Quick service bagel place, great sandwiches, nothing fancy but good food. Service is quick and efficient. read more

Three Star Bagels - Lox and bagel - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

I love this place. Nice guys. Typical deli. Don't expect fancy, expect good deli food. I'm rating this based on what this is, a New Jersey deli spot. Bagels, rolls, omelettes on a bagel, lox, all are solid. Good coffee- but make sure you drink it hot! They also have fresh squeezed oj! Enjoy read more

All I wanted to say is in case you don't remember what your orders were "please write it down you won't forget it" Don't blame it on me??? I repeated my order three times but you turned around you asked what kind of bagel. Write it down Eric please!!! And the lady!! You need to be train how your employees take orders. I know your place is so old and local!! But your bagel is so good two thumbs up!! read more

When we tried the bagels here like a year back, they were great. But unfortunately this time it was chewy!! We got everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese. We got 2 bagels and did not find consistency. One was much more chewy than other and looked over baked as well. Also we felt the prices are too high now. read more

See all

Extremely disappointing experience. The toaster--arguably the most essential piece of equipment in any bagel shop--was not working. The bagels themselves were bland and tasted like cardboard. What's worse, a staff member counted cash and then prepared my bagel without washing their hands or wearing gloves. Completely unacceptable hygiene standards. I won't be returning read more

I'm upgrading my review since this place hired a new guy who makes a great breakfast sandwich. Nonetheless, the bagels have been solid here. They have great croissants and, my favorite, the chocolate croissant... but, I'm still trying to figure out if they bake these fresh here, or just warm up a bunch of pre-made ones. What else... Tuna salad is done right. They even bake their own cookies, and the chocolate chip cookie is yummyyyy! read more

See all

Was excited to try my neighborhood bagel shop and overall wife and I enjoyed it! It was quite busy and happening on a weekend morning with at least 5-8 people lined up in front of us, and the bagels (I had toasted everything w/ veggie cream cheese) were quite tasty if not ginormous. Chewy and not too tough nor hard which is important for me. We actually split just one bagel because they are large and server also stuffed it good with the veggie cream cheese which after a while felt a bit too heavy. We also had coffee (eh... watered down diner coffee at best, but that might be because I grind and brew my own every morning) and took a small tub of veggie cream cheese home to repeat the experience at home. But once home, I did find out that the veggie cream cheese is overall a bit too heavy and we did not particularly enjoy eating that. Maybe it's a once-in-a-while thing. Take out is not recommended unless you're going to eat it soon because, it's bagel and they do get pretty hard the next day unless you do it right in storing it. It was a good experience but I don't think I would frequent this place. They do however have interesting menu of sandwiches so we might come try that. Definitely don't come for the coffee though. read more

See all

Very convenient, prompt delivery of our breakfast bagels. Great tasting bagels. Love their mini bagels.

I'm a displaced bagel consumer as my tried and true spot has closed down. I came to this spot less immediately after a subpar experience at a nearby shop. It was a Saturday morning and I wanted a decent breakfast sandwich. When you walk in, you know you're in a typical jersey bagel shop. I was actually a little worried they wouldn't accept cards but they did! I place an order for an egg bagel with sausage and egg, BEC on an egg bagel, and a plain bagel with bacon and egg. I was excited because just looking at the bagels in the display case, they looked good (fluffy and not flat!!!) I will say the pricing is high and it's why I have to deduct a star. Many shops in the area don't charge as much for breakfast sandwiches. However, they do offer breakfast platters with an option of a bagel toasted with butter that seems like an amazing deal. We were saved from a terrible bagel experience by this spot and will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Breakfast sandwiches got one egg you get a bacon egg and cheese and it's just a bacon with a slice of cheese and bagel you can barely see the egg. I should've looked at some of the pictures these people put on here claiming the sandwiches were good lol read more

They have great bagels but .. I was there a few weeks ago the young kid behind the counter dropped a bagel and put it back in the bin !!! He even try to hide it! Went today ask to be toasted and of course it wasn't same young kid that hide the bagel.. come folks ! read more

Once upon a time, this bagel shop was my go-to, the kind of place you'd stand in line for without a second thought. But recently, things have taken a turn. Imagine you're waiting patiently, almost tasting that fresh bagel already, and then--bam!--one of the employees' friends strolls in, skips to the front, and gets served. Just like that, loyalty takes a backseat. My friend has experienced the same thing. It's a real shame because, back when the owners were more hands-on, this would never have flown. Hopefully, they'll step back in to bring things back to the way they were. read more

Fantastic bagels. Best I've found in NJ so far. Soft inside and crispy outside. A variety of types. Definitely come here for the bagels.

