**TEMPORARILY CLOSED** The caramelized Pan crust is phenomenal. The first time we got it, there was no sauce on it. They did credit us and the next couple of times it was great, not to thick and very tasty - good balance of cheese, sauce, and crust read more

I've lived in the Chicago suburbs for 35 years and yesterday was my first pizza at Tortorice's at the recommendation of a friend. I was not disappointed. Here are some thoughts from our take out pizza order: -We ordered a large, thin crust pepperoni and sausage pizza. -The cost, with 2 sodas, was $35. -If you like thin crust, and I do, it is a really good pizza option. -The sauce is on the sweeter side, and very tasty. Sausage was above average--very good. -They also sell pizza by the slice--$7.50 for a big slice and soda. -There is no seating in store. Highly recommended! read more

See all

Amazing food great service! The owner is so welcoming and super friendly! love the place!

Their stuffed pizza with sausage and spinach is my favorite. Their delivery is always on time. #iraeats #iraeats1 read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Stuffed 14" - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

My fiancé and I were feeling pizza for dinner tonight, so we decided to give Tortorice's a try! We were both really impressed with the variety of the types of pizza they offered. We went with the Picasso style pizza which is a thin crust pizza covered in mozzarella then another thin crust pizza is put on top with more cheese and your toppings. It is a hefty pizza, but sooo worth it!! We agreed we will try the double dough pizza next. Their storefront is small, but the service was great! We placed our order on the phone and we were told about 40 minutes. That was more than fine with us! It's a simple counter when you walk in, but it smelled delicious and we didn't have to wait long to pick up our order. We will definitely be ordering from them again, and looking forward to trying their other styles. I also loved that they wrote a message inside the box! read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Picasso Pizza with Pepperoni, Black Olive, & Green pepper - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

Every time I order from this place it makes me hate them even more.. Ordered a DOUBLE dough sausage... they didn't send me that after waiting for almost 2 hrs... Sausage is HALF and not the full pizza.. read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Awful double dough - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

See all

Used to be a good place, tell me this pizza doesn't look burnt af ‍i didnt order charred pizza bruh what is this read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

Ordered a small cheese and sausage with half green peppers, was delicious but arrived not very hot. The fries ordered came sort of warm but needed to be cooked longer, they were hard. Ordered dessert came frozen read more

Delicious pizza at a great price. There are so many great pizza options around me. Tortorice's sticks out with a high quality pizza. They are using prime ingredients and you can tell. For a thin crust pizza, it is fairly thicker than most. Slightly doughy in the middle and crisp on the outer edge. To me the best part is the sauce - plentiful and flavorful. The cheese was not dried out and the pepperoni was good. Don't let the outside plain sign fool you. There is nothing plain about the pizza. As for the service, we made the order with ease and it was quickly available for pick up. Was pipping hot when we got. I personally say it rivals Nino's right down the road. I like them both and will continue to order from both. The sauce has a little more unique flavor over Nino's. Check it out! read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

I recently moved into the area and ordered a pizza from a local spot for me and my girlfriend. After checking out some reviews on Yelp we decided on Tortorice's. It wasn't a complicated order, we wanted a deep dish with green pepper and one-half with Italian sausage, and one-half with meatballs. We drove to pick it up and when we returned home we opened a bottle of wine and started eating our pizza. To our surprise, and disappointment we discovered that the pizza had zero green pepper! I doubled checked the receipt and my request for green pepper was right on top of the ticket so it would have been the first thing the cooks should have seen. Being upset that they messed up my order and that I paid for something I didn't get I called them up. The person who picked up put me on hold to ask the cooks about the order and returned to say that he didn't notice the request for green pepper. Again, it was the first thing on the requested ingredients. I was told they could make me a new pizza right now or I could get a credit for a new one to use at another time. I told them since we were already more than halfway through our bottle of wine it would be best to use the credit another time. I wrote down the person's name so that there wouldn't be any confusion later. This evening I called to use the credit and I asked for the person I spoke with and was told they weren't in today so I told my story to the person on the phone and to my surprise they did have a record of my situation so I placed an order for exactly what I tried to order last time. The person on the phone then gave me a total so I told her I wanted to use my credit. I was told I only have a credit for $4! Originally I drove all the way there to pick it up, they mess up my order, they offer to make me a new pizza to make up for the mistake or give me a credit for a new pizza, then when I try and use it they say the credit is only good for $4??!! There are way better pizza places in the area like Joe's, Lou's, and Nino's. I won't be wasting my time here again. read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - My request for green peppers in bold letters, how can you miss that??? - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

