experience,customer service and food!! read more

Every time I visit home (Cleveland) my first stop was Slyman's Tavern. Was. Last time was December 23rd as I was driving up for Christmas. I sat at the bar, my wife and I ordered a couple drinks and a couple sandwiches, and I invited my friend to join us. Sounds like a great evening, right? My friend, who is African-American, and I were talking about the old days when we were roommates when some drunk guy approached us at the bar. He said something to my friend, then came in between us and said "You guys trying to party tonight?". When we said no, he drunkenly muttered that we were causing trouble and that he was calling the police. He faked calling the police on his phone, saying things like "Yeah one of them is black so be careful". He got "off the phone" and told my friend that the police were on their way and that he should put his hands up because they were going to shoot him. That is where the fault of the business comes in. The guy then wandered off back into the kitchen! He clearly worked for Slyman's! I immediately noticed and asked for a manager. She looked grim faced when she arrived, but not particularly surprised. She claimed that she was going to fire the guy, but I was pretty skeptical because again, before I even told the story she had a pretty grim and knowing look on her face. She offered to buy us a round for our trouble. Really? That's the price of being racially harassed in their establishment? A beer? I will miss the corned beef. But I won't be back to a place that employs and appears to condone racism. read more

Probably the worst pastrami sandwich I've had the displeasure of cramming down my pie hole. Someone needs to tell the kitchen to cut the pastrami AGAINST the grain or you end up with rubber bands in your mouth and makes eating a sandwich very difficult. Cutting with the grain does not break up the rubber band like fat and makes it very difficult to chew. This is very, very, very, basic process when your business is all about sandwich's. read more

My 2 star rating is for the food truck. First, the truck didn't open until literally the minute stated even though a quite a line was forming. I ordered a Reuben which was 19.00 and it may have had a teaspoon of sauerkraut maybe not even, I had to look for it! Also, lucky me I got the smallest slices from the loaf of rye...ugh! Such a disappointment! I will give 5 stars to the people working the window, very polite. And 5 stars to the corned beef itself. For 19.00 that should've been an epic sandwich...just sayin' read more

See all

I thought I was going to experience the REAL Slyman's, instead I got something totally out of their league. I not only got taken once but TWICE. In the future, if I want a GREAT corned beef sandwich, I'll go where the best corned beef in town, Slyman's on St. Clair or Superior. THE REAL SLYMAN'S DELI! read more

I've been a Slyman's patron for many years. Their corned beef can't be beat. Last night I made the mistake of trying something different. I ordered the roast turkey dinner with mashed potatoes and green beans. The green beans were delicious. The mashed potatoes were dry. The "oven roasted turkey" was a major disappointment. It was basically a mound of thin sliced salty lunchmeat that was warmed up on the griddle. Not my idea of a roast turkey dinner. read more

First off ordered online. We got there & they sent our order out with grub hub. Had to wait for them to remake. Compensation was a small coleslaw & potato salad. After coming home (not a 10 minute drive) my pastrami sandwich was so greasy the bread was soggy as well as the paper it was wrapped in. Such a disappointment. Nothing like the original downtown. read more