This is THE place to go to for simple comfort food, though I'd only recommend coming on weekends when the buffet is served (and it's WAY better than the Amish Door. Yeah, I said it!) I don't usually frequent buffets, but this one is always clean, fresh, and usually well-stocked. Highlights include fresh breads with a whipped honey butter spread, salad bar with tons of fixings, sweet potatoes with a mountain of marshmallows, juicy pot roast, and delicious tea served in a mason jar. Skip the instant mashed potatoes, though :[ There's also a pond right outside where you can feed the ducks or sit on the swings, a pantry, gift shop, toy store, and archery range. Rather quaint, I'd say. read more

Had a great meal here today, but we ordered simple. Saw a few plates coming by where others had ordered items off the menu. We had the soup and salad. Some may say it's a bit pricey at just over $10 per person, but there are a lot of choices on the salad bar and there are several soups to choose from. The blueberry bread that was there today was delicious also! Will definitely be back. read more

This place could be great. It has so much potential. The interior is beautiful, and a menu revamp is really all it needs.... And a bar.... The food and service were both mediocare. Neither wowed us. The whole experience was just "eh...." Which sucks because of how truly beautiful the interior is. Salad bar for $10 was not worth it. Find better items at Ruby Tuesdays salad bar for $3. As others mentioned.... Vegetable of the day was canned corn. My steak wasn't bad, but my boyfriends burger was sad and depressing looking. Barn fries were good. Broccoli and cheese soup had noodles in it. Will not return. Not worth the price. read more

First time eating here with hopes of a hometown meal. To say the least it was far from. Ordered an 18oz T-bone steak that had been over tenderized so much that it was as flat as a crepe. After driving an hour we didn't want to fuss, rather suffered through. The steak was very dry with absolutely no juice; ordered as medium. It tasted as it was precooked and microwaved. When the waitress asked how our meal was we stated it was awful and we had to stop eating halfway this was because meat actually tasted bad/ old. Her response was, "did it taste old" this was before we even stated it tasted old or precooked, "you already ate some so we won't comp it" .... when we asked how the steak was prepared as it tasted precooked she stated, "I don't know what goes on in that kitchen". I should have left when the bread and our table were swarmed by fruit flies. Say the least we will never go back. read more

Is the food good? Very much 'Yes'. Is the food Amish or Mennonite food? No, but given the area, dress code, and decor, you might think so. Took my wife there because she loves Amish cooking. She was super excited when we arrived, but not so much when we left. Not that she didn't enjoy the food, that's not the case at all. It's just that it's not what she expected. read more

Delicious! Visiting from out of town and exceeded expectations. Would give it a 10/10. Staff were courteous and nice. The food was fantastic and fresh. Will come back if ever in the area. read more

My favorite restaurant here in Wooster (Smithville) OH. Great food, wonderful Salad Bar, Great Ambience, and service is really good. A wonderful place. read more

The Barn Restaurant - American Near Me - Smithville, Ohio

We had heard a lot about the Barn. While on a short trip to the area we checked it out. It was on a Sat so we expected a crowd. It was busy but we were seated quickly. The waitress was fast and friendly. The food was OK but with all the hype I expected much better for the price. It was bland. The mashed Potatoes were instants. Salad bar was very full with a lot of variety. To be honest I will drive a little farther and go to Mrs. Yoders in Mt Hope. read more

in the last week Not a fan! Drove past it at first as it looks like a container building. No curb appeal. Parked in back had to scale down a rocky ledge, no stairs or paths. Entered to what felt like a gym with hockey bags and kids. Walked down hall to door to the restrauant. Kids running around or doing homework. Ordered spinach pizza. Cold spinach thrown on top of a hot pizza=Cold pizza. Does have a bar but with kids runni g around seemed strange. Not a place to relax. May take grandkids back for lunch as it does have a glass window overlooking a ice rink. read more

My family and I found this place while just driving today. I was very impressed by the kids menu and choices. My daughter ordered a cheeseburger and fries and she was full by the end of the burger. My son ordered a hotdog with a side of mac and cheese. The mac and cheese was big enough for an entree on it own and he said it was really good. My husband got the unlimited salad bar that came with the soup and bread station too. He said the broccoli cheese soup was amazing. The salad bar had lots of options and all the items looked and tasted good. I had the hot roast beef sandwich and mashed potatoes with gravy and a salad from the salad bar. It was so good I could not stop eating. It is not a fancy place but it had good food. We will definitely go back. read more