I thought I had written a review for this place not too long ago but I guess not as I don't see it. Anyway, this carry-out pizza restaurant is a good place to get delicious variety of pizzas. Whenever, I am in the mood for good (non-generic, non-chain) pizzas and I happen to be in the area, I go for Tortorice's. They have been around for a while. In my recent visit, I got three different pizzas. I ordered one 16" thin crust (small squares tavern style)cheese pizza, one 14" pan green peppers and onions pizza and one 12" pepperoni deep dish. The previous time I was here, I think I had ordered a stuffed and Chicago style thin crust so this time around, I went for a different variety. We ordered the food over the phone and we were told it would be ready in about 35 min. We got there in 40 min. and our pizza was hot and ready to go. Our bill was about $53 and some change after a coupon discount. The pizza smelled so good that I could hardly wait to eat it. I liked all the three pizzas but my favorite was the tavern style thin crust, followed by the pan and then the deep dish. The thin crust was just perfect. Soft front and crispy back crust. It's best consumed while hot. The pan was not dough(y) as I thought it would be which is good. I hate dough(y) crusts. The veggies with the sauce and cheese made for a good tasting pizza. The deep dish was just fine. I like my fair share of deep dish and stuffed pizzas. I don't care if they are considered touristy or not original Chicago style or what have you. Anyway, check out Tortorice's. They are pretty good. It's a local establishment that serves good pizzas and they are worth checking out. read more

See all

One step up from your typical "fast food" pizza places, but not on par with other local pizza places. Ordered the appetizer sampler, the breading they use was lower quality. The chicken was at least all white meat. I also liked that they had both cheddar and cream cheese poppers in the mix. The pizza itself was just ok. Lot of cheese, but the bread was too thick for thin crust. It was also a little doughy. read more

Very tasty thin crust pizza. I will be back to try other things on menu. Its nice to find a good thin crust without going into city etc. Thank you Totorices's. read more

* Hot and Ready * * Super Nice * * Delicious * Have been going to the Arlington Heights location for years and just recently started coming to this one. Pizzas are the same: Delicious: This is a growing chain in Chicagoland and the fact that it is constantly good and on point with other locations is a great recipe for success. So far it's only been thin crust pizzas that I've gotten, the Picasso will be the ultimate test, stay tuned for the follow up. Super Nice: Every person I have had the pleasure of speaking to here is totally engaged. They are all about taking care of you and ensuring your happiness. Always service with a smile! Hot and Ready: I typically pick up my pizzas, crazy right, and they always ready when they say. Have yet to wait for a pizza. Experience at this location has been great and I will continue to purchase from here if in the area. Thank you to the business owners for providing such a great pizza! #Yum read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

See all

I like to make sure the places I give good ratings don't slip and make me appear to be a sycophant or glad-handler. I am none of those things! So I periodically review them again with fresh taste buds. Tortorice's does not disappoint. I got the Tortorice special this weekend - thin crust with onion, green pepper, sausage, and mushrooms, and the pie was perfect. Piping hot, not greasy, and very crisp and firm veggies! I ate 3 or 4 squares and I was full. This is the epitome of Chicago thin-crust pizza. Perhaps a little thicker crust than some places, but just right for the ingredients on top. If you have not tried Tortorice's and like pizza, make sure you order from here sooner rather than later! read more

I've had their pizza and I would say that I liked it. I would order from them again. This is a good choice for take out.

I ordered a rib and shrimp dinner, with three side sauces and two desserts. They sent one dessert, missed a sauce, and one sauce was wrong. I'm house sitting with a sick child and I called and they refused to redeliver the missing ingredients. Said the manager that handles problems was not there and the cook said that he put everything in. I asked that they please redeliver because I was 3 blocks away. They told me they only had one driver and couldn't. We ended up arguing because the person on the phone was so incredibly rude. They told me to come in and I explained again. Of course I paid cash. I think this happened the last time I housesat. Beware of these people they do not tell the truth. And kept my money. The shrimp was overcooked and the tirimisu was frozen read more

I have lived near this place for many years every once in a while I will give them a try and every time I regret it tonight it took 1 hour 35 minutes to get a thin pizza delivered . Sunday not a Friday or Saturday pizza came cold and greasy from sitting around . If your that short handed let me know I'll get from Ninos it will be here hot and in 40 minutes . Done done done with this place read more

