Great Italian food with that 'Sonoma' touch! I've been here several times over the last few years. The food is always good and delicious and the service is always exceptional! I ordered the Linguine with Pesto. It was very good - with the 'Sonoma' flair of course! Pasta was nice and 'mui al-dente' just as I had ordered it. It was delicious! Was it as authentic and "out of this world" with GENEROUS and garden fresh pesto I had when I was at the 'Trattoria Spagetto' in the West Village NYC? Of course not, but it was in the good experience category! read more

See all

Only 1 server who did their best but had a hard time attending to multiples parties who walked in at the same time. Food wasn't bad but nothing worth revisiting. read more

Great experience, I'm no food critic like some of these yelpers try to be lol Service was fast Food was incredibly fresh Restaurant was packed with people and still got our plates in under ten minutes And lastly the food tasted amazing. Nuff said. read more

Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

We got take out last night, the food was very good! I only have 1 bitch and that was the salad. A lot of restaurants use spring mix, take it out of the bag and throw it in the salad without thinking how big the pieces are. Some of my greens were 4"! Overall it was good but I sure would like it a little more chopped up. And this isn't the only restaurant that does this annoying habit. read more

Food was great...best meatballs ever! Staff were attentive & courteous. Outside dining was nice & comfortable! We will back soon!

My wife and I went here for an early dinner. If you are looking for authentic Italian food, you know the kind your Mama or Nanny made, pass on this restaurant. This isn't Italian food. It is like going to Olive Garden or Macaroni Grill. Pretty tasteless and bland. There are a dozen restaurants in Sonoma County we will go to for authentic Italian for and this one is not on the list. read more

Doordash delivery order review: Meatballs and sauce bland. Meatballs reminded me of the canned meatballs in Chef Boyardee spaghetti with meatballs. Spaghetti with red sauce was decent. Honestly the best thing was the bread. read more

My husband and I went here for dinner last night. The last time I went I tried the garlic bread and it is delicious! I wanted to bring him so he could try them and they were out! I seriously considering asking them what ingredients they needed so I could run to the store and get them lol. The food is good. I feel like it's comparable to Olive Garden honestly. Not a ton of flavor, but still decent. The service was great. They really should get rid of the dry bread sticks they give you...yuck. read more

Tomatina - The dry bread sticks :( - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Not one for writing reviews for people but I had to mention our dinner last night and the waitress Shelby!! Shelby was outstanding at her job and made sure we got our food on time right out of the kitchen. I recommend Tomatina's and I totally recommend asking for Shelby as your waitress. read more

Due to covid seating is outside. Waited maybe 5 minuets. Ordered piadine salmon. Tasted good but thought it was little bit too much oil.

My initial review of this restaurant stands unchanged. I'm adding this to let readers know that the management is responsive. I received a very nice DM from their manager, thanking me for my review and promising to share my comments with their GM and Executive Chef. However, as I stated in my response, restaurants must assume that each table, each guest, is the first impression and, possibly, the last. I still won't be going back, but the interest does show they take their business seriously. read more

The food is really good here. I love coming here. The service is okay, they could work on it a little. But I will continue to come back. I would recommend this place if haven't tried it yet. read more

Went here with a huge group of friends and the service was beyond amazing. Food was delicious and quality spectacular. The garlic rolls were not from this world. That's how good they were. Best chicken fettuccine I've had. Definitely recommend if you want your taste buds to have a wonderful time!!!! Manager is super nice and accommodating as well. read more

Seat yourself, use your phone to order, pay for your meal on your phone... no real personal touch. Had to wait to order water when my husbands drink came out. Waitress was really nice when we got see her. Nice for them they can use covid as an excuse. Is this the new business model? Can they get away with paying less than they already do? I'm older I know but is this how restaurants are changing their business plans? If so. I'm staying home. Why pay 20% for service you don't get? Part of going out is enjoying the atmosphere. Not so much anymore. read more

Stopped in by chance last month and have been back 4 times so far! We love the place, the food is delicious and the service is 5 Star. Today I had a chicken Piadine which is a meal in itself; it was way fresh and so delicious definitely a reorder favorite for my next visit, also had roasted cauliflower and broccoli and a Vanilla Mint Lemonade all of which were OTH...BTW, that's Off the Hook! Finally, our waiter today was Jay, I give him for service. read more

