I walked in the door, saw the chatter at the bar around whatever ball game was on, smelled the…read morelobster in the air and knew this food was going to be perfect. Regular tavern feel nothing special, but all the while perfect and cozy. Waiters were quick, kind, and didn't hover but were always around if you needed them. Portions had half sizes which I appreciated. The half was quite small and the regular was very large, so take your pick. THE BURGER!!! Get the burger! Bonus points if you get a side mac and cheese and put some on the burger ( that's what I did).

This was our go-to restaurant while staying in Hyannis. We actually ordered food from here twice to…read moretake back to the abnb. I loved the bacon wrapped scallops. The pizza was good as well. The lemon pepper wings were hardly seasoned. Also they were very dry. I could barely taste the lemon flavor. My fried cod fish sandwich was delicious though! With the exception of the wings every thing else was pretty good. Including the scallops and rice. They have lots of available parking. Can't comment on the dining in experience. Everything was called in for pick-up. So I would give this restaurant a 3.5 rating.

What a great find Sue had a coupon for the Cove…read moreWe were pleasantly surprised at the upscale restaurant right near the end of the Main Street in Hyannis The service was superb! Katie was our waitress,and she aimed to please from the wine tasting to make sure we like our choices from the wine list We both selected the fish taco with pineapple salsa with a very nice dressing The unique potato chip fried fish was so fresh We opt for the garlic bread to go with our wine and that too had its special flare I know we both said this is a first but not our last trip to enjoy the food ,service and ambience . Thanks Katie for answering all our many questions and making so many extra trips to the kitchen for us Jackie S

We came here because of the great reviews and sat at the bar, but we were pretty disappointed. The…read morebluefish pate itself was good, but rather on the salty side, so serving it with salt and vinegar chips made it pretty much inedibly salty (this was taken off the bill when the bartender noticed we didn't eat more than one bite each). My first glass of vinho verde wine was served at room temperature (the second was fine), and the side plate I was given was crusted with dried food residue. I also watched an employee behind the bar wipe her nose with her hand and then continue slicing citrus barehanded. The chicken empanadas were good but not particularly special. We also had one of the small pizzas, which was the best thing of the night, crispy and flavorful (with a little char at the edges, which we like). The decor is a little bananas (different shades of green between the walls, the napkins, the barstools, and the banquettes; five kinds of lighting fixtures; lots of sound and lighting items with exposed, hasty-looking wiring). The bathroom door doesn't really close and lock properly. And the restaurant is really loud, even half full. The writing on the menu, about family members and special recipes, tells me that there's pride here and real care about making a good restaurant. However, without the attention to detail (particularly cleanliness and hygiene!), that's kind of moot. Three stars instead of two here because the pizza was good and the staff obviously care about customers.

Got to get used to the new name. It will always be " the egg and I" to us, after coming for over 25…read moreyears. The sons took over in 2025, we knew something was different this trip. New umbrellas , things looked nice and tidy. Ilia greeted us, very nice young man, offered to bring water for Brewster. Kelly served us, so nice, and everything was perfect for a leisurely breakfast in the shade. We will return again and again. Great place.

I have been coming here for longer than I can remember. Way back in the Egg and I days and I NEVER…read moreleave unimpressed. This place has come a very long way through renovations and innovations and I'm happy to see the restaurant is blooming! The service is wonderful and the food is top notch! A staple in Hyannis and a must try for anyone passing through! A massive patio and just an overall awesome place on Main St!

Stopped by Old Yarmouth Inn with a few friends recently and had a really enjoyable dining…read moreexperience from start to finish. The restaurant was quite busy when we arrived, but since we had reservations we were seated right away. Our server was friendly and took the time to walk us through the menu and highlight the nightly specials. In the end, we all decided on the prix fixe menu, which included an appetizer, entrée, and dessert--an excellent value considering the quality and generous portion sizes. After placing our orders, our server returned with our drinks along with a basket of warm rolls and soft butter, a nice touch to start the meal. The atmosphere is warm and cozy, and the interior is surprisingly spacious. From the outside, you'd never guess how large the restaurant actually is. To start, I ordered the short rib and fontina arancini, which were outstanding. The portion was generous--honestly large enough to be a meal on its own. My wife began with the Caesar salad, which was crisp, fresh, and nicely balanced without being overly dressed. For our main course, my wife and I both chose the crab-stuffed sole. It was excellent and, once again, the portion size was impressive. We even had enough leftovers to make another meal the next day. By the end of the meal we were so full that we decided to take our desserts--New York-style cheesecake and tiramisu--home to enjoy later. There's plenty of parking available, and I'd definitely recommend making reservations, especially on busy nights. Overall, it was a great meal with generous portions, friendly service, and a comfortable atmosphere. I'd happily return

We were able to call a few hours ahead and get a reservation…read more We started with a beer, cosmo and baked clams casino. Cocktail was strong and the clams were good. I had the butter poached filet mignon and my husband had the baked seafood trio. The filet mignon was very good. The seafood trio was also good, just a little buttery. This is a very cute, historic restaurant, love the decor. The service l was ok.

We walked into the Island Cafe and grill the other night and was greeted immediately…read more Not knowing the cuisine that well. We started talking to the people around us and they recommended the Jamaican jerk chicken and oxtail combo. The chicken was to die for and the oxtail rich and gelatinous like it should be. We added a pina colada for an island touch and it was delicious. The most endearing part were the waitresses.. smiles everywhere welcoming everyone.. even though we may not have looked like their normal clientele, they treated us like family. I want to go back and try their fish and chips. I recommend you run not walk to the Island Cafe and grill in Hyannis.

Would've gone 4 1/2 stars if available. Got a couple of salads with jerk chicken. They were really…read moregood. My buddy went back a couple of days later for breakfast and got the coconut French toast, which he said was amazing. Friendly and helpful service. Will be back to try their other offerings.