Never seen so many negative reviews for a bagel place. Do us all a favor ... take your Apple Pay and step out of the line. Go pay 3$ for a stale bagel up the street Place is a staple in town Good people work there Never had a bad bagel read more

Three Star Bagels - Everything with lox - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Doesn't take much to be friendly, but after coming here for a while, each and every time I come in no one says hello, no one ever smiles, no one ever recognizes anyone who comes into their place, the older woman looks pissed off, the workers look pissed off...what gives, why so freakin unfriendly in a neighborhood bagel shop?? Then, don't even think about buying a sandwich here, because they either simply do not know how to make a decent deli sandwich or maybe they use inferior meats, cheese, etc, because I've tried a few and each time the sandwich is barely edible. I've learned that their bagels are decent, but will be taking my business elsewhere because I want to be somewhere where ppl are friendly and happy and can make a decent sandwich. read more

Best bagels I've ever had because when you get it toasted the cream cheese is very drippy and amazing. The service is good and the place is very nice. read more

I usually go to bagel Works on River Road in edgewater but they're closed. I don't know why so I ended up at three star in Fort Lee. All I did was order a toasted bagel. I thought it was actually fantastic. I don't know what the other review talking about chewy was, but it may have been the best bagel I ever had. I'll be back For sure. read more

Def a 3 star place lol. Stale products, skimpy sandwiches, mine had almost no egg!!! Service is crappy because prices vary daily. Ambiance is ok, average little store with no counters to eat at or seats read more

I feel compelled to post this. I had written a very positive review of this establishment recently, especially praising the workers. That review stands, they are great. My complaint is about their passing stale muffins. This sounds minor, and maybe it is, but on numerous occasions I bought a muffin and couldn't eat it because it was so dry and stale. It happened this Friday, again. I should have learned my lesson, now I have. This business has good food, but to push stale goods is sad. Money doesn't grow on trees, and I dispise throwing food away. My advice is to avoid the muffins, they're not good. read more

After trying another local place that was unsuccessful with making a simple Taylor Ham and cheese on a roll, I figured I'd try this place. As you can tell by the photo there is barely a slice of cheese and 4 very thinly sliced pieces of burnt Taylor ham. The server was very polite, I will say that. read more

Three Star Bagels - Taylor ham with cheese on a roll - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Mediocre bagels, mediocre cream cheese. Mediocre breakfast sandwiches. The store staff will try and rip you off at the cash register. BEWARE

Good bagel, terrible breakfast sandwich especially for the price! Very disappointed in the quality. read more

Three Star Bagels - Good bagel, awful breakfast sandwich! - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Rude and rude. Ordered ice coffee and asked me to put in hot coffee. Of course the ice melts. Then I asked for more ice and told me I had go back in line. Just wanted ice coffee in 90 degree weather. When I turned my back to walk out he said something and everyone in the store was laughing. The young Spanish worker did it all. Just wanted ice coffee! Bagels are nothing special. read more

I ordered veggie cream cheese bagel and found tissue in the cream cheese...... disgusting read more

Three Star Bagels - Ordered a bagel and found tissue in the cream cheese....... - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

My sausage, egg, and cheese.... after spending $32 on 4 sandwiches, this is what I get. Where is the sausage???? I didn't order the bacon because they're cheap with that also. A BLT.... or should I say an LT with a slice of bacon? Lesson learned. read more

Three Star Bagels - Sausage, egg, and cheese... - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

See all

I always get the mix bagel from here and it's good. However, today I bought a pumpkin cake and was so disappointed when I went to eat it and it was covered in mold in the bottom. Should be more diligent with the food that they have put out. read more

If leaving bagels on the floor is okay, not sure what isn't okay....thats my last time there for sure. Very disappointing.... read more

Three Star Bagels - Bagels on the floor! - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

I found this to be some pretty good bagels I have yet tried. Very fresh, nice chew to them and great taste. However, they are a little heavy handed when it came down to the amount of cream cheese added (TON)! They are not cheap with it at all. It was so much cream cheese you could have easily speared 2 other bagels. But, I enjoy it. Would recommend them. read more

I will never step foot into this place again if been a loyal customer there for almost 20 years and I usually order my meals over the phone as the line could be long at the establishment. They have this older woman who takes the order and consistently screws up the order but I've dealt with it for years because of her age. Today I call, and ask if they have a whole wheat everything so I asked for just an everything. She says no and Her exact words were "I'm not going to tell you if we have what we have" and the hangs up on me. I call back and ask to speak to the guys who all know me she hung up the phone on me again. I'm sorry you guys lost my business forever not to mention the thousand of dollars in tips as I would go there sometimes 4-5 times a week. read more

Whole in the wall mom and pop bagel kind of place.. scallion cream cheese on a everything bagel is everything! Wish they toasted a little bit more. read more

Three Star Bagels - Outside - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

See all

I mean the name says it all and they are speaking highly of themselves. Really tried to like this place but service is so bad I just can't try anymore read more

