Tommy had the best personality! And Donna his wife is a doll. The house salad with Italian dressing was fresh and delicious! Garlic bread was good. Would have loved marinara sauce on the side. Tommy created a personalized pizza based on our preferences, mushrooms, garlic, light cheese, and delish marinara. It was perfect! Definitely look forward to supporting them again in the future. read more

See all

Came back to Tommy's with family. Everyone was delighted with their dish and food was great. My son and I shared the Everything Pizza and three other family members got to taste the pizza. Some had the baked Ziti, Meatball Sub, Eggplant Parmigiana and the rest ordered the Cesar Salad with chicken which looked delicious also. Service is always great and the restaurant has plenty of room with pictures of past family members who have operated restaurants in New York. Have to return to try other dishes on the menu. read more

Tommys Way - Everything Pizza - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

See all

We loved Tommy's Place and we're very sad when Covid forced them to close. It was our go-to for birthdays and anniversaries. And it was nearby. A couple weeks ago I read somewhere that Tommy had opened a new place, Tommy's Way, so it was immediately added to our list of places we had to visit. Yesterday was that day! The location is a bit further for us, but the feeling of home is still there. And it's definitely smaller than the Place, but we're from the northeast and it reminds us of the pizza/pasta/sub shops of home. We were greeted as soon as we walked in and grabbed a table to look over the menu. I decided on the eggplant parm with penne and hubby went with chicken parm with spaghetti. He cleared his plate! But I saved enough of mine for lunch today and I have to admit, I think it was even better on day 2. (And I'm not usually a fan of leftovers.) We absolutely will be back. I remember how much I loved Tommy's calzones and of course we have to get pizza. And we want to try the subs too. We also grabbed some cheesecake to take home and have later. I'd say it's right up there with my homemade. Tommy's Way is worth the drive, and lucky for me, I have 2 appointments in the area this month so that gives me a good excuse to stop in again! read more

Tommys Way - Chicken parm w/spaghetti. - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

See all

Always amazing food here! I come on a weekly basis! The service is also super friendly and all family owned read more

See all

Birthday celebration at Tommy's Way! Five star service and food. Ordered the antipasto salad and garlic bread as sharable selections. Alfredo Fettuccine Pasta was ordered by two people. One had grilled chicken the other without. Ordered a large cheese pizza and a Ziti Pasta Dish. Plenty of food and take home portions. Finished off the meal with cannoli and one person had the chocolate cake. Prices are super reasonable and the ambiance is what you would expect for a New York Pizza Place! This place is hot and new! read more

See all

Nice small place with good food and very friendly staff. We were out of town looking for meatballs and popped in here. Seems to be new but very efficient. Will be back when we are there. read more

Love anything family owned and Tommy's Way did not disappoint! I had a calzone with meatball added and it was delicious. I'll be back to try other goodies. Couldn't resist the chocolate cake as it's my birthday week. Great service and wonderful atmosphere. read more

Tommys Way - The owner Tommy treated us like family! - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

I've seen a few pizza places come and go from this spot but really enjoyed this one and hope it stays!! Planned to dine in but had a very crabby toddler in the backseat fall asleep so ended up just ordering to go! It was ready on time and easy pick up. I liked how they had balloons outside for their opening! We got a cheese pizza and cheesy garlic bread. You have to order the marinara on the side separately. I also got ranch for my pizza. It was all delicious! Crust was perfectly crisp without being overcooked, yummy cheese and sauce! Good quality stuff and I'd totally come back here! read more

Tommys Way - Slice of cheese! - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Tried this place out and it was amazing. I'm originally from New Jersey so I know what's good believe me when I tell you. Had the meatball sub and the chicken parm sub and 2 slices. It was awesome , the sauce was spot on. The meatballs where just like moms. The service was like it was Back in the day there, Friendly and courteous that's hard to come . Definitely will be coming back going to try the sausage peppers and onions read more

Nice neighborhood family friendly restaurant. Great service and very good food. From the meatballs to the sausage to the Stromboli to the pizza. All delicious! We will be back. read more

AMAZING. May be the best pizza I've had in AZ yet. Customer service was on point, you can't find that type of service anymore. Owner (I'm assuming) checked on us, and even brought an extra special to-go. Will be back. Thank you!! read more

First time here! Easy parking right out front. We ate in. Cozy dining room with TV. Tried the lunch special, two slices and a drink. We added a regular cheesesteak sandwich. Yum! Friendly service and good food. I'd like to try pasta options next. We'll be back! read more

