Place was not busy but we still waited about 15-20 min to receive 2 lobster rolls. They were small and we got a few chips (and I mean a few) for $20. Served cold with mayo. I personally did not like the chewy texture or the taste with the mayo. See pic for what I received. read more

Tracy's Seafood - 2 lobster rolls. - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

My experience here was fantastic. Unbeatable value for the money, and really delicious food. Plus the family running the place is super nice. Highly recommend! read more

Tracy's Seafood - Fresh Lobster platter with deliciously sweet corn on the cob and impeccable onion rings - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

We ordered lobster rolls and clam chowder. Frankly it was the only place open on sunday within a reasonable distance from our hotel. Lobster rolls had limited flavor and clam chowder soup was clams and potatoes thrown together in a watery broth. My wife was feeling a bit uncomfortable a few hrs after the clam chowder. Rolls were at least 25 percent more expensive than comparable places. Overall lobster rolls was 1.5 to 2 stars, but given the clam chowder and relatively expensive pricing I would give the place 1 star. read more

The service was beyond excellent. Extremely friendly, and made great conversation. Food was delicious with great portions. The restaurant fits the small town atmosphere of the town. Great lunch. read more

Food and service is always on point. Delicious seafood and we were lucky to enjoy Prime Rib on Mother's Day. Don't miss the indoor dining area which has decent beer and wine selections as well! read more

Great lobster rolls and comfort food. Was two lobster rolls for $10 ten years ago. Now, two for $23

Not bad! Stopped for ice cream but not food so limited perspective. The ice cream was good. Smallish portion on the cone but delectable. Right on highway 1 so some road noise. I wish I'd had the lobster roll as they looked scrumptious. read more

Total rip-off. $15 for a half full container of chowder. About 2oz of lobster in their lobster rolls. Live and learn. Never again.

Sat inside for the $19.95 Lobster Dinner - 1-1.25 lb lobster, 1 lb of steamers (fresh and tender, but "muddier" than the littlenecks I'm used to) ear of corn, melted butter, cup of warm water (to rinse the clams ... which helped some. Lobster was terrific! Sweet and lots of meat in both claws and tail. Wife had fried shrimp that were closer to "popcorn" but tasted okay, with great fries. Several local beers available (Cadillac Mountain stout was really good). I'd come back again ... maybe without the clams (just not my taste). read more

Tracy's Seafood - Cadillac Mountain Stout Great! No added funkiness that a lot try to add. - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

See all

Waited for food over 70' for chowder and cheeseburgers! Chowder was good but burgers weren't hot.

There are plenty of road side seafood spots. Look for something else. It's sad, because from the outside it looked promising. However, after well over two hours of a wait to learn that out order hast been started, is simply not worth it. Unfortunately we didn't get a chance to try the food. They need a good manager. Too many staff members just sat around. I hope Tracy's gets their act together. Until then, look elsewhere. read more

Fresh and delicious. A quick stop on the way to some backpacking in Cutler for lunch. Highly recommend the lobster roll (get two!). If you're gluten free, they'll put it in a lettuce wrap. My wife said the fish and chips were also solid and plenty! read more

Excellent everything.family run and proud of it.Lobster rolls any way you like.Whole belly clams too!

Rude server, tiny fried shrimp that we were pretty sure were frozen. Expensive. French fries were soggy and limp. Onion rings were very good. Will not go back. Went there last year and things were much better. read more

Haddock sandwich is just chunks of fish and coleslaw is all vinegar. Food arrive just barely warm and there was an upcharge to try the coleslaw after waitress said she would give me a sample. read more

The food was okay until I ate 2/3's of the meal and had a big long hair I pulled out of my mouth after half chewing a fried scallop !!! Maybe the person cooking might consider a hair net?? Bummer!! I have recommended Tracy's to several. The big hair ruined my appetite for this place. read more