I have had a love/hate relationship with this place for many years. I've been putting off reviewing it as a result, but I think I've finally come to a consensus. 3 Star makes a good bagel, like the actual plain bagel before adding anything to it. Whatever their recipe is, it works really well. Nevertheless, I dislike every other thing about this place. First, the customer service is shoddy at best. They are rude, uninterested, and really don't care. Why? Because their bagels are better than any other place in a five mile radius most likely. Even the way they spread their cream cheese says "I don't care." Literally never evenly spread. Second, the price is too high. You can't charge me more than a bagel place in Manhattan. You just cant! Your rent is nowhere near as high on Columbia Ave in Fort Lee as a bagel place in most of Manhattan. These guys even charge to toast a bagel, which is simply absurd. A regular bagel with some cream cheese spread is like $3.50-$4 and if you add anything like a single slice of tomato you're going to be in the mid $4's. I once got a bagel with cream cheese and lox and it was no joke like $8. Third, the portions. They skimp on everything recently. In the past, they would put a ridiculous amount of cream cheese in a sort of blob shape. Now, it's a very thin layer of uneven cream cheese. Last is quality. Very often the cream cheese here tastes grainy. I think it's because it's previously frozen, but I'm not sure. In addition, their lox and their in-house turkey looks weathered and unappetizing. Overall, 3 stars because it's a decent bagel despite all the work they put in to making the taste and experience worse. read more

Since my usual bagel place was closed, tried this place today. Have to admit these are the best bagels in the area and the price is the same. Probably some of the best bagels I've had. There was a nice old lady behind the counter and everyone seemed friendly enough. Read all the bad reviews from all the angry, melodramatic Yelp terrorists and thought it was funny. Everyone needs to calm down. It's a bagel shop and it's only bagels. Save your drama for a restaurant with at least one Michelin Star and bill for a prix fixe dinner for two is $750. Otherwise relax and have a bagel. read more

One of the best my style bagels in north jersey. they tend to run out of certain bagels at around 1130 so if you want an everything bagel get there early! Consistent quality and friendly service. Did I mention that they have hammentasch and ruggalach? read more

Three Star Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

UPDATE: March 30, 2916: Ordered a BEC on a roll with extra bacon... If you've read my previous reviews, you will have see that I've ordered this sandwich (w extra bacon) before and was highly disappointed... After I left that review I ordered the sandwich again a few weeks later; and it was so so so freaking good. The lady (young woman) that cooked my sandwich did an excellent job. fast forward to today: they are back to their old ways; the older woman (I think the owner? I'm not sure) who cooked my order charged me for extra bacon and barely put 4 whole pieces on the sandwich. I was munchied and disappointed... I have included pictures of my sad sandwich (and I think I've already posted pics previously of the good sandwich for comparison . For fairness sake, most of the employees will hook you up when you ask for extra, they all pretty good employees! :) Come ONNN three star bagel, for the prices you charge ($3 for a bagel w cream cheese) you'd expect extra bacon (especially since you charge so much for it) Thanks! I'll be back soon to see how it goes next time :) Side note- their rolls are so awesome though! Nice and warm, chewy and soft! YUM!! FORMER REVIEW:: Well.... Their bagels are tasty but very pricy. Let's say a plain bagel is a dollar. To add cream cheese to that, the price jumps to 2.75! I'm sorry but that's crazy to me. Normally I'll get a BEC on a roll- even that is a rip off. Literally ONE piece of bacon per side. And this isn't a "oops one time" thing, it's standard. (I've included a photo of my last sandwich which I got this morning at about 6:30am). Do yourself a favor and hit up the Binghamton bagels on Anderson ave. at least they give you a filling sandwich! I'm disappointed, because 3 star used to be my favorite place :( read more

See all

This is the bagel place I've been going to all my life! I've been a loyal customer here bc the bagels and indisputably high quality and it's walking distance from my home. I love me an everything bagel, but can't stand when other places stint on the toppings (seeds? Garnishes?). This is never a problem here. What sometimes is a problem is that if you go too late in the morning (~10,11am) depending in the day they run out of certain types of bagels. I tend to go on the weekends, and there almost always are at least a few people in line. This isn't too much of a problem, as service is quick. CON: The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is that the prices are quite hefty. I don't mind too much because I like to go as a slight treat/cheat for myself and my family, and the convenience and quality of the place trumps the price for me...but I see how this could add up if I were more of a regular customer. read more

Three Star Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

See all

over priced $9.00 for a sandwich on round road is ridiculous. Only go there when I have too and most of the time they get it wrong. read more

Awful customer service. They had me wait on hold for five minutes just to hang up! I find it incredulous that someone would have another individual stay on the line for that extended period of time. I've eaten at this establishment for many years, but they will no longer receive my business. First, the typical sausage, egg, and cheese was $4.26 with tax and it was randomly raised to $5.36 with tax. Not to mention, the bacon, egg, and cheese is $6+. Poor service and bad pricing. Much better places nearby. read more

Three Star Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fort Lee, New Jersey

Terrible experience here. Don't know what has happened to this place; used to be great not anymore! Food quality was awful! Ordered chicken salad all I got was old dry chicken with old tasting mayo and celery for $11 per lb. They also charged me for 4 bagels and I only got 3. I think the owner better keep a check on this "operation". read more

Had a very good BLT , bagel order , and the lox selection is really good. Definitely would recommend for the variety of bagels .