This building has housed a couple pretty good pizza joints over the last couple years. Sadly, they did not make it. I was excited to see Tommy's open up. Stopped by today to grab the lunch special which consisted of two slices of pizza and a soda. The staff was extremely nice. The inside has been redecorated and looks much nicer than it did previously. The pizza came out hot and was delicious. I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Food was great. We had antipasto and a pizza. It was good to see Tommy again. We used to frequent the restaurant on Bell. Service was fantastic. Everyone was so friendly and wanted feedback in the food. Prices are reasonable and hit all price points. We liked the way they decorated. Currently they are word of mouth only. read more

Tommys Way - Antipasto - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

See all

I'm adding a positive pizza review to offset my prior negative review of their other menu items. The owner takes pride in his life-long dedication to crafting quality traditional pizza and delivers on his promise so I want to commend him. Corprate pizza chains come and go in their race to the bottom but I choose to support individuals with character that do what they say and so should you. Also, the employees are sharp and to the point, imagine that in today's world. read more

Beyond bad! $35 for the worst Chicken Parm and Meatball Sub I've ever had in my entire life. The previous owners had the best Chicken Parm I've ever had and I was hoping for the same. Very little chicken, soggy bread and would you look at the cheese?! The meatballs tasted mushy, soggy bread and again with the cheese. Never again... To say I was disappointed is an understatement. To be fair the pizza looked good and if I'm in the area I may try it. Let's see how long this place stays in business. read more

Tommys Way - Chicken Parm Hero - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

See all

Great place to experience tasty thin crust and other style pizza. Very authentic as I remember from years past when the owner and family members welcome you and genuinely ask you how your doing. You won't find many left like this place where the food is great with quality ingredients and price is lower than while others charge more for just a cardboard cutout of this original. Check this place out.. read more

I discovered this place randomly on my way to work one morning. I ordered the Italian Sub and it was by far one of the best, most authentic Sammie's I've had in AZ! Finished half it before I even made it to work and I'm only a few minutes up the road! 10/10 will be there again! read more

Just went to Tommy's! Excellent Italian food, being from new jersey am a little jaded concerning a good Italian restaurant. All entrees and salads our group ordered was excellent. Will definitely going back! read more

NY Style Pizza: 5 stars. Mouth still watering. Service: 5 stars. Cleanliness and ambiance: 5 stars. Stopped in for lunch with a lot of anticipation after learning that Tommy was back. If you remember Tommy's on Bell Rd or one of his other restaurants, you know why that matters. Now he has a new sign up at the former pizza place on Becker Lane. I started with a slice of cheese and a slice of pepperoni, and both were absolutely outstanding. I am already planning a return visit. Now the challenge is deciding what to try next. Pasta, calzone, chicken parm, meatballs, dessert. I might just go for all of them. Thanks Tommy, it was great to see you again. read more

We ate at Tommy's Way for the first time last night. Best Pizza that we have enjoyed, by far! We will not be ordering pizza from any other restaurant. Well done! read more

4th time picking up from Tommy's Way ans once again its rhe best pizza ive ever eaten. We ordered a large half cheese half works and both were amazing. I cant recommend this place enough. read more

Meatballs are excellent. Melt in your mouth. The owner Tommy was here and gave us two cannolis. I don't ever order them. These were amazing. I want more but on a diet. Love this place. No alcohol, though. That's OK. Not that kinda place. It's about the food. read more

Got a large New York style pie and it was great. Thin, the right amount of cheese and toppings, was not too flimsy so able to eat it without everything sliding off as is sometimes the case with NY style or Neapolitan. Will definitely go back and looking forward to trying some of the other items on the menu, as the chef/owner used to operate a classic East Coast style joint in Phoenix that was popular. Service is super friendly. Apparently, they have a kick A$$ espresso machine! read more

Absolutely awesome pizza! Just opened and I'm blown away. NJ native and this is my new favorite spot. read more

Tommys Way - Look at this crust! - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

A good slice of pepperoni pizza! Ample sized slice so much so I had just one slice and was very full. As an ex-New Yorker, I loved it! read more

NY style pizza! Staff is so friendly and location is very convenient! Feels like a pizzeria from back east.