If you don't want to read, just know you should RUN and not even dare to try this place. I don't know where to start here but everything that could go wrong in a restaurant went wrong here: 1. Food: Gross, undercooked and over cooked clams, scallops, haddock, shrimp and onion rings. The whole belly clams were huge, biggest I've ever had. The breading was falling off of most and tasted very fishy and were super chewy. Being a whole belly clam lover, these truly disappointed. The lobster rolls were super cheap 2 for $15. But I'd rather pay $25 for a fresh one. The lobster was so old, that it was dried, the mayo had already been absorbed by the meat and the buns were toasted but not buttered. 2. Service: Worst service I've ever had. After having wait for 50 minutes for our food I went to the window to inquire about it. The teenage boy simply said, well they're swamped. They are really busy! He didn't offer to check on it or anything. I chucked his attitude to the fact he's a teenager and doesn't care much. But after 1 hour and 15 mins I went looking for the only adult in the place, who after a few seconds, shut me up and said: Yeah, yeah I heard the story from your friend. You don't need to repeat your story again. We're busy here, I'll just check for your food. I don't see a reason to wait over an hour for less than mediocre food. This place doesn't deserve any stars, seafood is very simple, keep it fresh or it'll be terrible. read more

Kiss - Keep it simple, stupid. They got this right. Simple foods done well. I go the clam strips and lobster rolls. While it put a dent in my wallet, so will every place else. The ice cream is good. The service was great. Everyone was nice. In my humble opinion, this shack gives you a better cost-benefit analysis than some of the other lobster stands. I'd come back here again. read more

Such a shame that Tracey's chooses to take their perfectly fried seafood, fries, and onion rings and put them in plastic containers that act like a steam room thus sogging them up good! Best to eat immediately right there and open containers quickly! Oh for the days of red and white checked paper bowls and paper bags! Great service and all the charm you could want for a seafood shack in rural Maine! read more

First and foremost you have to remember that this is a working lobster pound. When we went in to be seated in the small attached restaurant to the lobster pound/ "take out" portion of the business- it smelled like a working fish market- so- that being said, if you don't like the smelly smell of a fish market DO NOT sit inside; instead, use the takeout. That being said, we ordered a seafood dish for two (see picture). The portions were generous. It was tasty, and the seafood was very fresh. I wished it had been a little less greasy, but it was a fried dish- so I had to expect it. Another indicator that this restaurant/take out/fish market is a good place to eat was that the place was packed with a very brisk take out trade. There is also ice cream available, which is good. read more

Tracy's Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

See all

I really wanted to like this place. It looked so cute from the road. However it was a big disappointment. Food was just OK for the price. I ordered three lobster rolls which were supposed to come with chips. The three rolls were stuffed into one plastic container and there were literally five potato chips total for three people. The prices are not cheap and we waited forever for the food. Do not recommend. read more

Disappointed to spend $15.00 on chowder that was not completely filled and contained very few clams.

Lobster rolls 2/$20 were a great deal! Delicious food and fresh made fries. Excellent find on the way back to Bar Harbor.

Seafood chowder was delicious! Made to order so don't expect it to instantly appear after you order-but worth the (short) wait. No frills, classic Maine seafood place. read more

We stopped in to buy some live lobsters for dinner... They were way below the "market price" of $8.00. They were asking $5.10 per pound. The guy who helped us was young and enthused. We found two very healthy 2 pounders to take with us, plus two lobster bibs to keep our clothes clean... No complaints. They cook them for $2 per pound, which is a deal as far as I am concerned. I would have paid the $8 to avoid cleaning up. We were interested in lobster for dinner and it was about 2PM when we stopped in... I would recommend them for a good lobster to take home... I would also say that if you are traveling and want to eat a fresh lobster and don't care about atmosphere, this is your place. I also noticed their lobster rolls, which were piled high with lobster. Great meal for travelers... Again, this is not a place full of atmosphere, so don't confuse the great price with a fine dinning recommendation. Would I go back? Yes I would. (If they were anywhere near South Carolina, I would be a frequent customer.) read more

Best lobster roll for under $10! My friend and I got the 2 for $10 deal, one regular and one naked. (they're usually one for $6 - still an amazing deal) We were impressed with how much meat were in them. The buns were perfectly toasted and the meat was not overly dressed or salty. We couldn't believe how cheap but tasty they were. They were also regular size, so not skimping there. I finished my meal with a scoop of blueberry ice cream. It tasted like yummy berry ice cream with frozen blueberry preserve swirls. Can't wait to go back next time I'm in the area! PS. Ignore Google Maps when trying to find this place. Note the street numbers and you'll be fine. read more

Tracy's Seafood - blueberry ice cream - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