We came here for lunch on our 4 year anniversary and I couldn't be more pleased with the food and service. (They dont even know we are on our celebrating today and yet treated us as if they did) This place is delicious! I love food and italian food! It tastes fresh and full of flavor at the same time! The atmosphere and people where warm. Good service! I will definitely come back! I just found my new italian restaurant:) The garlic rolls are delicious, the ravioli, the chicken spaghetti and the tomato soup! I want more! Lol read more

Tomatina - Ravioli, chicken spaghetti and Garlic rolls with tomato soup and salad. - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California

Second time I went this year when I go visit California, it's one of my favorite places. The food is generous the price is amazing the wine is good. Also friendly staff and great atmosphere. Truly enjoyed their pesto pasta with seafood read more

They have a Delicious and very filling gluten free vegetable pizza. and delicious whipped cream dessert with ice cream and espresso!! Their whipped cream is awesome. read more

Tomatina used to be one of my fave restaurants but they must have gotten a new chef because the quality of food has went down drastically- the noodles were over done completely and the saice is extremely watery and tasteless. I personally could make better chicken Alfredo at home for way less than 18.75$ this meal shouldn't cost over 15$ it's just not that good. And the service is pretty slow even when there's barley any costumers. read more

We are new to Santa Rosa and have had nothing but good experiences with restaurants in the area. Tonight we tried Tomatina. The food was expensive, entrees didn't come with salad or bread, pasta was floating in greasy tasteless sauce and barely edible. The table when we arrived was dirty. We won't be back read more

I absolutely love this restaurant. The food is incredible, the service is fast and polite. All around an amazing experience. Shelby was incredible helpful and extremely polite. I will definitely be returning! read more

Place is clean. Tables and booths available. Waiter today's great. Handled everything. No one else was there to help. He moved tables, greeted customers, Waited on tables, brought orders to the customers, picked up the dishes and handed us the receipt. He did it all. Very impressed. Problem for us is that they longer offer the Tomato Basil Soup, thus we won't be back. Once they have it, we'll return. read more

Tomatina won't disappoint! Go check out out for yourself. The food is delicious if you appreciate traditional Italian cooking. 5 stars in my book! read more

Love tomatina!! The cooks there know what they are doing! They've even made me special off the menu items. Delicious every time!! Plus the bar has great drinks 10 outta 10 read more

We brought a local couple here at their request. The restaurant was clearly popular and our server was both friendly and helpful. I do not recall what our guests ordered but they were allowed to share a serving. My wife and I ordered a piccata dish but, while it was OK, we both felt the classic piccata flavor was pretty minimal. read more

Love. Lunch combos are perfect and delicious. Quality is great and price is affordable for the quality.

The manager isn't customer service friendly at all! Gives attitude all the time. The food is good, just the service isn't!! I wouldn't go back! read more

Sadly I'm pretty disappointed by this place. I was craving some comfort Italian food, and I was recommended by a coworker to try this place. I was really looking forward to takeout and a glass of wine, and I have to say it wasn't what I was looking for. I am 5"2' and about 120 pounds, and let's just say I don't need a huge portion to feel satisfied, and normally when I order chicken Alfredo from a restaurant I can barely eat half. I ate the whole thing, and still feel like I could for sure eat a slice of pizza. Clearly I ate the whole thing, so the flavor was there, but the chicken was pretty dry and the Alfredo sauce had separated as if I was reheated. It was basically butter and separated Parmesan cheese, I wouldn't really call it Alfredo sauce. I'm bummed because chicken Alfredo is really a splurge meal for me, and it was wasted. I was so hungry so I ate it anyway, but I definitely wouldn't eat here again. Very expensive for the quality and quantity. I'm a local and always looking for a good local spot to frequent, and this place won't do it for me. So dissatisfied and disappointed. read more

Tomatina opened recently so my husband and I decided to try it out after receiving their promotional coupons in the mail and having someone tell us they loved it. Our server, Kristy, was awesome. She told us that if we signed up for the Thanx rewards app, we could get free garlic rolls. We did and did not regret that decision. Service was impeccable- friendly and swift. My husband ordered his go-to- chicken parm which he enjoyed. I ordered the caprese piadine- a flatbread/pizza/salad hybrid which was delicious, really glad that I took Kristy's recommendation and ordered. It was very unique and tasty. We'll be back! Update 2/26/17 - although I do really like the food, sad to say, I don't think we'll be coming back because every time we've been here, it takes quite a while to get seated (5-10 min for an early bird dinner), and then 40+ min to get your meal. It's also sad to see people who were seated after you get their meal first. Bummer! read more

