Really good spot that I got a Togo order from. People are super friendly and the price is reasonable. Ordered the Sicilian with pepperonis and a Greek salad and was very pleased. The salad was spot on with fresh lettuce, combo of olives and feta. The pizza crust and cheese top notch and I recommend if you are in the area! read more

The real deal! I knew we came to the right place when I saw a table of construction workers there for lunch! Red vinyl booths and a huge menu. Really good pizza!! Got 2 different pies, the supreme and the white, with a few alterations. Fabulous! We intended to come back for stromboli and calzone, but didn't get the chance. Nothing fancy, mom and pop pizzeria like in the old days. Highly recommend. read more

Best NY Style Pizza I have had in the St Augustine area. Ordered two medium pies and got delivery within the 45 minutes we were advised on phone. Takes Visa/MasterCard. Looks like our new go to pizza place on vacation! read more

This had to be the worst pizza I have ever had. We tried it due to how close they are to our house, but I would rather go a 1/2 hour out of my way than to ever eat there again. The crust was soft and soggy and in total no flavor. read more

Best New York style pizza in St Augustine area. Always friendly efficient staff. Supreme pizza perfect every time. Have never tried other items on menu but if like pizza will not disappoint. Usually order pick up always ready when promised. Always order one to take home when leaving area. read more

Reviewing take out pizza! We were tired from a day at the beach and ordered to the condo. Delivery was within the the time expected. We ordered the extra large Super Supreme and a white pizza. Both exceeded expectations. The sauce had a definite homemade taste and ingredients were of higher quality than most take out. We'd order again for sure. Left overs were good for breakfast cold too! read more

Good pizza strange decoration. The supreme pizza was good as was the bread and Greek pizza. Decently speedy service. Really just a whole in the wall place I would suggest just getting it To go. read more

I am vacationing and picked up a pie. I picked up, paid and left. As I was walking out of restaurant, owner came chasing after me, and I went back in. He said , cashier who was new innocently rang me up wrong and gave me money back! WOW! I was blown away by his honesty. Very cool and pizza was awesome! read more

Last night we had a pie from Tony's and I have to say it was really good. The crust was thin and crisp and the meatball topping was excellent. Also the tomato sauce was very fresh tasting. We will return to try some of their other fare for sure. Only one caveat- it was pretty warm in the restaurant. Could've used some more ac or air movement. read more

Giant, delicious and FRESH every single time, there's a reason this place has been a beloved part of the community for so long. Thank you Tony! For the smiles and the gourmet food! read more

Pizza was sub par at best ! Very thin ! All the toppings slid right off in the box ! Right across the street from the beach so that's a positive read more

I've been enjoying Tony's Pizza since I was a kid in the mid 1980's. Great Pizza and service. Ham subs are HUGE! Crust has that perfect NY style...thin and crispy with just the right amount of snap. Tony's also uses really good cheese. It has just the right amount of gooeyness and snap. Put the perfect sauce in the middle and you have one delicious pizza! read more

Tony told us it would be the best pizza in St Augustine and he is correct. Ordered medium tomato, banana pepper, and pepperoni - ingredients were fresh and the service was friendly, will be ordering again from Tony! read more

I waited 2 hours for our meal to be delivered and did not even get all my food . The driver called back to information the restaurant and got yelled at by who ever answer the phone . I waited another 20 min for food that was not cooked correctly. My pasta was a under cooked and the cheese was not melted .i understand this is cooked to order but come on Tony my Italian mother in-law can cook for 20 people faster than you . I called Tony to complain and demanded a refund. I did get my refund but my dinner was a waste read more

Even though it clearly says they have pizza by the slice on their website they told us at dinner time they didn't have any. Two seperate times we asked for oil and vinegar for a salad. Two times they acknowledged. Of course food comes with wrong dressing. When they finally bring it over it has several fruit flys in it. I call to inform them and he says "we got it from next door." This tells me they had no intention of delivering what we wanted until we complained. Pasta was so over cooked it was mush. HE offered my money back and as soon as I said " sure I'll take it back" he did nothing but back pedal until I had to hang up on him. Better food and service elsewhere read more