See all

Food portions were good, however food was a little soggy. A little pricey for the quality of food. For a family of 7, mostly children the bill was about $200. Overall not bad, but the most disturbing was watching the cook and help prepare food, no gloves, beard or hair nets. Cook outside smoking in between orders. Little children in the kitchen handling orders. We will not return. read more

I've been here twice for two different dining reasons and the outcome has been consistent. First visit was for dinner, dine out. The most striking thing is the time it takes to get an order out. I ordered two fried dinners (not hard) and it took nearly an hour to produce the dinners. Not just me but everyone. The number of times I saw patrons go to the window to check and see when their order would be done was very noticeable. The dinners when finished were well overcooked and not that good. Didn't finish either. We went the next night (convenience) for ice cream...pretty easy you would think. Apparently not. The person taking the order forgot she had taken it almost immediately. After seeing other families that arrived after us get served, I went to check. The very person that took my order wanted to see my reciept to confirm I had ordered in the first place then as the attitude started to ramp up cooler heads prevailed and another employee intervened. Nearly 30min to get an ice cream cone. I'm pretty calm headed but this one tested me. We won't be back. read more

Food was tasty, just not quite what we expected. Coming from Pittsburgh PA you get a much larger lobster roll, and Pittsburgh doesn't have any native lobster. Was expecting larger portions. read more

We ordered crab rolls and lobster rolls. The crab rolls were double stuffed and the meat was delicious. The lobster was excellent as well but less meat than the crab roll. The price was 2 for $15! It was a great bargain. The server was pleasant and it was a good experience. We will definitely visit again. read more

Tracy's has my all-time favorite seafood chowder. It is slightly sweet with a ton of fresh seafood in it. Great prices and very friendly staff. read more

Tracy's Seafood - This gives you the idea of the incredible amount of seafood Tracy's puts into their amazing chowder! - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

The seafood at Tracys was excellent and the onion rings were superb and the prices were reasonable had a great meal highly recommend it

The food was good. The lobster rolls pleased the men. The onion rings are delicious. The clam chowder was the chunkiest I had ever seen. Extremely rich, the cup was hard to finish. The fried fish was flaky and tasty. They offer dining in but I wouldn't recommend it. The service was very very very slow. The table was sticky. We waited a long time for the check. A ridiculous long time. After I found someone they did explain that they were two people short staffed. They also sell ice cream on the side through a window. They got the kids order wrong. So even being short staffed the whole experience was mediocre. The quality of the food saved it. And we could not find a bathroom. read more

I ordered a clam roll from here. Place an order at the window and then they call you number. The clams were a bit chewy and the portion of fries for the price was out of line. Ok in a pinch but there are other options further up the road. read more

Tracy's Seafood - Clam roll plus my $3 fries - Seafood Near Me - Sullivan, Maine

See all

We dined in and had lobster rolls, boiled lobster, fried clams, and blueberry pie. The seafood was hot and fresh. The pie wasn't too sweet and the blueberries were refreshing with a flaky crust and light whipped cream. Lovely family and relaxed atmosphere. read more

Pretty disappointed with this one. It was right near my Airbnb and instead of driving 40 min away, we decided to give this place a shot. All the reviews were either hit or miss, but it's Maine, so how bad could seafood be. That was my first mistake. My second mistake was the clam chowder. It was inedible. It tasted like a can of clams boiled in milk. Fish and chips were ok, but definitely not fresh. Fries were disappointing and the lobster roll was just eh. Tried it out and it wasn't for us. read more

I gave this place 5 stars because the fried clams and onion rings were very good. Clams were crispy and not chewy at all. The onion rings were thin and crispy as well. We got the carry out but ate it on the way home. Couldn't wait to try, plus we were ten minutes away. Fried food, the hotter the better. Great snack for the way home. read more

A little secret about main seafood restaurants is not all of them have fresh lobster. Some use frozen and some use canned.. But because the Tracy family are also lobster fishermen their lobster is fresh every single day and absolutely delicious read more

Yum!! Went to the back area to have lobster cooked right in front of us. The gentleman cooking was a great conversationalist and very informative. The lobster was fantastic! We also had shakes which were great too! Nice choice for getting your standard Maine treats! read more

We stopped here after visiting Acadia and felt it was just average. My fiancé said the scallops were delicious but we both agreed that the haddock was average (was soggy). read more