Decent food but I placed an online order for a family meal to be ready at 6. we get there, wait 20 minutes just for them to tell us it would be another hour and 20 minutes for our food to be ready. We went back after that hour and 20 and they said that it would be another 45 minutes on top of that. read more

I tried this place out when James Weber was the store manager here, now that he no longer works here, the quality of things has really decreased. He has managed other Tomatina locations before and everything has turned out great! The staff was always on point and the food always came out amazing. The food here at the Santa Rosa location was still good but it definitely wasn't as good as other locations. The pasta was semi dry and lacked a lot of taste. I ordered the Gorgonzola and it normally is bursting with flavor and very moist. I can't speak for the in house restaurant service since I always ordered to go but my food was always ready for pick up. The location of the place is pretty easy to find but the parking situation is not that great. It is rather small and on busy days, like the weekends and what not, it will fill up rather quickly and you will have to find parking else where. read more

Just wanted an Affogado -ice cream in espresso. Took almost 20 minutes to get and it definitely is not a traditional Affogado. It was mostly whipped cream and the ice cream tasted like ice crystals. And, $9.50?? read more

We had a great lunch here even though we were sitting in the parking lot due to Covid adjustments. The food was really good and we so enjoyed the experience because Jay, our server, is such a pro. He arranged our umbrellas to make sure we were in the shade, knew the menu up and down, was attentive throughout our meal (for instance, he remembered we had ordered sodas and asked if we needed refills, which servers often forget). In general, he made our day. Thanks, Jay! We will be back! read more

I really have enjoyed every meal I've had at Tomatina... from the pesto pasta, fettuccine alfredo, lasagna, margherita pizza. tomato soup and the AMAZING garlic rolls every meal has been on point. Service is a little slow at times but the food makes up for it. read more

Ordered the chicken Parmesan and lemon cheesecake. There was nothing special about both items. Both tasted bland and was overly priced for such bland plates. Would I come back? No. Would I recommend? No. Only came here Bc I was with a group and it was within their budget. read more

Well we decided to give this place a try and we won't be back. Poor service from the moment we walked in the door. Waiter never checked in with us then realized he was hanging out in the back of the restaurant eating. When food comes out burnt and yet they try to say "oh no it should look like that". I don't know about anyone else but burnt garlic doesn't taste good! Maybe you should check in before you just drop off the bill when you see no one really ate their food. read more

No good. Taste like the Olive Garden at best or hospital cafeteria food at worse. Have not been to one good restaurants in Santa Rosa.

My partner and I came in at about 8:30pm for a last minute dinner outing. We ordered garlic rolls and calamari for appetizers, and 2 entrees. She ordered the chicken fettuccine alfredo, and I ordered the crab and ricotta raviolis from the special menu (I believe my entree was $16.95). Our waiter was very polite and attentive, our appetizers were tasty and served an ample amount of time before our entrees, but the entrees themselves were lackluster. The fettuccine alfredo was decent, but nothing that would make me revisit this restaurant. The crab/ricotta raviolis were very good, although the portion was so abysmal that even our waiter apologized. I received 8 approximately 1.5" diameter raviolis, surrounded by an equal number of bisected cherry tomatoes that were under-ripe. The picture for the entree showed a moderate pile of raviolis, but what I received was a single layer of raviolis surrounded by twice as many pieces of under-rip tomatoes. I left our waiter a sizable tip (in cash) for good service, but I do not intend to visit this restaurant again unless someone else is paying for it. read more

The food was fresh they seemed to confuse happy hour with kid's meals. The time before I brought the kids the portions were different. What ever it happens. The customer service was the worst asked four different times for bread, nothing while other older patriots received double and triple of bread due to the order of wine. What ever will try the service again in a year see if they are still in in service. Did not fill welcome with kids. Four people two free meals worst eighty dollars spent. read more

I love this place! The salads are my favorite. The servers are friendly and the atmosphere is casual but nice. My only complaint would be the minestrone, which doesn't seem Italian at all to me. Try one of the lemonades, they're great! read more

Tomatina - Pizza Near Me - Santa Rosa, California