So happy to see Feast open again. New look and some new items - the food is amazing. We had Fish, lobster, and pasta dishes - all amazing. Our server, Melissa, was attentive and friendly. Considering this just reopened we expected some missed but there were none. read more

The food was excellent. Service was wonderful server was friendly and attentive. Prices reasonable. Would definitely recommend.

This pizza far exceeded expectations for beach town pizza. Growing up in NY and CT I have high pizza standards and was pleasantly surprised. Would go back! read more

I have now eaten here twice and I plan on coming back a lot more often. While the atmosphere is sort of like a pizza place or a family style restaurant, the food is more like a high quality upscale restaurant. They seem to specialize in seafood with a cajun flair but they offer many and I do mean many other options. Everything I've eaten at The Feast has been outstanding. The grouper bites are perfectly prepared with just the right amount of coating, the clam chowder is great and the caprese salad with a side of a slightly thicker balsamic dressing is huge. They offer a nice selection of local and imported fish. These can be ordered several different ways including with a lobster sauce or a stew like Cajun preparation that is somewhat spicy but outstanding. There is usually a rissoto option and a few pastas. They always have a good sized regular menu as well as a page of specials. I've never even tried the pizza (yes they also make pizzas) but I can say that I saw a LOT of people picking up pizzas to Go so I assume they are good at that too. They offer a nice selection of craft beers on tap as well as some popular brews in bottles / cans. Their wine options seem to perfectly match the style of restaurant that it is. Reasonably priced and good quality for the money. I haven't tried the deserts yet but I'm sure I will at some point. Can't wait to go back. The prices aren't "cheap" but they are fair considering the high quality of the food. My only minor complaint is the appearance / setup. The tables outside are run of the mill picnic tables and the inside is sort of cave like. Having said this, it definitely won't keep me away. I do look forward to trying their pizza as well as many of the other fantastic options on the menu. read more

Dont let the outside fool you the food is just as bad as the place looks. Their grouper was old tasting, the free cornbread was just as bad, even their French fries were not good. Drive a little further and go somewhere else. Service was ok food came out quickly. read more

The service and food wasn't what I was expecting for a random place search! Our friend suggested this place since we were visiting and recommended to eat out with them! I just want to say the Firecracker Shrimp appetizer is something I will never forget. I wish I could order like 5 of these and have it be my meal! It's so good! The Shrimp and Crab Alfredo was just as good! Both was given so much flavor into the dish and I will definitely be back to this place when I visit Florida again but very impressed! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Shrimp and Crab Alfredo - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

We made a reservation for 11 at 6pm . Arrived on time and the table was ready . We had excellent service and the ambiance was cozy. They have an excellent menu and a ton of choices . I recommend the escargot ! Spot on. We did however find out the pizza is take out only . You can't get a pizza in the restaurant . Will definitely return again . Well worth the money spent. read more

We found this place a few years back and still talk about the food. We had to pop back in when we were in town. It's still amazing!! We were greeted and sat quickly. The restaurant is an intimate size but very well laid out. The server was very nice and such a sweet person. She was willing to help with suggestions, very attentive. We ordered a beer and the red sangria- which was great. Glancing through the menu I found the same dish I had before Shrimp and Crab Alfredo. My husband went with one of the specials with two sides. Both were amazing. He couldn't stop taking about his dish. I LOVED mine....again. Full of shrimp and crab. Enough leftover to take a box with me for a nice lunch the next day. Definitely stop by if you are in the area. read more

We sat at the new bar (added since they reopened after the hurricanes). Drinks by Benjamin were amazing, and the Shrimp and Lobster risotto was out of this world! read more

We started with the Excellent Escargot. Backed up with a couple of glasses of J. Lohr Cab. Then split a blackened Snapper sandwich. Coleslaw was a great side. Mmmmm We will be back. Hope to see you there ! read more

See all

Staff was great! Good variety of beers! But the food was not great. Do not get the mac n cheese for you kid... it's a box of kraft mac n cheese that I make better at home. Sorry. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Crab Stuffed Shrimp was good - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