My reviews are for celiac vegetarians; check out my profile for more information about my reviews. Menu Labeled: Yes, marked GF Items prepped in a separate area: Yes! Pizza where the crust is prepared in-house and prepared in the same area as flour pizza is extremely risky as cross-contamination is likely to happen. Luckily at Tortorice's they are extremely careful about this, Pizza's are prepared in a separate area. I have never had an issue eating here. This is my go-to spot for pizza. Btw before diagnosis - I loved their pan pizza, absolutely amazing. read more

I ordered a pizza through Uber eats. The restaurant gave my order to someone else.. then when my Uber driver arrived for my order, they refused to remake the order and kicked her out and turned off all the lights. I understand they were closing, but if you mess someone's order up, fix it even if it means getting out late because YOU made the mistake. never ordering from this place again. read more

We ordered from the Arlington heights one and loved it now we are closer to buffalo grove . I ordered today 4/7 and the girl on the phone was so polite and helpful with my salad since I do not eat meat. The pizza was delicious . I recommend the caramelized crust on the pan pizza. I just recommended your pizza to my friend who is placing an order now. read more

Burnt cheese deep dish pizza, that is all. This is definitely a unique spin on a Chicago pie and with so many options around this specific place for deep dish pizza, the burnt cheese crust definitely stands out. I have ordered here twice, once for delivery, and once for pickup. Both times were excellent! I have had their burnt cheese deep dish pizza twice now and it is excellent! A great ratio of sauce to cheese and that burnt crust to round it out is something special. I have also had their thin crust and their Chicago thin crust which is basically extra chunky tomato sauce on a thin crust pizza. Both are also excellent options, but I am a fan of the deep dish. Service for pickup was easy and the pizzas were piping hot and fresh out of the oven. I'll definitely keep ordering from Torotice's again. read more

The outback pizza was amazing! The BLT pizza was awful!!!!!!! I was expecting a pizza with bacon, lettuce, tomato with mayo as the sauce. What I got was something else! It was a bacon, sliced tomato pizza with tomato sauce baked with wilted lettuce and mayo squirted all over. It was so nasty! A local competitor has a blt pizza and it is baked pizza crust with mayo sauce topped with cooked bacon, fresh chopped lettuce and tomato. It is great and light! Be sure to clarify their speciality pizza's as the description could be misleading. read more

Yum yum yum! The ingredients tasted fresh and the sauce was super good. I think this our new pizza spot! Only down side was the pickup time was slow on a Friday night. But that's understandable. read more

Tortorice's Pizzeria - Tortorices Special Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo Grove, Illinois

Just moved to the neighborhood and I wanted a good thin crust pizza. This was by far one of the best pizza I've had in awhile. I will order from here again soon! read more

We love this restaurant! The pizza is amazing and the sandwiches are great. I love a white pizza. It has Alfredo sauce, mozzarella cheese, grilled chicken, and green olives. Tortorices's has onion, which I am allergic to, so they kindly substitute green olives for me. They are the best! read more

Personally, I think the pizza is a bit on the greasy side. Nonetheless, the staff at this location are very dependent and easy to coordinate with. They also have lots of options that will please different dietary restrictions. read more

I just want to say Tortorice's really goes above and beyond for their customers! I ordered through their online menu (about a week or so ago) and always get an "how can we improve" email after the order is delivered. I first want to say they have a really good roast beef sub, but the last time I ordered it, it was different than usual and fell apart. The other food we ordered was great as usual. I filled out my "review" more so for my own selfish reasons for wanting them to go back to how their subs used to be. I just checked my email and they apologized and gave me a refund! I was not at all expecting that! They will always have me as a customer! read more

Pizza is very good staff is a wonderful highly recommend people who were looking for good night out for pizza delivery is a great option food is usually correct sizes usually differ read more

First time trying this place. We will go back. Looking forward to our next order. The double crust was exactly how they described it and tasted even better. Caesar salad was simple and delicious. Great local find read more

Pre fab crust that is uneventful and doughy, spotty sauce, no flavor at all. A cheese doughball.