We were in the area and over the years I had heard of this place. So we decided to stop there for a late lunch. We were greeted promptly by a friendly waiter and seated. The decor is very nice and seems well maintained. These are the ONLY complimentary things I can say about this place! Do yourself a favor and avoid! I looked at the menu before we went and was excited about the food, but the lunch menu had little resemblance to the online dinner menu. So we settled for a simple burger and roast beef sandwich - we should have just walked out instead. The restaurant was not busy and there were plenty of wait-staff around but somehow this simple meal took well over 20 minutes to come out. My wife's hamburger was dry and burnt. My mashed potatoes tasted fresh from a from a box and it was tasteless. The roast beef was overcooked/tasteless but it was hard to tell at first how little meat there was since the whole plate was drowning in a flavorless brown sauce. And in spite of the wait, the only thing hot was the onion rings (which also tasted like it fresh from the freezer). At night we stopped at another restaurant and we were reminded what a good experience is like. Fresh, tasty, hot, prompt service and food even when crowded. The Barn lacks all of that! One could argue that dinner is it strength, but I will NEVER waste my money or time to find out. read more

Just attempted to eat a burger here. Burnt and dry, it tasted like the frozen kind you get out of a box. Waitress said it was because they use an "open flame". Wtf lol. Cashier didn't ask nor care how the food was. 2 stars because my wife enjoyed the salad bar. I left nauseated read more

Great view and cool antique looking decor . Food is over priced and absolutely sucks!! Had the grilled chicken and it was way over cooked, under seasoned and super dry. Salad bar is decent and I like the bread and honey butter. read more

I can only review the soup and salad bar. The rest of the menu may be great, but I wouldn't know. Coming into the restaurant which has a great atmosphere younthink you are going to get some great home cooking. You would be wrong. As for the soups, the chili tasted like it was out of a can. The chicken noodle was very gamey, and the vegetable was so,so. All were luke warm. The salad bar was very blah, nothing special. The croutons were stale. The fruits were from a can also. And like another reviewer said, nothing was labeled, not even the dressings except for low-cal on one. Same for the soups. Annoying. The honey butter "spread" was the best thing on the salad bar as it saved the tast of the so- so bread. But even it wasn't real butter. There were tons of waitresses standing around but we finally had to put our plates on the table next to us in order to get rid of some items. So, all in all...salad bar worth about half the 9.50 price and service was nothing to rave about. We won't return. read more

the barn is the bomb. it's a restaurant... in a giant barn! how can you go wrong with farm implements and comfort food? if you're in the amish country tourist mode, be sure to visit during shopping hours. there are really cute shops just next door in the old farm houses. read more

I was disappointed at my first visit to the Barn Restaurant. I was with a group. If you like comfort food you will like this place but it did not appeal to me at all since I am trying to eat healthy. The salad bar not not even look good to me. I did not like the atmosphere or the seating arrangements. Would not go back. read more

We love the Barn! I usually go with the salad wagon, which includes their soups and homemade bread. Or, you can add a sandwich for just a couple bucks extra. Great place for families. read more

My daughter, my boyfriend and his daughter and I went to The Barn for lunch today. The girls and I opted for the salad bar but my boyfriend, since he ate earlier, ordered a piece of pie with ice cream. The pie was served to him cold. He asked if it could be heated up and the waitress took it back saying, "I thought I heated it up." Now I have been a server before and you should never argue with a customer, just make them happy. The pie was given to him cold again but this time the ice cream was melted because she kept the ice cream on the plate when she warmed up the pie in the microwave the second time. My boyfriend went to the manager and complained. I will say that the manager apologized, heated up the pie himself and gave it to my boyfriend for free. The waitress also half-heartedly apologized and never took any of our dirty dishes off the table. Her service was very poor. She did not have to do anything except serve of drinks, serve a piece of pie and clear dishes...and she couldn't even to do that. I will not go back. read more

It's good stick-to-your-ribs food- and there is a lot of it. Great place if you have kids, many choices even if you have one that's a picky eater. A lot of seating, so we didn't wait long. read more

This place is always busy and I can't understand why. The building is kind of cool, neat pond, some interesting shops on the grounds. The food is cafeteria. Bland, unseasoned. Soups are thin and tasteless. Service is no more than "what'll ya have" " here's the check." Really creepy that they don't play any music. Servers told us the owner won't "pay unions for music" read more

I go for the lunch salad bar and chili. Not cheap, but it's a good salad wagon. Go early..

I ordered their chicken breast meal that was listed at the time for $12, I thought i was gonna get a good sized piece of chicken, NOPE, looked like a 4 ounce piece of chicken with a little cup of what tasted like microwaved corn with a cold ass potato on the side. Very disappointed in this restaurant that was highly recommend to me. read more

Been coming here for years, always for the salad wagon. Servers are always friendly, and many have been there all along. Love the blueberry bread and their chili is fabulous too. A nice, home style family-friendly place. Setting is nice too and a bulk food shop is nearby for browsing while walking off the salad wagon! read more

The fact that this place is so busy all the time sort of surprises me. Bland, boring food the caliber of Golden Corral. 2nd visit for us. Don't think we would return. Come for the view, but not the food. read more

Come for the atmosphere not the food. Everything is frozen, bagged or canned. I got the salad bar and the chopped eggs were still frozen. Not my favorite place. read more

Big salad bar is the main feature. The food is adequate. It's got a homey atmosphere.