Attention was great, food was phenomenal! Highly recommend when you're on that side of town! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

The food was excellent! I had the Australian wagyu burger and It was amazing. I also shared the mozzarella wedges and that was delicious too! The place was certainly comfortable and it was very welcoming! Our waiter was extremely kind and helpful! We were in an out in about an hour. I would recommend eating here is you are in Anna Maria Island! read more

Atmosphere - OK. Nothing special. The restaurant is located in a strip mall and the decor inside is simple. The restaurant is relatively small. There is a combination of booths and stand alone tables that accommodate roughly 60 patrons. It is fairly loud in the restaurant when near capacity. Outside there are a couple of picnic tables under a canopy. Service - Excellent. In every way and by every measure our service was outstanding. Our server's name is William and he was a major factor in determining my overall rating. My entree was delivered in a timely manner and the food was hot. Food - Excellent. The dinner menu is a little odd. There is a variety but little depth in regard to entree options. However, most people should be able to find something that is appealing. I had the surf n turf, which is a 9 oz rib-eye and 6 large shrimp (with 4-5 preparation options). The steak was cooked to perfection. It was very tender and tasted great. I selected the coconut shrimp and it was excellent as well. Overall - Excellent. Setting aside the lack of ambiance, this was one of the best dining experiences that I have had over the past year. The entree was a reasonable $28. Trust me, I do not hand out 5 star rating often. This restaurant is a gem. read more

Paid high prices for horrid food. Grandsons pasta came with a hair. They wanted to charge for every little thing. Waitress didn't care that a kids meal had a hair in it. Fish was like rubber. Its a disaster. Do not recommend! read more

Our visit was wonderful!! We began with corn crab chowder, recommended by our great server. And followed with pizza, pepperoni and mushrooms!! This was delicious and we enjoyed every bite! Can't wait to go back and enjoy great food! read more

The pizza and cheese sticks didn't disappoint. We got The Works and Tasty white pizza. Both were very good. Service as great. Called ahead with reservations for outside and the fans kept it cool. read more

See all

First of all, very happy these guys were able to reopen after the hurricane damage. But, the reopening has major renovations that make you feel like you're in a subway car. We had a party of 6 and the booth they put us in is obviously only designed for 4. Eating elbow to elbow was not pleasant. Secondly and more importantly was the food! With the exception of the lobster bisque, It was not good at all! The pasta's in all of our dishes was not cooked and all stuck together with the sauces. No one finished their meals. Too bad because we all loved this place year after year but this experience will not have us coming back. read more

Feast has reopened- smaller plates, smaller portions, higher prices and disappointing food. Pre hurricane this was one of my Fav restaurants--- not anymore. Hopefully maybe they will settle on better food and a better value for diners. Meantime I will be going elsewhere. Sorry to lose them as one of my staples. read more

This place was nuts for our late lunch between the crazy prices for kids meals, noise and lack of options never will we return for a lunch. The place is orderly for table layout small dining area with a few booths to cozy up in. Their lunch specials run $12 for appetizers to $20 for lunch sized entrees. There is a all you can eat from 11:30-3:30 for $12 for fish n chips , $22 for gulf shrimp. This place would be great for dinner for adults. The wine list was extensive and worth exploring on a dinner night read more

The Feast Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

I've had food here a couple times. The Snow Crab is excellent. Pizzas are wonderful. Shrimp is very good. Service was really nice. Definitely worth your time. read more

We have been coming to the area for years and the feast is always a great spot. Whether you want take out or dine in the quality is not affected. Although located in a strip mall the food quality is far superior to the location. The risotto was the best I've ever had and food was hot, fresh, and great quality. If you want quality food that will keep you coming back for more than look no further. read more

See all

Food was okay, went toward the end of the night so it was slammed. Great service nonetheless and our waiter helped my boyfriend and I choose our entrees. read more

