My family and I visited here yesterday . For a Sunday afternoon in the Summer, it was not too busy . Our waitress was very nice and honest how the food was not homemade but ordered from distribution company, Sysco. I ordered a three meat combo pizza. My Aunt had the " homemade" lasagna .. tasted like a frozen lasagna you get at the grocery store . My cousin ordered the French dip.. very blah and meat not tasty at all. Salad bar was your typical salad bar you find at Fresh Choice. Nothing unique and not fresh- all prepackaged.. Overall, my family who are locals will never come back. read more

Service was fast and friendly despite them being understaffed and the pizza was delicious! Great lunch special prices. Also got the cheesy breadsticks, so yummy! Would definitely go back. read more

Their homemade McCall pizza was awesome. Loaded up with meat and veggies, it was very filling. The waitress was also awesome, she gave it that small restaurant vibe and was very energetic and happy! The only down side is the bar was wine and beer only. The pizza however was very good. read more

We came here for lunch and waited nearly an hour for our food on a slow Wednesday, while there were only three other tables in the whole restaurant. The food not hot, and the service was NOT good. Ivey, our server, never did refill our water, check in with how the food was, or apologize for the extremely slow service. She made us feel as if she was doing us a huge favor by letting us eat here. read more

The food is bland. I ordered the fettuccine alfredo and the pasta wasn't cooked all the through and the sauce didn't have much flavor. The garlic bread was also stale and we had three different waiters throughout the entire time we were there, wasn't impressed with the service at all. read more

Called ahead and arrived fir dinner was told would have to get to go, as we where ordering was told sorry kitchen closed 2 min ago. Will never go back read more

Pizza was barely edible. Toppings were bland. Mozzarella and sauce were gross. A large pizza is 12"? They automatically charge 15% gratuity on pick up which I thought was pretty trashy. Never seen that from a restaurant before. Staff was friendly and salad was decent. read more

This place was so clean and yummy! I loved my server on 2/18/2020, she was so sweet and always had a smile on her face! The other employees working were also so kind! The food was sooo good and I am a very picky eater. I also met the kindest family who knew sign language and we bonded over that! If you are in McCall Idaho definitely go to this restaurant! read more

Great service, great people, gluten-free options, fresh..... Absolutely would go back again! We happen to do it to To go order and they did great. Thank you Toll Station! read more

This is our go to place in McCall.. They have something for everyone. The staff is always freindly and welcoming! Very good salad bar! The appetizers and a full bar are good as well. But the pizza is always GREAT! This is a goos place for the faimly or big groups! read more

Toll Station Pizza - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Pizza was pretty good, not great and WAY too much cheese. The Chicken Caesar pizza sounded divine but ended up being on the bland side with twice as much cheese as it needed. It tasted like a cheese pizza with some artichoke. They overcooked my daughters mini pepp pizza (almost burnt), and PLEASE do not pay for their Bread "Sticks" or Garlic Bread. They charge 3-4.50 for this, and all you get is 4 little hard, dry squares of baguette bread. And it takes them a solid 25 mins to get you those. They offered to refill my Root Beer when I had 3/4 of a glass still, and then never came back until they brought our check. It would get 5 stars from me if the prices were lower, but to pay what they charge, I had much higher expectations. read more

Excellent! Our table had pizzas, sandwiches and kids spaghetti and finger steaks. Everyone one was pleased with their order. The salad bar was clean and well stocked. Service was great! We had 8 people total with 4 hungry kids. They sat us 10 minutes before they even opened. Will return. read more

Wow! This pizza is incredible. We had a 1/2 chicken caesar and 1/2 BBQ chicken. Both were amazing but the slight edge goes to the caesar. Happy servers, decently fast, good salad bar. Fun atmosphere. read more

Toll Station Pizza - Last piece of BBQ chicken and my sweet analie. - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

Awful service, food was absolutely subpar, the staff have no urgency and I'm sure take their jobs as a joke. The pizza is all you should ever get here and the salad bar is the saddest thing I've seen in Idaho. read more

This is probably the WORST restaurant I've been to in 10 years. We were seated rather quickly and got our drinks and then didn't see our servers for 45 minutes. Drinks were empty, then after the server showed up he let us know there was a mistake and our order hadn't been started. He claimed it would be another 20 minutes. 20 minutes later he came back to let us know another 5 minutes. So after sitting for a hour and twenty minutes we decided to leave. That's when the staff got nasty and even charged a gratuity for the drinks we covered. Awful servers, non existent customer respect. read more

We were looking for a sit down restaurant and ended up here. Much to our surprise it had great food and our server was great also. We weren't sure when we walked in as the older lady that was seating people was not the friendliest. Our server was named Charlie he was such a nice young man. Food was great I had the fish and chips and when I ordered it Charlie said it was his favorite thing on the menu. The fish came with fries and slaw and it was all really good. Kids had pizzas and the 3 year old almost ate her whole pizza she said it was delicious. Chicken tenders were good also and cheeseburger looked amazing. I am glad we stumbled upon this place. read more