My companion and I sat on the patio overlooking the harbor for an early dinner. My companion…read moreordered a Bully Boy Vodka Bloody Mary, while I enjoyed a Black Cat Sangria. Both drinks were very good. After our drinks were served, I asked our server a few questions about the portion size of the calamari. Since we were still undecided about our selections, the server left us to consider our options. Once we had made our choices, however, we had difficulty getting the server's attention. My companion had to first motion to the server and eventually call out to get their attention--three times! We both started with a cup of New England Clam Chowder, although I ordered a bowl with my meal. There is definitely a noticeable difference in portion size between the cup and bowl. The chowder itself was excellent--thick, flavorful, and delicious. For our entrées, we selected Clam Strips and Calamari, both as side-dish portions. The food was very good, as were the drinks. Overall, we enjoyed the food, drinks, and beautiful harbor-side patio setting. Unfortunately, the service was only just okay, primarily because of the difficulty we had getting our server's attention after we were ready to order.

As someone who work in the restaurant industry I hate doing this but unfortunately my experience at…read morethis restaurant ruined my romantic vacation. My boyfriend and I had such a great experience here our first night of vacation that we decided to come back our second night. So we went to the hostess and said table for 2 and took the buzzer and were told 45 minute wait. It was an hour wait but I loved the experience and was ok with waiting. So when our buzzer buzzed. I headed to the hostess stand and there was a long line. I didn't want to be rude so I said the lead hostess "hey I just got a buzz" she said "ok maam I will be right with you." She continued to take down the names of the multiple groups of people in line. I decided that I would go to the back of the line to be respectful. As we were just about to near the front I hear her say "table ___ is a no show we are giving away to table ___" the people she gave the table to were people who were bothering her about the long wait time while my boyfriend and I patiently waited. She went to then give me ANOTHER buzzer as she gave our table away although we were there on time and then ignored. I gave the new buzzer back to her and told her that we previously were there with our buzzer and told her and she told us to wait a minute but ignored us. My boyfriend chimed in to say that he saw her give the table away to the next people on the list that were bothering her while we patiently waited. The hostess didn't say sorry and let us leave after we were very respectful. As someone in the industry it breaks my heart. I have been in her position and have done everything I could to make it right and to allow my guests to have the best experience possible. All she did was stare at us as we expressed concern. I was deeply hurt after this interaction and left wondering what I did wrong. All I tried to do was be a loyal customer and be respectful and I was patient and was punished for being patient and respectful. All I want is some recognition and apology.

Its a nice little place right next to the Ferry Terminal. Buzzing with people that comes a goes…read moreabout their day. Mostly a grab and go type of thing. Foos is good and constantly re stocked .

Great offerings and wide selection from 'grab and go' to made to order breakfast. Great service…read more Fair prices. A nice way to start your trip to Nantucket! No negatives whatsoever.

It's been a month since we were on the Cape. Unable to get reservations last year, I plotted ahead…read morethis year. This is a really appealing, intimate, mom and pop (and summer help waitress) place. The hostess/ front of house boss, who was operating from the bar of this 10-12 table location, was gracious and endearing (in the way that an almost overbearing host can be- that meant as a compliment). The drinks took a minute, my fiancé's salad needed blue cheese brought out as it was left off (single most off-putting thing: the waitress, I suspect language mastery being the cause of this rather than malice or willful deceit, flat out told her that blue cheese did not come with the wedge salad...but when boss lady at the bar was asked, this was quickly corrected), there was a heavy does of reggae music. All of this less than optimal. The food was very good, though I can't remember off the top of my head what I had (it's been a month). Nor did I take pics: it seemed like it'd detract from the experience. There weren't any complaints about the food from others. (So I went back and looked at the menu: potstickers as an app- pretty good; baked local seafood as the main- good, but it is what it is in that not a ton of nuance added so as to let the seafood do the talking. The portion was decent for the price. I didn't leave stuffed, but for $38, very reasonable.) All in all, the first visit merits a second visit next year (as the website says they are temporarily closed to seek new management).

This is the best food I've had on the cape, and it's not close. We hope to see them reopen soon.read more

A great pre Thanksgiving dinner Samantha was our waitress…read moreand very entertaining as well as efficient We started with crackers and cheese and a glass of wine We went at 3:30 pm so we were in no way rushed My friend ordered the kale soup and warm rolls and I had the Coconut sweet chili shrimp The evening was just right to start off the November autumn season It is and has been my go to restaurant when friends and family come to Mashpee Jackie S

Food was below average! Ordered fish it was dry and such a small portion no lemon came with it!…read moreAlways liked to go to Hyannis location but it has slipped! Mashpee is so much better! Delivery was great though!

Today was the first time we've tried this place. We heard it was good. We liked it a lot. I had an…read moreegg white breakfast burrito. It was excellent. I'm trying to cut back on egg yolks a bit. Didn't miss the yolk at all in this dish. Came with sour cream, a bit of salsa and guacamole. All good. It also came with a bowl of excellent fresh fruit. Not the crappy stuff... very good fresh fruit including things like blackberries and strawberries. All sweet and ripe. My wife got an excellent omelet with a toasted blueberry muffin. She also got the fruit included. She liked hers a lot. The waitress was great. Very friendly and provided great service. She automatically brought me a second pitcher of hot water and a second tea bag without me even asking. That's a notable first!!! My wife and I looked at each other part way through the meal and said...."We're gonna come back here!"

Really enjoyed my Chef's salad (Orange Cranberry vinaigrette is a light splash of flavor; bacon was…read morebetter than I've had on most Chef's salads. My server was delightful! Love the simple diner-like vibe inside.