Pizza is legit NY style not like these other places that don't know any better. The new owner is attentive and well organized; big improvements to the service and operation. read more

We've eaten at Tommy's restaurants previously. Just heard about Tommy's Way. We'll be there. Looking forward to it. read more

Well, well, well pizza lovers. There is a new contender in the slices game in town and tommy is going to fit in nicely. First off, the atmosphere is very nice. Way better looking than the last spot. The girl at the register was very nice and helpful. The pizza was very good. I tried a cheese slice and a Sicilian cheese slice. The cheese slice was super solid, nice chew to the crust, a nice bit of crunch and the sauce was very flavorful. This recipe was definitely written by a New Yorker. The Sicilian slice was the 2nd best i have had in the valley. So light and airy with a nice crunchy crust and i love the sauce on top. Unfortunately it was cold. That's why i gave 4 star rating but it's really a 4.5. This place is highly recommended. If the pizza was that good (not knowing how long it was out) fresh has got to be top notch.!!!! A lot of other options to choose from, pasta, chicken Parmesan and so on. I work right around the corner and these people are probably going to know me by name! Benvenuto nel quartiere, è stato fantastico!!!! read more

Tommys Way - Cheese slice and Sicilian slice - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

I love this old school kind of small pizza place. Great NY style pizza, thin and cheesy with a crunchy crust. One of my go to pizza places. read more

So glad they opened. Great pizza! Plus I love that they answer the phone for a pick up order (unlike the last place). Authentic and tasty! Highly recommend! read more

Kind of hidden in small shopping area. But worth seeking out. Service was excellent. Had pepperoni slices which were very tasty! Will definitely come back to try other items. read more

Tommys Way - Dining room - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

super cute pizza place off scottsdale and shea; got to meet Tommy who gave me an xt slice on the house :) his thin crust pizza is perfect but sicilian deep dish is available as well! read more

Tommys Way - full cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

Tommy's Way is a great spot if you're craving authentic New York-style pizza. The crust has that nice thin, foldable texture with a good balance of crispiness, and the sauce and cheese work well together without being overwhelming. The slices are generously sized, and the casual atmosphere makes it a comfortable place to grab a meal. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 is that it can get busy, so service and wait times may be a bit longer than expected. Overall, it's a solid choice for quality NY-style pizza and definitely worth a visit. read more

First time having real NY pizza in Arizona! Amazing & welcoming staff too. Can't wait to come back next time read more

Tommys Way - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona

I have been having a pizza crisis over the past year or two. We have not had a go to pizza place in our Scottsdale Road and Shea boulevard neighborhood that we really liked enough to go back on a regular basis. We tried everything around us and it was either ridiculously expensive and weird or it just wasn't very good pizza. I think I found a place that is just right. It says something else on the outside but it will read Tommy's Way Pizza & Pasta as soon as they get the new sign up. I wandered in to try it today. I had one slice of white sauce pizza which was very good so I tried one piece of good old fashioned New York style pepperoni. It was also very good so I went for the meatballs which is always a reliable indicator of how good any Italian food place really is. Outstanding. These are not store bought breadcrumb packed low quality meatballs these are the kind of meatball that your Italian best friend's mom makes from scratch on holidays with an authentic red sauce to match. That sold me on Tommy's Way. The food was very good. The people were very nice. The prices were very reasonable especially considering what you get for your money. I will go back and I will bring my family. Thank you! Wade in Gainey Ranch. read more

Been here a few times since they opened. Regular slice and a Sicilian corner slice are my go to. Great NY style pizza, which we need in the area. I've also had the chicken parm hero and the TNT hero. Both solid. Tommy and the staff are very friendly too. read more

The owner, Tommy himself, cruises the dining room chatting with customers and keeps an eye on the kitchen to ensure food is prepared and delivered timely. The pizza was flop-free (crisp crust from edges to the center) and ingredients were plentiful and evenly dispersed across the pie. Also, the sauce was tasty, too, with just enough of it to allow the flavors to come through without overpowering the pizza. Donna (Mrs. Tommy) was our delightful server; she greeted us warmly, kept checking to see if everything was okay, if we needed anything else, and took away dirty dishes and refilled beverages throughout our time there. The photos on the walls are a special touch. We wish we lived closer so we could come here every week! read more

Wonderful Chicago style pizza the variety of cheese and ingredients delicious. You can tell the owner. I will be going back here and become a regular. Thank you Tommy. read more

Tommys Way - Outside of restaurant - Italian Near Me - Scottsdale, Arizona