Congratulations on your new space! The ambiance of the bar is exceptional, creating a welcoming and stylish atmosphere. The food is absolutely outstanding, showcasing both quality and creativity. Wishing you great success in this new location! read more

Delicious night out for pizza. We kept it simple with a large pepperoni. I love the large yet crispy pep topping and fresh shredded mozzarella was amazing! My family had the grouper bites and asked for the cajun aioli to dip them in...both adults and one child raved about them! Friendly service, recommend reservations to be on the safe side. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Pepperoni pizza - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

This was a wonderful dining experience. Reservations are recommended. Their menu changes I assume seasonally. Their side items change daily. The staff was welcoming and kind and attentive. To the meal. I was leaning towards a small salad to start but honestly the mozzarella wedges were calling my name. Hand cut mozzarella daily and breaded in house. I was dining solo. So I thought, why the heck not? I was not disappointed. Who doesn't love fried cheese? Also homemade marinara as well. I am happy to report I only at 90% of the wedges. I felt better that I didn't consume it all myself. I decided on the Hogfish Sanibel as my entree for a few reasons. One, Hogfish is local to the gulf and is spear caught. The lobster cream sauce accompaniment sounded wonderful and my server mentioned it was a popular dish. Well, I am sad to report it just wasn't for me. The fish I had was served in thinner filets and unfortunately overcooked I believe so no tender at all which is how it's best served. I ate a bit and luckily was pretty full from all the cheese I consumed. I mentioned this to Amanda (my server) when she asked if she could box it for me. A couple of minutes later, the manager Ken came over and mentioned that he took it off my bill. I was a bit shocked and really grateful for this kind gesture. I mean, we all order stuff sometimes that isn't great but that's just the roll of the dice right? In any case this place has to totally won me over. Their entire menu looks amazing and I can't wait to come back to try and few other things or maybe stop in for lunch which Amanda also told me about. Thank you! read more

See all

I love going to this place and getting all you can eat crab legs! We had a reservation, so we had no wait getting in to this busy spot for dinner. The crab legs were fantastic , brought out Luke-warm side for my second serving, but enjoyable nonetheless. read more

The Feast Restaurant - Crab legs - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

The Feast is a small friendly restaurant with a set menu and a daily specials menu. Eat in air conditioning or out on the front patio. We dined there twice in the last two weeks. The portions are satisfying and the service was great. read more

My family and I had carryout lunch here one day on a recent vacation. I have to say that this was my favorite food I had of the trip. I had the Charleston style B.L.T. with fried green tomatoes and ranch. This was outstanding! And the accompanying fries and pasta salad were equally as great. Plus the $10 price tag was outstanding! This is a must visit on AMI! read more

The Feast Restaurant - Fried Green Tomato BLT - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

I really do not understand why this place is not a 10/5... this place has been the best food we have eaten all week during our weeklong vacation. We have only been going to top rated restaurants, but this place beats everything we have eaten all week. My wife had the ribs, with garlic mashed potatoes and broccolini, best fall off the ribs... the sauce was perfect. I had the ribeye steak with the same sides as her. The steak was phenomenal. For dessert we had the deconstructed cheesecake; best cheesecake ever. It is one of those places where you can truly taste how savory, tasty and fresh everything is. If you are in Ana Marie Island, you would be a fool not to eat here. The service was amazing and the food came out fast. Also, this was the only place in the whole island where there water did not taste like pond water. They filter their water and you can actually enjoy your beverage of choice. If I would have known about this place earlier, I would have eaten here every night how good the food was. Everyone on here that is writing bad reviews do not know what they are talking about and are most likely the Karens no one likes anyways because this place was top notch in flavor and taste. Eat here and you will not be disappointed! read more

Nice atmosphere. Odd menu choices. Seems like they are torn between trying to be a high end restaurant but also appealing to a bar crowd. Escargot and onion rings on the same menu is a wide variety. Filet was basic, kind of stringy. Others in our party had grouper and said it was good but not great. The best thing we had was the fried mozzarella. I don't think we will try it again. read more