I had one of the best salads I have ever had. The freshest lettuce topped with mozzarella. Their garlic knots were to die for. Husband had a medium cheese pizza that was also excellent. I rarely write a review but when a place such as this is over the top I feel moved to compliment. I would consider this a small hole in the wall place. We were the only ones for about 15min at 5pm on a Sunday but they do a huge business in take out orders. Our server T was right on and filling our drinks to go. I highly recommend Tonys Pizza. read more

Worst pizza I ever ate. In fact, I've taken some out of cardboard boxes and popped them in the microwave to better effect. Don't bother. This is saddest pizza on the face of the planet. I wish I could send it back. read more

The very best pizza in and around St. Augustine! Love the green olives and the crust is amazing.

Very good pizza fresh ingredients friendly staff and nice break from the seafood diet.

Could not place a phone order after trying for 10 minutes... pizza was not fresh and ingredients were poor quality. Don't waste your time or money.. drive the extra 5 minutes. Total disappointment read more

I was told delivery was free. When the delivery person arrived, she was mad because I was out of the "delivery area" which of course was not my responsibility. I had given my address on the phone. She called me and requested that I walk out front to meet her, so I did. She continued with her nasty attitude. I gave her a $20 bill for an $18 pizza, and told her I was not giving her a tip due to her attitude, and she refused to give me change, due to the distance. I should have been told the truth when I called as to delivery fees, distance, etc. Further, the pizza was cold and soggy. Worst pizza ever!!!! read more

Delivery was quick. We had pizza and cheesy bread. Yum! Glad to have a good pizza on vacation.

My husband and I are from Georgia and we decided to try Tony's Pizza because it was convenient (we were staying at the condos across the way). It definitely was a surpise!! It was excellent!! read more

Vacation was 4 days had Tony's 6 times... not really, but considered it after eating one of their CALZONES.

Cheese pizza delivery. Who is it that thinks it is good?? Relatives?? It rivals the worst I have ever had and I have had some terrible pizza. Soggy dough, no taste. Doubt it was real mozzarella. However, delivery was reasonably fast. read more

Great food- very nice/helpful/friendly staff. Great portions...and they deliver! Perfecto! A+

Had the medium combo pizza. It was nasty. The small cheese pizza I ordered for the kids was just okay. It was $50 for a medium and small pizza, two ice teas and two sodas. A little steep unless you ordered beer, but you can't order beer because they don't have it. Bathroom is nasty too. All in all a bad experience. read more

This Is Our Friday Night "Wine & Pizza" Reward after a hard work week and 6 days of fitness training! We Love the Food and the Employees are the BEST EVER! My better half has been eating there since she live 2 blocks away when she was a young girl! Last Night I discovered the BEST WINGS I've Ever Tasted! BAKED; Juicy, Slightly Spicy and Melt in Your Mouth! GREAT PLACE! read more

Excellent! Salad was fresh and crisp! Meatball sub was awesome! They are a little pricy but they give you a lot of food!

Garlic cheese bread with marinaras sauce for dipping was very good. Loved the salad with Italian dressing. Really liked the thin crust of the pizza, but just not crazy about the pizza sauce or spices. If I went back I would try a pasta dish instead. read more

Absolutely the worst pizza and the dozen wings wound up being 8 slimy wings. Would NEVER recommend this place!! Yuk

Delicious pizza. We've been getting great pizza there for years. Tony calls everyone friend and means it. We don't typically get delivery as they are nearby and delivery adds wait time. Meatball topping was always a meatball cut in half. Last order the meatballs were sliced, not halved. Don't cut back on toppings. Go back to cutting meatballs in half. read more

This is not only a fabulous pizza place but the kind delivery women helped us jump our dead car battery!

THIS PLACE IS HORRIBLE!!!!!!! Not only did they take an hour and a half to deliver one pizza, but it was soggy, didn't taste good at all, had no sauce, and was impossible to pick up and break off a slice. It was also $30 for a large pizza. Beware! We found this place because it was attached to our hotel room key and they advertise free delivery. read more