BEST pizza in the NW burbs, PERIOD!! Prices are a tad above average, but well worth it. Bring an appetite if you want deep dish...huge and hot and gooey!! This is take out only and parking can be tight as lot is smallish. Try the other pizza places in the area, then compare for the best. No need for more...try this place!! read more

First I want to say that the owner of Tortorice's is very nice and accommodating. When he saw my Yelp review, he reached out to apologize for the bad pie and asked if he can try to make it better. Since there are so many positive reviews, it makes sense to try them again. A few weeks later, we called in to have the stuffed pizza remade (comped by the restaurant since our last pizza was inedible) and we also tried the Chicago style based on his recommendation. Stuffed pizza with half cheese and half spinach and sausage: happy to report that the pizza was thoroughly cooked this time. The pie was tasty and the ingredients were fresh. The price was also decent for the size of the pizza. Chicago style with half cheese and half spinach and sausage (identical to the stuffed so I can compare): I am not sure how I feel about this one. It's exactly the same as the stuffed but without the extra layer of dough on top. I was expecting something a little different - maybe more like the butter crust of the other Chicago style place. I also ordered a gluten-free pepperoni which was great (according to the kiddo) and a Godfather ribeye sandwich. I asked for the ribeye to be more on the medium rare to medium side, but I was told this wasn't possible due to cooking and baking of the sandwich. While the flavor a were spot on, it did come out well done - a little too dry for my liking. A nice bump up to 4 stars this time. Thanks for adding a new rotation to our carry out and delivery lineup! read more

Consistency has been a problem for me. Some pizzas are outstanding and others found lacking Hate to complain to owners in these times so when I call a new order in I remind them please be more careful. It helps read more

Great pizza and fast delivery , the best pizza I've had in a long time, I Pre ordered before they opened and my food was delivered exactly when they said it would. Thanks guys read more

The good - pizza was good (I ordered delivery online) and delivery was on time. The pizza reminded me of beggars pizza a little bit. I opted for the thin crust zah and the sausage really stood out. Authentic pub style Chicago thin crust cut into squares. The bad - the order was wrong. I still ate it, but it was a disappointment for my first order. Maybe I'll try em again in the future... read more

Tip: if you are trying to achieve the lofty goal of eating pizza every day for the week you are in Chicago, Tortorice's might derail such noble and ambitious plans--not in a bad way, it's just an intense dose, like pizza on steroids. I am ashamed to say I didn't attain the pizza every day badge of honor (self-invented), though I would not blame Tortorice's but rather my own weakness. My coworker who is a local suggested Tortorice's to us visitors, easily convincing us with the description of the double-decker Picasso pizza i.e. crust-cheese-crust-cheese-then-toppings. We decided to order to our hotel in Northbrook. Oddly, when I called the Tortorice's a similar if not closer distance away, they said that we were outside their delivery boundaries, but the second one was fine with the order. The delivery man did seem pleasantly quizzical about how I heard about them when we talked in person, so I guess it's not often that they deliver to that area. It's nice that they take credit card and you can add tip and finish the transaction upon delivery without cash. Everyone was pretty hungry by the time the large Tortorice's special, which is like a classic combo pizza, arrived accurately estimated an hour after ordering, but I don't think anyone could stomach more than one piece of the loaded pie. The cheese crust layers were not distinct to the eye, but it was clear after downing a slice that it was not a normal pizza. One of my coworkers was sweating profusely from eating it, like he was battling a formidable opponent. I felt cocky and proceeded to split a second slice with him but after a few more bites let the cheese and toppings slide off the bread sadly and, defeated, hung my head in shame. Tortorice's is not for the fainthearted. read more

After years of eating good food at Tortorices, I am now so disappointed. We ordered beef sandwiches and the beef was overdone with a weird aftertaste. French fries were undercooked and had a fishy taste. And they changed the coleslaw recipe that is not as good. It's very sad but we won't be returning. read more

The pizza I had ordered from this place was ok. On Friday though, I ordered their "1/2 pound shrimp special" and I ordered 2 since it sounded good for the price. Well, the thing turned out to be nasty small shrimp deep fried in a pound of greasy dough, yuk! I called them and the lady just said "ok ok". I am not going to order from this place again ever. read more

Really good! Having grown up on the South Side of Chicago, there was a pizza place on every corner. I suppose I was spoiled by the amount of different pizzerias there were. This is reminiscent. I believe they must go light on the sauce, since I ordered it with extra, and it was the perfect amount. The pizzas are very well made. The sauce is sweet, which I enjoy. I like sausage to have some spice and fennel. That's where they fall a bit short. However, it's still quite delicious. I'll be sure to stop back again. Thanks for the tip, Yelpers! read more