Wow-I haven't an experience like this in YEARS! Walked in, got glared at by one employee while they were chatting with friends. We were finally seated, but then waited 10 minutes for our waitress. Went to the salad bar and as soon as I started to fill my plate, an older male employee angrily grabbed the lettuce and stomped away, leaving me standing there. We ordered a pizza, and it was worse than any frozen one you might buy at the market! No flavor to the toppings and skimpy cheese. To end our crappy dining experience, no one ever came to check on how we were doing and after 20 minutes of waiting, we had to ask for our check from a random employee as we never saw our waitress again. We will never go bad and will be sure to tell everyone we know, Toll Station Pizza sucks. read more

Been a staple here in McCall for years. Great place to stop in and eat any time of the year. The outdoor patio is a must during warmer weather. Great place to relax while people-watching with a view of Payette Lake. Inside the restaurant is cozy, but a little dated. That doesn't bother me at all, but go for a booth as the chairs aren't exactly comfortable. There's a large back room to accommodate a larger party if you don't want to join tables in the main dining rooms with everyone else. Their pizza is good, mainly due to the crust. The sauce and meats, in my experience, tend to be a bit on the bland side. They do load it with lots of cheese, as its been said. The salad bar is big and very popular. My fav on the menu thus far is the salmon burger. Have yet to try the prime rib. The service for us has always been good, though I have seen what other reviewers have said about the younger inattentive staff. We've never had that experience. read more

We ordered half pepperoni and half margherita pizza. I wouldn't quite call it awful, but it really wasn't good. I would not got here again or recommend this place. However, I will compliment the service. read more

I worked here for 5 years. Love there food and the people. They have changed the menu a lot but the salad bar with always be a staple to me. The best salad bar around. the owner and manager are awesome :) read more

We just stopped in for lunch on our way up to Coeur d'Alene, ID. The kids got mini pizzas and kids' chicken strips. The portions were good sized. Our 5yo boy ate 3/4th of his pizza, our 8 yo girl ate 2/3rds of her chicken strips and most of her fries, our 10 yo boy ate 3/4 of his pizza, and our almost 13 yo girl ate all of her pizza and about half of the salad she got. Hubby and I each got a mini pizza, his with salad, mine with soup. It was all good!!! Would eat there again... Only downside was, the restaurant was pretty chilly when we went in, so my soup got cold pretty quickly. read more

Pretty great little place but I must say that I always get seated in the little side bar area and next time I'll insist otherwise because I never get the service that this place is capable of offering. Even on nights where it is packed we have waited 10-15 minutes to order after drinks are dropped off and I honestly think it's because we've been out of sight. I think this because our servers are always genuine and kind when they are present but that presence is unfortunately sparce. The last couple of times I have only seen my server when we order, when we get our food and when we ask for the ticket. Still if you are looking for a place to eat in McCall you've got to check this place out! Great pizza and spinach and artichoke dip is so tasty. I might get it as an entrée next time! read more

Toll Station Pizza - Spinach and artichoke dip - Pizza Near Me - McCall, Idaho

See all

Worst place to eat in McCall Food is so bland & mediocre So many staff and they have no idea what they are doing. When I finally got my check 10 mins after waiting for it. When I checked out the lady asked how my food was and I told her she seemed annoyed and didnt even say anything after I paid. I could have had food and walked out & they probably wouldn't have known read more

We hadn't been back to Toll Station for awhile. Our mouth was watering just thinking about their pizza. It did not disappoint! We had great service from Shari D - it was fun to visit with her. We so appreciate excellent service - and the bus boys were great too. Thanks for a fantastic meal! cf read more

We went here 2x on our trip which is funny because the food is average at best...but our kids loved the spaghetti marinara & the patio view is really nice...likewise they staff makes you feel comfortable from the moment you enter. My son had a small pizza that looked outstanding & as I mentioned before, the kids spaghetti was devour-able by 2 otherwise picky young girls! We would easily go again! read more

Do yourself a favor.....stay away. Horrible pizza. Crust like cardboard. Pleasant waitress. read more

Really good food !! Terrible service , took forever for someone to take our order , no refills and never came back to see if our food was good . Had to go up and ask for boxes and our check . We called to have a pizza delivered that night and the lady was so rude in the phone . Yelled at me saying they don't deliver even tho their website said they do order . Definitely go eat there just don't expect great service !! read more

The food is pretty good and the staff is awesome. Very competent and kind. We will continue coming back every time we visit McCall.

We stopped in and had lunch on the patio. There was a group of 9 of us and so we ordered several different things, everyone was pleased. The pizza was delicious. The burgers and fish battered fries were very yummy! We had great services, even a hostess that danced her way to our table It was a great atmosphere and we all enjoyed it! read more

Service is sloooooow. The pizza leaves much to be desired. The Margherita Pizza, had no sauce, was dry, sparse on the basil, and limited cheese. While the staff was friendly when we saw them, their appearances were few. They seemed to have staff members standing around and checking phones instead of tending to patrons. read more

We came here on a Friday night. We ordered two all you can salad bars, large half pepperoni and half house special and beers. The service was great and salad bar. The pizza was okay. The sausage was under seasoned. We weren't happy with the pizza. We will not return or recommend. read more

Ordered on the slice app and got our pizza within 45min. Amazing pizza, some of the best. Recommend the Hawaiian and Veggie

After a long day of enjoying beautiful McCall, we came to this restaurant only to be greeted by rude employees. Do NOT eat here.