Nice atmosphere and great scenery. Reasonable prices and the food is okay but nothing to write home about. You will mostly likely enjoy your surroundings more than the food, but still a decent place. read more

The soups are bland. The rest of the food is just okay (barely). I live in wayne county and would rather go to Das Dutch kitchen in Dalton or just about anywhere. I will not be back. read more

The service is great which is why it gets one star. We paid $15.50 a person for the buffet. The food was the equivalent to a Swanson's TV dinner. It is expensive and the quality is poor. It is warmed over cafeteria food at best. Steer clear of this barn. All-you-can-eat does not mean it's worth evening. read more

I have given The Barn one star for atmosphere but that is about as far as it goes. We have eaten here many times but have noticed the quality of the food steadily declining and the prices rising. This visit found the food bland and over priced. I wanted a potato crusted trout lunch that came with two sides for $10.95. I asked if I could substitute one side for the salad bar. I was told I could substitute BOTH sides and get the salad bar for an additional $4.95!! So in essence I would pay $10.95 for a piece of fish and an additional $4.95 for a salad. Somehow this just seems outrageous! I settled for a $5.95 creamed chicken on biscuits lunch and added a salad bar. Final cost? $10.90 for the meal. The creamed chicken was bland, nearly devoid of chicken, and was basically biscuits and cream sauce. What a disappointment. I guess I have learned my lesson. I won't be back. read more

Go for the building, not the food. Everything is either frozen, reheated product or bland. With such a large salad bar, we were expecting great things. But the dressings were bland and so were the soups. We also tried a burger and chicken fingers and fries, but everything was obviously a frozen product. Save your money and go to a place that actually cares about their customers. read more

Love coming to the salad bar upstairs and getting the broccoli cheese soup with blueberry beard. We have been going to this restaurant since I was a kid to have dinner and feed the ducks. The hot buffet downstairs is worth the money as everything is delicious! read more

We went to The Barn for dinner and must say that we were pleasantly surprised. While I may agree with the first review of the look of the cattle call in the basement where the buffet is, the upstairs was nice, clean, and the wait staff was extremely pleasant. The food was just fine as well as the salad bar/wagon. We were pleasantly surprised and would recommend. read more

Horrible! Just had a steak; one bite and almost puked from the putrid taste. I will never return there.

WE ateat the buffet.The food was good 2 years ago. But now the food was very very bad.. How ever the serivce was very good . Needles to say we will not be going back read more

Went here on the recommendation of some friends and family. They said it's been a long time since they have eaten there but salad bar was always great. Upon entering I was greeted warmly, the atmosphere quiet, and relaxing. It was set on a very scenic property. I had the unlimited soup, salad, and bread for $9.95 it was well worth it. The salad wagon very fresh with many choices, including 3 bean salad, peaches, cottage cheese, chicken salad, pudding etc. the soup was so delicious vegetable beef I had, but they also had broccoli cheese, ham and bean, chili which my uncle said was great and chicken noodle. They had several breads to choose from, I had corn bread which was good. I was happy with my overall experience. We checked out the gift shops and bought some Amish made goodies to take home. We took a stroll around the lake, and watched the fish and the ducks. This is a very family oriented place. It was a nice way to spend a sunny weekday afternoon. read more

See all

Neat restaurant, staff was great, food not so much. Canned corn, stove top stuffing, instant mashed potatoes, none of the so called soups were labeled it is a guessing game. Won't be going back anytime soon. read more

Great decor and atmosphere but upstairs the food is just awful and overpriced. Service was poor also. If you want good food and decent prices you won't get it here. If you like feeding ducks and fish, paying over $10 for an awful salad wagon, and hanging with seniors then maybe this is for you. read more

This was quite possibly the worst meal I have ever experienced. "TheBarn" leads you to believe you are going to sit down to some good home cooked food with its charming ambiance of a restored Barn & beautiful country views overlooking a pond. The staff was friendly & that's as far as this 1 star rating will get. If you like fresh out of a can salad bar toppings, a bread bar that has an array of various stale cornbread & other mystery bread slices then you've found hospital cafeteria food heaven. The soup was incredibly salty & the ribs & corn were shriveled up looking like they were sitting in a steam pan for days. I downloaded this yelp app before leaving the parking lot because I was so compelled to inform hungry people to be warned about the huge let down awaiting them inside this seemingly quaint country dining experience. read more

This restaurant is definitely more for the atmosphere than the food, but that wasn't bad either. Easily one of the coolest places to go for a meal. An old barn turned into a restaurant. Beautifully decorated and if you are lucky enough to get a seat near the window, excellent scenery. We went for the salad bar for lunch. The ingredients out were fresh nothing out of the ordinary food wise. Good soups and fresh bread. Good meal for the price. Service was quick and friendly. We went on a snowy weekend so there were very few people in the restaurant but I've heard it gets packed. Would definitely go back. read more