We went for a date night and made a reservation on the phone. It was excellent. Appetizer: fire cracker shrimp. Main: best salad and Lafayette shrimp and lobster linguini (this was a special so maybe not always available). Service was kind all around. read more

I never write reviews, but this was way too much and really ruined what was to be my anniverary dinner. We were there a few nights ago. i have never ever been in a place where you can hear a waitress in the back calling guests "aholes" and crying because she's not being treated well. you could hear everything from our table. We were also in the restaurant a week prior to that and everything seemed ok, but i heard the staff talking about the cooks being stoned???? which made sense because our food was late and not right. I don't know what kind of operation you are running, but i think it needs some adjusting. also, i find out that I'm drinking "wine" alchohol....what is that? read more

I've only ever been to this place on vacations to AMI. So over the past several years, I've eaten here about a dozen times. I remember each time fondly, and all but one I've eaten inside the restaurant. I got a takeout pizza one time (a margherita pizza, which was very good). However, I insist on eating in the restaurant because the daily specials rule. The most interesting thing about The Feast is the daily specials. They earned my trust with the first two dishes. Hogfish and Lane Snapper, if I remember correctly, that were prepared with special sauces and seasonings fitting to the type of fish that just made those plates fun to eat. The chefs that prepare these are artisanal. I've never been let down. I'll reiterate-- those specials are fun to eat. read more

I'm so bummed. Last year this was one of our favorites but we have no clue what happened. We called in and ordered two of the shrimp and lobster pasta specials. We always give grace with take out and realistic but this was just... blah. Zero flavor. I had to doctor it up to make it taste decent (we are talking salt and pepper situation) and the shrimp and lobster were both undercooked... especially the lobster. We aren't picky people but it was kind of scary how undercooked. There was zero seasoning on either. 26 dollars a plate... and we couldn't even eat it without re cooking it ourselves... read more

Amazing find on our AMI vacation. The atmosphere was wonderful and the staff was accommodating, attentive, and helpful. I had the Blackened Red Snapper and it was fresh and cooked to perfection. My wife had the lobster risotto and she loved it-huge chunks of claw meat in the risotto! My daughter had what she described as the best coconut shrimp she's ever tasted. The desserts were delectable-chocolate cake, crem brûlée', and Sunshine cake for us! I highly highly recommend anyone coming to AMI to stop here and dine! Edit: wanted to add that our waiter was Ricardo and he was fantastic-going above and beyond for us! read more

See all

I had the Wagyu beef, surf and turf, and I was here before. It rocked. This place is in a little strip mall, but is worthy of a five star dining. Everybody is super nice and our server was awesome. I highly recommend this place, if you're on the island for something different read more

Quality of the food has declined significantly over the last year or two; especially the shrimp. The restaurant used to be kind of a hidden gem, but now is more like just a Red Lobster. read more

I always thought "The Feast" meant a large buffet, so never looked at the menu. We happened across it and liked the looks of the seafood options. We ordered the blue crab and shrimp entree to split. There was no one at the restaurant for pick-up but us and the guy was somewhat distracted visiting with a friend. Our meal was a huge portion but smelled heavily of fish, most likely the blue crab-and somewhat offputting. The sauce was great flavored and there were at least 6 shrimp and half a cup of crab. We didn't feel well afterwards-didn't get sick but crampy stomachs and sweats. Not sure if not well-cleaned shrimp, old crab or what. Due to the discomfort we probably won't go back but will watch for future reviewers opinions. read more

The Feast Restaurant - meal looked delish but we both became ill after this dish. Had 7 shrimp & decent amount of crab. - Seafood Near Me - Holmes Beach, Florida

See all

We enjoyed our visit here while on vacation. Portion sizes were indeed hearty, you can literally share an entree with two people. We really enjoyed the pizza! The dough and ingredients were amazing! The only reason I don't give 5 stars is the atmosphere is dated; dark and drab. The customer service was good but a little slow on check ins after the food arrived and checkout (getting the check and charging card etc). read more

See all